In vitro fertilization and early embryogenesis: a cytological analysis

Singular features of fertilization and their impact on the male reproductive system in eutherian mammals

Therian (marsupial and eutherian) mammals have evolved a suite of novel reproductive features – seen variously in their gametes, the steps of fertilization and the male reproductive tract – whose adaptive significance remains unclear. Present evidence for the better-understood eutherian mammals suggests that the ‘prime mover’ in their evolution has been the character of the egg coat, with other such features being adaptations to the consequences of this. Its elastic thickness allows the zona pellucida to stretch to a variable degree and yet remain around the blastocyst during much or all of its expansion before implantation, but its character represents an unusual challenge for spermatozoa. Novel aspects of the acrosome related to this challenge enable it to maintain a relatively prolonged binding after the onset of the acrosome reaction, and the structure, shape and behaviour of the sperm head point to physical thrust as a major element of zona penetration – with the unique configuration of gamete fusion as a sequela of this strategy. In the male, such adaptations are reflected in sperm head formation in the testis and in sperm maturation in the epididymis involving at least the sperm head's structure, plasmalemma and acrosome. This complexity allied to a slow epididymal sperm transport, a relatively modest sperm production and the brief life span of mature spermatozoa kept above the cauda epididymidis could account for the evolution of the sperm storage function – a development seemingly linked, in turn, to the need for sperm capacitation and scrotal evolution.

Unresolved Issues in Mammalian Fertilization

This review considers the role of the sperm in fertilization, addressing areas of misunderstanding and unfounded assumptions and taking particular advantage of the large body of data resulting from work with rodent species in vitro. Considerable attention is given to the appropriate use and interpretation of assays for capacitation, acrosomal exocytosis, hyperactivation, and sperm protein phosphorylation, as well as tests for sperm-zona and sperm-oocyte membrane interactions. The lack of general agreement on the means of sperm adhesion to and penetration of the zona pellucida is addressed, and the need for new approaches to this problem is pointed out. Some molecular advances in our understanding of specific steps in the process of fertilization are discussed in the context of intact cell-matrix and cell-cell interaction. This review should provide practical information for researchers just beginning the study of fertilization and interesting but not widely known observations to stimulate new ideas in experienced scientists.

Characterization of zona pellucida glycoprotein 3 (ZP3) and ZP2 binding sites on acrosome-intact mouse sperm

There is considerable evidence that mouse fertilization requires the binding of sperm to two of the three glycoproteins that form the zona pellucida (ZP), ZP3 and ZP2. Despite the biologic importance of this binding, no one has demonstrated that sperm express separate, saturable, and specific binding sites for ZP3 and for ZP2. Such a demonstration is a prerequisite for defining the distribution, numbers, affinities, and regulation of function of ZP3 and ZP2 binding sites on sperm. The experiments reported herein used fluorochrome-labeled ZP3 and ZP2 and quantitative image analysis to characterize the saturable binding of ZP3 and ZP2 to distinct sites on living, capacitated, acrosome-intact mouse sperm. Approximately 20% of the ZP3 binding sites were found over the acrosomal cap, and the remaining sites were located over the postacrosomal region of the head. In contrast, ZP2 binding sites were detected only over the postacrosomal region. Saturation analysis estimated numbers and affinities of the binding sites for ZP3 (B(max) approximately 185 000 sites per sperm; K(d) approximately 67 nM) and ZP2 (B(max) approximately 500 000 sites per sperm; K(d) approximately 200 nM). Use of unlabeled ZP3, ZP2, and ZP1 as competitive inhibitors of the binding of fluorochrome-labeled ZP3 and ZP2 demonstrated that ZP3 and ZP2 bound specifically to their respective sites on sperm. Finally, we demonstrate that extracellular calcium as well as capacitation and maturation of sperm are required for these sites to bind their respective ligands.

Ultrastructural studies of early mouse embryos obtained by oocyte fusion

Oocyte fusion induced by inactivated Sendai virus results in the production of 'zygotes' that are able to undergo the first stages of embryonic development. The oocyte fusion products (OFP) obtained follow a morphological developmental pattern equivalent to that of control embryos, at least up to the 8-cell stage. The percentage of OFP that reach the 8-cell stage is extremely low (3%) compared with control embryos cultured in vitro (95%). On light microscopy, the OFP obtained show morphological characteristics identical to control embryos, although their cell diameters are larger. The cortical reaction, meiotic reactivation, extrusion of second polar bodies and pronucleus formation take place as observed in controls. The ultrastructural characteristics of oocyte fusion products at the 1-, 2-, 4- and 8-cell stages are analogous to those of controls, including the presence of structures related to the activation of the embryo genome. However some differences concerning cell ultrastructure, mainly in the nucleus, are observed and discussed in the text.

Role of ultrastructural studies in the analysis of cell lineage in the mammalian pre-implantation embryo

Ultrastructural studies have contributed significantly to our understanding of cell lineage differentiation in the mammalian pre-implantation embryo. Such studies have documented, and continue to document, morphological, biochemical, and physiological characteristics of the cell lineages established during the pre-implantation period in eutherian embryos, principally that of the mouse. This review evaluates these contributions and identifies areas of study in which ultrastructural analysis is most likely to have an important role in the future.

Proteins of the acrosomal region in mouse sperm: immunological probes reveal post-testicular modifications

Due to the central role the acrosomal region plays in sperm-egg interactions, monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) were used to identify components of this domain in mouse sperm. Several sperm proteins that localize specifically to the anterior acrosomal region are described here in terms of electrophoretic mobility, susceptibility to proteolytic degradation, and post-translational modification during epididymal transit. Six different mAbs were used, each recognizing a distinctive antigen (Ag) or set of Ags in cauda epididymal mouse sperm: a doublet of 185/200 Kd (M42 mAb); 150-160 Kd (M5 mAb); 105 Kd (W71 mAb); 21, 35, and 60 Kd (M41 mAb); 27 and 33 Kd (W33 mAb); and 57 and 86 Kd (W108 mAb). Previously reported work implicates two of these, M42 Ag and M5 Ag, as participants in sperm-zona interaction (Saling and Lakoski: Biol Reprod 33:527-536, 1985; Saling: Dev Biol 117:511-519, 1986; and Lakoski et al.: Biol Reprod 38:221-233, 1988). Recognition of some (M42, M5, W108), but not all (W33), of the Ags by their corresponding mAbs was affected by sperm incubation with proteases (trypsin or collagenase). Evidence of post-translational modification during epididymal maturation was suggested by altered electrophoretic mobility of several of the Ags (M42, M5, W33, and W108) accompanying sperm transit from proximal to distal epididymis. Retention of sperm within the caput epididymis prevented structural alterations for the four proteins examined, indicating that spatial rather than temporal factors are critical for Ag modification in maturing mouse sperm.

Ultrastructure of in vivo fertilization in the goat

In vivo fertilization of goat eggs has been studied by electron microscopy. Eggs were recovered from superovulated or natural cyclic goats, 32 to 52 hours after the onset of oestrus; only eggs recovered between 46 and 52 hours were fertilized. Spermatozoa penetrated the zona pellucida tangentially leaving vesiculated products of the acrosome reaction at the zona surface. As sperm penetrated into the ooplasm, the second meiotic division completed and cortical granule exocytosis occurred. However a few unreacted cortical granules usually remained in the cortex of the fertilized eggs, adjacent to the plasma membrane. After swelling the two pronuclei presented similar ultrastructural morphology: they contained small, compact, agranular nucleoli and unevenly distributed chromatin. The cytoplasm in close vicinity to the apposed pronuclei contained large stacks of annulate lamellae, smooth endoplasmic reticulum, prominent Golgi complexes, as well as dense areas of unidentified material. The abundance of cytoplasmic organelles near the pronuclei might be the expression of intensive metabolic activity. Conversely, in the cortex of fertilized ova several large organelles-free cytoplasmic areas were randomly distributed.

Sperm penetration through oocyte investments in mammals

Literature on the interactions between eutherian gametes is reviewed. The oocyte cumulus complex of the female is surrounded by a zona pellucida, corona radiata, and cumulus layer. Sperm undergo an acrosome reaction before penetrating the zona pellucida. The morphological consequences of this reaction and its possible role(s) in penetration of the oocyte cumulus complex are considered. The acrosomal enzyme, hyaluronidase, has been thought to aid sperm in penetrating the cumulus layer and corona radiata. Several recent investigations, including one that shows that motile cells lacking hyaluronidase can penetrate to the zona surface, do not support this idea. Other possible roles of this enzyme in fertilization are discussed. The development of in vitro fertilization systems that employ physiological numbers (1-100) of sperm will be valuable in studying the mechanisms used by sperm to penetrate the oocyte cumulus complex.

Mammalian gamete interactions: what can be gained from observations on living eggs?

Studies on fertilization have involved a variety of investigational techniques from the simple to the very complex. Perhaps the most direct approach has been the observation and photographic recording of the interactions of living gametes in vitro. The purpose of this paper is to review the major contributions that have been made, by means of this technique, to our knowledge of mammalian fertilization, and to examine its advantages and limitations. Some of the events of mammalian fertilization that have been observed in living eggs and are reviewed herein include sperm penetration through the zona pellucida, contact of the fertilizing spermatozoon with the oocyte surface and the subsequent incorporation of the sperm head into the oocyte cytoplasm, the formation and disappearance of the incorporation cone, the gradual incorporation of the sperm flagellum, surface movements of the oocyte after activation, and the formation of the second polar body. One advantage of studying living eggs is the opportunity it affords to witness events as they actually occur and, under favorable circumstances, to observe the whole series of events in individual eggs. Only by this mechanism can certain features of the process be fully appreciated and accurate data obtained on the timing of events. With the addition of time-lapse photographic methods, some of the more subtle changes become more amenable to study. Among the limitations of the technique are its limited resolution and the necessity for examining the gametes outside their normal in vivo environment.

Nuclear lamins and peripheral nuclear antigens during fertilization and embryogenesis in mice and sea urchins

Nuclear structural changes during fertilization and embryogenesis in mice and in sea urchins have been followed by using antibodies against the nuclear lamins A/C and B and against antigens at the periphery of nuclei and chromosomes. Lamins are found on all pronuclei and nuclei during mouse fertilization, but with a diminished intensity on the second polar body nucleus. On sperm in both systems, lamins are reduced and detected only at the acrosomal and centriolar fossae. In sea urchin eggs, lamins are found on both pronuclei. Unlike in other dividing cells, the mitotic chromosomes of sea urchin eggs and embryos retain an association with lamins. The peripheral antibodies delineate each chromosome and nucleus except the mature mouse sperm nucleus. A dramatic change from the expected lamin distribution occurs during early development. In mouse morulae or blastocysts, lamins A/C are no longer recognized, although lamin B remains. In sea urchins both lamins A/C and lamin B, as detected with polyclonal antibodies, are lost after the blastula stage, although a different lamin A/C epitope emerges as recognized by a monoclonal antibody. These results demonstrate that pronucleus formation in both systems involves a new association or exposure of lamins, that the polar body nucleus is largely restricted from the cytoplasmic pool of lamins, and that mitotic chromosomes in the rapidly proliferating sea urchin egg retain associated lamins. They also suggest that changes in the expression or exposure of different lamins are a common feature of embryogenesis.

Microtubule configurations during fertilization, mitosis, and early development in the mouse and the requirement for egg microtubule-mediated motility during mammalian fertilization

Microtubules forming within the mouse egg during fertilization are required for the movements leading to the union of the sperm and egg nuclei (male and female pronuclei, respectively). In the unfertilized oocyte, microtubules are predominantly found in the arrested meiotic spindle. At the time for sperm incorporation, a dozen cytoplasmic asters assemble, often associated with the pronuclei. As the pronuclei move to the egg center, these asters enlarge into a dense array. At the end of first interphase, the dense array disassembles and is replaced by sheaths of microtubules surrounding the adjacent pronuclei. Syngamy (pronuclear fusion) is not observed; rather the adjacent paternal and maternal chromosome sets first meet at metaphase. The mitotic apparatus emerges from these perinuclear microtubules and is barrel-shaped and anastral, reminiscent of plant cell spindles; the sperm centriole does not nucleate mitotic microtubules. After cleavage, monasters extend from each blastomere nucleus. The second division mitotic spindles also have broad poles, though by third and later divisions the spindles are typical for higher animals, with narrow mitotic poles and fusiform shapes. Colcemid, griseofulvin, and nocodazole inhibit the microtubule formation and prevent the movements leading to pronuclear union; the meiotic spindle is disassembled, and the maternal chromosomes are scattered throughout the oocyte cortex. These results indicate that microtubules forming within fertilized mouse oocytes are required for the union of the sperm and egg nuclei and raise questions about the paternal inheritance of centrioles in mammals.

Full-term development after transplantation of parthenogenetic embryonic nuclei into fertilized mouse eggs

Diploid parthenogenetically activated oocytes were obtained after gonadotropin-induced ovulation of virgin females of the LT/Sv (LT) inbred mouse strain. These oocytes cleave spontaneously and develop into blastocysts which implant in the uterus but die within a few days. We examined the developmental potential of nuclei from parthenogenetic embryos after transplantation into fertilized eggs. The inner cell mass (ICM) and trophectoderm (TE) of LT parthenogenetic blastocysts were mechanically isolated and dissociated into single cells. Their nuclei were then injected into fertilized C57BL/6J eggs from which the male and female pronuclei were removed. Of 94 eggs injected with TE cell nuclei, 4 embryos developed to the morula stage; all 4 showed abnormalities and subsequently became arrested in development. Enzyme analysis of these embryos revealed that TE cell nuclei could neither independently initiate or support preimplantation development. However, of 54 eggs injected with nuclei from ICM cells, 3 morulae and 3 blastocysts developed and enzyme analyses of them confirmed that the preimplantation development of 2 embryos was supported by transplanted parthenogenetic nuclei. In another experimental series, 3 morulae and 4 blastocysts developed from 107 eggs injected with ICM nuclei and were transferred to uteri of foster mothers to ascertain their postimplantation development. Four female offspring were born and all of them showed a diploid karyotype and expressed enzyme activity of only the LT genotype. One female proved to be fertile and transmitted the parthenogenetic genome to the next generation. These results demonstrate that the nucleus from LT parthenogenetic blastocysts contains a complete genome necessary to support development of an adult mouse. Therefore, the early postimplantation death of parthenogenetic embryos does not seem to be related to an aberrant genotype but rather to undefined mechanisms associated with fertilization and normal morphogenetic processes.

An ultrastructural study of epididymal mouse spermatozoa binding to zonae pellucidae in vitro: sequential relationship to the acrosome reaction

Mouse sperm bind to the zona pellucida of the egg prior to penetration of the zona and entry into the perivitelline space. The question then arises: when does the acrosome reaction occur relative to these processes? An ultrastructural study of mouse epididymal sperm bound to the surface of the zona and in the privitelline space was undertaken to clarify this point. Cumulus-free mouse eggs were inseminated in either a complete defined culture medium capable of supporting in vitro fertilization or in Tris/NaCl buffer containing Ca+2. Both media support sperm binding to the zona to the same extent; binding is complete in 15 minutes. Unbound sperm were removed by a step gradient density centrifugation to yield a preparation of eggs with sperm firmly bound. All sperm in the perivitelline space had undergone the acrosome reaction. Sperm bound at the surface of the zonae pellucidae of eggs recovered at ten minutes after insemination all had intact acrosomes. At 40 minutes after insemination, half of the sperm were intact; the other half were in the initial stages of the acrosome reaction. At 90 minutes after insemination, 12% of the sperm had undergone the full acrosome reaction and were starting to penetrate the zona; of the balance, half were in various stages of the acrosome reaction, while half were still intact. These findings support the hypothesis that the sequence of the early reactions leading to fertilization in the mouse is: intact sperm binding to zona; acrosome reaction at the zona surface; penetration of the zona.

Temperature dependence of sperm-egg fusion and post-fusion events in hamster fertilization

The effects of temperature (4--37 degrees C) on sperm-egg fusion and the post-fusion events were studied. At 4--10 degrees C, acrosome-reacted spermatozoa bound to egg plasma membranes, but could not fuse with them. At 25 degrees C or above, both binding and fusion took place. The post-fusion events could occur over a broad temperature range (4--37 degrees C) but the events progressed faster with increasing temperature. An abnormal development of egg pronucleus, possibly due to an incomplete functioning of the meiotic spindle mechanism, was observed in eggs inseminated at 37 degrees C and cultured at 25 degrees C.