Separations of DNA fragments by capillary electrophoresis in N-substituted polyacrylamides

Sieving polymer synthesis by reversible addition fragmentation chain transfer polymerization

Replaceable sieving polymers are the fundamental component for high resolution nucleic acids separation in CE. The choice of polymer and its physical properties play significant roles in influencing separation performance. Recently, reversible addition fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization has been shown to be a versatile polymerization technique capable of yielding well defined polymers previously unattainable by conventional free radical polymerization. In this study, a high molecular weight PDMA at 765 000 gmol-1 with a PDI of 1.55 was successfully synthesized with the use of chain transfer agent - 2-propionic acidyl butyl trithiocarbonate (PABTC) in a multi-step sequential RAFT polymerization approach. This study represents the first demonstration of RAFT polymerization for synthesizing polymers with the molecular weight range suitable for high resolution DNA separation in sieving electrophoresis. Adjustment of pH in the reaction was found to be crucial for the successful RAFT polymerization of high molecular weight polymer as the buffered condition minimizes the effect of hydrolysis and aminolysis commonly associated with trithiocarbonate chain transfer agents. The separation efficiency of PABTC-PDMA was found to have marginally superior separation performance compared to a commercial PDMA formulation, POP™-CAP, of similar molecular weight range.

Capillary electrophoresis ribosomal RNA single-stranded conformation polymorphism: a new approach for characterization of low-diversity microbial communities

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) has been the principle system for nucleic acid analysis since the early 1990s due to its inherent advantages such as fast analysis time, high resolution and efficiency, minimal sample requirement, high detection sensitivity, and automation. In the past few decades, microbial community fingerprinting methods such as terminal restriction fragment length polymorphism and single-stranded conformation polymorphism (SSCP) have migrated to CE to utilize its advantages over conventional slab gel electrophoresis. Recently, a gel-based direct rRNA fingerprint method was demonstrated. Different from other existing microbial community characterization approaches, this novel approach is polymerase chain reaction free and capable of providing information on the relative abundance of rRNA from individual phylotypes in low-diversity samples. As a gel-based method, it has a long analysis time and relatively large reagent and sample requirements. Here, we addressed these limitations by transferring the RNA fingerprint approach to the CE platform. Analysis time significantly improved from 24 h to 60 min, and the use of a fluorescently labeled hybridization probe as the detection strategy decreased the sample requirement by ten-fold. The combination of fast analysis time, low sample requirement, and sensitive fluorescence detection makes CE-RNA-SSCP an appealing new approach for characterizing low-diversity microbial communities.

Effect of the matrix on DNA electrophoretic mobility

DNA electrophoretic mobilities are highly dependent on the nature of the matrix in which the separation takes place. This review describes the effect of the matrix on DNA separations in agarose gels, polyacrylamide gels and solutions containing entangled linear polymers, correlating the electrophoretic mobilities with information obtained from other types of studies. DNA mobilities in various sieving media are determined by the interplay of three factors: the relative size of the DNA molecule with respect to the effective pore size of the matrix, the effect of the electric field on the matrix, and specific interactions of DNA with the matrix during electrophoresis.

Polymer systems designed specifically for DNA sequencing by microchip electrophoresis: a comparison with commercially available materials

Electrophoresis-based DNA sequencing is the only proven technology for the de novo sequencing of large and complex genomes. Miniaturization of capillary array electrophoresis (CAE) instruments can increase sequencing throughput and decrease cost while maintaining the high quality and long read lengths that has made CAE so successful for de novo sequencing. The limited availability of high-performance polymer matrices and wall coatings designed specifically for microchip-sequencing platforms continues to be a major barrier to the successful development of a commercial microchip-sequencing instrument. It has been generally assumed that the matrices and wall coatings that have been developed for use in commercial CAE instruments will be able to be implemented directly into microchip devices with little to no change in sequencing performance. Here, we show that sequencing matrices developed specifically for microchip electrophoresis systems can deliver read lengths that are 150-300 bases longer on chip than some of the most widely used polymer-sequencing matrices available commercially. Additionally, we show that the coating ability of commercial matrices is much less effective in the borosilicate chips used in this study. These results lead to the conclusion that new materials must be developed to make high-performance microfabricated DNA-sequencing instruments a reality.

Ultrafast DNA sequencing on a microchip by a hybrid separation mechanism that gives 600 bases in 6.5 minutes

To realize the immense potential of large-scale genomic sequencing after the completion of the second human genome (Venter's), the costs for the complete sequencing of additional genomes must be dramatically reduced. Among the technologies being developed to reduce sequencing costs, microchip electrophoresis is the only new technology ready to produce the long reads most suitable for the de novo sequencing and assembly of large and complex genomes. Compared with the current paradigm of capillary electrophoresis, microchip systems promise to reduce sequencing costs dramatically by increasing throughput, reducing reagent consumption, and integrating the many steps of the sequencing pipeline onto a single platform. Although capillary-based systems require approximately 70 min to deliver approximately 650 bases of contiguous sequence, we report sequencing up to 600 bases in just 6.5 min by microchip electrophoresis with a unique polymer matrix/adsorbed polymer wall coating combination. This represents a two-thirds reduction in sequencing time over any previously published chip sequencing result, with comparable read length and sequence quality. We hypothesize that these ultrafast long reads on chips can be achieved because the combined polymer system engenders a recently discovered "hybrid" mechanism of DNA electromigration, in which DNA molecules alternate rapidly between repeating through the intact polymer network and disrupting network entanglements to drag polymers through the solution, similar to dsDNA dynamics we observe in single-molecule DNA imaging studies. Most importantly, these results reveal the surprisingly powerful ability of microchip electrophoresis to provide ultrafast Sanger sequencing, which will translate to increased system throughput and reduced costs.

Capillary electrophoretic separation of dsDNA under nonuniform electric fields

Improved sensitivity for the analysis of DNA by capillary electrophoresis has been achieved, based on simultaneous increases in optical path length and injection volume. To increase the optical path length, bubble cells with diameters ranging from 150 to 450 microm have been fabricated and tested. In terms of resolution and sensitivity, a bubble cell of 300 microm diameter is appropriate when using 75-microm capillaries. To allow greater injection volumes, we performed on-line concentration of DNA in the presence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) using 2.0% poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO). With a 300-microm bubble cell, a 170-fold improvement in the sensitivity for the 89-bp fragment has been accomplished when injecting about 0.33 microL DNA. In the presence of the bubble cell, the resolution for the large fragments improves while that for the small ones (<124 base pair) decreases. The effect of bubble cells was further investigated by conducting DNA separation in the absence of EOF, showing that improvements in resolution are mainly due to increased migration differences when DNA migrated at low electric field strengths in the bubble region. We have suggested that such an effect is more profound using shorter capillaries, leading to complete separation of phiX 174 RF DNA-Hae III digest in 2 min.

Comparison of the separation of large DNA fragments in the presence and absence of electroosmotic flow at high pH

This paper describes the analysis of large DNA fragments at pH > 10.0 by capillary electrophoresis (CE) in the presence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) using hydroxyethylcellulose (HEC) solution. HEC solution in the anodic reservoir enters the capillaries filled with high-pH buffer by EOF after sample injection. With respect to resolution, sensitivity, and speed, separation conducted under discontinuous conditions (different pH values of HEC solutions and buffer filling the capillary) is appropriate. Using HEC solution at concentrations higher than its entanglement threshold ensures a good separation of large DNA fragments in the presence of EOF at high pH. In addition to pH and HEC, the electrolyte species, dimethylamine, methylamine, and piperidine, play different roles in determining the resolution. The separation of DNA fragments ranging in size from 5 to 40 kilo base pairs was completed in 6 min using 1.5% HEC prepared in 20 mM methylamine-borate, pH 12.0, and the capillary filled with 40 mM dimethylamine-borate, pH 10.0. In comparison, this method allows faster separations of large DNA fragments compared with that conducted in the absence of EOF using dilute HEC solutions.

Effects of metal ions on concentration of DNA in high-conductivity media by capillary electrophoresis

On-line concentration and separation of DNA prepared in low- or high-conductivity media has been demonstrated using poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) solution in the presence of electroosmotic flow. DNA fragments migrating against EOF stacked at the boundary between the sample zone and PEO solutions, mainly because of sieving and increases in the viscosity. Unlike conventional methods, the large DNA fragments were detected earlier toward the cathode end in this study. The limit of detection (LOD) at a signal-to-noise ratio=3 for phiX174 RF DNA-Hae III digest prepared in 50 mM Tris-borate, pH 10.0, was down to 0.171 ng/ml, with an 860-fold improvement (compared to that obtained by 10-s injection at 25 V/cm) in the sensitivity, when injecting about 2.58 microl. By applying a short plug (2.3 cm) of 0.5 mM AgNO3 prepared in 1.5% PEO solution after sample injection, the analysis of up to 0.75 microl DNA prepared in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) has been carried out without any tedious desalting processes. This results in an LOD of 6.86 ng/ml for the DNA sample and a 155-fold improvement in the sensitivity. Moreover, this method has allowed the analysis of 0.75 micro] of polymerase chain reaction products amplified after 18 cycles with good reproducibility.

Separation of DNA fragments in hydroxylated poly(dimethylacrylamide) copolymers

The novel polymer matrices reported here are low-viscosity sieving media for DNA capillary electrophoresis. This new family of matrices comprises copolymers of N,N-dimethylacrylamide with different monomers which increase polymer hydrophilicity. All these new copolymers self-coat on fused-silica capillaries. Resolution, peak spacing and peak width were the parameters taken into account to assess the influence of polymer structure on separation selectivity and efficiency. This work demonstrates that the performance of polydimethylacrylamide (PDMA) can be improved through copolymerization with hydrophilic monomers. The improvement is related to the efficiency parameter. The new copolymers, due to their low viscosity high sieving capacity and ability to suppress EOF, represent a better alternative to PDMA and are suitable replaceable matrices for capillary and microchip electrophoresis.

Maximization of injection volumes for DNA analysis in capillary electrophoresis

We report concentration and separation of DNA in the presence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) using poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) solution. DNA fragments migrating against EOF stacked between the sample zone and PEO solution. To maximize the injection volume, several factors, such as concentrations of Tris-borate (TB) buffer and PEO solution, capillary size, and matrix, were carefully evaluated. The use of 25 mM TB buffers, pH 10.0, containing suitable amounts (less than 10 mM) of salts, such as sodium chloride, sodium phosphate, and sodium acetate, to prepare DNA is essential for the concentration of large-volume samples. In the presence of salts, the peaks also became sharper and the fluorescence intensity of DNA complexes increased. Using 2.5% PEO and a 150 microm capillary filled with 400 mM TB buffer, pH 10.0, up to 5 microL DNA samples (phiX 174 RF DNA-HaeIII digest or the mixture of pBR 322/HaeIII, pBR 328/Bg/I, and pBR 328/HinfI digests) have been analyzed, resulting in more than 400-fold improvements in the sensitivity compared to that by conventional injections (ca. 36 nL). Moreover, this method allows the analysis of 3.5 microL PCR products amplified after 17 cycles without any sample pretreatment.

Separation of double-stranded DNA fragments by capillary electrophoresis in interpenetrating networks of polyacrylamide and polyvinylpyrrolidone

Mixtures of two polymers with totally different chemical structures, polyacrylamide and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) have been successfully used for double-stranded DNA separation. By polymerization of acrylamide in a matrix of PVP solution, the incompatibility of these two polymers was suppressed. Laser light scattering (LLS) studies showed that highly entangled interpenetrating networks were formed in the solution. Further systematic investigation showed that double-stranded DNA separation was very good in these interpenetrating networks. With a concentration combination of as low as 2% w/v PVP (weight-average molecular mass Mr = 1 x 10(6) g/mol) + 1% w/v polyacrylamide (Mr = 4 x 10(5) g/mol), the 22 fragments in pBR322/HaeIII DNA, including the doublet of 123/124 bp, have been successfully separated within 6.5 min. Under the same separation conditions, similar resolution could only be achieved by using polyacrylamide (Mr = 4 x 10(5) g/mol) with concentrations higher than 6% w/v and could not be achieved by using only PVP (Mr = 1 x 10(6) g/mol) with a concentration as high as 15% w/v. It is noted that the interpenetrating network formed by 2% PVP and 1% polyacrylamide has a very low viscosity and can dynamically coat the inner wall of a fused-silica capillary. The separation reached an efficiency of more than 10(7) theoretical plate numbers/m and a reproducibility of less than 1% relative standard deviation of migration time in a total of seven runs. The interpenetrating network could stabilize polymer chain entanglements. Consequently, the separation speed was increased while retaining resolution.

A new strategy for optimizing sensitivity, speed, and resolution in capillary electrophoretic separation of DNA

DNA separations were performed in poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) solutions prepared in 100 mM Tris-boric acid (TB) buffers using a capillary filled with TB buffers with concentrations up to 2.5 M, pH 10.0. The electroosmotic flow (EOF) increased with increasing the concentration of TB buffers till 1.5 M as a result of decreasing PEO adsorption on the capillary wall. At high TB concentrations (> 1.5 M), the peaks corresponding to small DNA fragments (11 and 8 base pairs) became sharper and were detected. Relative standard deviations of the EOF coefficient and the migration times of the DNA fragments were all less than 1% using a capillary filled with TB buffers at concentrations higher than 1.5 M. When separations were performed at different pH values of PEO solutions and TB buffers, better results in terms of sensitivity, speed, and resolution were generally achieved. The fluorescence intensity of the 2176 bp fragment obtained at pH values of TB buffers/PEO solutions 10.0/8.2 was 27-fold of that at pH values 8.2/8.2. The enhancement was related to effects of pH and borate on fluorescence intensity, DNA conformation, stacking, and interactions with the capillary wall. Using a capillary filled with 400 mM TB buffers, pH 10.0, the separation of DNA (pBR 322/HaeIII digest, pBR 328/Bg/I digest and pBR 328/HinfI digest) in 1.5% PEO solutions prepared in 100 mM TB buffers, pH 9.0, at 375 V/cm was accomplished in less than 18 min.

Performances of new sugar-bearing poly(acrylamide) copolymers as DNA sieving matrices and capillary coatings for electrophoresis

We have synthesized two new sugar monomers, allylamine of gluconic and lactobionic acid, by opening the corresponding lactone ring with allylamine. These monomers were copolymerized with acrylamide leading to formation of copolymers with a relative molecular mass of 288000 and 180000 Da, respectively. Double-stranded DNA fragments were separated in entangled solutions of these linear polymers in capillary electrophoresis. Resolution, peak spacing and peak width were the parameters taken into account to evaluate the quality of the separation achieved with the new polymers. This work indicates that the copolymers of acrylamide and allyl gluconic acid have a high sieving capacity and provide a performance similar to that of hydroxyethylcellulose (HEC) of comparable viscosity. Unlike HEC, this copolymer selfcoats onto the capillary wall, allowing DNA fragments to be efficiently separated in an uncoated capillary.

Principles of DNA separation with capillary electrophoresis

During the last decade, capillary electrophoresis (CE) of DNA has undergone rapid development. This improvement was especially important for DNA sequencing, where CE has now become a standard method facilitating to decipher several genomes within a very short time. Here, we give a review of the fundamentals of DNA separation in CE and the major factors influencing the performance.

Separation of dsDNA in the presence of electroosmotic flow under discontinuous conditions

Separations of phiX-174/HaeIII DNA restriction fragments have been performed in the presence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) using five different polymer solutions, including linear polyacrylamide (LPA), poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO), hydroxypropylcellulose (HPC), hydroxyethylcellulose (HEC), and agarose. During the separation, polymer solutions entered the capillary by EOF. When using LPA solutions, bulk EOF is small due to adsorption on the capillary wall. On the other hand, separation is faster and better for the large DNA fragments (> 872 base pairs, bp) using derivative celluloses and PEO solutions. Several approaches to optimum resolution and speed by controlling EOF and/or altering electrophoretic mobility of DNA have been developed, including (i) stepwise changes of ethidium bromide (0.5-5 microg/mL), (ii) voltage programming (125-375 V/cm), (iii) use of mixed polymer solutions, and (iv) use of high concentrations of Tris-borate (TB) buffers. The DNA fragments ranging from 434 to 653 bp that were not separated using 2% PEO (8,000,000) under isocratic conditions have been completely resolved by either stepwise changes of ethidium bromide or voltage programming. Compared to PEO solutions, mixed polymer solutions prepared from PEO and HEC provide higher resolving power. Using a capillary filled with 600 mM TB buffers, pH 10.0, high-speed (< 15 min) separation of DNA (pBR 322/HaeIII digest, pBR 328/ Bg/l digest and pBR 328/Hinfl digest) has been achieved in 1.5% PEO.

Polymeric matrices for DNA sequencing by capillary electrophoresis

We review the wide range of polymeric materials that have been employed for DNA sequencing separations by capillary electrophoresis. Intensive research in the area has converged in showing that highly entangled solutions of hydrophilic, high molar mass polymers are required to achieve high DNA separation efficiency and long read length, system attributes that are particularly important for genomic sequencing. The extent of DNA-polymer interactions, as well as the robustness of the entangled polymer network, greatly influence the performance of a given polymer matrix for DNA separation. Further fundamental research in the field of polymer physics and chemistry is needed to elucidate the specific mechanisms by which DNA is separated in dynamic, uncross-linked polymer networks.

Effect of ionic strength, pH and polymer concentration on the separation of DNA fragments in the presence of electroosmotic flow

DNA separations in the presence of electroosmotic flow (EOF) using poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) solutions have been demonstrated. During the separations, PEO entered capillaries filled with Tris-borate (TB) free buffers by EOF and acted as sieving matrices. We have found that ionic strength and pH of polymer and free solutions affect the bulk EOF and resolution differently from that in capillary zone electrophoresis. The EOF coefficient increases with increasing ionic strength of the free TB buffers as a result of decreases in the adsorption of PEO molecules. In contrast, the bulk EOF decreases with increasing the ionic strength of polymer solutions using capillaries filled with high concentrations of free TB buffers. Although resolution values are high due to larger differential migration times between any two DNA fragments in a small bulk EOF using 10 mM TB buffers, use of a capillary filled with at least 100 mM TB free buffers is suggested for high-speed separations. On the side of PEO solutions, 1.5% PEO solutions prepared in 100 to 200 mM TB buffers are more proper in terms of resolution and speed. The separation of DNA markers V and VI was accomplished less than 29 min in 1.5% PEO solutions prepared in 100 mM TB buffers, pH 7.0 at 500 V/cm using a capillary filled with 10 mM free TB buffers, pH 7.0.

Capillary electrophoresis of drugs: current status in the analysis of pharmaceuticals

The current status of capillary electrophoresis (CE) in pharmaceutical analyses is reviewed with about 300 references, mainly from 1996 until 1999. This article covers the use of CE for assay and purity determination of the main component, analysis of natural medicines, antisense DNA, peptides, and proteins. Analysis of hydrophobic and/or electrically neutral drugs by electrokinetic chromatography, capillary electrochromatography and nonaqueous CE is critically evaluated. Detailed techniques for the separation of enantiomers are given in the text with some actual applications. Furthermore, this review includes sensitivity and regulatory aspects for the actual use of CE in new drug applications (NDA). The analytical validation required for CE in NDA is also treated.

Separation of double-stranded and single-stranded DNA in polymer solutions: II. Separation, peak width and resolution

The electrophoretic separation of single-stranded and double-stranded DNA has been examined, using a matrix of linear poly-N,N-dimethylacrylamide (pDMA). The dependence of peak spacing, peak width and resolution on important parameters such as polymer concentration, polymer chain length and electric field strength, has been studied. This work complements our systematic study on electrophoretic mobility under different conditions (C. Heller, Electrophoresis 1999, 20, 1962-1977), and will help to further optimize and improve high performance DNA separation in capillary electrophoresis with entangled polymer solutions.

Separation of double-stranded and single-stranded DNA in polymer solutions: I. Mobility and separation mechanism

We have studied the separation of single-stranded and double-stranded DNA in a matrix of entangled, linear poly-N,N-dimethylacrylamide. Our results give better insight into the mechanisms involved during separations in polymer solutions. The dependence of different parameters on DNA size, electric field, pore size and the polymer chain length are evaluated and compared to theoretical predictions. Striking differences between experimental data and predicted scaling laws are found. Our data should help to optimize DNA separation in capillary electrophoresis and to improve existing models for DNA separation in porous matrices.

A fully automated multicapillary electrophoresis device for DNA analysis

We describe the construction and performance of a fully automated multicapillary electrophoresis system for the analysis of fluorescently labeled biomolecules. A special detection system allows the simultaneous spectral analysis of all 96 capillaries. The main features are true parallel detection without any moving parts, high robustness, and full compatibility to existing protocols. The device can process up to 40 microtiter plates (96 and 384 well) without human interference, which means up to 15,000 samples before it has to be reloaded.

Electrophoretic separation of small DNA fragments in the presence of electroosmotic flow using poly(ethylene oxide) solutions

A new and simple method was demonstrated for separating phi X-174/Hae III DNA restriction fragments and DNA markers V and VI, respectively, without filling capillaries with polymer solutions prior to analysis. Using this novel method, poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) solutions containing ethidium bromide migrated into capillaries by electroosmotic flow (EOF) during the separation. Two DNA fragments (123 and 124 bp) in markers V and VI were well-resolved. RSD values for the separation of phi X-174/Hae III DNA restriction fragments were less than 0.52% for 3 runs using a single 75-micron capillary and less than 3.96% using three different 75-micron capillaries. A highly viscous polymer solution prepared from 3% PEO was also used for separation of DNA markers V and VI. Theoretical plates up to 11.91 million/m and separation times of less than 7 min were achieved in the separation of phi X-174/Hae III DNA restriction fragments using a 10-micron capillary and a 2% PEO solution. Advantages of this method include simplicity, short separation times, the ability to use highly viscous polymer solutions for separating small DNA fragments, and the possibility of introducing several different polymer solutions into capillaries to extend the DNA separation range.

Routine DNA sequencing of 1000 bases in less than one hour by capillary electrophoresis with replaceable linear polyacrylamide solutions

Long, accurate reads are an important factor for high-throughput de novo DNA sequencing. In previous work from this laboratory, a separation matrix of high-weight-average molecular mass (HMM) linear polyacrylamide (LPA) at a concentration of 2% (w/w) was used to separate 1000 bases of DNA sequence in 80 min with an accuracy close to 97% (Carrilho, E.; et al. Anal. Chem. 1996, 68, 3305-3313). In the present work, significantly improved speed and sequencing accuracy have been achieved by further optimization of factors affecting electrophoretic separation and data processing. A replaceable matrix containing a mixture of 2.0% (w/w) HMM (9 MDa) and 0.5% (w/w) low-weight-average molecular mass (50 kDa) LPA was employed to enhance the separation of DNA sequencing fragments in CE. Experimental conditions, such as electric field strength and column temperature, as well as internal diameter of the capillary column, have been optimized for this mixed separation matrix. Under these conditions, in combination with energy-transfer (BigDye) dye-labeled primers for high signal-to-noise ratio and a newly developed expert system for base calling, the electrophoretic separation of 1000 DNA sequencing fragments of both standard (M13mp18) and cloned single-stranded templates from human chromosome 17 could be routinely achieved in less than 55 min, with a base-calling accuracy between 98 and 99%. Identical read length, accuracy, and migration time were achieved in more than 300 consecutive runs in a single column.

Recent developments in DNA electrophoretic separations

DNA electrophoresis is now a fairly mature technology. Nevertheless, as we approach the 21st century, new ideas are frequently suggested that could lead to a revolution for DNA sequencing and mapping. Here, we review some of the novel concepts that have been studied since ca. 1990. Our review focuses on new separation mechanisms, new sieving matrices and recent conceptual advances.

Advances in capillary electrophoresis

This review summarizes the advancement in operational modes and selected applications of the title technique over the past five years. Regarding operational modes particular emphasis is put upon increasing selectivity and resolution, hyphenation of capillary electrophoresis with techniques based on other than electromigration principles, the so-called chip technology and new ways of detection. In applications selected examples of chiral separation and separation of biopolymers (proteins, nucleic acids) are emphasized. It is demonstrated that capillary electrophoresis represents a complementary technique to high-performance column chromatography and in a number of cases it offers better separations than standard chromatographic procedures.