High-resolution proton magnetic resonance studies of the 3'-terminal colicin fragment of 16 S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli. Assignment of iminoproton resonances by nuclear Overhauser effect experiments and the influence of adenine dimethylation on the hairpin conformation

'View From A Bridge': A New Perspective on Eukaryotic rRNA Base Modification

Eukaryotic rRNA are modified frequently, although the diversity of modifications is low: in yeast rRNA, there are only 12 different types out of a possible natural repertoire exceeding 112. All nine rRNA base methyltransferases (MTases) and one acetyltransferase have recently been identified in budding yeast, and several instances of crosstalk between rRNA, tRNA, and mRNA modifications are emerging. Although the machinery has largely been identified, the functions of most rRNA modifications remain to be established. Remarkably, a eukaryote-specific bridge, comprising a single ribosomal protein (RP) from the large subunit (LSU), contacts four rRNA base modifications across the ribosomal subunit interface, potentially probing for their presence. We hypothesize in this article that long-range allosteric communication involving rRNA modifications is taking place between the two subunits during translation or, perhaps, the late stages of ribosome assembly.

Structural rearrangements in the active site of the Thermus thermophilus 16S rRNA methyltransferase KsgA in a binary complex with 5'-methylthioadenosine

Posttranscriptional modification of ribosomal RNA (rRNA) occurs in all kingdoms of life. The S-adenosyl-L-methionine-dependent methyltransferase KsgA introduces the most highly conserved rRNA modification, the dimethylation of A1518 and A1519 of 16S rRNA. Loss of this dimethylation confers resistance to the antibiotic kasugamycin. Here, we report biochemical studies and high-resolution crystal structures of KsgA from Thermus thermophilus. Methylation of 30S ribosomal subunits by T. thermophilus KsgA is more efficient at low concentrations of magnesium ions, suggesting that partially unfolded RNA is the preferred substrate. The overall structure is similar to that of other methyltransferases but contains an additional alpha-helix in a novel N-terminal extension. Comparison of the apoenzyme with complex structures with 5'-methylthioadenosine or adenosine bound in the cofactor-binding site reveals novel features when compared with related enzymes. Several mobile loop regions that restrict access to the cofactor-binding site are observed. In addition, the orientation of residues in the substrate-binding site indicates that conformational changes are required for binding two adjacent residues of the substrate rRNA.

Role of 16S ribosomal RNA methylations in translation initiation in Escherichia coli

Translation initiation from the ribosomal P-site is the specialty of the initiator tRNAs (tRNA(fMet)). Presence of the three consecutive G-C base pairs (G29-C41, G30-C40 and G31-C39) in their anticodon stems, a highly conserved feature of the initiator tRNAs across the three kingdoms of life, has been implicated in their preferential binding to the P-site. How this feature is exploited by ribosomes has remained unclear. Using a genetic screen, we have isolated an Escherichia coli strain, carrying a G122D mutation in folD, which allows initiation with the tRNA(fMet) containing mutations in one, two or all the three G-C base pairs. The strain shows a severe deficiency of methionine and S-adenosylmethionine, and lacks nucleoside methylations in rRNA. Targeted mutations in the methyltransferase genes have revealed a connection between the rRNA modifications and the fundamental process of the initiator tRNA selection by the ribosome.

New developments in structure determination of pseudoknots

Recently, several high-resolution structures of-RNA pseudoknots have become available. Here we review the progress in this area. The majority of the structures obtained belong to the classical or H-type pseudoknot family. The most complicated pseudoknot structure elucidated so far is the Hepatitis Delta Virus ribozyme, which forms a nested double pseudoknot. In particular, the structure-function relationships of the H-type pseudoknots involved in translational frameshifting have received much attention. All molecules considered show interesting new structural motifs.

The structure of a methylated tetraloop in 16S ribosomal RNA

BACKGROUND

Ribosomal RNAs contain many modified nucleotides. The functions of these nucleotides are poorly understood and few of them are strongly conserved. The final stem loop in 16S-like rRNAs is an exception in both regards. In both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, the tetranucleotide loop that caps the 3'-terminal stem contains two N6, N6-dimethyladenosine residues. The sequence and pattern of methylation are conserved within the loop, and there is evidence that these methylated nucleotides play an important role in subunit association and the initiation of protein synthesis. Because of the integral role that helix 45 plays in ribosome function, it is important to know what consequences these methylated nucleotides have on its structure.

RESULTS

We have solved the solution structure of a 14-nucleotide analog of the terminal stem loop of bacterial 16S rRNA, which contains N2-methylguanosine as well as two N6,N6-dimethyladenosines.

CONCLUSIONS

The methylation of the 16S rRNA stem loop completely alters its conformation, which would otherwise be a GNRA tetraloop. It is likely that the conformation of this loop is crucial for its function, having implications for its interaction with ribosomal subunits and its role in the initiation of protein synthesis.

Methylation of the conserved A1518-A1519 in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA by the ksgA methyltransferase is influenced by methylations around the similarly conserved U1512.G1523 base pair in the 3' terminal hairpin

An in vitro system developed for the site-specific mutagenesis of 16S rRNA of Escherichia coli ribosomes was used to make five mutations around the highly conserved U1512.G1523 base pair in the 3' terminal hairpin. Each of the mutant RNAs was reconstituted with a complete mixture of 30S proteins to yield 30S ribosomal particles, which were tested for the ability of the ksgA methylase to form m6(2)A1518 and m6(2)A1519. Dimethylation of A1518 and A1519 in the hairpin loop was inhibited 20-80% by the mutations. The results indicate that G1523 and C1524 in the stem are important determinants for the dimethylation of A1518 and A1519 in the loop. Either the enzyme recognition region extends that far or the effect of mutations in the stem are propagated in some manner to the loop. The conserved U.G base pair does not of itself appear to play a major role in ksgA methylase recognition.

Is there a special function for U.G basepairs in ribosomal RNA?

U.G basepairs are well-established elements of RNA structure. The geometry of this pair is different, however, from classical Watson-Crick basepairs. This leads to an unusual stacking of the basepair: overlap with the basepair at the 5' side of the U (and the 3' side of the G) is strong (stacked) while it is weak with the basepair on the other side (destacked). The closure of an RNA helix by a U.G pair will be energetically unfavourable when the U residue occupies the 5' end. In transfer RNA there is a strong selection against a 'destacked' U.G pair at helix ends. In the 16S rRNA model of Escherichia coli there are 72 U.G pairs of which 36 or 22 occupy a helix end, depending on how such an end is defined. There is a slight preference for 'stacked' U.G's in these positions. It is remarkable, however, that of 13 very conserved U.G pairs in the 16S (-like) rRNA, 7 occur at helix ends and that 5 of these have the 'destacked' configuration. It is suggested that these pairs, if they exist at all in a hydrogen-bounded form, are stabilized by co-axial stacking with other helices or by interaction with a protein.

Conformational and thermodynamic effects of naturally occurring base methylations in a ribosomal RNA hairpin of Bacillus stearothermophilus

The 3'-terminal colicin fragments of 16S ribosomal RNA were isolated from Bacillus stearothermophilus and from its kasugamycin-resistant (ksgA) derivative lacking N6-dimethylation of the two adjacent adenosines in a hairpin loop. The fragment from the ksgA strain still contains a naturally occurring N2-methylguanosine in the loop. An RNA molecule resembling the B. stearothermophilus colicin fragment but without modified nucleosides was synthesized in vitro using a DNA template and bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. Proton-NMR spectra of the RNAs were recorded at 500 MHz. The imino-proton resonances of base-paired G and U residues could be assigned on the basis of previous NMR studies of the colicin fragment of Escherichia coli and by a combination of methylation-induced shifts and thermal melting of base pairs. The assignments were partly confirmed by NOE measurements. Adenosine dimethylation in the loop has a distinct conformational effect on the base pairs adjoining the loop. The thermal denaturation melting curve of the enzymatically synthesized RNA fragment was also determined and the transition midpoint (tm) was found to be 73 degrees C at 15 mM Na+. A comparison with previously determined thermodynamic parameters for various colicin fragments demonstrates that base methylations in the loop lead to a relatively strong destabilization of the hairpin helix. In terms of free energy the positive contribution of the methylations are in the order of the deletion of one base pair from the stem. Other data show that recently published free-energy parameters do not apply for certain RNA hairpins.

Autogenous regulation of the Escherichia coli ksgA gene at the level of translation

Various plasmids that contain the Escherichia coli ksgA gene, which encodes a 16S rRNA adenosine dimethyltransferase (methylase), were constructed. In one of these plasmids, the DNA encoding the N-terminal part of the methylase was fused to the lacZ gene, and in another construct, the ksgA gene contained a deletion which resulted in a truncated version of the methylase. When a cell contained one plasmid directing the synthesis of the intact, active methylase and another plasmid encoding the methylase-beta-galactosidase protein, production of the latter product became strongly reduced. Likewise, synthesis of the truncated version of the methylase was diminished when the cell at the same time contained a plasmid producing the complete enzyme. These results were partly substantiated by in vitro experiments with a coupled transcription-translation assay system. By using a recently developed gel electrophoresis system for measuring protein-nucleic acid interactions, a specific binding of the ksgA methylase with its own mRNA could be established. Our results demonstrate that the expression of the ksgA gene can be, at least partly, autogenously controlled at the level of translation.

In vitro methylation of Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA and 30S ribosomes

Treatment of synthetic 30S particles lacking all of the normally methylated nucleotides with S-adenosyl-[3H]methionine and either an S100 or ribosomal high salt wash extract resulted in ribosome-dependent incorporation of [3H]methyl groups into trichloroacetic acid-insoluble material. No incorporation was observed when naturally methylated isolated 30S particles were used, showing that methylation at unnatural sites did not occur. Enzymatic hydrolysis of the labeled RNA to nucleosides followed by HPLC analysis identified the [3H]methylated residues. Activities for the formation of N6-methyladenosine, N6-dimethyladenosine, 5-methylcytidine (m5C), 3-methyluridine, and N2-methylguanosine were found. Fractionation by ammonium sulfate partially resolved the different activities. All of the fractions with m5C activity were 6-8 times more active on synthetic unmethylated 16S RNA than on synthetic 30S ribosomes, whereas the N2-methylguanosine activity preferred 30S ribosomes to 16S RNA by a factor of more than 10. The N6-methyladenosine and N6-dimethyladenosine activities were 30S ribosome-specific. The m5C activity present in the 55-85% ammonium sulfate fraction of the high salt wash yielded a maximum of 1.0 mol of m5C per mol of 16S RNA, although two m5C residues, positions 967 and 1407, are found in vivo. RNase protection by hybridization with the appropriate oligodeoxynucleotide identified the methylated residue as C-967. Methylation of m5C-967 did not require prior methylation of G-966, and methylation of A-1518 and A-1519 was not dependent on prior methylation of G-1516.

The 3' terminal colicin fragment of Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA. Conformational details revealed by enzymic and chemical probing

The conformation of the colicin fragment of E. coli 16S rRNA was probed with various nucleases and with the adenosine-specific reagent diethylpyrocarbonate (DEP). The results confirm the presence of a stable central hairpin in the colicin fragment and a weaker additional secondary structure involving the regions 5' and 3' to this hairpin. By monitoring DEP accessibility at various stages of heat-denaturation sequential unfolding of individual base pairs was followed. In agreement with previous results it could be shown that dimethylation of the two adjacent adenosines in the hairpin loop (a feature in virtually all ribosomes) leads to a destabilization of the hairpin helix. Accessibilities of G residues, involved in the weaker additional secondary structure is anomalous. One G residue is sensitive to the single strand specific RNase T1 and insensitive to DEP, while the situation is reversed for the adjoining G residue. The strong reaction of the latter G-residue with DEP is unusual and indicates a very special conformation.

Escherichia coli ribosomal protein S1 does not protect the 49-nucleotide 3' terminal cloacin fragment of 16 S rRNA from nuclease S1

Footprinting of ribosomal protein S1 on the 49-nucleotide 3' terminal cloacin DF13 fragment of 16 S rRNA at physiological ionic strength, pH and temperature yielded no detectable protection of any nucleotides from subsequent attack by the single strand specific nuclease S1, even at large excesses of ribosomal protein S1.

Identification and assignment of base pairs in three helical stems of Torulopsis utilis ribosomal 5S RNA and its RNase T1 and RNase T2 cleaved fragments via 500-MHz proton homonuclear overhauser enhancements

Imino proton resonances in the downfield region (10-14 ppm) of the 500-MHz 1H NMR spectrum of Torulopsis utilis 5S RNA are identified (A X U, G X C, or G X U) and assigned to base pairs in helices I, IV, and V via analysis of homonuclear Overhauser enhancements (NOE) from intact T. utilis 5S RNA, its RNase T1 and RNase T2 digested fragments, and a second yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) 5S RNA whose nucleotide sequence differs at only six residues from that of T. utilis 5S RNA. The near-identical chemical shifts and NOE behavior of most of the common peaks from these four RNAs strongly suggest that helices I, IV, and V retain the same conformation after RNase digestion and that both T. utilis and S. cerevisiae 5S RNAs share a common secondary and tertiary structure. Of the four G X U base pairs identified in the intact 5S RNA, two are assigned to the terminal stem (helix I) and the other two to helices IV and V. Seven of the nine base pairs of the terminal stem have been assigned. Our experimental demonstration of a G X U base pair in helix V supports the 5S RNA secondary structural model of Luehrsen and Fox [Luehrsen, K. R., & Fox, G.E. (1981) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 78, 2150-2154]. Finally, the base-pair proton peak assigned to the terminal G X U in helix V of the RNase T2 cleaved fragment is shifted downfield from that in the intact 5S RNA, suggesting that helices I and V may be coaxial in intact T. utilis 5S RNA.

Circular dichroism and 500-MHz proton magnetic resonance studies of the interaction of Escherichia coli translational initiation factor 3 protein with the 16S ribosomal RNA 3' cloacin fragment

The RNA helix destabilizing properties of Escherichia coli initiation factor 3 protein (IF3), and its affinity for an evolutionarily conserved sequence at the 3' end of 16S rRNA, led us to examine the details of the protein-nucleic acid interactions upon IF3 binding to the 49-nucleotide 3'-terminal cloacin DF13 fragment of 16S rRNA by studying the circular dichroism (CD) and proton magnetic resonance spectra of the RNA, the protein, and their complex. In a physiological tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane buffer, where the interaction is primarily nonionic and sequence specific, addition of IF3 decreases the RNA 268-nm CD peak hyperbolically by 19% to an end point of about one IF3 per RNA strand. The titration curve is best fit by an association constant of (1.80 +/- 0.05) X 10(7) M-1, within the range estimated by a nuclease mapping study of the same system [Wickstrom, E. (1983) Nucleic Acids Res. 11, 2035-2052]. In a low-salt phosphate buffer without Mg2+, where the interaction is primarily ionic and nonspecific, titration with IF3 decreases the peak CD sigmoidally by 35% to an end point of two IF3 per strand. The titration curve is best fit by an intrinsic association constant of (1.7 +/- 0.7) X 10(6) M-1 for each IF3 and a cooperativity constant of 33 +/- 6. In a physiological phosphate buffer lacking Mg2+, the dispersion of aromatic proton magnetic resonance peaks and upfield-shifted methyl proton resonances indicates a high degree of secondary and tertiary structure in the protein. In an equimolar mixture of IF3 and RNA cloacin fragment, several changes in identifiable IF3 and RNA resonances are observed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Identification of three G.U base pairs in Bacillus subtilis ribosomal 5S RNA via 500-MHz proton homonuclear Overhauser enhancements

Three distinct G.U base pairs in Bacillus subtilis 5S RNA have been identified via homonuclear Overhauser enhancements (NOE) of their low-field (9-15 ppm) proton Fourier transform nuclear magnetic resonances at 11.75 T. With these G.U resonances as starting points, short segments of NOE connectivity can be established. One G.U-G.C-G.C segment (most probably G4.C112-G5.C111-U6.G110) can definitely be assigned to the terminal helix. The existence of at least part of the terminal helical stem of the secondary structure of a Gram-positive bacterial 5S RNA has thus been established for the first time by direct experimental observation. Addition of Mg2+ produces almost no conformational changes in the terminal stem but results in major conformational changes elsewhere in the structure, as reflected by changes in the 1H 500-MHz low-field NMR spectrum. Assignment of the two remaining G.U base pairs will require further experiments (e.g., enzymatic-cleavage fragments). Finally, the implications of these results for analysis of RNA secondary structure are discussed.

Influence of the polyamines spermine and spermidine on yeast tRNAPhe as revealed from its imino proton NMR spectrum

A comparison of imino proton NMR spectra of yeast tRNAPhe recorded at various solution conditions indicates, that polyamines have a limited effect on the structure of this tRNA molecule. Polyamines are found to catalyse the solvent exchange of several imino protons in yeast tRNAPhe not only of non hydrogen bonded imino protons, but also of imino protons of the GU and of some AU and tertiary base pairs. It is concluded that at low levels of catalysing components the exchange rates of the latter protons are not determined by the base pair lifetime. In the presence of high levels of spermidine the solvent exchange rates of imino protons of several base pairs in the molecule were assessed as a function of the temperature. Apparent activation energies derived from these rates were found to be less than 80 kJ/mol, which is indicative for (transient) independent opening of the corresponding base pairs. In the acceptor helix the GU base pair acts as a dynamic dislocation. The AU base pairs at one side of the GU base pair exhibit faster transient opening than the GC base pairs on the other side of this wobble pair. The base pairs m2GC10 and GC11 from the D stem and GC28 from the anticodon stem show relatively slow opening up to high temperatures. Model studies suggest that 1-methyladenosine, an element of tRNA itself, catalyses imino proton solvent exchange in a way similar to polyamines.

Phylogeny of the conserved 3' terminal structure of the RNA of small ribosomal subunits

The strongest conserved part of the RNA of small ribosomal subunits is probably located near the 3' end. This paper reviews the primary and secondary structures of some 40 sequenced 3' termini and tries to classify these structures according to common features and differences. The regions under consideration contain at the 5' side an almost universal, supposedly single-stranded stretch of nucleotides with the sequence--AAGUCGUAACAAGGU--. This is followed by a stem-loop structure. The stem always contains 9 basepairs (including U-G pairs) and no mismatches or bulged nucleotides. The loop of the hairpin is either (m2)GGm62Am62A (bacteria, chloroplasts and mitochondria) or UGm62Am62A (cytoplasm). The hairpin is, in most cases, followed at the 3' side by--GGAUCA--. Next to it bacteria and chloroplasts contain the so-called "Shine and Dalgarno" sequence --CCUCC--. The stem region of the hairpin contains a conserved A-U U-G junction. The two basepairs between this junction and the loop are either of type 1 (G-C G-C) or type 2 (C-G C-G). Classification according to type links certain bacteria with mitochondria of yeast and plants and others with chloroplasts and with animal mitochondria.