Microtubule dynamics in the spindle. Theoretical aspects of assembly/disassembly reactions in vivo

Traction fibre: toward a "tensegral" model of the spindle

Most current hypotheses of mitotic mechanisms are based on the "PAC-MAN" paradigm in which chromosome movement is generated and powered by disassembly of kinetochore microtubules (k-MTs) by the kinetochore. Recent experiments demonstrate that this model cannot explain force generation for anaphase chromosome movement [Pickett-Heaps et al., 1996: Protoplasma 192:1-10]. Another such experiment is described here: a UV-microbeam cut several kinetochore fibres (k-fibres) in newt epithelial cells at metaphase and the half-spindle immediately shortened: in several cells, the remaining intact spindle fibres bowed outwards as they came under increased compression. Thus, severing of k-MTs can lead to increased tension between chromosomes and poles. This observation cannot be explained by models in which force is produced by motor molecules at the kinetochore actively disassembling k-MTs. Rather, we argue that tensile forces act along the whole k-fibre, which, therefore, can be considered as a classic "traction fibre." We suggest that anaphase polewards force is generated by MTs interacting with the spindle matrix and when k-MTs are severed, polewards force continues to act on the remaining kMT-stub; spindle MTs act as rigid struts concurrently resisting and being controlled by these forces. We suggest that the principles of "cellular tensegrity" [Ingber, 1993: J. Cell Sci. 104:613-627] derived from the behaviour and organization of the interphase cell apply to the spindle. In an evolutionary context, this argument further suggests that the spindle might originally have evolved as the mechanism by which a single tensegral unit (cytoplast) is divided into two cytoplasts; use of the spindle for segregating chromosomes might represent a secondary, more recent development of this primary function. If valid, this concept has implications for the way the spindle functions and for the spindle's relationship to cytokinesis.

Ultraviolet microbeam irradiations of epithelial and spermatocyte spindles suggest that forces act on the kinetochore fibre and are not generated by its disassembly

Ultraviolet (UV) microbeam irradiations of crane-fly spermatocyte and newt epithelial spindles severed kinetochore fibres (KT-fibres), creating areas of reduced birefringence (ARBs): the remnant KT-fibre consists of two "stubs," a pole-stub attached to the pole and a KT-stub attached to the kinetochore. KT-stubs remained visible but pole-stubs soon became undetectable [Forer et al., 1996]. At metaphase, in both cell types the KT-stub often changed orientation immediately after irradiation and its tip steadily moved poleward. In spermatocytes, the chromosome attached to the KT-stub remained at the equator as the KT-stub elongated. In epithelial cells, the KT-stub sometimes elongated as the associated chromosome remained at the equator; other times the associated chromosome moved poleward together with the KT-stub, albeit only a short distance toward the pole. When an ARB was generated at anaphase, chromosome(s) with a KT-stub often continued to move poleward. In spermatocytes, this movement was accompanied by steady elongation of the KT-stub. In epithelial cells, chromosomes accelerated polewards after irradiation until the KT-stubs reached the pole, after which chromosome movement returned to normal speeds. In some epithelial cells fine birefringent fibres by chance were present along one edge of ARBs; these remnant fibres buckled and broke as the KT-stub and chromosome moved polewards. Similarly, KT-stubs that moved into pole stubs (or astral fibres) caused the pole stubs (or astral fibres) to bend sharply from the point of impact. Our results contradict models of chromosome movement that postulate that force is generated by the kinetochore disassembling the KT-fibre. Instead, these results suggest that poleward directed forces act on the KT-fibre and the KT-stub and suggest that continuity of microtubules between kinetochore and pole is not obligatory for achieving anaphase motion to the pole.

Reactivation of isolated mitotic apparatus: metaphase versus anaphase spindles

Mitotic spindles isolated from sea urchin eggs can be reactivated to undergo mitotic processes in vitro. Spindles incubated in reactivation media containing sea urchin tubulin and nucleotides undergo pole-pole elongation similar to that observed in living cells during anaphase-B. The in vitro behavior of spindles isolated during metaphase and anaphase are compared. Both metaphase and anaphase spindles undergo pole-pole elongation with similar rates, but only in the presence of added tubulin. In contrast, metaphase but not anaphase spindles increase chromosome-pole distance in the presence of exogenous tubulin, suggesting that in vitro, tubulin can be incorporated at the kinetochores of metaphase but not anaphase chromosomes. The rate of spindle elongation, ultimate length achieved, and the increase in chromosome-pole distance for isolated metaphase spindles is related to the concentration of available tubulin. Pole-pole elongation and chromosome-pole elongation does not require added adenosine triphosphate (ATP). Guanosine triphosphate (GTP) will support all activities observed. Thus, the force generation mechanism for anaphase-B in isolated sea urchin spindles is independent of added ATP, but dependent on the availability of tubulin. These results support the hypothesis that the mechanism of force generation for anaphase-B is linked to the incorporation of tubulin into the mitotic apparatus. (If, in addition, a microtubule-dependent motor-protein(s) is acting to generate force, it does not appear to be dependent on ATP as the exclusive energy source.

UV microbeam irradiations of the mitotic spindle. II. Spindle fiber dynamics and force production

Metaphase and anaphase spindles in cultured newt and PtK1 cells were irradiated with a UV microbeam (285 nM), creating areas of reduced birefringence (ARBs) in 3 s that selectively either severed a few fibers or cut across the half spindle. In either case, the birefringence at the polewards edge of the ARB rapidly faded polewards, while it remained fairly constant at the other, kinetochore edge. Shorter astral fibers, however, remained present in the enlarged ARB; presumably these had not been cut by the irradiation. After this enlargement of the ARB, metaphase spindles recovered rapidly as the detached pole moved back towards the chromosomes, reestablishing spindle fibers as the ARB closed; this happened when the ARB cut a few fibers or across the entire half spindle. We never detected elongation of the cut kinetochore fibers. Rather, astral fibers growing from the pole appeared to bridge and then close the ARB, just before the movement of the pole toward the chromosomes. When a second irradiation was directed into the closing ARB, the polewards movement again stopped before it restarted. In all metaphase cells, once the pole had reestablished connection with the chromosomes, the unirradiated half spindle then also shortened to create a smaller symmetrical spindle capable of normal anaphase later. Anaphase cells did not recover this way; the severed pole remained detached but the chromosomes continued a modified form of movement, clumping into a telophase-like group. The results are discussed in terms of controls operating on spindle microtubule stability and mechanisms of mitotic force generation.

The mechanism of anaphase spindle elongation

At anaphase chromosomes move to the spindle poles (anaphase A) and the spindle poles move apart (anaphase B). In vitro studies using isolated diatom spindles demonstrate that the primary mechanochemical event responsible for spindle elongation is the sliding apart of half-spindle microtubules. Further, these forces are generated within the zone of microtubule overlap in the spindle mid-zone.

Characteristics of microtubules at the different stages of neuronal differentiation and maturation

The developing nervous system has proved to be a very powerful tool to analyze how MT are involved in basic biological processes such as cell proliferation, cell migration, cell shaping, and transport. A better knowledge of the basic events occurring during neurogenesis also affords us the possibility of establishing the basis of experiments and trying to solve unanswered and important questions. Despite the considerable value of cell culture, we need to use more discrete regions of the developing brain in situ in order to analyze the MT and their modifications into cells developing their "natural" environment. One major problem remains the question of the mode of assembly and disassembly, that is, the behavior of MT in living cells. Dynamic instability and/or treadmilling are accurate interpretations of the dynamics of MT at least in vitro or in cell culture, but we do need more information on what happens in situ and in vitro. One of the main tasks of cell biologists is to devise satisfactory tests to approach this fundamental question. In this view, pharmacological manipulation of embryos treated in whole-embryo culture systems might be a possible way. Microtubules are ubiquitous cell components. However, the extensive heterogeneity of MAP and tubulin in the CNS confers on the neurons a wide range of capabilities of assembly of these proteins and suggests that the neuron has a unique potential of a relation between MT composition and cell function. We have seen that each major event during neurogenesis is related to a specific series of modifications of the MT components. It remains to be determined if there is a causal or just a correlative relationship between the appearance of specific isotypes and the occurrence of specific events and/or functions. We have also to determine the exact spatial and temporal relations among the different isotypes of MT proteins, tubulin, and MAP. Is there a close correspondence between a tubulin and a MAP isotype? Can the appearance of one isotype of tubulin influence the appearance and the assembly of a specific MAP, or vice versa? Recent results obtained with the Tyr- and Glu-MT shed light on these questions and suggest a whole series of possibilities for cells to modulate the structure, behavior, and function of MT in specific domains of the neuron or in specific regions of the brain, by only a minute modification of the molecule of tubulin. Microtubule protein heterogeneity raises also a number of questions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The mechanism of anaphase spindle elongation: uncoupling of tubulin incorporation and microtubule sliding during in vitro spindle reactivation

To study tubulin polymerization and microtubule sliding during spindle elongation in vitro, we developed a method of uncoupling the two processes. When isolated diatom spindles were incubated with biotinylated tubulin (biot-tb) without ATP, biot-tb was incorporated into two regions flanking the zone of microtubule overlap, but the spindles did not elongate. After biot-tb was removed, spindle elongation was initiated by addition of ATP. The incorporated biot-tb was found in the midzone between the original half-spindles. The extent and rate of elongation were increased by preincubation in biot-tb. Serial section reconstruction of spindles elongating in tubulin and ATP showed that the average length of half-spindle microtubules increased due to growth of microtubules from the ends of native microtubules. The characteristic packing pattern between antiparallel microtubules was retained even in the "new" overlap region. Our results suggest that the forces required for spindle elongation are generated by enzymes in the overlap zone that mediate the sliding apart of antiparallel microtubules, and that tubulin polymerization does not contribute to force generation. Changes in the extent of microtubule overlap during spindle elongation were affected by tubulin and ATP concentration in the incubation medium. Spindles continued to elongate even after the overlap zone was composed entirely of newly polymerized microtubules, suggesting that the enzyme responsible for microtubule translocation either is bound to a matrix in the spindle midzone, or else can move on one microtubule toward the spindle midzone and push another microtubule of opposite polarity toward the pole.

In vitro reactivation of anaphase B in isolated spindles of the sea urchin egg

Spindles may be isolated from sea urchin eggs so that some mitotic processes can be reactivated in vitro. The isolation media allow spindles to remain stable for days. Transfer of the spindles to reactivation media results in loss of birefringence and breakdown of the matrix within which the microtubules function. If, however, tubulin and either guanosine triphosphate or adenosine triphosphate are present in these media so that tubulin can cycle, the spindles do not break down but grow in size and birefringence and show some of the movements of in vivo spindles. The most prominent is that of anaphase B if the mitotic apparatuses (MAs) have been isolated at a time when anaphase was initiated. When isolated during metaphase, MAs either do not show chromosome movement or, if they do, it is a random movement which causes redistribution of the chromosomes on the spindle surface. In either case, such metaphase spindles grow in size and birefringence. Thus under the proper conditions, cycling microtubules can interact with the spindle matrix to induce chromosome movements which resemble those seen in in vivo cells in the case of anaphase B and show some aspects of anaphase A in at least half the spindles isolated at metaphase, although such movements are not coordinated to show a true anaphase movement.

On the mechanism of anaphase A: evidence that ATP is needed for microtubule disassembly and not generation of polewards force

As anaphase began, mitotic PtK1 and newt lung epithelial cells were permeabilized with digitonin in permeabilization medium (PM). Permeabilization stopped cytoplasmic activity, chromosome movement, and cytokinesis within about 3 min, presumably due to the loss of endogenous ATP. ATP, GTP, or ATP-gamma-S added in the PM 4-7 min later restarted anaphase A while kinetochore fibers shortened. AMPPNP could not restart anaphase A; ATP was ineffective if the spindle was stabilized in PM + DMSO. Cells permeabilized in PM + taxol varied in their response to ATP depending on the stage of anaphase reached: one mid-anaphase cell showed initial movement of chromosomes back to the metaphase plate upon permeabilization but later, anaphase A resumed when ATP was added. Anaphase A was also reactivated by cold PM (approximately 16 degrees C) or PM containing calcium (1-10 mM). Staining of fixed cells with antitubulin showed that microtubules (MTs) were relatively stable after permeabilization and MT assembly was usually promoted in asters. Astral and kinetochore MTs were sensitive to MT disassembly conditions, and shortening of kinetochore MTs always accompanied reactivation of anaphase A. Interphase and interzonal spindle MTs were relatively stable to cold and calcium until extraction of cells was promoted by longer periods in the PM, or by higher concentrations of detergent. Since we cannot envisage how both cold treatment or relatively high calcium levels can reactivate spindle motility in quiescent, permeabilized, and presumably energy-depleted cells, we conclude that anaphase A is powered by energy stored in the spindle. The nucleotide triphosphates effective in reactivating anaphase A could be necessary for the kinetochore MT disassembly without which anaphase movement cannot proceed.

Interzone microtubule behavior in late anaphase and telophase spindles

We have studied microtubule behavior in late anaphase and telophase spindles of PtK1 cells, using fluoresceinated tubulin (DTAF-tubulin), microinjection, and laser microbeam photobleaching. We present the results of two novel tests which add to the evidence that DTAF-tubulin closely mimics the behavior of native tubulin in vivo. (a) Microinjected DTAF-tubulin was as effective as injected native tubulin in promoting division of taxol-dependent mitotic mutant cells that had been deprived of taxol. (b) Microinjected colchicine-DTAF-tubulin complex was similar to injected colchicine-native tubulin complex in causing depolymerization of spindles. Immediately after microinjection of DTAF-tubulin into wild-type cells during late anaphase or telophase, fluorescence incorporation by microtubules was seen in chromosomal half-spindles and just behind the chromosomes, but there was no fluorescence incorporation near the middle of the interzone. Over the next few minutes, tubulin fluorescence accumulated at the center of the interzone (the equator), becoming progressively more intense. In other experiments, cells were microinjected with DTAF-tubulin at prophase and allowed to equilibrate for 30 min. Cells that had progressed to late anaphase were then photobleached to reduce the fluorescence in the central portion of the interzone. Over a period of several minutes, the only substantial redistribution of fluorescence was the appearance of a bright area at the equator of the interzone. Both the site of fluorescence incorporation and the photobleaching data suggest that tubulin adds to the elongating spindle interzone near the equator where the plus ends of the interdigitated microtubules are located. In further experiments, several dark lines were photobleached perpendicular to the pole-to-pole axis of fluorescent anaphase-telophase spindles. Time-dependent changes in the spacings between the lines indicated that the two halves of the interzone lying on opposite sides of the spindle equator moved away from one another. This shows that the interdigitated microtubules, which make up most of the interzone, can undergo antiparallel sliding. Our data support a model for anaphase B in which plus end elongation of interdigitated microtubules and antiparallel sliding contribute to chromosome separation.

The role of tubulin polymerization during spindle elongation in vitro

We describe the effect of exogenous tubulin on reactivation of anaphase spindle elongation in isolated diatom spindles. In the absence of tubulin, spindle elongation is limited to the equivalent of the microtubule overlap zone, but in the presence of tubulin spindle elongation is several times the length of the overlap zone. Biotinylated neurotubulin is incorporated into the overlap zone and around the poles. Before spindles have elongated by the equivalent of the overlap zone, there are two regions of incorporated tubulin flanking this zone. After further elongation, there is one broad zone of incorporated tubulin in the spindle midzone. Spindle elongation and the pattern of tubulin incorporation into the midzone, but not the poles, are ATP-dependent and vanadate-sensitive. These results suggest that tubulin adds onto the ends of microtubules in the overlap zone, which then slide through the midzone as the spindle elongates.

Quinacrine-induced changes in mitotic PtK1 spindle microtubule organization

Quinacrine, an acridine derivative which competitively binds to ATP binding sites, has been used to study the role of ATP requiring molecules in microtubule organization in mitotic PtK1 cells. Brief treatments of metaphase cells with concentrations of quinacrine ranging from 2 to 10 microM decreased spindle length and birefringence in a concentration-dependent manner. With either increasing quinacrine concentrations or duration of treatment, metaphase cells demonstrated a specific reorganization of spindle microtubules. Both polarization and electron microscopy showed a substantial loss of non-kinetochore spindle microtubules with an increase in astral microtubules: this was particularly evident in the region adjacent to the spindle domain. Addition of millimolar concentrations of dinitrophenol to quinacrine-containing medium did not potentiate the response of metaphase cells to quinacrine treatment. Time-lapse video analysis demonstrated that the astral microtubules are the result of reorganization of spindle microtubules. These data suggest that functional ATP binding sites are required to maintain stable interactions between microtubules and that these interactions are responsible for maintaining the bowed configuration of non-kinetochore spindle microtubules which are under compression at metaphase.

Microtubule dynamics in the spindle. II. A thermodynamic and kinetic description

We have previously presented a model for the assembly and disassembly of mitotic spindle microtubules (MTs) (Pickett-Heaps et al., 1986). In this paper, we describe the thermodynamics of such spindle MT assembly and present equations to describe the polymerization kinetics of different classes of spindle MTs. These equations are used to predict, in terms of kinetics parameters, the magnitude of forces extant on spindle MTs and to define the critical force needed to halt MT assembly. We calculate several of these forces for a hypothetical model cell; our predicted value for the force generated along kinetochore fibers is in close agreement with measured values taken from living cells. The model and its implications are discussed with reference to other recent models of spindle and MT dynamics.