Vaccine-related paralytic poliomyelitis in an immunodeficient child

Immunodeficiency-related vaccine-derived poliovirus (iVDPV) cases: a systematic review and implications for polio eradication

BACKGROUND

Vaccine-derived polioviruses (VDPVs), strains of poliovirus mutated from the oral polio vaccine, pose a challenge to global polio eradication. Immunodeficiency-related vaccine-derived polioviruses (iVDPVs) are a type of VDPV which may serve as sources of poliovirus reintroduction after the eradication of wild-type poliovirus. This review is a comprehensive update of confirmed iVDPV cases published in the scientific literature from 1962 to 2012, and describes clinically relevant trends in reported iVDPV cases worldwide.

METHODS

We conducted a systematic review of published iVDPV case reports from January 1960 to November 2012 from four databases. We included cases in which the patient had a primary immunodeficiency, and the vaccine virus isolated from the patient either met the sequencing definition of VDPV (>1% divergence for serotypes 1 and 3 and >0.6% for serotype 2) and/or was previously reported as an iVDPV by the World Health Organization.

RESULTS

We identified 68 iVDPV cases in 49 manuscripts reported from 25 countries and the Palestinian territories. 62% of case patients were male, 78% presented clinically with acute flaccid paralysis, and 65% were iVDPV2. 57% of cases occurred in patients with predominantly antibody immunodeficiencies, and the overall all-cause mortality rate was greater than 60%. The median age at case detection was 1.4 years [IQR: 0.8, 4.5] and the median duration of shedding was 1.3 years [IQR: 0.7, 2.2]. We identified a poliovirus genome VP1 region mutation rate of 0.72% per year and a higher median percent divergence for iVDPV1 cases. More cases were reported from high income countries, which also had a larger age variation and different distribution of immunodeficiencies compared to upper and lower middle-income countries.

CONCLUSION

Our study describes the incidence and characteristics of global iVDPV cases reported in the literature in the past five decades. It also highlights the regional and economic disparities of reported iVDPV cases.

Spread of vaccine-derived poliovirus from a paralytic case in an immunodeficient child: an insight into the natural evolution of oral polio vaccine

Sabin strains used in the manufacture of oral polio vaccine (OPV) replicate in the human organism and can give rise to vaccine-derived polioviruses. The increased neurovirulence of vaccine derivatives has been known since the beginning of OPV use, but their ability to establish circulation in communities has been recognized only recently during the latest stages of the polio eradication campaign. This important observation called for studies of their emergence and evolution as well as extensive surveillance to determine the scope of this phenomenon. Here, we present the results of a study of vaccine-derived isolates from an immunocompromised poliomyelitis patient, the contacts, and the local sewage. All isolates were identified as closely related and slightly evolved vaccine derivatives with a recombinant type 2/type 1 genome. The strains also shared several amino acid substitutions including a mutation in the VP1 protein that was previously shown to be associated with the loss of attenuation. Another mutation in the VP3 protein resulted in altered immunological properties of the isolates, possibly facilitating virus spread in immunized populations. The patterns and rates of the accumulation of synonymous mutations in isolates collected from the patient over the extended period of excretion suggest either a substantially nonuniform rate of mutagenesis throughout the genome, or, more likely, the strains may have been intratypic recombinants between coevolving derivatives with different degrees of divergence from the vaccine parent. This study provides insight into the early stages of the establishment of circulation by runaway vaccine strains.

Use of licensed vaccines for active immunization of the immunocompromised host

The latter part of the 20th century has witnessed an unprecedented rise in the number of individuals with impaired immunity. This is primarily attributable to the increased development and use of antineoplastic therapy for malignancies, organ and bone marrow transplantation, and the AIDS epidemic. Individuals with impaired immunity are often at increased risk for infections, and they can experience more severe and complicated courses of infection. The lack of therapy for a variety of viruses and the rise in antimicrobial resistance of many pathogens have focused attention on vaccination to prevent infectious diseases. The efficacy of most licensed vaccines has been established in immunocompetent hosts. However, there is also considerable experience with most vaccines in those with impaired immunity. We reviewed the use of licensed live, inactivated, and polysaccharide vaccines in this group, and several themes emerged: (i) most vaccines are less immunogenic in those with impaired immunity than in normal individuals; (ii) live vaccines are generally contraindicated in this group; and (iii) the efficacy of many commonly used vaccines has not been established in people with impaired immunity. This review suggests that for most vaccines there are little or no efficacy data in those with impaired immunity but their use in this patient group is generally safe.

Intrathecal immune response in patients with the post-polio syndrome

BACKGROUND

The syndrome of progressive muscular atrophy decades after acute paralytic poliomyelitis (post-polio syndrome) is not well understood. The theory that physiologic changes and aging cause the new weakness does not explain the immunologic abnormalities reported in some patients. An alternative explanation is persistent or recurrent poliovirus infection.

METHODS

We assessed the intrathecal antibody response to poliovirus and intrathecal production of interleukin-2 and soluble interleukin-2 receptors in 36 patients with the post-polio syndrome and 67 controls (including 13 who had had poliomyelitis but had no new symptoms and 18 with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis). Intrathecal antibody responses to measles, mumps, herpes simplex, and varicella zoster viruses were also determined.

RESULTS

Oligoclonal IgM bands specific to poliovirus were detected in the cerebrospinal fluid of 21 of the 36 patients with the post-polio syndrome (58 percent) but in none of the control group (P less than 0.0001). In quantitative studies there was evidence of increased intrathecal synthesis of IgM antibodies to poliovirus only among the patients with the post-polio syndrome; there was no increased synthesis of IgM to measles, mumps, herpes simplex, or varicella zoster viruses. The patients with post-polio syndrome had significantly higher mean (+/- SD) (cerebrospinal fluid levels of interleukin-2 and soluble interleukin-2 receptors than the controls (8.1 +/- 5.3 vs. 1.4 +/- 0.8 U per milliliter and 159.6 +/- 102.9 vs. 10.7 +/- 6.2 U per milliliter, respectively). The intrathecal synthesis of IgM antibodies to poliovirus correlated with the cerebrospinal fluid concentrations of interleukin-2 (P less than 0.0005) and soluble interleukin-2 receptors (P less than 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

An intrathecal immune response against poliovirus is present in many patients with the post-polio syndrome. In some of these patients the recrudescence of muscle weakness may be caused by persistent or recurrent infection of neural cells with the poliovirus.

Vaccine-associated poliomyelitis in a household contact with Netherton's syndrome receiving long-term steroid therapy

Paralytic poliomyelitis developed in a man 51 days after his two-month-old daughter received her first dose of trivalent live oral poliovirus vaccine. The patient was receiving long-term glucocorticosteroid therapy (tapered to 12.5 mg per day for the eight months prior to his poliomyelitis) for Netherton's syndrome, a congenital syndrome characterized by bamboo-like hair, hyperkeratotic and hyperhidrotic skin, and multiple allergies. The patient was ventilator-dependent and quadriplegic throughout most of his hospital stay and died in the hospital 10 months after the onset of paralysis. "Vaccine-like" type 3 poliovirus was isolated from a stool specimen and his serum showed a significant rise in neutralizing antibody titer against type 3 virus. This case report represents the first documented case of vaccine-associated poliomyelitis in a household contact receiving glucocorticosteroids, although evidence of immunosuppression was not documented. Nevertheless, the case reinforces current recommendations not to administer oral poliovirus vaccine to persons known to be immune deficient or suppressed or to normal persons with close contacts known to be immune deficient or suppressed.

Progressive ascending paralysis following administration of intrathecal and intravenous cytosine arabinoside. A Pediatric Oncology Group study

Two childhood acute myelogenous leukemia (AML) patients receiving intrathecal (IT) and intravenous (IV) cytosine arabinoside (Ara-C) developed progressive ascending paralysis, resulting in death in one patient. Necropsy findings on this patient included spinal cord demyelination characteristic of Ara-C neurotoxicity. An unusual aspect of these two cases was the delay between cessation of IT therapy and the onset of neurologic symptoms. These patients received relatively low total doses of IT Ara-C and standard doses of IV Ara-C. Previous studies have shown that Ara-C equilibrates readily between serum and cerebrospinal fluid; this implies that total IV and IT doses of Ara-C may be additive in relation to development of neurotoxicity. For these reasons, use of IV and IT Ara-C in childhood AML must be approached with greater caution, especially if neurologic abnormalities develop during or after therapy.

Prolonged intracerebral infection with poliovirus in asymptomatic mice

A heretofore unrecognized prolonged asymptomatic infection has been identified in mice intracerebrally inoculated with Lansing strain type II poliovirus. Virus was detected by infectivity assay and nucleic acid hybridization and was found in brains as long as 77 days after injection. Viral RNA replication occurred, indicating that persisting virus was not an inactive residuum of the infecting dose. Virus was sometimes found by infectivity even when viral RNA could not be demonstrated by hybridization, but detection by nucleic acid hybridization alone never occurred. Among 56 animals--including mice that died of infection, mice with prolonged infection, and survivors from which virus was not recovered--no animal had a serum neutralization titer above 1:2 in a plaque reduction assay Moreover, brain homogenates of 30 survivors without virus did not have neutralization titers above 1:4 in the plaque reduction assay. These findings were the same as in mock-infected mice.

Giant cell pneumonia associated with parainfluenza virus type 3 infection

Giant cell pneumonia associated with parainfluenza virus type 3 infection and chronic poliovirus type 2 meningoencephalomyelitis are documented in an infant with combined immunologic deficiency (Swiss type). Caution should be exercised in attributing cases of giant cell pneumonia to measles virus without serologic or virologic evidence.

Vaccine-associated poliomyelitis in an infant with agammaglobulinemia

We describe a female infant with agammaglobulinemia who contracted vaccine-associated poliomyelitis. Poliovirus type 2 was isolated from the initial stool specimen. In our patient, temporary changes in the cerebrospinal fluid resembled those in patients without immunodeficiencies, although gammaglobulin therapy had not yet been started. Pleocytosis was observed for a short time after viremia, but soon there was a return to normal without antibody production.

Vaccine-associated poliomyelitis in a child with sex-linked agammaglobulinemia

Paralytic poliomyelitis was observed in a child with a sex-linked defect in immunoglobulin synthesis. Evidence is presented that this was secondary to administration of oral, live poliovaccine. The demonstration of a familial sex-linked gammaglobulin deficiency and the failure to document a defect in cell-mediated immunity in this child extends the risk of vaccine associated poliomyelitis to virtually all forms of immunodeficiency. The critical host factors in the pathogenesis of poliovirus vaccine infection and in particular its unfavorable outcome appear to include either a deficiency in the humoral (B cell) system or in the cell-mediated (T cell) system.

Chronic progressive poliomyelitis secondary to vaccination of an immunodeficient child

We investigated an immunodeficient child in whom chronic progressive poliomyelitis developed after she had received live oral poliovirus vaccine. Poliovirus, Type II, was isolated from throat and stool during life and from several sites within the brain at autopsy. The brain isolate was classified as vaccine-like on the basis of temperature sensitivity and antigenic markers. However, in the monkey neurovirulence test, the brain isolate produced moderately severe lesions throughout the spinal cord and brainstem and appeared nonvaccine-like. Thus, the brain isolate demonstrated a dissociation between the antigenic and neurovirulence markers. Our observations suggest that, under unusual circumstances, such as immunodeficiency, attenuated poliovirus can produce a chronic progressive neurologic disease. This case also emphasizes the need to diagnose immunodeficiency as early as possible, so that live-virus vaccines will not be administered.

Combined immunodeficiency and vaccine-related poliomyelitis in a child with cartilage-hair hypoplasia

Patients previously described with cartilage-hair hypoplasia, a distinctive form of short-limbed dwarfism, have been found to have deficient cell-mediated immunity with intact antibody-mediated immunity. The patient with cartilage-hair hypoplasia described in the present report is unusual in that she had both deficient antibody-mediated immunity and deficient cell-mediated immunity. In addition, she developed severe, vaccine-related paralytic poliomyelitis. This complication suggests that live viral vaccines should not be administered to children with short-limbed dwarfism until the form of short-limbed dwarfism is established and immunologic evaluation is performed when indicated.