Mechanisms responsible for the limited lifespan and immortal phenotypes in cultured mammalian cells

Twenty years of ageing research at the Mill Hill laboratories

Research on ageing was carried out in the Genetics Division laboratories, Mill Hill, London, from 1970 to 1990, resulting in more than 100 publications. The work centred around the in vitro ageing of human diploid fibroblasts, but there was also research on transformed cells, rat and mouse tissues, human lymphocytes, chick cells, mice and a microbial model system. The major conclusion from all this research, together with a broad overview of the whole field of gerontology, is that ageing has multiple causes, and that adult animals become senescent through the eventual failure of several important maintenance mechanisms.

Ageing research in Greece

Ageing research in Greece is well established. Research groups located in universities, research institutes or public hospitals are studying various and complementary aspects of ageing. These research activities include (a) functional analysis of Clusterin/Apolipoprotein J, studies in healthy centenarians and work on protein degradation and the role of proteasome during senescence at the National Hellenic Research Foundation; (b) regulation of cell proliferation and tissue formation, a nationwide study of determinants and markers of successful ageing in Greek centenarians and studies of histone gene expression and acetylation at the National Center for Scientific Research, Demokritos; (c) work on amyloid precursor protein and Presenilin 1 at the University of Athens; (d) oxidative stress-induced DNA damage and the role of oncogenes in senescence at the University of Ioannina; (e) studies in the connective tissue at the University of Patras; (f) proteomic studies at the Biomedical Sciences Research Center Alexander Fleming; (g) work on Caenorhabditis elegans at the Foundation for Research and Technology; (h) the role of ultraviolet radiation in skin ageing at Andreas Sygros Hospital; (i) follow-up studies in healthy elderly at the Athens Home for the Aged; and (j) socio-cultural aspects of ageing at the National School of Public Health. These research activities are well recognized by the international scientific community as it is evident by the group's very good publication records as well as by their direct funding from both European Union and USA. This article summarizes these research activities and discuss future directions and efforts towards the further development of the ageing field in Greece.

A proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy study of aging and transformed human fibroblasts

Proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H MRS) has been used to monitor changes occurring during aging and transformation in human lung fibroblasts. Aging was studied in MRC-5 cells from nonsenescent (early passage) to presenescent (late passage) and senescence. Nonsenescent cells infected with SV40 virus (pretransformed) were monitored through crisis and subsequent immortalization. Aging changes were observed with one- and two-dimensional MR spectra. Cholesterol and lipid resonances were significantly increased from nonsenescent cultures to senescence. These changes could be caused by chemical or structural changes in the plasma membrane or in intracellular lipid pools. In contrast, choline levels rose from nonsenescent to presenescent cells but at senescence dropped to that of nonsenescent cells. Increased choline levels are often associated with increased cellular proliferation. After SV40 infection of MRC-5 cells there was an increase of cholesterol and lipid levels that peaked at crisis. Newly immortalized cells exhibited a drop in cholesterol and lipid to nonsenescent cell levels, but these rose again in established immortalized cells. In contrast to presensescent cultures, the levels of choline gradually increased from pretransformed to crisis phase but still continued to rise after immortalization. Thus, 1H MRS illustrates similarities in lipid behavior at senescence and crisis, whereas the choline levels are different.

The role of DNA damage in cellular aging: is it time for a reassessment?

There is now evidence that the immediate cause of the loss of proliferative capacity in senescent cells is mediated by a specific inhibitor. If this tentative interpretation is correct, the next hurdle will be to determine mechanism(s) that regulate this putative senescence cell inhibitor that would, in effect, be the determinant of proliferative life span. One previously proposed hypothesis predicts that the decline of replicative activity is analogous to a checkpoint response to accumulated chromosomal damage (Rosenberger et al., 1991). Advances in our basic understanding of the nature of DNA damage, DNA repair mechanisms, and the response of eukaryotic cells to accumulated DNA damage provide a solid rationale for a reassessment of the causal role of the accumulation of chromosomal damage in cell senescence in vitro.

The initiation of senescence and its relationship to embryonic cell differentiation

Mouse embryonic stem cells have an unlimited lifespan in cultures if they are prevented from differentiating. After differentiating, they produce cells which divide only a limited number of times. These changes seen in cultures parallel events that occur in the developing embryo, where immortal embryonic cells differentiate and produce mortal somatic ones. The data strongly suggest that differentiation initiates senescence, but this view entails additional assumptions in order to explain how the highly differentiated sexual gametes manage to remain potentially immortal. Cells differentiate by blocking expression from large parts of their genome and it is suggested that losses or gains of genetic totipotency determine cellular lifespans. Cells destined to be somatic do not regain totipotency and senesce, while germ-line cells regain complete genome expression and immortality after meiosis and gamete fusions. Losses of genetic totipotency could induce senescence by lowering the levels of repair and maintenance enzymes.

Decrease in cellular replicative potential in "giant" mice transfected with the bovine growth hormone gene correlates to shortened life span

Adult mice, (C57BL/6 x Sjl)F1 hybrids, transfected with the bovine growth hormone gene (bGH) grow to twice normal size, but have a mean life span less than 50% that of control siblings without the transgene. The replicative potentials of cells from six different tissue sites (tail skin and ear skin dermal fibroblasts, tail subdermal connective tissue fibroblasts, kidney medulla epithelial cells, bone marrow myofibroblasts, and spleen myofibroblasts) were assayed in vitro using clone size distribution analysis. Cells from all of the above bGH+ tissues produced a smaller fraction of large clones, relative to age-matched controls, in all of these cell types. The loss of replicative potential did not appear to be the result of negative conditioning of the cloning media by the bGH+ cells, and was tightly correlated to the period of accelerated growth in these animals (3-12 weeks), a time when additional GH receptors are expressed.

Cellular senescence

The ageing of cells, cellular senescence, is an event that is encountered in all normal cells. Cells grown in vitro have a limited life span and do not grow well after a certain number of divisions. They cease to divide and eventually die. In accordance with this, the life expectancy of an established cell culture depends on the age of the donor. Cells that have undergone immortalization via a crisis period of transformation by chemicals or viruses, as well as malignant cell lines in general, have an ability to divide indefinitely. A distinct form of cell death, apoptosis or programmed cell death, is encountered in many physiological situations like in keratinocyte differentiation.

Simian virus 40 large tumor antigen alone or two cooperating oncogenes convert REF52 cells to a state permissive for gene amplification

Gene amplification is characteristic of tumors and continuous cell lines but not of primary, normal, diploid, senescing cells. However, the rat cell line REF52, which resembles primary cells in requiring expression of cooperating oncogenes for transformation, is unusual among cell lines as it is not permissive for amplification. REF52 cells did not form colonies in N-(phosphonacetyl)-L-aspartate (PALA), a drug for which the only known mechanism of resistance is amplification of the carbamoylphosphate synthetase/aspartate transcarbamoylase/dihydroorotase (CAD) gene. Colonies did form in a low concentration of methotrexate but did not contain amplified dihydrofolate reductase genes. Expression of two cooperating oncogenes in REF52 cells converted them to a state permissive for amplification. Cells expressing only the 12S E1A mRNA of adenovirus 5 did not give rise to PALA-resistant colonies, but expression of an activated ras gene together with E1A readily allowed the cells to form resistant colonies in which the CAD gene was amplified. Cells expressing E1A plus ras were fully transformed, but expression of simian virus 40 large tumor antigen alone converted REF52 cells to a state permissive for amplification without transforming them fully. The ability to manipulate gene amplification in REF52 cells by expression of oncogenes should contribute to an understanding of the nature of the permissive state.

The cultured diploid fibroblast as a model for the study of cellular aging

The limited proliferative potential of the cultured human diploid fibroblast is now well established. A number of biological correlates suggest that this culture system is a model for the study of aging at the cellular level. The mechanism(s) that causes the loss of proliferative activity is unknown; the results of some recent studies indicate that specific genes may play a pivotal role in cellular aging in vitro. The extent to which changes in proliferative functions are causally related to aging in vivo is currently under investigation.

Altered cellular responsiveness during ageing

The capacity of cells and organisms to respond to external stimuli and to maintain stability in order to survive decreases progressively during ageing. The mitogenic and stimulatory effects of growth factors, hormones and other agents are reduced significantly during cellular ageing. The sensitivity of ageing cells to toxic agents including antibiotics, phorbol esters, radiations and heat shock increases. This failure of homeostasis during cellular ageing does not appear to be due to any quantitative and qualitative defects in the receptor systems. Instead, metabolic defects in the pathways of macromolecular synthesis may be the basis of altered cellular responsiveness during ageing.

Senescence and the accumulation of abnormal proteins

Mammalian cells can produce abnormal proteins in a number of different ways. These include random errors during protein synthesis, spontaneous or metabolite-induced modifications of amino acid sidechains and changes in polypeptide folding. The evidence that such alterations occur in proteins during growth and senescence is discussed. An important function controlling the accumulation of abnormal proteins is the rate at which they are hydrolysed by proteases. Modified proteins are much better protease substrates than their normal parent molecules, but in spite of this sensitivity to proteolysis they accumulate during ageing. This indicates a drop during senescence in the activity of those proteases degrading abnormal polypeptides. Ways in which abnormal proteins could inhibit cell growth and how these inhibitions may be negated during the immortalisation of diploid cells are discussed.

Genetic basis of limited cell proliferation

Knowledge about the changes that occur as cells traverse their replicative lifespans grows apace, as evidenced by the articles in this issue. Controversy over the interpretation of this knowledge continues, however, and is indeed fuelled by new discoveries (e.g., see Cristofalo, 1990; Holliday, 1990; Smith, 1990). This paper makes a brief commentary on the problems of cellular ageing, with particular emphasis on the unfolding picture of the genetic control of ageing and longevity which derives from evolutionary theory (Kirkwood and Rose, 1991). The case is argued for a synthetic view which recognizes that the immediate causes of limited cell proliferation probably involve some form of active genetic control, but that the ultimate reason for cell ageing is found in evolutionary theories which suggest that the ageing process is not actively programmed and that senescence may be due to the accumulation of damage.