Combined use of temperature and solvent strength in reversed-phase gradient elution IV. Selectivity for neutral (non-ionized) samples as a function of sample type and other separation conditions

Chromatographic benefits of elevated temperature for the proteomic analysis of membrane proteins

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) perform crucial cellular functions and are the primary targets for most pharmaceutical agents. However, the hydrophobic nature of their membrane-embedded domains and their intimate association with lipids make them difficult to handle. Numerous proteomic platforms that include LC separations have been reported for the high-throughput profiling of complex protein samples. However, there are still many challenges to overcome for proteomic analyses of IMPs, especially as compared to their soluble counterparts. In particular, considerations for the technical challenges associated with chromatographic separations are just beginning to be investigated. Here, we review the benefits of using elevated temperatures during LC for the proteomic analysis of complex membrane protein samples.

Characterization and applications of reversed-phase column selectivity based on the hydrophobic-subtraction model

A total of 371 reversed-phase columns have now been characterized in terms of selectivity, based on five solute-column interactions (the hydrophobic-subtraction model). The present study illustrates the use of these data for interpreting peak-tailing and column stability. New insights are also provided concerning column selectivity as a function of ligand and silica type, and the selection of columns for orthogonal separations is re-examined. Some suggestions for the quality control of reversed-phase columns during manufacture are offered.

Practice and theory of high temperature liquid chromatography

High temperature liquid chromatography (HTLC) exists in a temperature region beyond ambient (ca. 40 degrees C) and below super critical temperatures. The promises of HTLC, such as increased analysis speed, enhanced separation productivity, "green" LC with pure water mobile phases coupled to universal FID detection, and fast analysis of complex samples by combination with fast 2-D techniques, have become an option for routine practice. The focus of this paper is to review the key developments that have made the application of HTLC a practical technique and draw attention to new developments in 2-D techniques that incorporate HTLC that offer an opportunity to vastly increase the usefulness of HPLC for the analysis of complex samples.

Stationary phase characterization and method development

The properties of stationary phases and their characterization methods are reviewed. New and significant developments have occurred in the last few years, and new methods for stationary phase characterization have become available. The characterization methods are discussed, and the differences between the different methods are pointed out. In addition, method development approaches are reviewed, with special emphasis on recent developments that employ multiple parameters in parallel. Also, the renewed interest of temperature as a tool in method development is surveyed.

Selectivity in reversed-phase separations: General influence of solvent type and mobile phase pH

The influence of the mobile phase on retention is studied in this paper for a group of over 70 compounds with a broad range of multiple functional groups. We varied the pH of the mobile phase (pH 3, 7, and 10) and the organic modifier (methanol, acetonitrile (ACN), and tetrahydrofuran (THF)), using 15 different stationary phases. In this paper, we describe the overall retention and selectivity changes observed with these variables. We focus on the primary effects of solvent choice and pH. For example, transfer rules for solvent composition resulting in equivalent retention depend on the packing as well as on the type of analyte. Based on the retention patterns, one can calculate selectivity difference values for different variables. The selectivity difference is a measure of the importance of the different variables involved in method development. Selectivity changes specific to the type of analyte are described. The largest selectivity differences are obtained with pH changes.

High efficiency liquid chromatography on conventional columns and instrumentation by using temperature as a variable

Theoretical aspects of temperature in liquid chromatography (LC) have mostly been studied to elucidate changes in retention behavior of small and large molecules in various solvents. That temperature also plays a significant role in chromatographic performance is less known. Kinetic plots are an established tool to predict chromatographic performance in terms of speed and efficiency that can be obtained with a certain particle size at the maximum attainable column pressure. In this paper, temperature effects on mobile phase viscosity and analyte diffusion are incorporated in these plots to prove that superior performances are within experimental reach for conventional LC columns and equipment. Verification of the modified kinetic plots with experimental data points is presented.

Selectivity in reversed-phase separations

The selectivity difference between 15 different stationary phases was measured using a large number of analytes at 2 or 3 different pH values (3, 7 and 10) with acetonitrile and methanol as the mobile phase modifiers. The packings discussed include standard C(8) and C(18) packings, packings with embedded polar groups, a phenyl packing, a pentafluoro-phenyl packing, an adamantylethyl packing and others. The major selectivity differences observed are discussed in detail. Specific effects such as pi-pi interactions on phenyl packings or hydrogen-bond interactions on phases with embedded polar groups are confirmed.

Can the theory of gradient liquid chromatography be useful in solving practical problems?

Advances in the theory of gradient liquid chromatography and their practical impacts are reviewed. Theoretical models describing retention in reversed-phase, normal-phase and ion-exchange modes are compared. Main attention is focused on practically useful models described by two- or three-parameter equations fitting the experimental data in the range of mobile phase composition utilized for sample migration during gradient elution. The applications of theory for gradient method development, optimization and transfer are addressed. The origins and possibilities for overcoming possible pitfalls are discussed, including the effects of the instrumental dwell volume, uptake of mobile phase components on the column and size of the sample molecules. Special attention is focused on gradient separations of large molecules.

High-performance liquid chromatography profiling of the major carotenoids in Arabidopsis thaliana leaf tissue

Carotenoids are extremely sensitive to a variety of physico-chemical attacks which may have a profound effect on their characteristic properties, thereby influencing the accurate identification and quantification of individual compounds. In this light, a comprehensive summary of the pitfalls encountered and precautions to be administered during handling and storage of authentic standards and samples was found to be incomplete. Furthermore, acceptable baseline separation of trans-lutein from trans-zeaxanthin and between the cis- and trans-forms of neoxanthin and violaxanthin has not been satisfactorily demonstrated. Hence the most optimal sample preparation and analytical steps were determined and a sensitive and reproducible method for the quantitative HPLC profiling of the principal carotenoids found in plant leaf tissue was developed. A reverse-phase C(30) column with a binary mobile solvent system was used for the baseline separation of eight of the major carotenoids and the two chlorophylls (a and b) within 18min. These compounds were identified via the use of authentic standards, their spectral characteristics and HPLC-atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI)-mass spectrometry (MS) confirmation. This method has been successfully applied for the quantification of plant pigments in Arabidopsis thaliana wild-type (WT) leaf tissue and in two A. thaliana non-photochemical mutants, namely npq1 and npq2. These mutants have previously been well-characterised and provided valuable reference data as well as acting as internal controls for the assessment of our new method.

“Orthogonal” separations for reversed-phase liquid chromatography

A general procedure is proposed for the rapid development of a reversed-phase liquid chromatographic (RP-LC) separation that is "orthogonal" to a pre-existing ("primary") method for the RP-LC separation of a given sample. The procedure involves a change of the mobile-phase organic solvent (B-solvent), the replacement of the primary column by one of very different selectivity, and (only if necessary) a change in mobile phase pH or the use of a third column. Following the selection of the "orthogonal" B-solvent, column and mobile phase pH, further optimization of peak spacing and resolution can be achieved by varying separation temperature and either isocratic %B or gradient time. The relative "orthogonality" of the primary and "orthogonal" RP-LC methods is then evaluated from plots of retention for one method versus the other. The present procedure was used to develop "orthogonal" methods for nine routine RP-LC methods from six pharmaceutical analysis laboratories. The relative success of this approach can be judged from the results reported here.

Rational method development strategies on a fluorinated liquid chromatography stationary phase: Mobile phase ion concentration and temperature effects on the separation of ephedrine alkaloids

Fluorinated, silica-based stationary phases are becoming increasingly popular alternatives to traditional alkyl phases owing to their differential selectivity and retention for a variety of analyte classes. In this report, the ion-exchange mechanisms characteristic of a fluorinated phase are exploited to rapidly develop separation conditions for ephedrine alkaloids and synephrine using a mobile phase compatible with mass spectrometry. A linear relationship of basic analyte retention with the reciprocal of ammonium acetate concentration is first established. This linear relationship can then be used to optimize retention and selectivity in just two experiments. The relationship of retention with temperature is also explored. Greater retention with increasing temperature is demonstrated on the fluorinated phase at high percentages of organic modifier, which is in contrast to behavior observed in typical reversed-phase separations. The unexpected observation is explicated based on the reduction in solvent solvating power with increasing temperature. As solvation power of the mobile phase decreases, decreased solvation of both mobile phase and ionized surface groups of the stationary phase leads to stronger interactions between analyte and stationary phase. Both mobile phase ion concentration and temperature are shown to be powerful tools for the manipulation of analyte retention and selectivity.

Effect of temperature on the chromatographic retention of ionizable compounds

The retention mechanism of acids and bases in reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) has been experimentally studied by examining the temperature dependence of retention, with emphasis on the role of the buffer ionization equilibria in the retention and selectivity. Retention factors of several ionizable compounds in a typical octadecylsilica column and using buffers dissolved in 50% (w/w) methanol as eluents at three temperatures in the range of 25-50 degrees C were measured. Two pairs of buffer solutions were prepared by a close adjusting of their pH at 25 degrees C; differences in their ionization enthalpies determined a different degree of ionization when temperature was raised and, as a consequence, a different shift in the eluent pH. Predictive equations of retention that take into account the temperature effect on both the transfer and the ionization processes are proposed. This study demonstrates the significant role that the selected buffer would have in retention and selectivity in RPLC at temperatures higher than 25 degrees C, particularly for co-eluted solutes.

High-temperature liquid chromatography

The present state of the active use of elevated temperatures in liquid chromatography is reviewed, including the effects on retention, selectivity and efficiency. Separations in aqueous mobile phases as well as non-aqueous media are discussed, with particular emphasis on narrow-bore columns.

Computerized design of separation strategies by reversed-phase liquid chromatography: development of DryLab software

The development of DryLab software is a special achievement in analytical HPLC which took place in the last 16 years. This paper tries to collect some of the historical mile stones and concepts. DryLab, being always subject to change according to the needs of the user, never stopped being developed. Under the influence of an ever changing science market, the DryLab development team had to consider not just scientific improvements, but also new technological achievements, such as the introduction of Windows 1.0 and 3.1, and later Windows NT and 2000. The recent availability of new 32-bit programming tools allowed calculations of chromatograms to be completed more quickly so as to show peak movements which result for example from slight changes in eluent pH. DryLab is a great success of interdisciplinary and intercontinental cooperation by many scientists.

Temperature selectivity in reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography

Column temperature plays two important roles in reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC): control of retention (k) and control of selectivity (a). While changes in retention as a function of temperature are ubiquitous, selectivity changes for any given solute pair are more pronounced for ionized samples and samples with more polar substituents. With many samples, column temperature can be selected in a manner that optimizes resolution. The selectivity effects observed for temperature changes in RP-HPLC generally are complementary to those observed for mobile phase strength changes, so it is often possible to improve resolution by simultaneous optimization of temperature and mobile phase percent organic or gradient steepness. Computer simulation is a powerful tool for such optimization experiments. This paper reviews the influence of temperature on chromatographic selectivity for RP-HPLC.

Effects of temperature on retention of chiral compounds on a ristocetin A chiral stationary phase

The isocratic retention of enantiomers of chiral analytes, i.e. tryptophan, 1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline and gamma-butyrolac tone analogs, was studied on a ristocetin A chiral stationary phase at different temperatures and with different mobile phase compositions, using the reversed-phase, polar-organic and normal-phase modes. By variation of the both mobile phase composition and the temperature, baseline separations could be achieved for these enantiomers. The retention factors and selectivity factors for the enantiomers of all investigated compounds decreased with increasing temperature. The natural logarithms of the retention factors (ln k) of the investigated compounds depended linearly on the inverse of temperature (1/T). van't Hoff plots afforded thermodynamic parameters, such as the apparent change in enthalpy (deltaH(o)), the apparent change in entropy (deltaS(o)) and the apparent change in Gibbs free energy (deltaG(o) ) for the transfer of analyte from the mobile to the stationary phase. The thermodynamic parameters (deltaH(o), deltaS(o) and deltaG(o)) were calculated in order to promote an understanding of the thermodynamic driving forces for retention in this chromatographic system.

Analysis of linear and cyclic oligomers in polyamide-6 without sample preparation by liquid chromatography using the sandwich injection method. III. Separation mechanism and gradient optimization

The first six linear and cyclic oligomers of polyamide-6 can be quantitatively determined in the polymer using HPLC with the sandwich injection method and an aqueous acetonitrile gradient. In this final part of the triptych concerning the determination of the oligomers in polyamide-6, the irregular elution behavior of the cyclic monomer compared to the cyclic oligomers was investigated. We also optimized the separation of the involved polyamide oligomers, with respect to gradient steepness, stationary phase, column temperature and mobile phase pH. The irregular elution behavior of the cyclic monomer could be caused by its relatively large exposed/accessible hydrophobic surface, which permits relatively easy penetration into the hydrophobic stationary phase giving extra retention. The dipole moment of the different oligomers was used as a measure for this exposed/accessible hydrophobic area to correlate the retention factors using quantitative structure-retention relationships. We also studied the retention behavior of the polyamide, which is injected each run directly onto the column and modifies the stationary phase. Using a 250-microl post gradient injection zone of formic acid on a 250x3 mm Zorbax SB-C18 column, the polyamide could be effectively removed from the stationary phase after each separation. The linear solvent strength (LSS) model was used to optimize the separation of the first six linear and cyclic oligomers. As the LSS model assumes a linear correlation between the modifier concentration and the logarithm of the retention factor and the cyclic monomer and dimer show extreme curvation of this relation in the eluting region, we investigated different models to predict gradient elution from isocratic data. A direct translation of the isocratic data to gradient retention times did not yield adequate retention times using the LSS model. It was found that the LSS model worked acceptably if gradient retention times were used as input data. Even for fast non-linearly eluting components, an average error of 0.4 resolution units of 4sigma was obtained. Using the LSS model in combination with different column temperatures and mobile phase pH values, a separation of the first six linear and cyclic oligomers was accomplished.

Effect of temperature on retention and selectivity in ion chromatography of anions

The temperature dependence of retention of a wide range of inorganic anions is studied on two commercially available ion exchangers (Dionex AS11 and AS14 columns). Anion retention exhibited both exothermic and endothermic behavior, such that varying the temperature from ambient to 60 degrees C produced selectivity changes. The anions displayed three groupings of temperature dependence: weakly retained singly charged anions (e.g., iodate, bromate, nitrite, bromide and nitrate); multiply charged anions (sulfate, oxalate, phosphate and thiosulfate); and strongly retained singly charged anions (iodide, thiocyanate and perchlorate). Temperature was ineffective at changing the selectivity of retention between anions of the same grouping. However, significant selectivity changes, including elution order reversal, could be achieved between anions from different groupings.

Computer-assisted high-performance liquid chromatography method development with applications to the isolation and analysis of phytoplankton pigments

We used chromatography modeling software to assist in HPLC method development, with the goal of enhancing separations through the exclusive use of gradient time and column temperature. We surveyed nine stationary phases for their utility in pigment purification and natural sample analysis. For purification, a complex algal matrix was separated on an efficient monomeric column, from which partially purified fractions were collected and purified on polymeric columns that exaggerated resolution between pigments of interest. Additionally, we feature an HPLC method that is simple, fast, demonstrates excellent transferability and is ideal for quantitative analysis of pigments in dilute natural water samples.

Selectivity differences for C18 and C8 reversed-phase columns as a function of temperature and gradient steepness. I. Optimizing selectivity and resolution

Four experimental runs where temperature T and gradient time tG are varied allow the computer-prediction of reversed-phase liquid chromatographic (RPLC) separation for different combinations of temperature and gradient time. This in turn can provide significant changes in selectivity and a resulting optimization of separation. If this procedure is repeated for different columns, additional control over selectivity and resolution becomes possible. The simultaneous variation of T and tG for columns from different sources was studied for two samples, as a means of evaluating the general advantage of this approach for RPLC method development. Changes in relative retention with T were found to be approximately constant for different values of tG and for different RPLC columns; similarly, changes in relative retention with tG were roughly independent of changes in temperature or the column. The latter relationships can be useful in matching ("tracking") peaks between runs during method development based on the present approach, as well as for other applications discussed in here and in Part II.

Optimization methods in chromatography and capillary electrophoresis

Many methods have been developed in order to optimize the parameters of interest in either chromatography or capillary electrophoresis. In chemometric approaches experimental measurements are performed in such a way that all factors vary together. An objective function is utilized in which the analyst introduces the desired criteria (selectivity, resolution, time of analysis). Simplex methods and overlapping resolution maps are declining. Factorial designs and central composite designs are more and more popular in electrodriven capillary separations since the number of parameters to master is much larger than in either GC or LC. The use of artificial neural networks is increasing. The advantage of chemometrics tools is that no explicit models are required, conversely the number of experiments to perform may be high and boundaries of the domain are not straightforward to draw and the approach does more than is required. When models are available optimization is easier to perform by regression methods. Computer assisted methods in RPLC are readily available and work well but are still in infancy in CE. Linear solvation energy relationships seem a very valuable tool but estimates of coefficients still require many experiments.

Reversed-phase separation of achiral isomers by varying temperature and either gradient time or solvent strength

The separation of several isomer pairs of widely varied structure was studied as a function of changes in temperature, gradient time, mobile phase pH, column type ("monomeric" vs. "polymeric" C18-silica) and organic solvent (methanol vs. acetonitrile). General conclusions are drawn which may prove useful in future attempts at the separation of these and other achiral isomers.

C30 stationary phases for the analysis of food by liquid chromatography

The introduction of a polymeric C30 liquid chromatographic column by Sander et al. [Anal. Chem., 66 (1994) 1667] designed for the separation of carotenoid isomers, has led to the development of improved analytical methods for these compounds. Subsequent commercial availability of polymerically bonded C30 columns has facilitated these advances, and applications to a wide variety of separation problems with biological samples have been described. This report provides a comprehensive review of applications of polymeric C30 columns, utilized in the determination of carotenoids, retinoids, and other nutrients and related compounds in complex, natural-matrix samples.

Characterization of C18-bonded liquid chromatographic stationary phases by Raman spectroscopy: the effect of temperature

This study represents the first time that both the mobile phase composition and the temperature are simultaneously controlled to examine silica-bonded octadecylsilyl (C18) ligands spectroscopically at typical liquid chromatographic (LC) mobile phase flow-rates and back-pressures. Raman spectroscopy is used to characterize the behavior of the C18 bonded ligands equilibrated at temperatures from 45 to 2 degrees C in neat, single-component, mobile phase solvents including: water, acetonitrile, methanol, and chloroform. In addition, the effect of stationary phase ligand bonding density is examined by using two different monomeric reversed-phase liquid chromatographic (RPLC) stationary phases, a 2.34 and a 3.52 micromol m(-2) Microporasil C18 stationary phase, under identical conditions. The direct, on-column, spectroscopic analysis used in this study allows direct evaluation of the temperature-dependent behavior of the bonded C18 ligands. The temperature-dependent ordering of the stationary phase ligands is examined to determine if the ligands undergo a phase transition from a less-ordered "liquid-like" state at higher temperatures to a more-ordered "solid-like" state at lower temperatures. A discrete phase transition was not observed, but rather a continual ordering as temperature was lowered.

Control of column temperature in reversed-phase liquid chromatography

When separations by reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC) are carried out at temperatures other than ambient, resulting retention times and bandwidths can depend on the equipment used. As a result, an RP-LC separation that is adequate when carried out on one LC system may prove inadequate when the separation is repeated on a second system. In the present study, various temperature-related problems which can result in a failure of method transfer for non-ambient RP-LC methods were examined. Means for correcting for such effects and thereby ensuring method transferability are described.

Computer simulation for the convenient optimization of isocratic reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separations by varying temperature and mobile phase strength

Software is described which allows the rapid development of separations by means of isocratic reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RP-LC), based on the optimization of column temperature (T) and mobile phase strength (%B). For a given sample, four initial experiments are carried out at two different temperatures, using either isocratic or (better) gradient elution. If isocratic experiments are chosen for computer simulation, it is necessary to select appropriate values of %B for these initial runs. Literature data for solute retention as a function of T are reviewed, as a basis for estimating suitable values of %B at the two values of T selected. The use of optimized values of T and %B led to acceptable separations for three representative samples. The prediction of isocratic separation on the basis of initial gradient experiments is more convenient than the use of initial isocratic experiments, but less reliable. When gradient experiments are used, one additional isocratic experiment can improve the accuracy of such predictions by a "reflection" procedure. The latter approach was confirmed for predictions of both isocratic and gradient separation from initial gradient experiments.

Retention and separation studies of cholesterol and bile acids using thermostated thin-layer chromatography

The influence of temperature on retention and separation of cholesterol and bile acids, using reversed-phase thin-layer chromatography, was studied. As mobile phases methanol-water mixtures of various compositions were used. Chromatographic experiments were performed using vapor-saturated chambers at temperatures ranging from 5 to 60 degrees C. A linear relationship between R(M) values and temperature (1/T) as well as mobile phase composition was observed. The elution order of steroids under the conditions investigated was discussed. Each chromatogram was evaluated using simple optimization parameters and the best chromatographic conditions for the separation of multicomponent samples were chosen.

Reversed-phase liquid chromatographic separation of complex samples by optimizing temperature and gradient time III. Improving the accuracy of computer simulation

Previous studies have shown that four experimental runs, where both temperature T and gradient time tG are varied, can be used for the reliable prediction of separation as a function of these two variables (two-dimensional optimization). Computer simulation (e.g., DryLab) can then be used to predict "optimized" conditions for maximum sample resolution using either isocratic or gradient elution. Samples that contain a large number of components (e.g., n>15-20) present a greater challenge. Resolution for these more complex samples is often quite sensitive to small changes in T or tG in turn requiring greater accuracy in predictions that result from computer simulation. In the present study of several samples, we have examined computer simulation errors that can arise from inexact expressions for retention time as a function of T, tG or isocratic %B. Resulting conclusions are applicable to both complex and simpler samples, in either one- or two-dimensional optimization. Means to anticipate and minimize the impact of these predictive errors are examined.

An approach to the concept of resolution optimization through changes in the effective chromatographic selectivity

It is very common chromatographic practice to optimize resolution by making changes in selectivity by systematically varying key retention controlling factors. In many instances, a change in conditions merely results in monotonic, systematic variation in the relative retention of all pairs of peaks. Useful or "effective" changes in selectivity generally result when we see peak crossovers, changes in elution order or differential changes in band position of three or more peaks upon changing some operating condition. In this work, we demonstrate that changes in what we now call the effective selectivity can only take place when retention depends on a minimum of two solute molecular properties and further the dependencies must differ for the two sets of conditions. To verify our concept, real chromatographic data are examined from the viewpoint of linear solvation energy relationships (LSERs) and linear solvent strength theory. Five different RPLC stationary phases in different eluents are compared to elucidate the similarities and differences in their effective selectivities. Of major importance is our finding that the effective selectivity can only be understood when it is viewed in terms of the ratios of system-dependent interaction coefficients, such as the LSER coefficients, and not merely the absolute values of the coefficients. We confirm, both theoretically and experimentally, that a change in mobile-phase volume fraction and in column temperature is not as powerful a mechanism for tuning the effective selectivity as is a change in stationary-phase type.