Structural study of the yeast RNA polymerase A. Electron microscopy of lipid-bound molecules and two-dimensional crystals

Odd RNA polymerases or the A(B)C of eukaryotic transcription

Pioneering studies on eukaryotic transcription were undertaken with the bacterial system in mind. Will the bacterial paradigm apply to eukaryotes? Are there promoter sites scattered in the eukaryotic genome, and sigma-like proteins? Why three forms of RNA polymerase in eukaryotic cells? Why are they structurally so complex, in particular RNA polymerases I and III, compared to the bacterial enzyme? These questions and others that were raised along the way are evoked in this short historical survey of odd RNA polymerases studies, with some emphasis on the contribution of these studies to our global understanding of eukaryotic transcription systems. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Transcription by Odd Pols.

Two-dimensional crystallisation of soluble protein complexes

This method aims at providing structural information on protein or nucleoprotein complexes by high-resolution electron microscopy. The objective is to promote the self-assembly of the macromolecules into two-dimensional crystals in order to use electron crystallography methods. When combined with observations in the frozen hydrated states and dedicated image processing software these methods can provide detailed 3-D models of the complex. The 2-D crystals of soluble nucleoprotein complexes are formed on lipid monolayers spread at the air-water interface. The macromolecule of interest is targeted to the monolayer by either electrostatic or ligand-induced interactions with the hydrophilic head group of the lipid. Upon interaction with the lipids, the nucleoprotein complex is concentrated at the vicinity of the lipid layer whose in-plane mobility facilitates the contacts between macromolecules and the formation of ordered arrays.

Cryo-negative staining reveals conformational flexibility within yeast RNA polymerase I

The structure of the yeast DNA-dependent RNA polymerase I (RNA Pol I), prepared by cryo-negative staining, was studied by electron microscopy. A structural model of the enzyme at a resolution of 1.8 nm was determined from the analysis of isolated molecules and showed an excellent fit with the atomic structure of the RNA Pol II Delta4/7. The high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the stained molecular images revealed a conformational flexibility within the image data set that could be recovered in three-dimensions after implementation of a novel strategy to sort the "open" and "closed" conformations in our heterogeneous data set. This conformational change mapped in the "wall/flap" domain of the second largest subunit (beta-like) and allows a better accessibility of the DNA-binding groove. This displacement of the wall/flap domain could play an important role in the transition between initiation and elongation state of the enzyme. Moreover, a protrusion was apparent in the cryo-negatively stained model, which was absent in the atomic structure and was not detected in previous 3D models of RNA Pol I. This structure could, however, be detected in unstained views of the enzyme obtained from frozen hydrated 2D crystals, indicating that this novel feature is not induced by the staining process. Unexpectedly, negatively charged molybdenum compounds were found to accumulate within the DNA-binding groove, which is best explained by the highly positive electrostatic potential of this region of the molecule, thus, suggesting that the stain distribution reflects the overall surface charge of the molecule.

Structure analysis of soluble proteins using electron crystallography

Electron crystallography as a structural determination technique has grown dramatically in use over recent years. Improvements in microscopes, equipment, practical techniques, computation facilities and image processing methods are reflected in the increasing number of near-atomic resolution structures that have been published. In this review we shall summarize the techniques involved in structure determination of soluble proteins using electron crystallography. Many soluble protein structures have been investigated in this manner over the past two decades. Here we present several examples where a variety of approaches have been used to gradually increase the information obtained.

Association of yeast RNA polymerase I with a nucleolar substructure active in rRNA synthesis and processing

A novel ribonucleoprotein complex enriched in nucleolar proteins was purified from yeast extracts and constituents were identified by mass spectrometry. When isolated from rapidly growing cells, the assembly contained ribonucleic acid (RNA) polymerase (pol) I, and some of its transcription factors like TATA-binding protein (TBP), Rrn3p, Rrn5p, Rrn7p, and Reb1p along with rRNA processing factors, like Nop1p, Cbf5p, Nhp2p, and Rrp5p. The small nucleolar RNAs (snoRNAs) U3, U14, and MRP were also found to be associated with the complex, which supports accurate transcription, termination, and pseudouridylation of rRNA. Formation of the complex did not depend on pol I, and the complex could efficiently recruit exogenous pol I into active ribosomal DNA (rDNA) transcription units. Visualization of the complex by electron microscopy and immunogold labeling revealed a characteristic cluster-forming network of nonuniform size containing nucleolar proteins like Nop1p and Fpr3p and attached pol I. Our results support the idea that a functional nucleolar subdomain formed independently of the state of rDNA transcription may serve as a scaffold for coordinated rRNA synthesis and processing.

Two-dimensional crystallization of streptavidin: in pursuit of the molecular origins of structure, morphology, and thermodynamics

The streptavidin two-dimensional (2D) crystallization model has served as a paradigm for molecular self-assembly at interfaces. We have developed quantitative Brewster angle microscopy for the in situ measurement of spatially resolved relative protein surface densities. This allows investigation of both the thermodynamics and morphologies of 2D crystal growth. For crystal structure analysis, we employ TEM on grown crystals transferred to solid substrates. Comparison of results between commercially available streptavidin, recombinant streptavidin, and site-directed streptavidin mutants has provided insight into the protein protein and protein-lipid interactions that underlie 2D crystallization.

Interactions between the full complement of human RNA polymerase II subunits

As an approach to elucidating the rules governing the assembly of human RNA polymerase II (hRPB), interactions between its subunits have been systematically analyzed. Eleven of the 12 expected hRPB subunits have previously been tested for reciprocal interactions (J. Biol. Chem. 272 (1997) 16815-16821). We now report the results obtained for the last subunit (hRPB4; Mol. Cell. Biol. 18 (1998) 1935-1945) and propose an essentially complete picture of the potential interactions occurring within hRPB. Finally, complementation experiments in yeast indicated that hRPB4 expression efficiently cured both heat and cold-sensitivity of RPB4-lacking strains, supporting the existence of conserved functional subunit interactions.

Structure and function of a membrane-bound murine MHC class I molecule

MHC molecules are expressed at the surface of nucleated cells to present peptides to T cells. Structural information on MHC molecules has been gathered by x-ray crystallography techniques by using soluble proteins. Although relationships between MHC molecules and cell membranes have not been studied in detail, they are of critical importance for T cell recognition. Using a chemically modified lipid, we have been able to capture and orient histidine-tagged MHC molecules on lipid membranes. Surface plasmon resonance experiments show that the protein binds to the nickel lipid in a specific manner and in an oriented fashion, which allows T cell receptor binding. Similar lipid surfaces have been used to grow two-dimensional crystals and to determine the structure of a membrane-anchored murine H-2Kb MHC class I molecule. The docking of the crystallographic structure into the three-dimensional reconstructed structure derived from the two-dimensional crystals allows us to determine that the histidine tag is near the membrane surface and that the MHC molecule is in an upright position, exposing the peptide/alpha1-alpha2 domains toward the T cell.

Synthesis of Enzymatically Stable Analogues of GDP for Binding Studies with Transducin, the G-Protein of the Visual Photoreceptor

The synthesis of five enzymatically stable analogues of guanosine diphosphate (GDP) has been carried out. The pyrophosphate moiety was mimicked in turn by the malonate, the acetophosphonate, the phosphonoacetate, the methylene-bis-phosphonate, and the imidodiphosphate groups. All the compounds were prepared via the synthesis of a transient fully protected nucleoside diphosphate analogue, and the final deprotection step was achieved by catalytic hydrogenolysis. The biological properties of the compounds have been evaluated toward transducin, the G-protein of the visual photoreceptor. Three guanosine imidodiphosphate derivatives bearing a linker at different positions on the sugar and on the base were then prepared and evaluated, giving some insight into the GDP binding site of transducin.

Characterization of the growth of 2D protein crystals on a lipid monolayer by ellipsometry and rigidity measurements coupled to electron microscopy

We present here some sensitive optical and mechanical experiments for monitoring the process of formation and growth of two-dimensional (2D) crystals of proteins on a lipid monolayer at an air-water interface. The adsorption of proteins on the lipid monolayer was monitored by ellipsometry measurements. An instrument was developed to measure the shear elastic constant (in plane rigidity) of the monolayer. These experiments have been done using cholera toxin B subunit (CTB) and annexin V as model proteins interacting with a monosialoganglioside (GM1) and dioleoylphosphatidylserine (DOPS), respectively. Electron microscopy observations of the protein-lipid layer transferred to grids were systematically used as a control. We found a good correlation between the measured in-plane rigidity of the monolayer and the presence of large crystalline domains observed by electron microscopy grids. Our interpretation of these data is that the crystallization process of proteins on a lipid monolayer passes through at least three successive stages: 1) molecular recognition between protein and lipid-ligand, i.e., adsorption of the protein on the lipid layer; 2) nucleation and growth of crystalline patches whose percolation is detected by the appearance of a non-zero in-plane rigidity; and 3) annealing of the layer producing a slower increase of the lateral or in-plane rigidity.

Structure of wild-type yeast RNA polymerase II and location of Rpb4 and Rpb7

The three-dimensional structure of wild-type yeast RNA polymerase II has been determined at a nominal resolution of 24 A. A difference map between this structure and that of the polymerase lacking subunits Rpb4 and Rpb7 showed these two subunits forming part of the floor of the DNA-binding (active center) cleft, and revealed a slight inward movement of the protein domain surrounding the cleft. Surface plasmon resonance measurements showed that Rpb4 and Rpb7 stabilize a minimal pre-initiation complex containing promoter DNA, TATA box-binding protein (TBP), transcription factor TFIIB and the polymerase. These findings suggest that Rpb4 and Rpb7 play a role in coupling the entry of DNA into the active center cleft to closure of the cleft. Such a role can explain why these subunits are necessary for promoter-specific transcription in vitro and for a normal stress response in vivo.

Specific interaction and two-dimensional crystallization of histidine tagged yeast RNA polymerase I on nickel-chelating lipids

Nickel-chelating lipid monolayers were used to generate two-dimensional crystals from yeast RNA polymerase I that was histidine-tagged on one of its subunits. The interaction of the enzyme with the spread lipid layers was found to be imidazole dependent, and the formation of two-dimensional crystals required small amounts of imidazole, probably to select the specific interaction of the engineered tag with the nickel. Two distinct preparations of RNA polymerase I tagged on different subunits yielded two different crystal forms, indicating that the position of the tag determines the crystallization process. The orientation of the enzyme in both crystal forms is correlated with the location of the tagged subunits in a three-dimensional model which shows that the tagged subunits are in contact with the lipid layer.

Resolution of RNA polymerase I into dimers and monomers and their function in transcription

We have further analyzed the requirements of yeast RNA polymerase I (pol I) to initiate transcription at the ribosomal gene promoter. Resolution of yeast whole cell extracts through several chromatographic steps yielded three protein fractions required for accurate initiation. One fraction is composed of TBP associated within a 240 kDa protein complex. The fraction contributing the RNA polymerase I (pol I) activity consists of dimeric and monomeric pol I under conditions optimal for in vitro transcription. The capability to utilize the ribosomal gene promoter correlates with monomeric pol I complexes which are possibly associated with further transcription factors. These initiation competent pol I complexes appeared to be resistant to high salt concentrations. Pol I dimers which represent the majority of the isolated pol I, can be reversibly dissociated into monomers and are only active in non-specific RNA synthesis, if single stranded DNA serves as a template. We suggest a model in which dimeric inactive pol I is converted into an active monomeric form that might be associated with other transcription factors to maintain a stable initiation competent complex.

Interactions between the human RNA polymerase II subunits

As an initial approach to characterizing the molecular structure of the human RNA polymerase II (hRPB), we systematically investigated the protein-protein contacts that the subunits of this enzyme may establish with each other. To this end, we applied a glutathione S-transferase-pulldown assay to extracts from Sf9 insect cells, which were coinfected with all possible combinations of recombinant baculoviruses expressing hRPB subunits, either as untagged polypeptides or as glutathione S-transferase fusion proteins. This is the first comprehensive study of interactions between eukaryotic RNA polymerase subunits; among the 116 combinations of hRPB subunits tested, 56 showed significant to strong interactions, whereas 60 were negative. Within the intricate network of interactions, subunits hRPB3 and hRPB5 play a central role in polymerase organization. These subunits, which are able to homodimerize and to interact, may constitute the nucleation center for polymerase assembly, by providing a large interface to most of the other subunits.

Two-dimensional crystallography of TFIIB- and IIE-RNA polymerase II complexes: implications for start site selection and initiation complex formation

SUMMARY

Transcription factors IIB (TFIIB) and IIE (TFIIE) bound to RNA polymerase II have been revealed by electron crystallography in projection at 15.7 A resolution. The results lead to simple hypotheses for the roles of these factors in the initiation of transcription. TFIIB is suggested to define the distance from TATA box to transcription start site by bringing TATA DNA in contact with polymerase at that distance from the active center of the enzyme. TFIIE is suggested to participate in a key conformational switch occurring at the active center upon polymerase-DNA interaction.

Three-dimensional structure of E. coli core RNA polymerase: promoter binding and elongation conformations of the enzyme

The structure of E. coli core RNA polymerase (RNAP) has been determined to approximately 23 A resolution by three-dimensional reconstruction from electron micrographs of flattened helical crystals. The structure reveals extensive conformational changes when compared with the previously determined E. coli RNAP holoenzyme structure, but resembles the yeast RNAPII structure. While each of these structures contains a thumb-like projection surrounding a channel 25 A in diameter, the E. coli RNAP holoenzyme thumb defines a deep but open groove on the molecule, whereas the thumb of E. coli core and yeast RNAPII form part of a ring that surrounds the channel. This may define promoter-binding and elongation conformations of RNAP, as E. coli holoenzyme recognizes promoter sites on double-stranded DNA, while both E. coli core and yeast RNAPII are elongating forms of the polymerase and are incapable of promoter recognition.

Evolution of viral DNA-dependent RNA polymerases

The DNA-dependent RNA polymerase (DdRP or RNAP) is an essential enzyme of transcription of replicating systems of prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms as well as cytoplasmic DNA viruses. DdRPs are complex multisubunit enzymes consisting of 8-14 subunits, including two large subunits and several smaller polypeptides (small subunits). An extensive search between the amino acid sequences of the known largest subunit of DNA-dependent RNA polymerases (RPO1) of different organisms indicates that all these polypeptides possess a universal heptapeptide NADFDGD in domain D. All RPO1 harbor a second well-conserved hexapeptide RQP(TS)LH upstream (26-31 amino acids) of the universal motif. The genes encoding the largest subunit of DdRP of insect iridescent virus type 6 (IIV6), fish lymphocystis disease virus (LCDV), and molluscum contagiosum virus (MCV-1), all members of the group of cytoplasmic DNA viruses, were identified by PCR technology. With the exception of IIV6, all other viral RPO1 possess the two C-terminal conserved regions G and H. The lack of C-terminal repetitive heptapeptide (YSPTSPS), which is a common feature of the largest subunit of eukaryotic RNAPII, is an additional characteristic of RPO1 proteins of LCDV and of MCV-1. All viral RPO1 proteins were found to be lacking the amino acid N at a distinct position in domain F. This amino acid is known to be highly conserved in alpha-amanitin-sensitive eukaryotic RNA polymerases II. Comparison of the amino acid sequences of the RPO1 polypeptides of IIV6, LCDV, and MCV-1 with the corresponding prokaryotic, eukaryotic, and viral proteins revealed differences in amino acid similarity and phylogenetic relationships. IIV6 RPO1 possesses the closest similarity to the homologous subunit of eukaryotic RNAPII and lower but also significant similarity to that of eukaryotic RNAPI and RNAPIII, archaeal, eubacterial, and viral polymerases. The similarity between RPO1 of IIV6 and the cellular polymerase subunits is consistently higher than to the RPO1 of other cytoplasmic DNA viruses, for example, vaccinia and variola virus, African swine fever virus (ASFV), and MCV-1. The RPO1 of LCDV shows the highest similarity to the RPO1 of IIV6 and significant lower similarity to the eukaryotic polymerases II and III as well as to the archaebacteral subunit. However, it is still considerably more similar to the cellular polymerase subunits than to the homologous viral proteins. The RPO1 of IIV6 possesses more similarity to cellular polymerases than the complete RPO1 of LCDV, indicating that there is a substantial difference in the organization of the RPO1 genes between these members of two genera of the Iridoviridae family. Analysis of the MCV-1 RPO1 revealed high amino acid homologies to the corresponding polypeptides of vaccinia and variola virus. The viral RPO1 proteins, including vaccinia and variola virus, MCV-1, ASFV, IIV6, and LCDV, share the common feature of showing the highest similarity to the largest subunit of eukaryotic RNAPII than to that of RNAPI, RNAPIII, and RPO1 of archaebacterias, eubacterias, ASFV, IIV6, and LCDV. Evolution of the individual largest subunit of DdRPs was tentatively investigated by generating phylogenetic trees using multiple amino acid alignments. These indicate that the RPO1 proteins of IIV6 and LCDV might have evolved from the largest subunit of eukaryotic RNAPII after divergence from the homologous subunits of RNAPI and RNAPIII. In contrast, evolutionary development of the RPO1 of vaccinia and variola virus, MCV-1, and ASFV seems to be quite different, with their common ancestor diverging from cellular homologues before the separation of the three types of eukaryotic ploymerases and having probably diverged earlier from their common lineage with cellular proteins.

Genetics of eukaryotic RNA polymerases I, II, and III

The transcription of nucleus-encoded genes in eukaryotes is performed by three distinct RNA polymerases termed I, II, and III, each of which is a complex enzyme composed of more than 10 subunits. The isolation of genes encoding subunits of eukaryotic RNA polymerases from a wide spectrum of organisms has confirmed previous biochemical and immunological data indicating that all three enzymes are closely related in structures that have been conserved in evolution. Each RNA polymerase is an enzyme complex composed of two large subunits that are homologous to the two largest subunits of prokaryotic RNA polymerases and are associated with smaller polypeptides, some of which are common to two or to all three eukaryotic enzymes. This remarkable conservation of structure most probably underlies a conservation of function and emphasizes the likelihood that information gained from the study of RNA polymerases from one organism will be applicable to others. The recent isolation of many mutations affecting the structure and/or function of eukaryotic and prokaryotic RNA polymerases now makes it feasible to begin integrating genetic and biochemical information from various species in order to develop a picture of these enzymes. The picture of eukaryotic RNA polymerases depicted in this article emphasizes the role(s) of different polypeptide regions in interaction with other subunits, cofactors, substrates, inhibitors, or accessory transcription factors, as well as the requirement for these interactions in transcription initiation, elongation, pausing, termination, and/or enzyme assembly. Most mutations described here have been isolated in eukaryotic organisms that have well-developed experimental genetic systems as well as amenable biochemistry, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Drosophila melanogaster, and Caenorhabditis elegans. When relevant, mutations affecting regions of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase that are conserved among eukaryotes and prokaryotes are also presented. In addition to providing information about the structure and function of eukaryotic RNA polymerases, the study of mutations and of the pleiotropic phenotypes they imposed has underscored the central role played by these enzymes in many fundamental processes such as development and cellular differentiation.

2D crystallization: from art to science

The techniques as well as the principles of the 2D crystallization of membrane and water-soluble proteins for electron crystallography are reviewed. First, the biophysics of the interactions between proteins, lipids and detergents is surveyed. Second, crystallization of membrane proteins in situ and by reconstitution methods is discussed, and the various factors involved are addressed. Third, we elaborate on the 2D crystallization of water-soluble proteins, both in solution and at interfaces, such as lipid monolayers, mica, carbon film or mercury surfaces. Finally, techniques and instrumentations that are required for 2D crystallization are described.

Rational design and synthesis of phospholipids for the two-dimensional crystallization of DNA gyrase, a key element in chromosome organization

Properties required of lipids for two-dimensional crystallization of proteins on lipid layers at the air/water interface are discussed in terms of molecular structure. These properties are related to essential features of the overall system such as (i) the fluidity and stability of the lipid film, (ii) the affinity of the protein to be crystallized for the lipids and (iii) the accessibility of the protein to the ligand in the lipid layer as well as (iv) technical constraints of the crystallization technique. The resulting ideas were tested through the rational design and synthesis of original phospholipid structures linked to novobiocin subsequently used in the production of two-dimensional crystals of DNA gyrase (B subunit), a prokaryotic type II DNA topoisomerase.

Two-dimensional and epitaxial crystallization of a mutant form of yeast RNA polymerase II

A mutant form of yeast RNA polymerase II that lacks the fourth and seventh largest subunits, referred to as pol II delta 4/7, crystallized on positively charged lipid layers. Both single-layered (two-dimensional) crystals and several multi-layered crystal forms were obtained. The two-dimensional crystals, preserved in negative stain, diffracted strongly to about 1/20 A-1 and more weakly to 1/13 A-1 resolution. A projection map computed from averaged Fourier transforms revealed four pol II delta 4/7 complexes per unit cell and further revealed a cleft on the surface of the complex similar to that previously observed in the structure of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. One of the multi-layered crystal forms, preserved in negative stain, diffracted strongly beyond 1/15 A-1 resolution. Coherent diffraction from the multi-layered crystal is indicative of protein-protein interactions between layers and ordering in the third dimension.

Three-dimensional structure of yeast RNA polymerase II at 16 A resolution

The structure of yeast RNA polymerase II has been determined by three-dimensional reconstruction from electron micrographs of two-dimensional crystals at approximately 16 A resolution. The most prominent feature of the structure is an arm of protein density surrounding a channel about 25 A in diameter, similar to that found previously for E. coli RNA polymerase. The 25 A-diameter channel bifurcates on one face of the protein, connecting with a 25 A-wide groove and with a channel about half as wide. The 25 A channel and groove, and the narrow channel, may bind double- and single-stranded nucleic acids, respectively. A finger of protein density projecting from the molecule adjacent to the arm-like feature may represent the C-terminal domain of the largest subunit. These results provide a structural basis for analyses of the transcription process and its regulation.