Nucleosome arrangement in green monkey alpha-satellite chromatin. Superimposition of non-random and apparently random patterns

The polymorphisms of the chromatin fiber

In eukaryotes, the genome is packed into chromosomes, each consisting of large polymeric fibers made of DNA bound with proteins (mainly histones) and RNA molecules. The nature and precise 3D organization of this fiber has been a matter of intense speculations and debates. In the emerging picture, the local chromatin state plays a critical role in all fundamental DNA transactions, such as transcriptional control, DNA replication or repair. However, the molecular and structural mechanisms involved remain elusive. The purpose of this review is to give an overview of the tremendous efforts that have been made for almost 40 years to build physiologically relevant models of chromatin structure. The motivation behind building such models was to shift our representation and understanding of DNA transactions from a too simplistic 'naked DNA' view to a more realistic 'coated DNA' view, as a step towards a better framework in which to interpret mechanistically the control of genetic expression and other DNA metabolic processes. The field has evolved from a speculative point of view towards in vitro biochemistry and in silico modeling, but is still longing for experimental in vivo validations of the proposed structures or even proof of concept experiments demonstrating a clear role of a given structure in a metabolic transaction. The mere existence of a chromatin fiber as a relevant biological entity in vivo has been put into serious questioning. Current research is suggesting a possible reconciliation between theoretical studies and experiments, pointing towards a view where the polymorphic and dynamic nature of the chromatin fiber is essential to support its function in genome metabolism.

Organisation of nucleosomal arrays reconstituted with repetitive African green monkey alpha-satellite DNA as analysed by atomic force microscopy

Alpha-satellite DNA (AS) is part of centromeric DNA and could be relevant for centromeric chromatin structure: its repetitive character may generate a specifically ordered nucleosomal arrangement and thereby facilitate kinetochore protein binding and chromatin condensation. Although nucleosomal positioning on some satellite sequences had been shown, including AS from African green monkey (AGM), the sequence-dependent nucleosomal organisation of repetitive AS of this species has so far not been analysed. We therefore studied the positioning of reconstituted nucleosomes on AGM AS tandemly repeated DNA. Enzymatic analysis of nucleosome arrays formed on an AS heptamer as well as the localisation of mononucleosomes on an AS dimer by atomic force microscopy (AFM) showed one major positioning frame, in agreement with earlier results. The occupancy of this site was in the range of 45-50%, in quite good agreement with published in vivo observations. AFM measurements of internucleosomal distances formed on the heptamer indicated that the nucleosomal arrangement is governed by sequence-specific DNA-histone interactions yielding defined internucleosomal distances, which, nevertheless, are not compatible with a uniform phasing of the nucleosomes with the AGM AS repeats.

HMGA proteins: flexibility finds a nuclear niche?

The mammalian HMGA family of chromatin proteins possesses an unusual constellation of physical, biochemical, and biological characteristics that distinguish them from other nuclear proteins. Principal among these is the fact that, unlike other proteins, they possess little detectable secondary structure prior to interactions with other macromolecules (DNA, RNA, proteins). Upon binding to substrates, however, the HMGA proteins undergo specific disordered-to-ordered structural transitions and also induce alterations in the structure of the substrates themselves. Their intrinsic structural flexibility, combined with other features such as the control of their substrate interactions via complex patterns of in vivo biochemical modifications, allows the HMGA proteins to actively participate in a wide variety of nuclear activities including DNA replication, DNA repair, chromatin remodeling, control of gene transcription, and regulation of mRNA processing

Molecular biology of HMGA proteins: hubs of nuclear function

Members of the HMGA (a.k.a. HMGI/Y) family of 'high mobility group' (HMG) proteins participate in a wide variety of nuclear processes ranging from chromosome and chromatin mechanics to acting as architectural transcription factors that regulate the expression of numerous genes in vivo. As a consequence, they function in the cell as highly connected 'nodes' of protein-DNA and protein-protein interactions that influence a diverse array of normal biological processes including growth, proliferation, differentiation and death. The HMGA proteins, likewise, participate in pathological processes by, for example, acting as regulators of viral gene transcription and by serving as host-supplied proteins that facilitate retroviral integration. HMGA genes are bona fide proto-oncogenes that promote tumor progression and metastasis when overexpressed in cells. High constitutive HMGA protein levels are among the most consistent feature observed in all types of cancers with increasing concentrations being correlated with increasing malignancy. The intrinsic attributes that endow the HMGA proteins with these remarkable abilities are a combination of structural, biochemical and biological characteristics that are unique to these proteins. HMGA proteins have little, if any, secondary structure while free in solution but undergo disordered-to-ordered structural transitions when bound to substrates such as DNA or other proteins. Each protein contains three copies of a conserved DNA-binding peptide motif called the 'AT-hook' that preferentially binds to the minor groove of stretches of AT-rich sequence. In vivo HMGA proteins specifically interact with a large number of other proteins, most of which are transcription factors. They are also subject to many types of in vivo biochemical modifications that markedly influence their ability to interact with DNA substrates, other proteins and chromatin. And, most importantly, both the transcription of HMGA genes and the biochemical modifications of HMGA proteins are direct downstream targets of numerous signal transduction pathways making them exquisitely responsive to various environmental influences. This review covers recent advances that have contributed to our understanding of how this constellation of structural and biological features allows the HMGA proteins to serve as central 'hubs' of nuclear function.

Genome-wide chromatin remodeling modulates the Alu heat shock response

During heat shock recovery in Hela cells, the level of Alu RNA transiently increases with kinetics that approximately parallel the transient expression of heat shock protein mRNAs. Coincidentally, there is a transient increase in the accessibility of Alu chromatin to restriction enzyme cleavage suggesting that an opening and re-closing of chromatin regulates the Alu stress response. Similar changes occur in alpha satellite and LINE1 chromatin showing that heat shock induces a genome-wide remodeling of chromatin structure which is independent of transcription. The increased accessibility of restriction sites within these repetitive sequences is inconsistent with a simple lengthening of the nucleosome linker region but instead suggests a scrambling of nucleosome positions. Chromatin structure and its dynamics account for many of the principal features of SINE transcriptional regulation potentially providing a functional rationale for the dispersion and high copy number of SINEs.

K562 cells implicate increased chromatin accessibility in Alu transcriptional activation

Alu repeats in K562 cells are unusually hypomethylated and far more actively transcribed than those in other human cell lines and somatic tissues. Also, the level of Alu RNA in K562 cells is relatively insensitive to cell stresses, namely heat shock, adenovirus infection and treatment with cycloheximide, which increase the abundance of Alu RNA in HeLa and 293 cells. Recent advances in understanding the interactions between DNA methylation, transcriptional activation and chromatin conformation reveal reasons for the constitutively high level of Alu expression in K562 cells. Methylation represses transcription of transiently transfected Alu templates in all cell lines tested but cell stresses do not relieve this repression suggesting that they activate Alu transcription through another pathway. A relatively large fraction of the Alus within K562 chromatin is accessible to restriction enzyme cleavage and cell stresses increase the chromatin accessibility of Alus in HeLa and 293 cells. Cell stress evidently activates Alu transcription by rapidly remodeling chromatin to recruit additional templates.

Differences in in vivo and in vitro sequence-specific sites of cisplatin-DNA adduct formation and detection of a dose-response relationship

The cytotoxic and mutagenic properties of the anticancer drug cis-diammine-dichloroplatinum(II) (cisplatin) are mediated by bifunctional adducts between purines. Experiments performed in this study employed a new repetitive thermal-cycling technique to detect cisplatin adduct formation following exposure of cells in culture (in vivo) or following treatment of purified DNA (in vitro exposure). The initial goal of this study was to determine if cisplatin-DNA adduct formation could be measured accurately using phosphor-imaging over a broad concentration range. If this proved possible, it would then be feasible to determine if adduct formation differed within chromatin compared with purified DNA. There were no significant differences in the cisplatin-DNA adduct pattern induced in closed circular or linear double-stranded plasmids in vitro, suggesting that this type of tertiary structural change does not affect the formation of adduct sites. Sequence-specific DNA adduct formation within a human repetitive DNA target sequence, alphoid DNA, following cisplatin treatment of prostate cancer cells in culture (in vivo) and treatment of purified DNA in vitro revealed consistent increases in adduct formation over a broad concentration range, validating the experimental technique. Comparing preferences for cisplatin adduct site formation under these different conditions of exposure demonstrated statistically significant differences. Similar differences were detected for cisplatin repair-deficient Xeroderma pigmentosum cells treated in cell culture, indicating that in vivo/in vitro preferences for adduct site formation are not the result of DNA repair in vivo.

Nonrandom localization of recombination events in human alpha satellite repeat unit variants: implications for higher-order structural characteristics within centromeric heterochromatin

Tandemly repeated DNA families appear to undergo concerted evolution, such that repeat units within a species have a higher degree of sequence similarity than repeat units from even closely related species. While intraspecies homogenization of repeat units can be explained satisfactorily by repeated rounds of genetic exchange processes such as unequal crossing over and/or gene conversion, the parameters controlling these processes remain largely unknown. Alpha satellite DNA is a noncoding tandemly repeated DNA family found at the centromeres of all human and primate chromosomes. We have used sequence analysis to investigate the molecular basis of 13 variant alpha satellite repeat units, allowing comparison of multiple independent recombination events in closely related DNA sequences. The distribution of these events within the 171-bp monomer is nonrandom and clusters in a distinct 20- to 25-bp region, suggesting possible effects of primary sequence and/or chromatin structure. The position of these recombination events may be associated with the location within the higher-order repeat unit of the binding site for the centromere-specific protein CENP-B. These studies have implications for the molecular nature of genetic recombination, mechanisms of concerted evolution, and higher-order structure of centromeric heterochromatin.

Nonrandom localization of recombination events in human alpha satellite repeat unit variants: implications for higher-order structural characteristics within centromeric heterochromatin

Tandemly repeated DNA families appear to undergo concerted evolution, such that repeat units within a species have a higher degree of sequence similarity than repeat units from even closely related species. While intraspecies homogenization of repeat units can be explained satisfactorily by repeated rounds of genetic exchange processes such as unequal crossing over and/or gene conversion, the parameters controlling these processes remain largely unknown. Alpha satellite DNA is a noncoding tandemly repeated DNA family found at the centromeres of all human and primate chromosomes. We have used sequence analysis to investigate the molecular basis of 13 variant alpha satellite repeat units, allowing comparison of multiple independent recombination events in closely related DNA sequences. The distribution of these events within the 171-bp monomer is nonrandom and clusters in a distinct 20- to 25-bp region, suggesting possible effects of primary sequence and/or chromatin structure. The position of these recombination events may be associated with the location within the higher-order repeat unit of the binding site for the centromere-specific protein CENP-B. These studies have implications for the molecular nature of genetic recombination, mechanisms of concerted evolution, and higher-order structure of centromeric heterochromatin.

Chromatin digestion with restriction endonucleases reveals 150-160 bp of protected DNA in the centromere of chromosome XIV in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Isolated nuclei of Saccharomyces cerevisiae were incubated with five restriction nucleases. Out of the twenty-one recognition sequences for these nucleases in the centromere region of chromosome XIV, only five are accessible to cleavage. These sites map 11 bp and 74 bp to the left and 27 bp, 41 bp and 290 bp to the right, respectively, of the boundaries of the 118 bp functional CEN14 DNA sequence. The distance between the sites accessible to cleavage and closest to CEN14 is 156 bp, suggesting this is the maximal size of DNA protected in CEN14 chromatin. The DNA in CEN14 chromatin protected against cleavage with DNase I and micrococcal nuclease overlaps almost completely with this region. Hypersensitive regions flanking both sides are approximately 60 bp long. Analyses of other S. cerevisiae centromeres with footprinting techniques in intact cells or nucleolytic cleavages in isolated nuclei are discussed in relation to our results. We conclude that structural data of chromatin obtained with restriction nucleases are reliable and that the structure of CEN14 chromatin is representative for S. cerevisiae centromeres.

A proposal for a possible role of nucleosome positioning in the evolutionary adjustment of introns

1. Prokaryotes and yeast have mostly intronless genes, whereas the presence of a large number of extended introns are characteristic of the genes of of multicellular eukaryotic organisms which, however, as an exception also have a few intronless genes. 2. According to the current view, the lack of introns in prokaryotic organisms and yeast is due to the selective pressure of a short cell division time. On the other hand, the presence of introns in multicellular eukaryotic organisms is explained by the lack of selective forces against them. 3. In the present hypothesis it is proposed that introns were used as tools in the course of evolution for the organization of eukaryotic genes within the repeating units of nucleosomes, since the distinct DNA conformations of the nucleosome core particle and of the linker region, respectively, represent a constraint for the positioning of genes. 4. Recently it was shown that initiation of transcription is inhibited when the promoter sequence is within a nucleosome. 5. Since the nucleosomal organization of DNA leads to a severely deformed DNA helix and recognition of sequences by regulatory proteins is likely to depend on the conformation of the double helix, it is postulated that for the different sizes of eukaryotic genes which have to be organized within repeating units of nucleosomes, introns provided the flexibility of adjustment for the positioning of regulatory sequences, by drifting in length, sequence and position.

Structural organization of satellite I chromatin of calf liver

The organization of liver calf satellite DNA I chromatin has been studied. Precisely seven nucleosomes per DNA satellite repeat (1.4 kb) are shown to be present. Several strict positionings of the nucleosomes along the satellite DNA repeat have been described. One of these positionings, the major phase, was shown to be preferentially organized in clustered repeats. Most of the non-methylated CpG restriction sites were shown to be located in the linker DNAs of the satellite I nucleosomes, whilst, accordingly, methylated HpaII sites were found in the core satellite I DNA. The significance of these results is discussed.

Characterization of a human 'midisatellite' sequence

We have examined the structure and DNA sequence of a human genomic locus that consists of a large hypervariable region made up of repeats of a simple sequence. With several restriction enzymes, the locus shows many restriction fragments that vary quantitatively as well as qualitatively. Other restriction enzymes produce only a single, high-molecular-weight fragment at this locus. Almost all of the fragments are revealed with a simple sequence probe. Southern transfers of the high-molecular-weight restriction fragments produced by the restriction enzymes NotI and SfiI, resolved by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis, gave at most two fragments, demonstrated to be allelic, showing that the majority of the restriction fragments seen in the complex patterns are at a single locus. The estimated size of the region homologous to the probe varied from 250 to 500 kilobases. DNA sequencing indicated that the region consists of tandem repeats of a 40-base-pair sequence. Some homology was detected to the tandem repeating units of the insulin gene and the zetaglobin pseudogene hypervariable regions, and to the "minisatellite" DNA at the myoglobin locus.

Molecular analysis of a deletion polymorphism in alpha satellite of human chromosome 17: evidence for homologous unequal crossing-over and subsequent fixation

The human alpha satellite DNA family is organized into chromosome-specific subsets characterized by distinct higher-order repeats based on a approximately 171 basepair monomer unit. On human chromosome 17, the predominant form of alpha satellite is a 16-monomer (16-mer) higher-order repeat present in 500-1000 copies per chromosome 17. In addition, less abundant 15-monomer and 14-monomer repeats are also found constitutively on chromosome 17. Polymorphisms in the form of different higher-order repeat lengths have been described for this subset, the most prominent polymorphism being a 13-monomer (13-mer) higher-order repeat present on approximately 35% of all chromosomes 17. To investigate the nature of this polymorphism, we have cloned, sequenced and compared the relevant regions of the 13-mer to the previously characterized 16-mer repeat. The results show that the repeats are virtually identical, with the principal difference being the exclusion of three monomers from the 13-mer repeat. We propose that the 13-mer is the product of an isolated homologous recombination event between two monomers of the 16-mer repeat. Sequence comparisons reveal the approximate site of recombination and flanking regions of homology. This recombination site corresponds to a position within the alphoid monomer which has been previously implicated in an independent homologous recombination event, suggesting that there may exist a preferred register for recombination in alphoid DNA. We suggest that these events are representative of an ongoing process capable of reorganizing the satellite subset of a given chromosome, thereby contributing to the establishment of chromosome-specific alpha satellite subsets.

DNA engineering shows that nucleosome phasing on the African green monkey alpha-satellite is the result of multiple additive histone-DNA interactions

The mechanism underlying sequence-specific positioning of nucleosomes on DNA was investigated. African green monkey alpha-satellite DNA was reconstituted in vitro with histones. Histone octamers were found to adopt one major and several minor positions on the satellite repeat unit, very similar to those positions found previously in vitro, demonstrating that sequence-specific histone-DNA interactions are responsible for nucleosome positioning on this DNA. In order to understand the nature of these interactions in more detail, we have constructed a variant satellite fragment containing an insertion of half a helical DNA turn. The parent fragment directs histones to one major and two overlapping minor positions that are all affected by the insertion. All three frames respond in a unique fashion to the additional five base-pairs. From a quantitative analysis of the nucleosome positions on the engineered fragment, consensus "phasing boxes" as the basis for nucleosome positioning can be ruled out. Instead, our results argue very strongly that nucleosome positioning is due to the independent contribution of many different DNA-histone contacts along the entire core particle, in an apparently additive fashion.

Sequence heterogeneity within the human alphoid repetitive DNA family

We have cloned and determined the base-sequence and genome organization of two human chromosome-specific alphoid DNA fragments, designated L1.26, mapping principally to chromosomes 13 and 21, and L1.84, mapping to chromosome 18. Their copy number is estimated to be approximately 2,000 per haploid genome. L1.84 has a double-dimer organization, whereas L1.26 has a much less defined higher order tandem organization. Further, we present evidence that the restriction-site spacing within the alphoid DNA family is chromosome specific. From sequence analysis, clones L1.26 and L1.84 are found to consist of 5 and 4 tandemly duplicated 170 bp monomers. Cross-homology between the various monomers is 65-85%. The analysis suggests that the evolution of tandem-arrays does not take place via a defined 340 bp unit, as was inferred by others, but via circularly permutated monomers or multimers of the 170 bp unit.

A mammalian high mobility group protein recognizes any stretch of six A.T base pairs in duplex DNA

alpha-Protein is a high mobility group protein originally purified from African green monkey cells based on its affinity for the 172-base-pair repeat of monkey alpha-satellite DNA. We have used DNase I footprinting to identify 50 alpha-protein binding sites on simian virus 40 DNA and thereby to determine the DNA binding specificity of this mammalian nuclear protein. alpha-Protein binds with approximately equal affinity to any run of six or more A X T base pairs in duplex DNA, to many, if not all, runs of five A X T base pairs, and to a small number of other sequences within otherwise (A + T)-rich regions. Unlike well characterized sequence-specific DNA binding proteins such as bacterial repressors, alpha-protein makes extensive contacts within the minor groove of B-DNA. These and related findings indicate that, rather than binding to a few specific DNA sequences, alpha-protein recognizes a configuration of the minor groove characteristic of short runs of A X T base pairs. We discuss possible functions of alpha-protein and the similarities in DNA recognition by alpha-protein and the antibiotic netropsin.

Chromosome-specific subfamilies within human alphoid repetitive DNA

Nucleotide sequence data of about 20 X 10(3) base-pairs of the human tandemly repeated alphoid DNA are presented. The DNA sequences were determined from 45 clones containing EcoRI fragments of alphoid DNA isolated from total genomic DNA. Thirty of the clones contained a complete 340 base-pair dimer unit of the repeat. The remaining clones contained alphoid DNA with fragment lengths of 311, 296, 232, 170 and 108 base-pairs. The sequences obtained were compared with an average alphoid DNA sequence determined by Wu & Manuelidis (1980). The divergences ranged from 0.6 to 24.6% nucleotide changes for the first monomer and from 0 to 17.8% for the second monomer of the repeat. On the basis of identical nucleotide changes at corresponding positions, the individual repeat units could be shown to belong to one of several distinct subfamilies. The number of nucleotide changes defining a subfamily generally constitutes the majority of nucleotide changes found in a member of that subfamily. From an evaluation of the proportion of the total amount of alphoid DNA, which is represented by the clones studied, it is estimated that the number of subfamilies of this repeat may be equal to or exceed the number of chromosomes. The expected presence of only one or a few distinct subfamilies on individual chromosomes is supported by the study, also presented, of the nucleotide sequence of 17 cloned fragments of alphoid repetitive DNA from chromosome 7. These chromosome-specific repeats all contain the characteristic pattern of 36 common nucleotide changes that defines one of the subfamilies described. A unique restriction endonuclease (NlaIII) cleavage site present in this subfamily may be useful as a genetic marker of this chromosome. A family member of the interspersed Alu repetitive DNA was also isolated and sequenced. This Alu repeat has been inserted into the human alphoid repetitive DNA, in the same way as the insertion of an Alu repeat into the African green monkey alphoid DNA.

Histones and their modifications

Histones constitute the protein core around which DNA is coiled to form the basic structural unit of the chromosome known as the nucleosome. Because of the large amount of new histone needed during chromosome replication, the synthesis of histone and DNA is regulated in a complex manner. During RNA transcription and DNA replication, the basic nucleosomal structure as well as interactions between nucleosomes must be greatly altered to allow access to the appropriate enzymes and factors. The presence of extensive and varied post-translational modifications to the otherwise highly conserved histone primary sequences provides obvious opportunities for such structural alterations, but despite concentrated and sustained effort, causal connections between histone modifications and nucleosomal functions are not yet elucidated.

Transcriptionally active chromatin

Eukaryotic chromatin has a dynamic, complex hierarchical structure. Active gene transcription takes place on only a small proportion of it at a time. While many workers have tried to characterize active chromatin, we are still far from understanding all the biochemical, morphological and compositional features that distinguish it from inactive nuclear material. Active genes are apparently packaged in an altered nucleosome structure and are associated with domains of chromatin that are less condensed or more open than inactive domains. Active genes are more sensitive to nuclease digestions and probably contain specific nonhistone proteins which may establish and/or maintain the active state. Variant or modified histones as well as altered configurations or modifications of the DNA itself may likewise be involved. Practically nothing is known about the mechanisms that control these nuclear characteristics. However, controlled accessibility to regions of chromatin and specific sequences of DNA may be one of the primary regulatory mechanisms by which higher cells establish potentially active chromatin domains. Another control mechanism may be compartmentalization of active chromatin to certain regions within the nucleus, perhaps to the nuclear matrix. Topological constraints and DNA supercoiling may influence the active regions of chromatin and be involved in eukaryotic genomic functions. Further, the chromatin structure of various DNA regulatory sequences, such as promoters, terminators and enhancers, appears to partially regulate transcriptional activity.

A protein binds to a satellite DNA repeat at three specific sites that would be brought into mutual proximity by DNA folding in the nucleosome

Using a generally applicable assay for specific DNA-binding proteins in crude extracts, we have detected and purified an HMG-like nuclear protein from African green monkey cells that preferentially binds to the 172 bp repeat of alpha-satellite DNA (alpha-DNA). DNAase I footprinting with the purified protein detects three specific binding sites (I-III) per alpha-DNA repeat. Site II is 145 bp (one core nucleosome length) from site III on the adjacent alpha-DNA repeat, while site I lies midway between sites II and III. In the alpha-nucleosome phasing frame corresponding with this arrangement, sites I-III would be brought into mutual proximity by DNA folding in the nucleosome. This phasing frame is identical with the preferred frame detected previously in isolated chromatin. Our results suggest that this new and abundant protein recognizes a family of short, related nucleotide sequences found not only in alpha-DNA but also throughout the genome, and that functions of this protein are mediated through its nucleosome-positioning activity. Such nucleosome-positioning proteins may underlie the sequence specificity of both nucleosome arrangements and higher order chromatin structures.

Nucleosome arrangement in alpha-satellite chromatin of African green monkey cells

By analyzing the accessibility of restriction endonuclease sites in African green monkey alpha-satellite chromatin, we demonstrate the absence of a unique phase relationship between nucleosomes and alpha-satellite DNA. The data indicate a minimum of three different positions for nucleosome cores relative to the alpha-satellite sequence and suggest a random distribution in at least some regions. In addition, while we confirm published reports that staphylococcal nuclease cuts the alpha-satellite sequence in chromatin at a highly preferred site, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of nuclear digests demonstrates that this site is preferentially cut by staphylococcal nuclease even when it is within the nucleosome core. These data indicate that staphylococcal nuclease is not useful for determining nucleosome positions on alpha-satellite DNA, and perhaps on other specific DNA sequences as well.