Recognition of tRNA backbone for aminoacylation with cysteine: evolution from Escherichia coli to human

Structural diversity and protein engineering of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS) are the enzymes that ensure faithful transmission of genetic information in all living cells, and are central to the developing technologies for expanding the capacity of the translation apparatus to incorporate nonstandard amino acids into proteins in vivo. The 24 known aaRS families are divided into two classes that exhibit functional evolutionary convergence. Each class features an active site domain with a common fold that binds ATP, the amino acid, and the 3'-terminus of tRNA, embellished by idiosyncratic further domains that bind distal portions of the tRNA and enhance specificity. Fidelity in the expression of the genetic code requires that the aaRS be selective for both amino acids and tRNAs, a substantial challenge given the presence of structurally very similar noncognate substrates of both types. Here we comprehensively review central themes concerning the architectures of the protein structures and the remarkable dual-substrate selectivities, with a view toward discerning the most important issues that still substantially limit our capacity for rational protein engineering. A suggested general approach to rational design is presented, which should yield insight into the identities of the protein-RNA motifs at the heart of the genetic code, while also offering a basis for improving the catalytic properties of engineered tRNA synthetases emerging from genetic selections.

Interaction of human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase with specific tRNA according to thiophosphate footprinting

The interaction of human cytoplasmic phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase (an enzyme with yet unknown 3D-structure) with homologous tRNA(Phe) under functional conditions was studied by footprinting based on iodine cleavage of thiophosphate-substituted tRNA transcripts. Most tRNA(Phe) nucleotides recognized by the enzyme in the anticodon (G34), anticodon stem (G30-C40, A31-U39), and D-loop (G20) have effectively or moderately protected phosphates. Other important specificity elements (A35 and A36) were found to form weak nonspecific contacts. The D-stem, T-arm, and acceptor stem are also among continuous contacts of the tRNA(Phe) backbone with the enzyme, thus suggesting the presence of additional recognition elements in these regions. The data indicate that mechanisms of interaction between phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases and specific tRNAs are different in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Evolution of acceptor stem tRNA recognition by class II prolyl-tRNA synthetase

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (AARS) are an essential family of enzymes that catalyze the attachment of amino acids to specific tRNAs during translation. Previously, we showed that base-specific recognition of the tRNA(Pro) acceptor stem is critical for recognition by Escherichia coli prolyl-tRNA synthetase (ProRS), but not for human ProRS. To further delineate species-specific differences in acceptor stem recognition, atomic group mutagenesis was used to probe the role of sugar-phosphate backbone interactions in recognition of human tRNA(Pro). Incorporation of site-specific 2'-deoxynucleotides, as well as phosphorothioate and methylphosphonate modifications within the tRNA acceptor stem revealed an extensive network of interactions with specific functional groups proximal to the first base pair and the discriminator base. Backbone functional groups located at the base of the acceptor stem, especially the 2'-hydroxyl of A66, are also critical for aminoacylation catalytic efficiency by human ProRS. Therefore, in contrast to the bacterial system, backbone-specific interactions contribute significantly more to tRNA recognition by the human enzyme than base-specific interactions. Taken together with previous studies, these data show that ProRS-tRNA acceptor stem interactions have co-adapted through evolution from a mechanism involving 'direct readout' of nucleotide bases to one relying primarily on backbone-specific 'indirect readout'.

Interaction of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases with tRNA: general principles and distinguishing characteristics of the high-molecular-weight substrate recognition

This review summarizes results of numerous (mainly functional) studies that have been accumulated over recent years on the problem of tRNA recognition by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Development and employment of approaches that use synthetic mutant and chimeric tRNAs have demonstrated general principles underlying highly specific interaction in different systems. The specificity of interaction is determined by a certain number of nucleotides and structural elements of tRNA (constituting the set of recognition elements or specificity determinants), which are characteristic of each pair. Crystallographic structures available for many systems provide the details of the molecular basis of selective interaction. Diversity and identity of biochemical functions of the recognition elements make substantial contribution to the specificity of such interactions.

Acquisition of an Insertion Peptide for Efficient Aminoacylation by a Halophile tRNA Synthetase

Enzymes of halophilic organisms contain unusual peptide motifs that are absent from their mesophilic counterparts. The functions of these halophile-specific peptides are largely unknown. Here we have identified an unusual peptide that is unique to several halophile archaeal cysteinyl-tRNA synthetases (CysRS), which catalyze attachment of cysteine to tRNA(Cys) to generate the essential cysteinyl-tRNA(Cys) required for protein synthesis. This peptide is located near the active site in the catalytic domain and is highly enriched with acidic residues. In the CysRS of the extreme halophile Halobacterium species NRC-1, deletion of the peptide reduces the catalytic efficiency of aminoacylation by a factor of 100 that largely results from a defect in kcat, rather than the Km for tRNA(Cys). In contrast, maintaining the peptide length but substituting acidic residues in the peptide with neutral or basic residues has no major deleterious effect, suggesting that the acidity of the peptide is not important for the kcat of tRNA aminoacylation. Analysis of general protein structure under physiological high salt concentrations, by circular dichroism and by fluorescence titration of tRNA binding, indicates little change due to deletion of the peptide. However, the presence of the peptide confers tolerance to lower salt levels, and fluorescence analysis in 30% sucrose reveals instability of the enzyme without the peptide. We suggest that the stability associated with the peptide can be used to promote proper enzyme conformation transitions in various stages of tRNA aminoacylation that are associated with catalysis. The acquisition of the peptide by the halophilic CysRS suggests an enzyme adaptation to high salinity.

A method for coupled transcription and aminoacylation of cysteinyl-tRNA

A novel method for coupled transcription and aminoacylation of transfer RNA was developed where Escherichia coli cysteine-specific tRNA (tRNA(cys)) was transcribed and aminoacylated in a single reaction. The cys-tRNA(cys) that was synthesized and aminoacylated using this method was functional in in vitro translation. The cys-tRNA(cys) was further modified with biotin (N-iodoacetyl-N-biotinhexylenediamine) to facilitate detection. The biotin-modified cys-tRNAs(cys) was also functional in in vitro translation, allowing the synthesis and detection of biotin-labeled protein.

Shape-selective RNA recognition by cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase

The crystal structure of Escherichia coli cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase (CysRS) bound to tRNA(Cys) at a resolution of 2.3 A reveals base-specific and shape-selective interactions across an extensive protein-RNA recognition interface. The complex contains a mixed alpha/beta C-terminal domain, which is disordered in the unliganded enzyme. This domain makes specific hydrogen bonding interactions with all three bases of the GCA anticodon. The tRNA anticodon stem is bent sharply toward the enzyme as compared with its conformation when bound to elongation factor Tu, providing an essential basis for shape-selective recognition. The CysRS structure also reveals interactions of conserved enzyme groups with the sugar-phosphate backbone in the D loop, adjacent to an unusual G15.G48 tertiary base pair previously implicated in tRNA aminoacylation. A combined mutational analysis of enzyme and tRNA groups at G15.G48 supports the notion that contacts between CysRS and the sugar-phosphate backbone contribute to recognition by indirect readout.

Prokaryotic and eukaryotic tetrameric phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases display conservation of the binding mode of the tRNA(Phe) CCA end

The interaction of human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase, a eukaryotic prototype with an unknown three-dimensional structure, with the tRNA(Phe) acceptor end was studied by s(4)U-induced affinity cross-linking with human tRNA(Phe) derivatives site-specifically substituted at the single-stranded 3' end. Two different subunits of the enzyme bind two adjacent nucleotides of the tRNA(Phe) 3' end: nucleotide 76 is associated with the catalytic alpha subunit, while nucleotide 75 is in contact with the beta subunit. The binding mode is similar to that revealed previously in structural and affinity cross-linking studies of the prokaryotic Thermus thermophilus phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase. Our results suggest that the distinctive features of tRNA(Phe) acceptor end binding are conserved for the eukaryotic and prokaryotic tetrameric phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetases despite their significant differences in the domain composition of the beta subunits. The data from affinity cross-linking experiments with human phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase complexed with small ligands (ATP and/or phenylalanine or a stable synthetic analogue of phenylalanyl adenylate) reveal that the location of the tRNA(Phe) acceptor end varies with the presence and nature of other substrates. The lack of substrate activity of human tRNA(Phe) substituted with s(4)U at the 3'-terminal position suggests that base-specific interactions of the terminal adenosine are critically important for a productive interaction. The conformational rearrangement of the tRNA 3' end induced by the other substrates and dictated by base-specific contacts of the terminal nucleotide is an additional means of ensuring the phenylalanylation specificity in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems.

Aminoacylation of an unusual tRNA(Cys) from an extreme halophile

The extreme halophile Halobacterium species NRC-1 overcomes external near-saturating salt concentrations by accumulating intracellular salts comparable to those of the medium. This raises the fundamental question of how halophiles can maintain the specificity of protein-nucleic acid interactions that are particularly sensitive to high salts in mesophiles. Here we address the specificity of the essential aminoacylation reaction of the halophile, by focusing on molecular recognition of tRNA(Cys) by the cognate cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase. Despite the high salt environments of the aminoacylation reaction, and despite an unusual structure of the tRNA with an exceptionally large dihydrouridine loop, we show that aminoacylation of the tRNA proceeds with a catalytic efficiency similar to that of its mesophilic counterparts. This is manifested by an essentially identical K(m) for tRNA to those of the mesophiles, and by recognition of the same nucleotide determinants that are conserved in evolution. Interestingly, aminoacylation of the halophile tRNA(Cys) is more closely related to that of bacteria than eukarya by placing a strong emphasis on features of the tRNA tertiary core. This suggests an adaptation to the highly negatively charged tRNA sugar-phosphate backbone groups that are the key elements of the tertiary core.

Developments in RNA chemistry, a personal view

This review describes some of the contributions of chemistry to the RNA field with a personal bias towards the phosphorothioate modification and the derivatives at the ribose 2'-position. The usefulness of these modifications is discussed and documented with some examples.