Effect of residual noise level on reproducibility of the signal-averaged ECG

Uncertainty principle of signal-averaged electrocardiography

BACKGROUND

Signal-averaged ECG (SAECG) reproducibility is reported to have a component that is independent of residual noise. Methods and Results-In group 1, multiple paired SAECGs were obtained to noise levels of 0.3+/-0.1 and 0.5+/-0.2 microV. For the 0.5- and 0. 3-microV noise recordings, QRS duration (QRSd) was 101.2+/-11.3 and 104.6+/-9.6 ms, respectively (P<0.0001), and the differences in paired QRSd (DeltaQRSd) were normally distributed, with variances of 11.4 and 26.2 ms(2) (P<0.0001). Paired SAECGs were obtained in group 2 patients without and with late potentials; DeltaQRSd variance was 3.3 and 217.9 ms(2) (P<0.0001). In group 3, >/=10 SAECGs were acquired at noise levels of 0.2 to 0.8 microV, in 0.1-microV increments. QRSd increased as noise level decreased. The variance was greater in low-noise (0.2 to 0.4 microV) versus higher-noise (0. 5 to 0.8 microV) recordings. In group 4, SAECGs were analyzed with bidirectional and Bispec filters, with no difference in QRSd between the 2 filters and a normally distributed DeltaQRSd. A computer simulation demonstrated that alterations in the phase relationship of noise to signal results in a normal distribution of signal end points.

CONCLUSIONS

Within the acceptable noise range for SAECG, lower noise results in longer QRSd and larger variance, suggesting that more accurate recordings may have less reproducibility. The random timing of noise relative to signal results in the distribution/variance of repeated measurements. Statistical strategies may be used to reduce some of this variance and may enhance the diagnostic utility of SAECG.

Effect of parasympathetic blockade on the signal-averaged electrocardiogram

Low parasympathetic activity is associated with late potentials detected at a noise level of 0.4 microV in a signal-averaged electrocardiogram (SAECG) following myocardial infarction. In contrast, at a noise level of 0.2 microV, lowering parasympathetic activity influences late potential parameters in the opposite direction in healthy subjects. The aim of this study was to estimate the relationship between parasympathetic activity and the SAECG obtained at noise levels of 0.4 and 0.2 microV in healthy subjects. Two SAECG recordings in 10 healthy subjects were obtained at noise levels of 0.2 and 0.4 microV before and after parasympathetic blockade using atropine (1 mg). Signal-averaged QRS duration (SA-QRS), late potential duration (LPD) defined as duration of terminal signals below 40 microV, and root mean square voltage of the terminal 40 ms of the averaged QRS (RMS40) were measured. At a noise level of 0.2 microV SA-QRS reduced from 124 +/- 14 to 114 +/- 17 ms (P = 0.008), LPD from 37 +/- 10 to 28 +/- 14 ms (P = 0.01), and RMS40 increased from 26 +/- 22 to 41 +/- 25 microV (P = 0.006) during parasympathetic blockade compared to baseline values. At a noise level of 0.4 microV the SA-QRS (115 +/- 15 ms) and LPD (29 +/- 11 ms) were lower and the RMS40 (37 +/- 23 microV) was higher compared to the noise level 0.2 microV, and no systematic alterations of the three variables were found during parasympathetic blockade. The parasympathetic nervous system may induce a very low-amplitude late potential in the SAECG. The data suggest that parasympathetic activity and a low noise level may lead to a false late potential-positive SAECG in low arrhythmia risk subjects. Therefore, we recommend the use of a noise level of 0.4 microV or identification of high arrhythmia risk patients by late potential and low parasympathetic activity.