Negative correlation between the abundance of Escherichia coli aminoacyl-tRNA families and their affinities for elongation factor Tu-GTP

Quaternary organization of the human eEF1B complex reveals unique multi-GEF domain assembly

Protein synthesis in eukaryotic cell is spatially and structurally compartmentalized that ensures high efficiency of this process. One of the distinctive features of higher eukaryotes is the existence of stable multi-protein complexes of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and translation elongation factors. Here, we report a quaternary organization of the human guanine-nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) complex, eEF1B, comprising α, β and γ subunits that specifically associate into a heterotrimeric form eEF1B(αβγ)3. As both the eEF1Bα and eEF1Bβ proteins have structurally conserved GEF domains, their total number within the complex is equal to six. Such, so far, unique structural assembly of the guanine-nucleotide exchange factors within a stable complex may be considered as a 'GEF hub' that ensures efficient maintenance of the translationally active GTP-bound conformation of eEF1A in higher eukaryotes.

The central role of tRNA in genetic code expansion

BACKGROUND

The development of orthogonal translation systems (OTSs) for genetic code expansion (GCE) has allowed for the incorporation of a diverse array of non-canonical amino acids (ncAA) into proteins. Transfer RNA, the central molecule in the translation of the genetic message into proteins, plays a significant role in the efficiency of ncAA incorporation.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Here we review the biochemical basis of OTSs for genetic code expansion. We focus on the role of tRNA and discuss strategies used to engineer tRNA for the improvement of ncAA incorporation into proteins.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

The engineering of orthogonal tRNAs for GCE has significantly improved the incorporation of ncAAs. However, there are numerous unintended consequences of orthogonal tRNA engineering that cannot be predicted ab initio.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Genetic code expansion has allowed for the incorporation of a great diversity of ncAAs and novel chemistries into proteins, making significant contributions to our understanding of biological molecules and interactions. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled "Biochemistry of Synthetic Biology - Recent Developments" Guest Editor: Dr. Ilka Heinemann and Dr. Patrick O'Donoghue.

Model-based inference of gene expression dynamics from sequence information

A dynamic model of prokaryotic gene expression is developed that makes considerable use of gene sequence information. The main contribution arises from the fact that the combined gene expression model allows us to access the impact of altering a nucleotide sequence on the dynamics of gene expression rates mechanistically. The high level of detail of the mathematical model is considered as an important step towards bringing together the tremendous amount of biological in-depth knowledge that has been accumulated at the molecular level, using a systems level analysis (in the sense of a bottom-up, inductive approach). This enables to the model to provide highly detailed insights into the various steps of the protein expression process and it allows us to access possible targets for model-based design. Taken as a whole, the mathematical gene expression model presented in this study provides a comprehensive framework for a thorough analysis of sequence-related effects on the stages of mRNA synthesis, mRNA degradation and ribosomal translation, as well as their nonlinear interconnectedness. Therefore, it may be useful in the rational design of recombinant bacterial protein synthesis systems, the modulation of enzyme activities in pathway design, in vitro protein biosynthesis, and RNA-based vaccination.

Modulation of tRNAAla identity by inorganic pyrophosphatase

A highly sensitive assay of tRNA aminoacylation was developed that directly measures the fraction of aminoacylated tRNA by following amino acid attachment to the 3'-(32)P-labeled tRNA. When applied to Escherichia coli alanyl-tRNA synthetase, the assay allowed accurate measurement of aminoacylation of the most deleterious mutants of tRNA(Ala). The effect of tRNA(Ala) identity mutations on both aminoacylation efficiency (k(cat)/K(M)) and steady-state level of aminoacyl-tRNA was evaluated in the absence and presence of inorganic pyrophosphatase and elongation factor Tu. Significant levels of aminoacylation were achieved for tRNA mutants even when the k(cat)/K(M) value is reduced by as much as several thousandfold. These results partially reconcile the discrepancy between in vivo and in vitro analysis of tRNA(Ala) identity.

Uniform binding of aminoacyl-tRNAs to elongation factor Tu by thermodynamic compensation

Elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu) binds all elongator aminoacyl-transfer RNAs (aa-tRNAs) for delivery to the ribosome during protein synthesis. Here, we show that EF-Tu binds misacylated tRNAs over a much wider range of affinities than it binds the corresponding correctly acylated tRNAs, suggesting that the protein exhibits considerable specificity for both the amino acid side chain and the tRNA body. The thermodynamic contributions of the amino acid and the tRNA body to the overall binding affinity are independent of each other and compensate for one another when the tRNAs are correctly acylated. Because certain misacylated tRNAs bind EF-Tu significantly more strongly or weakly than cognate aa-tRNAs, EF-Tu may contribute to translational accuracy.

Energy cost of translational proofreading in vivo. The aminoacylation of transfer RNA in Escherichia coli

In many cases, the intrinsic binding energies of amino acids to aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are inadequate to give the required accuracy of translation. This has necessitated the evolution of a second determinant of specificity, proofreading, or editing mechanisms that involve the expenditure of energy to remove errors. Studies of an error-editing function of bacterial methionyl-tRNA synthetase have led to the discovery of a distinct chemical mechanism of editing and to molecular dissection of the dual synthetic-editing function of the active site of the synthetase. Studies have also established the importance of proofreading in living cells and allowed direct measurements of energy costs associated with editing in vivo. An unexpected outcome of these studies was a discovery of functional and structural similarities between methionyl-tRNA synthetase and S-adenosylmethionine synthetase, suggesting an evolutionary relationship between the two proteins. The mechanism of editing involves a nucleophilic attack of a sulfur atom on the side chain of homocysteine in homocysteinyl adenylate on its carbonyl carbon, yielding homocysteine thiolactone. The model of the active site of methionyl-tRNA synthetase derived from structure-function studies explains how the active site partitions amino acids between synthetic and editing pathways. Hydrophobic and hydrogen bonding interactions of active site residues Trp305 and Tyr15 with the side chain of methionine prevent the cognate amino acid from entering the editing pathway. These interactions are missing in the case of the smaller side chain of the noncognate homocysteine, which therefore enters the editing pathway. Homocysteine thiolactone is formed as a result of editing of homocysteine by methionyl-tRNA synthetase in bacteria, yeast, and some cultured mammalian cells. In mammalian cells, enhanced synthesis of homocysteine thiolactone, is, thus far, associated with oncogenic transformation. In E. coli, most of the energy cost of proofreading by methionyl-tRNA synthetase is due to editing of the incorrect product, homocysteinyl adenylate.

Effects of tRNA(1Leu) overproduction in Escherichia coli

Strains of Escherichia coli have been produced which express very high levels of the tRNA(1Leu) isoacceptor. This was accomplished by transforming cells with plasmids containing the leuV operon which encodes three copies of the tRNA(1Leu) gene. Most transformants grew very slowly and exhibited a 15-fold increase in cellular concentrations of tRNA(1Leu). As a result, total cellular tRNA concentration was approximately doubled and 56% of the total was tRNA(1Leu). We examined a number of parameters which might be expected to be affected by imbalances in tRNA concentration: in vivo tRNA charging levels, misreading, ribosome step time, and tRNA modification. Surprisingly, no increase in intracellular ppGpp levels was detected even though only about 40% of total leucyl tRNA was found to be charged in vivo. Gross ribosomal misreading was not detected, and it was shown that ribosomal step times were reduced between two- and threefold. Analyses of leucyl tRNA isolated from these slow-growing strains showed that at least 90% of the detectable tRNA(1Leu) was hypomodified as judged by altered mobility on RPC-5 reverse-phase columns, and by specific modification assays using tRNA(m1G)-methyltransferase and pseudo-uridylate synthetase. Analysis of fast-growing revertants demonstrated that tRNA concentration per se may not explain growth inhibition because selected revertants which grew at wild-type growth rates displayed levels of tRNA comparable to that of control strains bearing the leuV operon. A synthetic tRNA(1Leu) operon under the control of the T7 promoter was prepared which, when induced, produced six- to sevenfold increases in tRNA(1Leu) levels. This level of tRNA(1Leu) titrated the modification system as judged by RPC-5 column chromatography. Overall, our results suggest that hypomodified tRNA may explain, in part, the observed effects on growth, and that the protein-synthesizing system can tolerate an enormous increase in the concentration of a single tRNA.

Editing of errors in selection of amino acids for protein synthesis

All living cells must conduct protein synthesis with a high degree of accuracy maintained in the transmission and flow of information from gene to finished protein product. One crucial "quality control" point in maintaining a high level of accuracy is the selectivity by which aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases furnish correctly activated amino acids, attached to tRNA species, as the building blocks for growing protein chains. During selection of amino acids, synthetases very often have to distinguish the cognate substrate from a homolog having just one fewer methyl group in its structure. The binding energy of a methyl group is estimated to contribute only a factor of 100 to the specificity of binding, yet synthetases distinguish such closely related amino acids with a discrimination factor of 10,000 to 100,000. Examples of this include methionine versus homocysteine, isoleucine versus valine, alanine versus glycine, and threonine versus serine. Many investigators have demonstrated in vitro the ability of certain aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to edit, that is, correct or prevent incorrect attachment of amino acids to tRNA molecules. Several major editing pathways are now established from in vitro data. Further, at least some aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases have recently been shown to carry out the editing function in vivo. Editing has been demonstrated to occur in both Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Significant energy is expended by the cell for editing of misactivated amino acids, which can be reflected in the growth rate. Because of this, cellular levels of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, as well as amino acid biosynthetic pathways which yield competing substrates for protein synthesis, must be carefully regulated to prevent excessive editing. High-level expression of recombinant proteins imposes a strain on the biosynthetic capacity of the cell which frequently results in misincorporation of abnormal or wrong amino acids owing in part to limited editing by synthetases. Unbalanced amino acid pools associated with some genetic disorders in humans may also lead to errors in tRNA aminoacylation. The availability of X-ray crystallographic structures of some synthetases, combined with site-directed mutagenesis, allows insights into molecular details of the extraordinary selectivity of synthetases, including the editing function.

Absolute in vivo translation rates of individual codons in Escherichia coli. The two glutamic acid codons GAA and GAG are translated with a threefold difference in rate

We have determined the absolute translation rates for four individual codons in Escherichia coli. We used our previously described system for direct measurements of in vivo translation rates using small, in-frame inserts in the lacZ gene. The inserts consisted of multiple synthetic 30 base-pair DNA oligomers with high densities of the four individual codons, GAA (Glu), GAG (Glu), CCG (Pro) and CGA (Arg). Our method is independent of expression level, of mRNA half-life and of transcription rate. Codon GAA was found to be translated with a rate of 21.6 codons/second whereas codon GAG was translated 3.4-fold slower (6.4 codons/s). These two codons are read by the same tRNA species. Codon CCG and CGA are both read by abundant tRNA species but nevertheless we found them to be translated slowly with rates of 5.8 and 4.2 codons/second, respectively. The context of these codons were varied, but we found no significant influence of context on their translation rates and we suggest a mechanism for why context may not affect translation rates. One insert with a low translation rate gave results that most readily can be explained by assuming queue formation of ribosomes on the insert. Such a queue was found to reduce the expression level by approximately 35%. Our experiments allowed us to estimate the average distance between ribosomes and thereby the translation initiation frequency on the wild-type lacZ mRNA. This was found to be one per three seconds.

Uncharged tRNA, protein synthesis, and the bacterial stringent response

Uncharged tRNA has been shown in vivo to have an active role both in the stringent response, and in modulating the rate of translational elongation. Both of these effects appear to be mediated by codon-anticodon interactions on the ribosome. Although the involvement of uncharged tRNA in the stringent response was expected from in vitro experiments, it has only recently been confirmed in vivo. Inhibition of translation by cognate uncharged tRNA was not expected, and a model is proposed in which excess uncharged tRNA competes with charged tRNA (in ternary complex) for the 30S component of the ribosomal A site. When uncharged tRNA is in sufficient excess over charged tRNA, interaction of uncharged tRNA with the 50S component of the A site occurs as well, leading to a stringent response. The cell has a continuum of responses to decreasing aminoacyl-tRNA levels: in moderately limited conditions, the proportion of uncharged tRNA increases, and the translation rate is slowed; under more severe limitations, uncharged tRNA provokes a stringent response, with pleiotropic consequences for the cell.

Relationship between protein synthesis and concentrations of charged and uncharged tRNATrp in Escherichia coli

We have continuously monitored Trp-tRNA(Trp) concentrations in vivo and, in the same cultures, measured rates of protein synthesis in isogenic stringent and relaxed strains. We have also manipulated cellular charged and uncharged [tRNA(Trp)] by two means: (i) the strain used contains a Trp-tRNA synthetase mutation that increases the Km for Trp; thus, varying exogenous Trp varies cellular Trp-tRNA(Trp); and (ii) we have introduced into the mutant strain a plasmid containing the tRNA(Trp) gene behind an inducible promoter; thus, total [tRNA(Trp)] also can be varied depending on length of induction. The use of these conditions, combined with a previously characterized assay system, has allowed us to demonstrate that (i) the rate of incorporation of Trp into protein is proportional to the fraction of tRNA(Trp) that is charged; for any given total [tRNA(Trp)], this rate is also proportional to the [Trp-tRNA(Trp)]; (ii) uncharged tRNA(Trp) inhibits incorporation of Trp into protein; and (iii) rates of incorporation into protein of at least two other amino acids, Lys and Cys, are also sensitive to [Trp-tRNA(Trp)] and are inhibited by uncharged tRNA(Trp). Our results are consistent with models of translational control that postulate modulating polypeptide chain elongation efficiency by varying concentrations of specific tRNAs.

Codon discrimination due to presence of abundant non-cognate competitive tRNA

It has been thought that preferential use of synonymous codons provides high efficiency and fidelity of protein synthesis through specific codon-anticodon interactions. In yeast genes, some codon boxes seem to prefer a codon which is unsuited for its cognate anticodon. Now, we propose that codon usage biases may arise due to presence of abundant non-cognate competitive tRNA capable of misreading a codon by C-U or G-U pairing in the middle position.