Phospholipid flip-out controls the cell cycle of Escherichia coli

Hypothesis: a phospholipid translocase couples lateral and transverse bilayer asymmetries in dividing bacteria

Cell division in bacteria such as Escherichia coli entails changes in the radii of curvature of the invaginating cytoplasmic membrane which culminate in rearrangements of its monolayers. Division therefore risks perturbing transverse and lateral asymmetries and compromising membrane integrity. This leads us to propose that a strong selective pressure exists for a phospholipid translocator that would transfer phospholipids across the cytoplasmic membrane so as to both demarcate the division site and mediate lipid composition during division. This translocase has an affinity for phospholipids with small headgroups and unsaturated acyl chains which it translocates so as to (1) generate changes in the radius of curvature, (2) facilitate septum formation, (3) minimise bilayer disruption during fusion and (4) prevent septum formation at old or inappropriate division sites. We discuss briefly possible candidates for this translocase including ABC transporters and proteins localised to the division site.

kdsA mutations affect FtsZ-ring formation in Escherichia coli K-12

No one has, as yet, addressed the relationship between the nature of the outer membrane and cell division. kdsA encodes 3-deoxy-D-manno-octulosonic acid (KDO) 8-phosphate synthetase which catalyses the first step in the synthesis of KDO, the linker between lipid A and oligosaccharide of lipopolysaccharide (LPS). Seven temperature-sensitive mutants containing missense mutations in kdsA were affected in the production of KDO and all mutants stopped dividing at 41 degrees C and formed filaments with either one or no FtsZ ring. All observed defects were reversed by the plasmid-borne wild-type kdsA gene. Western blotting analysis, however, demonstrated that the amount of FtsZ protein was not affected by the mutation. The mutants were more susceptible to various hydrophobic materials, such as novobiocin, eosin Y and SDS at 36 degrees C. Methylene blue, however, restored kdsA mutant growth. Plasmid-borne wild-type msbA, encoding a lipid A transporter in the ABC family, partially suppressed kdsA mutation. A mutation of lpxA, functioning at the first stage in lipid A biosynthesis, inhibited both cell division and growth, producing short filaments. These results indicate that the instability of the outer membrane, caused by the defect in KDO biosynthesis, affects FtsZ-ring formation.

Facilitated phosphatidylcholine flip-flop across erythrocyte membranes using low molecular weight synthetic translocases

The transmembrane distribution of phospholipids plays an important regulatory role in human erythrocytes. Membrane-bound translocase enzymes maintain an asymmetric phospholipid distribution across the membrane monolayers by promoting transmembrane diffusion or flip-flop. Mechanistic understanding of the flip-flop process is weak at the molecular level. Recently, we discovered that amide and sulfonamide derivatives of tris(aminoethyl)amine facilitate phospholipid flip-flop across vesicle membranes; that is, they act as low molecular weight, synthetic translocases. In this report, NMR evidence is provided that suggests that the synthetic translocases work by forming a hydrogen-bonded complex with the phosphocholine headgroup which decreases headgroup polarity and promotes diffusion across the lipophilic interior of the membrane. Also cell morphology and fluorescence probe methods are used to show that these synthetic translocases facilitate phosphatidylcholine flip-flop across erythrocyte membranes. Addition of a small amount of dilauroylphosphatidylcholine to erythrocytes produces echinocyte morphology which takes days to revert back to the original discocyte shape. The rate of return is significantly accelerated by the presence of the synthetic translocases. The synthetic translocases facilitate inward-translocation (flip) of the fluorescent phosphatidylcholine probe, 1-palmitoyl-2-(N-[7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl]aminohexanoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (PC-NBD).

An assessment of the role of intracellular free Ca2+ in E. coli

We have previously proposed that fluctuations in Ca(2+) levels should play an important role in bacteria as in eukaryotes in regulating cell cycle events (Norris et al., J. Theor. Biol. 134 (1998) 341-350). This proposal implied the presence of Ca(2+) uptake systems in bacteria, cell cycle mutants simultaneously defective in Ca(2+)-homeostasis, and perturbation of cell cycle processes when cellular Ca(2+) levels are depleted. We review the properties of new cell cycle mutants in E. coli and B. subtilis resistant to inhibitors of calmodulin, PKC or Ca(2+)-channels; the evidence for Ca(2+)-binding proteins including Acp and FtsZ; and Ca(2+)-transporters. In addition, the effects of EGTA and verapamil (a Ca(2+) channel inhibitor) on growth, protein synthesis and cell cycle events in E. coli are described. We also describe new measurements of free Ca(2+)-levels, using aequorin, in E. coli. Several new cell cycle mutants were obtained using this approach, affecting either initiation of DNA replication or in particular cell division at non-permissive temperature. Several of the mutants were also hypersensitive to EGTA and or Ca(2+). However, none of the mutants apparently involved direct alteration of a drug target and surprisingly in some cases involved specific tRNAs or a tRNA synthetase. The results also indicate that the expression of several genes in E. coli may be regulated by Ca(2+). Cell division in particular appears very sensitive to the level of cell Ca(2+), with the frequency of division clearly reduced by EGTA and by verapamil. However, whilst the effect of EGTA was clearly correlated with depletion of cellular Ca(2+) including free Ca(2+), this was not the case with verapamil which appears to change membrane fluidity and the consequent activity of membrane proteins. Measurement of free Ca(2+) in living cells indicated levels of 200-300 nM, tightly regulated in wild type cells in exponential phase, somewhat less so in stationary phase, with apparently La(2+)-sensitive PHB-polyphosphate complexes involved in Ca(2+) influx. The evidence reviewed increasingly supports a role for Ca(2+) in cellular processes in bacteria, however, any direct link to the control of cell cycle events remains to be established.

A fission-fusion origin for life

To develop a comprehensive 'cells-first' approach to the origin of life, we propose that protocells form spontaneously and that the fission and fusion of these protocells drives the dynamics of their evolution. The fitness criterion for this evolution is taken to be the the stability (conservation) of domains in the protocellular membrane as determined by non-covalent molecular associations between the amphiphiles of the membrane and a subset of the macromolecules in the protocell. In the presence of a source of free energy the macromolecular content of the protocell (co-)evolves as the result of (domain-dependent) membrane-catalysed polymerisation of the prebiotic constituents delivered to the protocell by fusion. The metabolism of the cell therefore (co-)evolves on a rugged fitness landscape. We indicate how domain evolution with the same fitness criterion can potentially give rise to coding. Membrane domains may therefore provide the link between protocells and the RNA/DNA-world.

Cardiolipin synthase from Escherichia coli

Escherichia coli cardiolipin synthase catalyzes reversible phosphatidyl group transfer from one phosphatidylglycerol molecule to another to form cardiolipin (CL) and glycerol. The enzyme is specified by the cls gene, located at min 28.02 of the E. coli genetic map. Cells with mutations in cls have longer doubling times, tend to lose viability in the stationary phase, are more resistant to 3,4-dihydroxybutyl-1-phosphonate, and have an altered sensitivity to novobiocin. Although cls null mutants appear to lack CL synthase activity, they are still able to form trace quantities of CL. The enzyme appears to be regulated at both the genetic and enzymatic levels. CL synthase's molecular mass is 45-46 kDa, or about 8 kDa less than the polypeptide predicted by the gene sequence, suggesting that posttranslational processing occurs. CL synthase can use various polyols such as mannitol and arabitol to convert CL to the corresponding phosphatidylglycerol analog. When the amino acid sequences of four bacterial CL synthases are compared, three highly conserved regions are apparent. One of these regions contains a conserved pentapeptide sequence, RN(Q)HRK, and another has a conserved HXK sequence. These two sequences may be part of the active site. E. coli CL synthase has been studied by using a mixed micelle assay. The enzyme is inhibited by CL, the product of the reaction, and by phosphatidate. Phosphatidylethanolamine partially offsets inhibition caused by CL but not by phosphatidate. CDP-diacylglycerol does not appear to affect the activity of the purified enzyme but does stimulate the activity associated with crude membrane preparations.

Selective association of phospholipids as a clue for the passive flip-flop diffusion through bilayer lipid membranes

We showed that the investigation of the selective association of phospholipids might contribute to the insight of the flip-flop diffusion processes. The process of selective association was studied quantitatively by testing the association probabilities for both parallel and anti-parallel orientations of the polar headgroups. The model of double chain binary mixture confirms a high capacity of phospholipids for self-association in parallel configuration of the electric dipole moments whether the cross-sectional area of the polar headgroups are in an usual range of 25-55 A2. It is demonstrated that the aggregation of a class of phospholipids from a binary mixture is strongly dependent on the dipole-dipole interaction between the same phospholipids and is modulated by the magnitude of the electric dipole moment of the other phospholipids from that binary mixture. There are a great number of mechanisms involved in the transbilayer movement of phospholipids. We referred here only to the passive transport of lipids from one monolayer to the other. The flip-flop mechanisms raised in this paper are the breakdown of bilayer due to the increase of the packing density and the inversion of the coupled phospholipids from the opposite monolayers of the same bilayer. Thus, the pair formation promoting a drop in occupied volume decreases the packing pressure in the respective monolayer and consequently triggers a flip-flop into the other direction since the packing pressure in the other monolayer has not dropped. According to the present model for the binary mixtures of double-chain lipids, the rate of the flip-flop diffusion decreased by increasing the number of the methylene groups added to the acyl chain. This dependence may be perturbed whether the phospholipids possesses a very high cross-section area of the polar headgroups (a > 55 A2). We think that the selective association of phospholipids is neither exclusively, nor only involved in promoting the transbilayer diffusion of phospholipids. Most probably, the selective association determines some phospholipid domains that attract certain particular proteins so that it can modulate the protein activity.

Elements of a unifying theory of biology

To discover a unifying theory of biology, it is necessary first to believe in its existence and second to seek its elements. Such a theory would explain the regulation of the cell cycle, differentiation and the origin of life. Some elements of the theory may be obtained by considering both eukaryotic and prokaryotic cell cycles. These elements include cytoskeletal proteins, calcium, cyclins, protein kinase C, phosphorylation, transcriptional sensing, autocatalytic gene expression and the physical properties of lipids. Other more exotic candidate elements include the dynamic enzoskeleton, ATP generation, mechanotransduction, the piezoelectric effect and resonance. Bringing these disparate elements together--and discovering others--will require extensive collaborations between specialists from different sciences. This can only be achieved within the context of an integrated approach to biology.

Lateral inhomogeneous lipid membranes: theoretical aspects

The physical concepts underlying the lateral distribution of the components forming a lamellar assembly of amphiphiles are discussed in this review. The role of amphiphiles' molecular structure and/or aqueous environment (ionic strength, water soluble substances) on formation and stability of lateral patterns is investigated. A considerable effort is devoted to the analysis of the properties of patterned structure which can be different from those of randomly mixed multi-component lamellae. Examples include adhesion and fusion among laterally inhomogeneous bilayers, enhanced interfacial adsorption of ions and polymers, enhanced transport across the bilayer, modified mechanical properties, local stabilization of non-planar geometries (pores, edges) and related phenomena (electroporation, budding transition and so on). Furthermore, an analysis of chemical reactivity within or at the water interface of a laterally inhomogeneous bilayer is briefly discussed. A link between these concepts and experimental findings taken from the biological literature is attempted throughout the review.

Phospholipid domains determine the spatial organization of the Escherichia coli cell cycle: the membrane tectonics model

Escherichia coli normally divides at its equator between segregated nucleoids. Such division is inhibited during perturbations of chromosome replication (even in the absence of inducible division inhibitors); eventually, division resumes at sites which are not at this equator. Escherichia coli will also divide at its poles to generate minicells following overproduction of the FtsZ or MinE proteins. The mechanisms underlying the division inhibition and the positioning of the division sites are unknown. In the membrane tectonics model, I propose that the formation of phospholipid domains within the cytoplasmic membrane positions division sites. The particular phospholipid composition of a domain attracts particular proteins and determines their activity; conversely, particular proteins change the composition of domains. Principally via such proteins, the interaction of the chromosome with the membrane creates a chromosomal domain. The development of chromosomal domains during replication and nucleoid formation contributes to the formation and positioning of a septal domain between them. During septation (cell division), this septal domain matures into a polar domain. Each domain attracts and activates different enzymes. The septal domain attracts and activates enzymes necessary for septation. Preventing the formation of the septal domain by preventing chromosome replication prevents normal division. Altering the composition of the polar domain may allow septation enzymes to function there and generate minicells. A corollary of the model explains how the formation of an origin domain by the attachment of hemi-methylated origin DNA to the membrane may underlie the creation and migration of structures within the envelope, the periseptal annuli.

Metabolic regulations and biological functions of phospholipids in Escherichia coli

Extensive genetic and biochemical studies in the last two decades have elucidated almost completely the framework of synthesis and turnover of quantitatively major phospholipids in E. coli. The knowledge thus accumulated has allowed to formulate a novel working model that assumes sophisticated regulatory mechanisms in E. coli to achieve the optimal phospholipid composition and content in the membranes. E. coli also appears to possess the ability to adapt phospholipid synthesis to various cellular conditions. Understanding of the functional aspects of E. coli phospholipids is now advancing significantly and it will soon be able to explain many of the hitherto unclear cell's activities on the molecular basis. Phosphatidylglycerol is believed to play the central role both in metabolism and functions of phospholipids in E. coli. The results obtained with E. coli should undoubtedly be helpful in the study of more complicated phospholipid metabolism and functions in higher organisms.

Synthesis of the cell surface during the division cycle of rod-shaped, gram-negative bacteria

When the growth of the gram-negative bacterial cell wall is considered in relation to the synthesis of the other components of the cell, a new understanding of the pattern of wall synthesis emerges. Rather than a switch in synthesis between the side wall and pole, there is a partitioning of synthesis such that the volume of the cell increases exponentially and thus perfectly encloses the exponentially increasing cytoplasm. This allows the density of the cell to remain constant during the division cycle. This model is explored at both the cellular and molecular levels to give a unified description of wall synthesis which has the following components: (i) there is no demonstrable turnover of peptidoglycan during cell growth, (ii) the side wall grows by diffuse intercalation, (iii) pole synthesis starts by some mechanism and is preferentially synthesized compared with side wall, and (iv) the combined side wall and pole syntheses enclose the newly synthesized cytoplasm at a constant cell density. The central role of the surface stress model in wall growth is distinguished from, and preferred to, models that propose cell-cycle-specific signals as triggers of changes in the rate of wall synthesis. The actual rate of wall synthesis during the division cycle is neither exponential nor linear, but is close to exponential when compared with protein synthesis during the division cycle.

A protein kinase C-like activity in Escherichia coli

The protein kinase C (PKC) family comprises calcium- and phospholipid-dependent kinases whose activity is stimulated by diacylglycerol and tumour-promoting phorbol esters such as 12-tetradecanoyl phorbol-13-acetate (TPA). In the Gram-negative bacterium Escherichia coli, functional similarity to PKC was demonstrated in crude extracts by calcium and phospholipid-dependent, TPA-stimulated phosphorylation of a small number of endogenous substrates. Activity was reduced by sphingosine, a known inhibitor of eukaryotic PKC. Structural similarity to PKC was demonstrated in crude and partially purified bacterial extracts by cross-reactivity with several monoclonal antibodies. This revealed isozyme-specific homology between a protein(s) of relative molecular mass 80-85,000 in E. coli and the alpha- and gamma-isozymes, but probably not the beta-isozyme, of eukaryotic PKC.

Control of the bacterial cell cycle

New insights into the control of DNA replication through growth, hemimethylated DNA and DnaA protein have been described. Fundamental shifts in thinking have resulted in the identification of new cell cycle genes with potential roles in initiation of DNA replication, chromosomal segregation and division. Excitingly, this trend may also narrow the apparent differences between the prokaryotic and eukaryotic cell cycles.

Calcium in bacteria: a solution to which problem?

Calcium and calcium-binding proteins including those resembling calmodulin are implicated in numerous diverse processes in bacteria. These processes include chemotaxis, sporulation, virulence, the transport of sugars and proteins, phosphorylation, heat shock, the initiation of DNA replication, septation, nucleoid structure, nuclease activity and recombination, the stability of the envelope, and phospholipid synthesis and configuration. That such varied processes should have a common factor, calcium, suggests major underlying principles of calcium metabolism which have yet to be discovered.

DNA replication in Escherichia coli is initiated by membrane detachment of oriC. A model

An adequate model for the initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli should explain why the introduction of multiple copies of the chromosomal origin of replication, oriC, does not perturb cells seriously and why such multiple origins are replicated synchronously; it should explain why the key initiator protein, DnaA, is activated in vitro by binding specifically to acidic phospholipids and why the Dam methyltransferase is essential for the correct timing of initiation; it should explain why phospholipid synthesis and fluidity are necessary for initiation. In the detachment model, presented here, cyclical changes in the phospholipid composition of the cytoplasmic membrane activate initiator proteins such as DnaA protein and cause origins to detach; this detachment allows torsional stresses to open 13mer sequences in oriC; DnaA assists in the serial opening of these sequences and guides the entry of the helicase to form a pre-priming complex and trigger initiation; the greater affinity of hemi-methylated origin for membrane is re-interpreted as a mechanism for preventing re-initiation.

Transmembrane movements of lipids

Membranes allow the rapid passage of unchanged lipids. Phospholipids on the other hand diffuse very slowly from one monolayer to another with a half-time of several hours. This slow spontaneous movement in a pure lipid bilayer can be selectively modulated in biological membranes by intrinsic proteins. In microsomes, and probably in bacterial membranes, non-specific phospholipid flippases allow the rapid redistribution of newly synthesized phospholipids. In eukaryotic plasma membranes, aminophospholipid translocase selectively pumps phosphatidylserine (PS) and phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) from the outer to the inner leaflet and establishes a permanent lipid asymmetry. The discovery of an aminophospholipid translocase in chromaffin granules proves that eukaryotic organelles may also contain lipid translocators.

A calcium flux at the termination of replication triggers cell division in Escherichia coli. Hypothesis

Cell division in Escherichia coli is coupled to chromosome replication. Even in the absence of known inducible division inhibitors, perturbations of chromosome replication affect cell division. Early studies suggested that a signal at the termination of replication might trigger subsequent division. Although later studies have suggested that fork encounter during termination is an active process involving specific termination sites and the tus protein, the coupling mechanism between termination and cell division remains to be elucidated. Recently it has been shown that the chromosome of a bacterium, Pseudomonas tabaci, contains a high proportion of calcium. E. coli maintains an intracellular concentration of free calcium identical to that of higher organisms and in dividing cells of E. coli a twenty-fold increase in the level of total calcium in the cytoplasm, a flux, occurs. In this article I propose that during the replication of the chromosome calcium entry balances calcium binding to DNA. At the termination of replication, there is a brief interval between the end of calcium binding to the chromosome and the end of calcium entry or release into the cytoplasm. During this interval the level of free calcium therefore rises. This rise may result in the observed flux by triggering the entry of calcium directly via voltage-gated calcium channels or indirectly via changes in phospholipid configurations. Mechanisms whereby these changes in calcium levels might be coupled to cell division and to a phospholipid control of the cell cycle are discussed.