Modulation of homo- and heterodimerization of Harvey sarcoma virus RNA by GACG tetraloops and point mutations in palindromic sequences

Cross- and Co-Packaging of Retroviral RNAs and Their Consequences

Retroviruses belong to the family Retroviridae and are ribonucleoprotein (RNP) particles that contain a dimeric RNA genome. Retroviral particle assembly is a complex process, and how the virus is able to recognize and specifically capture the genomic RNA (gRNA) among millions of other cellular and spliced retroviral RNAs has been the subject of extensive investigation over the last two decades. The specificity towards RNA packaging requires higher order interactions of the retroviral gRNA with the structural Gag proteins. Moreover, several retroviruses have been shown to have the ability to cross-/co-package gRNA from other retroviruses, despite little sequence homology. This review will compare the determinants of gRNA encapsidation among different retroviruses, followed by an examination of our current understanding of the interaction between diverse viral genomes and heterologous proteins, leading to their cross-/co-packaging. Retroviruses are well-known serious animal and human pathogens, and such a cross-/co-packaging phenomenon could result in the generation of novel viral variants with unknown pathogenic potential. At the same time, however, an enhanced understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved in these specific interactions makes retroviruses an attractive target for anti-viral drugs, vaccines, and vectors for human gene therapy.

Murine leukemia virus RNA dimerization is coupled to transcription and splicing processes

Most of the cell biological aspects of retroviral genome dimerization remain unknown. Murine leukemia virus (MLV) constitutes a useful model to study when and where dimerization occurs within the cell. For instance, MLV produces a subgenomic RNA (called SD') that is co-packaged with the genomic RNA predominantly as FLSD' heterodimers. This SD' RNA is generated by splicing of the genomic RNA and also by direct transcription of a splice-associated retroelement of MLV (SDARE). We took advantage of these two SD' origins to study the effects of transcription and splicing events on RNA dimerization. Using genetic approaches coupled to capture of RNA heterodimer in virions, we determined heterodimerization frequencies in different cellular contexts. Several cell lines were stably established in which SD' RNA was produced by either splicing or transcription from SDARE. Moreover, SDARE was integrated into the host chromosome either concomitantly or sequentially with the genomic provirus. Our results showed that transcribed genomic and SD' RNAs preferentially formed heterodimers when their respective proviruses were integrated together. In contrast, heterodimerization was strongly affected when the two proviruses were integrated independently. Finally, dimerization was enhanced when the transcription sites were expected to be physically close. For the first time, we report that splicing and RNA dimerization appear to be coupled. Indeed, when the RNAs underwent splicing, the FLSD' dimerization reached a frequency similar to co-transcriptional heterodimerization. Altogether, our results indicate that randomness of heterodimerization increases when RNAs are co-expressed during either transcription or splicing. Our results strongly support the notion that dimerization occurs in the nucleus, at or near the transcription and splicing sites, at areas of high viral RNA concentration.

The packaging signal of MLV is an integrated module that mediates intracellular transport of genomic RNAs

Packaging of MLV genomes requires four cis-acting stem-loops. Stem-loops A and B are self-complementary and bind Gag in their dimeric form, while the C and D elements mediate loop-loop interactions that facilitate RNA dimerization. Packaging also requires nuclear export of viral genomes, and their cytoplasmic transport toward the plasma membrane. For MLV, this is mediated by Gag and Env, and occurs on endosomal vesicles. Here, we report that MLV Psi acts at several steps during the transport of genomic RNAs. First, deletion of stem-loop B or C leads to the accumulation of genomic RNAs in the nucleus, suggesting that these elements are involved in export. Second, in chronically infected cells, mutation of the C and D loops impairs endosomal transport. This suggests that RNA dimerization is essential for vesicular transport, consistent with its proposed requirement for Gag binding. Surprisingly, deletion of stem-loop A blocks vesicular transport, whereas removal of stem-loop B has no effects. This suggests that stem-loop A has unique functions in packaging, not predicted from previous in vitro analyses. Finally, in packaging cells that do not express any Psi-containing RNA, endosomal RNA transport becomes sequence-independent. This non-specific activity of Gag likely promotes packaging of cellular mRNAs.

RNA flexibility in the dimerization domain of a gamma retrovirus

Retroviruses are the causative agents of serious diseases, such as acquired immunodeficiency syndromes and several cancers, and are also useful gene therapy vectors. Retroviruses contain two sense-strand RNA genomes, which become linked at their 5' ends to form an RNA dimer. Understanding the molecular basis for dimerization may yield new approaches for controlling viral infectivity. Because this RNA domain is highly conserved within retrovirus groups, it has not been possible to define a consensus structure for the 5' dimerization domain by comparative sequence analysis. Here, we defined a 170-nucleotide minimal dimerization active sequence (MiDAS) for a representative gamma retrovirus, the Moloney murine sarcoma virus, by stringent competitive dimerization. We then analyzed the structure at every nucleotide in the MiDAS monomeric starting state with quantitative selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension (SHAPE) chemistry. Notably, SHAPE analysis demonstrated that the RNA monomer contains an extensive flexible domain spanning 50 nucleotides. These findings support a structural model in which RNA flexibility directly facilitates retroviral genome dimerization by reducing the energetic cost of disrupting pre-existing base pairings in the monomer.

Identification and visualization of the dimerization initiation site of the prototype lentivirus, maedi visna virus: a potential GACG tetraloop displays structural homology with the alpha- and gamma-retroviruses

Dimerization of retroviral genomic RNA is essential for efficient viral replication and is mediated by structural interactions between identical RNA motifs in the viral leader region. We have visualized, by electron microscopy, RNA dimers formed from the leader region of the prototype lentivirus, maedi visna virus. Characterization by in vitro assays of the domains responsible for this interaction has identified a 20 nucleotide sequence that functions as the core dimerization initiation site. This region is predicted to form a GACG tetraloop and therefore differs significantly from the kissing loop palindromes utilized to initiate dimerization in primate lentiviruses. The motif is strongly conserved across the ovine and caprine lentiviruses, implying a critical functional role. Furthermore, the proposed GACG tetraloop exhibits marked structural homology with similar structural motifs present in the leader regions of the alpha- and gamma-retroviruses, and the maedi visna virus dimer linkage region is capable of forming heterodimeric species with the Moloney murine leukemia virus Psi domain. This may be indicative of commonality of origin of the two viruses or convergent evolution.

Complementarity between RNA dimerization elements favors formation of functional heterozygous murine leukemia viruses

The cis-elements that direct packaging and dimerization of retroviral RNAs overlap, and it has been suggested that dimerization is required for RNA packaging. This also implies that heterodimerization would be necessary for co-packaging and recombination. Moreover, co-packaging of distinct RNAs may be reduced if incapable of heterodimerizing. In this study, we have designed a novel two-vector rescue system in which co-packaging and interstrand transfer are necessary for transduction. Thus, the rescue titer is a measure of the ability of a given vector combination to co-package and subsequently generate a provirus. In the current MLV-based set-up, we explored Akv- and MLV-like-endogenous virus (MLEV)-derived vectors with modulated dimerization signals. Results show that rescue is influenced by competition at the level of RNA packaging, as well as complementarity between dimerization elements. Altogether, the results support the hypothesis that complementarity between dimerization elements may favor co-packaging of distinct retroviral RNAs.

mRNA molecules containing murine leukemia virus packaging signals are encapsidated as dimers

Prior work by others has shown that insertion of psi (i.e., leader) sequences from the Moloney murine leukemia virus (MLV) genome into the 3' untranslated region of a nonviral mRNA leads to the specific encapsidation of this RNA in MLV particles. We now report that these RNAs are, like genomic RNAs, encapsidated as dimers. These dimers have the same thermostability as MLV genomic RNA dimers; like them, these dimers are more stable if isolated from mature virions than from immature virions. We characterized encapsidated mRNAs containing deletions or truncations of MLV psi or with psi sequences from MLV-related acute transforming viruses. The results indicate that the dimeric linkage in genomic RNA can be completely attributed to the psi region of the genome. While this conclusion agrees with earlier electron microscopic studies on mature MLV dimers, it is the first evidence as to the site of the linkage in immature dimers for any retrovirus. Since the Psi(+) mRNA is not encapsidated as well as genomic RNA, it is only present in a minority of virions. The fact that it is nevertheless dimeric argues strongly that two of these molecules are packaged into particles together. We also found that the kissing loop is unnecessary for this coencapsidation or for the stability of mature dimers but makes a major contribution to the stability of immature dimers. Our results are consistent with the hypothesis that the packaging signal involves a dimeric structure in which the RNAs are joined by intermolecular interactions between GACG loops.

The retroviral RNA dimer linkage: different structures may reflect different roles

Retroviruses are unique among virus families in having dimeric genomes. The RNA sequences and structures that link the two RNA molecules vary, and these differences provide clues as to the role of this feature in the viral lifecycles. This review draws upon examples from different retroviral families. Differences and similarities in both secondary and tertiary structure are discussed. The implication of varying roles for the dimer linkage in related viruses is considered.

Efficient replication of full-length murine leukemia viruses modified at the dimer initiation site regions

Retroviruses encapsidate two copies of full-length viral RNA molecules linked together as a dimeric genome. RNA stem loop structures harboring palindromic (or "kissing") loop sequences constitute important cis-elements for viral dimerization known as dimer initiation sites (DIS). In murine leukemia virus (MLV), a 10-mer and a 16-mer palindrome (DIS-1 and DIS-2, respectively) located in the viral leader region mediate dimerization in vitro and affect dimer stability of vector RNA in vivo. We have investigated the effect on viral replication of introducing deletions or nucleotide substitutions within these palindromes in a full-length MLV genome. Our results demonstrate that viruses modified at the dimer initiation site regions are viable and show wild-type levels of RNA encapsidation. One mutant lacking the DIS-1 palindrome was severely impaired and displayed an increased cellular ratio of spliced versus genomic RNA that most likely contributes to the inefficient replication. The implications for development of DIS-modified retrovirus-based vectors are discussed.

Complementarity-directed RNA dimer-linkage promotes retroviral recombination in vivo

Retroviral particles contain a dimeric RNA genome, which serves as template for the generation of double-stranded DNA by reverse transcription. Transfer between RNA strands during DNA synthesis is governed by both sequence similarity between templates and structural features of the dimeric RNA. A kissing hairpin, believed to facilitate intermolecular recognition and dimer formation, was previously found to be a preferred site for recombination. To investigate if hairpin loop-loop-complementarity is the primary determinant for this recombination preference, we have devised a novel 5' leader recombination assay based upon co-packaging of two wild-type or loop-modified murine leukemia virus vector RNAs. We found that insertion of an alternative palindromic loop in one of the two vectors disrupted site-directed template switching, whereas site-specificity was restored between vectors with complementary non-wild-type palindromes. By pairing vector RNAs that contained identical non-palindromic loop motifs and that were unlikely to interact by loop-loop kissing, we found no preference for recombination at the kissing hairpin site. Of vector pairs designed to interact through base pairing of non-palindromic loop motifs, we could in one case restore hairpin-directed template switching, in spite of the reduced sequence identity, whereas another pair failed to support hairpin- directed recombination. However, analyses of in vitro RNA dimerization of all studied vector combinations showed a good correlation between efficient dimer formation between loop-modified viral RNAs and in vivo cDNA transfer at the kissing hairpin. Our findings demonstrate that complementarity between wild-type or non-wild-type hairpin kissing loops is essential but not sufficient for site-specific 5' leader recombination and lend further support to the hypothesis that a specific 'kissing' loop-loop interaction is guided by complementary sequences and maintained within the mature dimeric RNA of retroviruses.