Evaluation of the Limulus test for endotoxemia in neonates with suspected sepsis

Diagnostic Accuracy of Endotoxin and Endotoxin Binding Protein in Late-Onset Neonatal Sepsis

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the diagnostic utility of endotoxin and endotoxin binding protein (EBP) for the diagnosis of late-onset neonatal sepsis (LOS) and compare it with the diagnostic utility of C-reactive protein (CRP).

METHODS

This diagnostic study of neonates, both term and preterm, with clinical suspicion of LOS was conducted in a tertiary care institute in India between January 2021 and March 2023. Blood samples were collected for evaluating endotoxin and EBP along with culture. Endotoxin and EBP were measured with enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, CRP was measured by nephelometry method, and the results were compared with blood culture done with BACTEC (gold standard).

RESULTS

Out of 160 samples, 73 showed culture positivity. Endotoxin was positive in 81 samples and showed sensitivity of 84%, specificity of 78% and diagnostic accuracy of 81% (AUC 0.837, P value <0.001). EBP was positive in 82 samples and showed sensitivity of 80.8%, specificity of 73% and diagnostic accuracy of 76% (AUC 0.824, P value <0.001). CRP was positive in 105 samples and had sensitivity of 86%, specificity of 51% and diagnostic accuracy of 67% (AUC 0.827, P value <0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study showed endotoxin and EBP have higher specificity for diagnosing neonatal sepsis. As culture takes minimum 48 h, endotoxin and EBP can be utilized as biomarkers for diagnosis of sepsis.

Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) detection of endotoxin in human blood

Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) has been applied to the detection of endotoxin in human serum, plasma and blood since the early 1970s. Although the diagnostic potential of LAL for endotoxemia was recognized immediately, the assay's modest sensitivity and specificity (for Gram-negative sepsis/bacteremia) were perceived as limiting the clinical usefulness of LAL. In an attempt to overcome these drawbacks, many studies have been conducted since the initial work by Levin and his colleagues. Numerous attempts have been made to improve the sensitivity of the assay by changing the formulation of the LAL and assay methodology. The original gel-clot method has for the most part been replaced with turbidimetric or chromogenic methods. The amount of endotoxin detectable within a 1 h incubation period has gone from the nanogram to the picogram range. Since blood (plasma) components interfere with the test, various methods to remove inhibition and/or enhancement have been developed. The chloroform extraction technique of Levin and co-workers has been replaced with acid extraction or with dilution and heating. Partitioning of endotoxin in blood may also influence the assay (recovery). Many recent investigators use platelet-rich plasma instead of ordinary plasma, while a few studies have used whole blood. Even with all the improvements, the specificity and related diagnostic usefulness of the LAL assay for Gram-negative sepsis remain an obstacle for regulatory acceptance. This may have more to do with our understanding of the septic process than with the ability of LAL to detect endotoxin. Although a recent study indicates that the type of Gram-negative bacteremia may be a critical determinant for clinical utility of the LAL test, the presence of endotoxin is not highly predictive of Gram-negative sepsis and vice versa. However, with the potential availability of anti-endotoxin therapy, the diagnosis of endotoxemia, with or without bacteremia, may be extremely important for timely and effective treatment modalities. It is concluded that the LAL test and accompanying sample preparation has evolved into a clinically useful test for the detection of circulating endotoxins and even its modest predictability for sepsis may have some clinical utility.

Does gram-negative bacteraemia occur without endotoxaemia? A meta-analysis using hierarchical summary ROC curves

The limulus assay for endotoxin has been studied as a method for the rapid identification of gram-negative (GN) bacteraemia. The chromogenic (C-limulus) version is 100-fold more sensitive to an internal endotoxin standard than the earlier gelation version (G-limulus). The objective of this analysis is to compare the concordance between GN bacteraemia and endotoxaemia as determined in clinical studies using either version of the limulus assay. The summary results for the diagnostic odds ratio (DOR), sensitivity and specificity were derived using a hierarchical summary receiver operating characteristic (HSROC) method of meta-analysis. Fifty-eight studies (25 G-limulus and 33 C-limulus) were included. Surprisingly, the mean DOR (4.9; 3-7.9 versus 10.7; 5.2-21.8) was inferior for studies using the C-limulus versus the original G-limulus version of the assay. Moreover, among studies limited to sepsis syndrome patients, the mean DOR remains poor at 4.2 (1.8-9.5). The proportion of GN bacteraemic patients for whom endotoxaemia is not detectable with either version of the limulus assay is >20% among the 58 studies overall, but >30% after the exclusion of studies with <25 patients and >20% among studies of patients with sepsis syndrome. These findings help to reconcile seemingly disparate study results.

A systematic review of serologic tests in the diagnosis of necrotizing enterocolitis

BACKGROUND

Although many serologic markers have been suggested for diagnosis of necrotizing enterocolitis, there is little consensus on which of these is potentially clinically useful. Our aims were (i) to systematically review circulating markers that are potentially useful in the diagnosis of NEC and (ii) to compare the relative performance of each serologic marker of NEC by pooling estimates of marker accuracies and presenting their combined diagnostic accuracies.

METHODS

We undertook a systematic review of the literature to identify studies that reported serologic markers at the time of diagnosis of necrotizing enterocolitis. Where possible, we constructed 2-by-2 tables of diagnostic accuracy from each article, if 2 or more studies investigated the same test, their results were meta-analyzed by pooling estimates of sensitivity, specificity, likelihood ratio for positive index test (LR+), likelihood ratio for negative index test (LR-), diagnostic odds ratio, and their corresponding 95% confidence intervals.

RESULTS

Twenty-five articles provided information on serology at the time of diagnosis of necrotizing enterocolitis. Of these, it was possible to construct diagnostic accuracy tables from 16 articles and to combine data from studies that used C-reactive protein, intestinal fatty acid binding protein, and platelet-activating factor. Of these C-reactive protein was a sensitive but nonspecific marker for necrotizing enterocolitis, whereas platelet-activating factor and intestinal fatty acid binding protein were both sensitive and specific.

CONCLUSIONS

Most serologic markers of necrotizing enterocolitis have been used in too few studies to evaluate their use. Of those tests that have been tested repeatedly, platelet-activating factor and intestinal fatty acid binding protein are potentially useful, although their use must be further tested in larger prospective studies.

Lipopolysaccharide-binding protein, lipopolysaccharide, and soluble CD14 in sepsis of critically ill neonates and children

OBJECTIVE

To compare the diagnostic accuracy of lipopolysaccharide-binding protein (LBP) for sepsis in critically ill neonates and children with the two markers participating in the same inflammatory pathway, lipopolysaccharide and soluble CD14.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Prospective, observational study in a multidisciplinary neonatal and pediatric intensive care unit.

PATIENTS

47 critically ill neonates and 49 critically ill children with systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) and suspected sepsis, classified into two groups: those with and those without sepsis.

INTERVENTIONS

Serum LBP, lipopolysaccharide, soluble CD14, C-reactive protein, and procalcitonin were measured on 2 consecutive days. The area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC), sensitivity, specificity, and predictive values were evaluated.

RESULTS

AUC for LBP on the first day of suspected infection was 0.97 in neonates aged under 48 h, 0.93 in neonates over 48 h and 0.82 in children. AUCs for lipopolysaccharide and soluble CD14 were 0.77 and 0.74 in neonates under 48 h, 0.53 and 0.76 in neonates over 48 h, and 0.72 and 0.53 in children. AUCs for procalcitonin and C-reactive protein were 0.65 and 0.89 in neonates under 48 h, 0.65 and 0.91 in neonates over 48 h, and 0.76 and 0.69 in children.

CONCLUSIONS

In critically ill neonates and children LBP concentration on the first day of suspected sepsis is a better marker of sepsis than lipopolysaccharide, soluble CD14, procalcitonin, and in neonates younger than 48 h and children, also a better marker than C-reactive protein. Lipopolysaccharide and soluble CD14 are not suitable markers for the differentiation of infectious and noninfectious SIRS.

Different acute-phase response in newborns and infants undergoing surgery

In a prospective clinical study, we investigated the inflammatory response in 88 neonatal subjects (43 boys and 45 girls) who underwent major abdominal surgery owing to congenital malformation involving the gastrointestinal tract and compared it with the response in 20 infants (8 boys, 12 girls; mean age, 4 mo) who underwent elective surgery for resolution of an existing temporary stoma. In both groups, plasma levels of endotoxin, IL-6, and C-reactive protein as well as leukocyte counts were determined during and after surgery. Endotoxin was measured by the Limulus amebocyte test, IL-6 by ELISA, and C-reactive protein by nephelometry. Statistical analyses were performed using the Wilcoxon signed-rank test. A significant increase in circulating endotoxin and a leukocyte shift was observed in the infant group only. Postoperatively, IL-6 levels peaked between 2 and 6 h and C-reactive protein after 24 h in the infant group. In contrast, no significant increase in the levels of endotoxin, IL-6, and C-reactive protein in plasma were observed during and after surgery in the neonatal subjects, except those with gastroschisis. Newborns with gastroschisis developed an inflammatory response after surgery that was less pronounced than the response of infants older than 4 mo. The finding that endotoxemia in newborns does not follow surgical trauma is most likely because of the absence of bacterial colonization of the gastrointestinal tract.

Role of nitric oxide in down-regulation of CYP2B1 protein, but not RNA, in primary cultures of rat hepatocytes

There are conflicting reports about the role of nitric oxide in the down-regulation of cytochrome P450 that occurs when animals or cultured hepatocytes are exposed to inflammatory stimuli. Here, we investigated the participation of NO in the down-regulation of CYP2B1 by bacterial endotoxin (LPS) in rat hepatocytes cultured on Matrigel. LPS caused the down-regulation of CYP2B1 mRNA to 20% of control values within 12 h of treatment, and this was not reversed by concentrations of NO synthase inhibitors that completely blocked NO production. LPS was several orders of magnitude more potent in the down-regulation of CYP2B1 mRNA than in induction of NO production. In contrast, concentrations of LPS in the 1 to 100 ng/ml range induced NO production and produced a rapid down-regulation of CYP2B1 protein to 30% and <5% of control at 6 and 24 h, respectively, that could be completely prevented both by inhibitors of NO synthase and by LY83583, which prevents NO synthase-2 induction. The blockade of CYP2B1 down-regulation by NO synthase inhibitors was reversed by arginine, and the NO donors S-nitrosoglutathione and S-nitroso-N-acetylpenicillamine mimicked CYP2B1 protein suppression. Taken together, these experiments demonstrate two independent mechanisms of CYP2B1 down-regulation by LPS: a rapid, NO-dependent suppression of the protein occurring at high concentrations of LPS and a slower, NO-independent pretranslational suppression occurring at low concentrations of LPS.

Concordance of endotoxemia with gram-negative bacteremia. A meta-analysis using receiver operating characteristic curves

OBJECTIVE

To apply meta-analysis to compare the concordance between the results of 2 types of limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) assay, gelation (GLAL) and chromogenic (CLAL), with the detection of gram-negative bacteremia in patients with suspected bacteremia.

DESIGN

Meta-analysis using receiver operating characteristic-based analytical method.

DATA SOURCES

MEDLINE literature search and manual reviews of article bibliographies together with direct approaches to authors of potentially eligible studies.

STUDY SELECTION

The studies that were selected had all included at least 10 patients, of whom at least 2 patients were diagnosed with gram-negative bacteremia, and all had data available for extraction into a contingency table format.

RESULTS

Fifty-six studies (28 GLAL and 28 CLAL studies) met the inclusion criteria. Studies were stratified by type of test (GLAL vs CLAL). Each analysis was repeated with smaller studies excluded. There was no difference between the 2 types of LAL assays. Among the CLAL studies, there was no difference between studies that did versus those that did not use the sepsis syndrome criteria as a basis for patient inclusion. Among 45 studies for which data on the proportion of non-Enterobacteriaceae were available, there was a trend toward higher concordance as this proportion increased.

CONCLUSIONS

The concordance between the LAL test and the detection of gram-negative bacteremia in patients with suspected bacteremia is no higher with the CLAL assay than with the original GLAL version. However, the concordance is higher among studies with a higher proportion of non-Enterobacteriaceae among the gram-negative bacteremia isolates.

Diagnostic tests for bacterial infection from birth to 90 days--a systematic review

AIM

To determine the clinical value of common diagnostic tests for bacterial infection in early life.

METHODS

A Medline search (1966-95) was undertaken to identify studies that reported the assessment of a diagnostic "test," predicting the presence or absence of bacterial infection in infants up to 90 days of age. The quality of each selected study was assessed using defined criteria. Data were extracted twice to minimise errors.

RESULTS

Six hundred and seventy articles were identified. Two independent investigators agreed that 194 studies met the inclusion criteria (kappa = 0.85), 52 of which met primary quality criteria; 23 studies reported data on (a) haematological indices, (b) C reactive protein evaluation, and (c) surface swab assessment. For haematological indices, the likelihood ratios for individual tests ranged from 20.4 (95% confidence interval 7.3 to 56.8) for a white cell count < 7000/mm3 to 0.12 (0.04 to 0.37) for an immature:total (I:T) white cell ratio < 0.2. For C reactive protein evaluation, the likelihood ratios ranged from 12.56 (0.79 to 199.10) for a value of > 6 mg/l to 0.22 (0.08 to 0.65) for a negative value. For surface swab assessment, the likelihood ratios ranged from 33.6 (2.1 to 519.8) for a positive gastric aspirate culture to 0.08 (0.006 to 1.12) for microscopy of ear swab material that did not show any neutrophils. Likelihood ratios for combinations of these individual tests ranged from 10.17 (3.64 to 28.41) to 0.47 (0.22 to 1.00).

CONCLUSIONS

The methodological quality of studies assessing the accuracy of diagnostic tests is generally poor. Even in rigorous studies, the reported accuracy of the tests varies enormously and they are of limited value in the diagnosis of infection in this population.

Early diagnosis and treatment of neonatal sepsis

Perinatally acquired bacterial neonatal sepsis is a low incidence, high risk disease with a relatively benign treatment. Accurate diagnosis is difficult because there is no definitive diagnostic test; even blood cultures have an unacceptably low sensitivity. Therefore, the clinician must accept that a number of neonates who do not have the disease will have treatment initiated for sepsis. In order to treat rapidly all infants with sepsis and to minimize therapy for those without infection, historical, clinical, and laboratory data can be used together in a management approach to achieve optimal results. A systemized approach using history, examination, sepsis screen laboratory tests, and cultures is presented to guide clinical management.

Circulating neutrophils in septic preterm neonates: comparison of two reference ranges

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect of sepsis on circulating neutrophils in very low birth weight neonates and to assess the usefulness of recently revised reference ranges for circulating neutrophils in the diagnosis of sepsis in this population by comparison with previously reported reference ranges.

METHODS

Neutrophil parameters (absolute total neutrophils, absolute total immature neutrophils, and the immature:total neutrophil proportion) were analyzed retrospectively in 202 sepsis episodes in 192 neonates (birth weight = 1055 +/- 246 g, X +/- SD; estimated gestational age = 29 +/- 2 weeks) between birth and 30 days of age. The percentage of values lying outside the reference ranges reported recently by Mouzinho et al and previously by Manroe et al were compared. To more accurately assess possible differences in specificity between the two reference ranges, neonates with early-onset group B streptococcal infection (n = 19) were compared with a matched control group (n = 51) using conditional logistic regression.

RESULTS

Greater sensitivity was observed using the previous reference ranges of Manroe et al over the entire study period (0 to 720 hours) both for the initial and the second complete blood count (CBC). The previous reference ranges also were more sensitive than the revised ranges for the initial CBC at 0 to 72 and at 73 to 720 hours and for infections attributable to coagulase-negative staphylococci. However, specificity in neonates without group B streptococcal infection was significantly greater with the revised reference ranges compared with those of Manroe et al (initial CBC, 73% vs 45%; serial CBCs, 59% vs 10%).

CONCLUSION

The observed differences in sensitivities may be of limited clinical significance because very low birth weight infants often are begun on antibiotic therapy regardless of laboratory values. However, the striking differences in specificity using the revised reference ranges suggest that these ranges may be clinically useful in determining length of antimicrobial therapy in infants in whom cultures remain sterile.

Endotoxemia: methods of detection and clinical correlates

As an assay for endotoxin, the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay has several desirable properties: sensitivity, specificity, and potential for adaptation to a quantitative format. Several modifications have been developed to enhance its potential for clinical application. The modifications that allow quantitative measurement of endotoxin and also improve its application to blood samples are described in this review. In fluids other than blood, the detection of endotoxin with the Limulus amebocyte lysate assay can be used as an aid to identify the presence of gram-negative bacteria, and the assay has established utility. With blood, however, there are a range of factors that interfere with the detection of endotoxemia and there are disparate views with respect to the diagnostic and prognostic significance of the test results. In general, the clinical significance of the finding of endotoxemia broadly parallels the frequency and importance of gram-negative sepsis in the patient groups studied and a decline in endotoxin levels accompanies clinical improvement. However, with therapies designed to reduce levels of endotoxin, or to antagonize its effects, it is unclear whether clinical improvement occurs as a consequence of changes in the levels of endotoxemia.

Concordance of endotoxemia with gram-negative bacteremia in patients with gram-negative sepsis: a meta-analysis

The Limulus amebocyte lysate (LAL) assay is a sensitive method for detecting endotoxin. Using gram-negative (GN) bacteremia as the basis for comparison, concordance with endotoxemia in 45 studies could be expressed as an odds ratio. Calculation of summary odds ratios by the Mantel-Haenszel-Peto method indicated that the concordance of the results was no higher by the chromogenic LAL assay than by the gelation version, and the sensitivity was improved by only 11% (62 versus 51%). Endotoxemia was detected in 77 (68%) of 114 patients with bacteremia caused by an organism that was not a member of the family Enterobacteriaceae, whereas endotoxemia was detected in only 120 (45%) of 269 patients with bacteremia caused by a member of the family Enterobacteriaceae or an anaerobe (P < 0.001). This difference was also apparent for patients with GN bacteremia for whom a fatal outcome had been recorded. The prevalence of GN bacteremia in the tested population and the type of etiological agent are critical and previously unrecognized variables which affect the interpretation of the LAL test in patients with suspected sepsis.

Perioperative change of plasma endotoxin levels in early infants

As a preliminary study to elucidate the relationship of endotoxemia to postoperative morbidity, the plasma endotoxin levels in 64 surgical neonates were quantitated by the chromogenic limulus test (Toxicolor test; Seikagaku Kogyo, Tokyo, Japan). The preoperative levels of plasma endotoxin were 64 +/- 59 pg/mL in the group of infants with perforated peritonitis (n = 9), 63 +/- 51 pg/mL in the group of infants with gastroschisis (n = 7), and 15 +/- 16 pg/mL in the group of infants with ileus (n = 28), while the mean level was 6 +/- 5 pg/mL in the remaining 20 surgical neonates who had no signs of ileus or peritonitis. In the serial determination of plasma endotoxin in 28 neonates, the levels on the first postoperative day increased significantly compared with the preoperative levels (16 +/- 18 pg/mL to 46 +/- 25 pg/mL, P less than .01). They decreased gradually to 8 +/- 5 pg/mL within a week in 15 neonates who had no postoperative complications. However, in 13 neonates who had postoperative complications such as wound infection or postoperative ileus, the postoperative levels of plasma endotoxin increased to a much higher level and remained there. In this article the relationship of clinical endotoxemia to postoperative thrombocytopenia and hyperbilirubinemia is analyzed, and the usefulness of evaluating endotoxemia in surgical neonates is discussed.

Current perspectives on septic shock

Although septic shock may be initiated by invading microbes, it is the metabolic and immunologic host responses that determine the true pathophysiology of this common critical care illness. Currently, septic shock therapeutics emphasize empiric and symptomatic treatment. Biochemical elucidation of the septic process will ultimately result in specific interventions for this ominous intensive care syndrome.

Septicaemic low birthweight neonates treated with human antibodies to endotoxin

In a double blind controlled study antilipopolysaccharide gammaglobulin given intramuscularly did not reduce mortality in low birthweight babies suffering from septicaemia. It did, however, reduce the recovery period of survivors from 310 to 120 hours.

Turbidimetric method for quantifying serum inhibition of Limulus amoebocyte lysate

This study describes a method to quantify the inhibition of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) activity by serum with a turbidimetric Limulus amoebocyte lysate assay. Assays were performed in multiwell microplates, and turbidity was measured as the optical density at 380 nm with a microplate spectrophotometer. LPS potency was measured as the 50% maximal Limulus amoebocyte response (LR50) of LPS diluted with saline. By comparing LR50s in saline, LPSs from various species of bacteria were standardized against the U.S. Reference Standard Endotoxin, lot EC-5. The potency of Escherichia coli O113 and O18 and Serratia marcescens LPSs was found to be equal to that of the reference standard EC-5, whereas LPSs from two salmonella species were half as potent. The least potent LPSs tested, obtained from Klebsiella pneumoniae and E. coli rough mutant J5, were 5- and 10-fold less potent, respectively, than EC-5. As a measure of inhibition, the LR50 of LPS in serum was compared to the LR50 of LPS in saline. Serum inhibited the potency of LPS 103- to 6,400-fold compared with saline. A positive correlation was found between standardized potency in saline and serum inhibition of the various LPSs tested. Thus, LPSs from E. coli O113, O18, and EC-5 and S. marcescens, which exhibited the highest potency in saline, were inhibited the most by serum. Likewise, E. coli J5 and K. pneumoniae LPSs, which were the least potent tested, were the least inhibited. The degree of inhibition of all types of LPS tested increased with increasing serum concentration.

Endotoxin clearance by exchange blood transfusion in septic shock neonates

The role of exchange transfusion with fresh whole blood in septic shock infants was evaluated. Endotoxin was positive in 8 of 10 infants and completely removed from 6 by exchange transfusion. All 6 infants with negative endotoxins after exchange transfusions survived, but 2 with positive reactions died despite the exchange transfusion. Staphylococcus aureus was cultured in the blood from 2 infants with negative reactions and one of them survived. These findings suggested that the clearance of endotoxin has an important role in exchange transfusion among septic shock neonates.