Efficacy of Retrograde Endopyelotomy in Children

Outcomes of endopyelotomy for pelviureteric junction obstruction in the paediatric population: A systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Dismembered pyeloplasty is the gold standard treatment for pelviureteric obstruction (PUJO) although endourological techniques are also employed. Outcomes and success rates for paediatric endopyelotomy are variably reported.

OBJECTIVE

The study aimed to systematically analyse published literature to give an overall success rate for endopyelotomy in children.

STUDY DESIGN

Medline and Embase databases were searched using relevant key terms to identify reports of paediatric endoplyelotomy. Literature reviews, case reports, series of <3 children and adult studies (age >20 years) were excluded. Primary and secondary procedures were considered separately. The procedure was considered successful if [a] the author reported success AND [b] there was no immediate conversion to open pyeloplasty OR a subsequent procedure to the PUJ 3 or more weeks after endopyelotomy.

RESULTS

One hundred and fourteen studies were assessed, 15 were included in the final review. Overall, 220 endopyelotomies were performed in 216 patients; 128 had primary PUJO, 92 underwent secondary endopyelotomy. Median success rate was 71% (range 46-100) in the primary group and 75% (25-100) in the secondary group. Previously undetected crossing vessels were found at subsequent open pyeloplasty in 12 failures (11 primary = 31% of failed primary endopyelotomies). Complications were reported in 14.8% of primary and 14.1% of secondary procedures.

DISCUSSION

This study is limited by the data given in the individual series: varied criteria used for patient selection and outcome as well as inconsistent pre and post operative imaging data precluded a meta-analysis. Designating procedures as failures if there were subsequent procedures to the PUJ lowered success rates from author-given figures for some studies. Complications rates after endopyelotomy are higher than those for open and minimally invasive pyeloplasty. Success rates for endoplyelotomy do not compare favourably with pyeloplasty and crossing vessels should be excluded before considering the procedure.

Endopyelotomy for pediatric ureteropelvic junction obstruction: a review of our 25-year experience

PURPOSE

We elucidate the role of endopyelotomy as a primary and secondary intervention for ureteropelvic junction obstruction in children.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively identified 79 pediatric patients who underwent endopyelotomy for ureteropelvic junction obstruction between 1986 and 2011. Eleven patients were lost to followup and were excluded from analysis. Patient demographics, operative information, complications and success rates were reviewed for the remaining 68 patients. Treatment success was defined as the absence of symptom recurrence and improved radiographic features on ultrasound, computerized tomography, diuretic renogram or excretory urogram at most recent followup.

RESULTS

Primary endopyelotomy data were analyzed in 37 patients with a median age of 11.1 years. The success rate was 65% at a median followup of 34 months (range 1.5 to 242). Treatment failure occurred in 13 patients with a median time to failure of 8 months (range 1.5 to 131). There were 8 cases of failure during 12 months of surgery. Secondary endopyelotomy data were analyzed in 31 patients with a median age of 6.5 years. The success rate was 94% at a median followup of 61 months (range 1 to 204). Treatment failure occurred in 2 patients at 1 and 6 months. Approximately two-thirds of all procedures used an antegrade approach.

CONCLUSIONS

Primary endopyelotomy is significantly less successful than pyeloplasty in the treatment of ureteropelvic junction obstruction in pediatric patients. However, secondary endopyelotomy following failed pyeloplasty represents a viable alternative to redo pyeloplasty.

Endourologic techniques for ureteropelvic junction obstruction therapy. Comparative animal study

PURPOSE

The aim of this work is to compare 3 endourologic techniques for treating a ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction. To accomplish this, we performed a study in a porcine animal specimen, in which we compared laparoscopic pyeloplasty that emerges as the future gold standard technique, with 2 endopyelotomy techniques.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Twenty-four healthy large white female pigs were randomly divided in 3 groups-group I (laparoscopic pyeloplasty), group II (endopyelotomy-Acucise, Applied Medical, Rancho Margarita, CA), and group III (endoballoon rupture endopyelotomy). Percutaneous and endoluminal ultrasonographic and fluoroscopic studies were analyzed during the different phases of the study. The study was divided in 3 phases. First one included premodel documentation of normal urinary tract and laparoscopic UPJ obstruction induction. During second phase at 6 weeks later, diagnosis and endourologic treatment were carried out. Fifteen weeks after obstruction treatment, follow-up imaging studies and postmortem evaluation of all animals were performed.

RESULTS

After the sonographic and fluoroscopic assessment, we determined the percentage of success rate for each technique-with an 87.5% for groups I and II and 75% for group III. Significant statistical differences were found between the 2 pyelotomy groups and the pyeloplasty group regarding the duration of the intervention. Significant statistical differences are evident in the evolution of the UPJ's diameter between groups I and III.

CONCLUSIONS

Laparoscopic pyeloplasty is the technique that produces fewer side effects in the reconstructed area, as well as a wider dilation of the UPJ. Nevertheless, as we show in this study, we found similar results between endopyelotomy in selected patients than pyeloplasty, and it is simpler and less invasive than the latter.

Case Report: Laparoscopic Pyeloplasty with Pyelolithotomy in Crossed Fused Ectopia

An 8-year-old boy with right flank pain was found on ultrasonography and intravenous urography to have hydronephrosis secondary to ureteropelvic junction obstruction with calculi in the lower pole of the right kidney and a fusion anomaly. Transperitoneal laparoscopic dismembered pyeloplasty and removal of calculi was carried out. The patient had uneventful recovery and is doing well at 6 months' follow-up. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case of laparoscopic pyeloplasty with pyelolithotomy in crossed fused ectopic kidneys in the pediatric population.

Endopyelotomy in Childhood: Our Experience with 37 Patients

PURPOSE

To evaluate our experience and results with endopyelotomy in the pediatric population.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between 1990 and 2002, we performed percutaneous antegrade endopyelotomy under general anesthesia in 37 children because of ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) stricture. The youngest patient was 4.5 years and the oldest 17 years at the time of the procedure (mean age 11.5 years). One patient had bilateral stenosis; the two sides were operated on separately. After insertion of a 4F ureteral catheter and filling the collecting system with colored contrast material, a middle calix was punctured under fluoroscopic control. The tunnel was dilated to 26F by telescopic metal dilators. After insertion of a 0.035-inch gidewire through the UPJ, all its layers were cut by a cold knife in the dorsolateral direction so that the periureteral fatty tissue could be seen. Finally, the ureteral wound was stented by a 6F to 12F transrenal drain or a double-J catheter, which was removed after 6 weeks.

RESULTS

Among the 37 patients, the procedure had to be repeated in 1 because the transrenal drain stenting the UPJ slid back to the renal pelvis. We had to perform open pyeloplasty or nephrectomy in two patients because of bleeding or failed procedure. The average postoperative hospital stay was 6 days. Comparison of the preoperative intravenous urograms with studies performed 1 year after endopyelotomy showed an overall success rate of 89%. All patients are without complaints at the moment.

CONCLUSIONS

In experienced hands, endopyelotomy is a safe and effective method for the treatment of UPJ stricture, not only in the adult, but also in the pediatric, population.

Stented versus nonstented pediatric pyeloplasty: a modern series and review of the literature

PURPOSE

Dismembered pyeloplasty remains the principal surgical therapy for pediatric ureteropelvic junction obstruction, although the method of postoperative drainage continues to be debated. We compared stented versus nonstented repairs in a modern series.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We evaluated 117 pediatric dismembered pyeloplasties performed by 3 pediatric urologists at 2 institutions from 1991 to 2000. Hospital stay, success rate and complication rate were reviewed. Results were compared with 833 evaluable cases in the literature.

RESULTS

Of the 52 stented repairs urological complications developed in 6 (12%), including symptomatic urinary tract infection in 3 and temporary obstruction in 3. Of the 65 nonstented repairs urological complications developed in 10 (15%), including prolonged leakage in 3, urinoma in 3, obstruction in 3 and urinary tract infection in 1. Mean hospitalization plus or minus standard error was shorter in the stented group (2.1 +/- 0.89 versus 2.6 +/- 1.1 days, p <0.02). We identified 9 previous studies comparing a total of 339 stented with 494 nonstented repairs. Overall the number of complications was almost equal (12% versus 14%) but the stented group had more infections, whereas more leaks occurred in the nonstented group. The nonstented group required more secondary procedures (12 of 339 versus 45 of 494, p = 0.003). Hospital stay was 12 days for stented and 5 days for nonstented repair in these earlier series.

CONCLUSIONS

In children the outcome of stented pyeloplasty is similar to that of nonstented repair. In contrast to previous reports, using a stent for drainage should not necessitate a longer hospital stay.

A transperitoneal laparoscopic approach to endourology

Although endoscopic methods have become the preferred means of management for many diseases facing the genitourinary surgeon, a laparoscopic approach might be considered comparable or advantageous in select circumstances. In the literature, laparoscopists reporting their work have favored the transperitoneal approach; however, there are clear advantages and disadvantages to both transperitoneal and retroperitoneal laparoscopy. Intracorporeal suturing remains the most time-consuming aspect of reconstructive surgery, and research emphasis has been on suturing devices and novel anastomotic techniques. Laparoscopic pyeloplasty is efficacious and should be considered, particularly in the case of a capacious renal pelvis, crossing vessel, or failed previous endopyelotomy. Laparoscopic pyelolithotomy is uniquely suitable for patients with aberrant anatomy, such as a horseshoe kidney, and may be performed concurrently with pyeloplasty for ureteropelvic junction obstruction. The use of laparoscopic extravesical ureteral reimplantation awaits further development in both open and subtrigonal injection techniques. Its use in colposuspension is undetermined and requires further study as suturing technology improves. During laparoscopic exploration, it is possible to address intraoperative injuries to the ureter and bladder laparoscopically. In summary, laparoscopic surgery of the urinary tract is a "work in progress," but it offers promise for some of the most challenging of circumstances. As the technology advances and the clinical experience widens, the indications and contraindications for these techniques will be better established.

Radiologic evaluations affecting surgical technique in ureteropelvic junction obstruction

Ureteropelvic junction obstructions can be explored by radiographic methods including ultrasonography, intravenous pyelography, radionuclide scanning, magnetic resonance imaging and computerized tomography. The decision to operate on an ureteropelvic stricture is best given by the results of a radionuclide scan, which can demonstrate the obstruction. The operative technique is influenced by the presence of a polar artery, as this presence represents a danger when endopyelotomy is performed. The presence of a polar artery may be demonstrated by computerized tomography using helicoidal reconstruction. Magnetic resonance imaging with injection of gadolinium is also useful when available. The outcome and the results of the surgical procedure are also evaluated by radionuclide scanning.

Symptomatic ureteropelvic junction obstruction in children in the era of prenatal sonography-is there a higher incidence of crossing vessels?

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether prenatal sonography and early detection and correction of ureteropelvic junction obstruction (UPJO) has changed the incidence of crossing vessels as the etiology of obstruction in older children presenting with symptomatic UPJO.

METHODS

We reviewed the medical records of all children and adolescents who underwent pyeloplasty for symptomatic UPJO between 1986 and 1999, during the era of widespread use of prenatal sonography. Operative notes were used to determine which patients had obstruction due to lower pole crossing vessels.

RESULTS

Thirty-eight patients were identified who underwent pyeloplasty for symptomatic UPJO. Lower pole vessels were identified in 22 (58%) of 38 patients (P <0.0001 compared with historical controls). All patients underwent dismembered pyeloplasty and remained asymptomatic after surgery, with renal scans demonstrating excellent drainage and preservation of function.

CONCLUSIONS

Prenatal ultrasonography has increased the incidence of crossing vessels as the etiology of UPJO in young children and adolescents presenting with symptomatic UPJO compared with the historical incidence of 11% to 15%. This finding may impact treatment recommendations with respect to endourologic management of the obstruction in this patient population. Currently, we recommend open dismembered pyeloplasty for young children and adolescents presenting with symptomatic UPJO.

Upper ureteral reconstructive surgery

Upper ureteral reconstructive surgery encompasses a wide variety of procedures directed at the correction of abnormal processes and structural defects in the proximal ureter. Although some of these techniques have strict indications for specific causes, technical innovations have led to development of numerous alternatives in upper ureteral reconstructive surgery. These innovations provide the practicing urologist with various options from which to choose for the management of upper ureteral disease.

Pelviureteric obstruction in children: conventional pyeloplasty is superior to endo-urology

BACKGROUND

Hydronephrosis secondary to pelviureteric junction (PUJ) obstruction is common in infancy and childhood. Pyeloplasty has until recently been the accepted method of management, but alternative endo-urological techniques have evolved in the last decade.

METHODS

Published results of conventional pyeloplasty for primary PUJ obstruction in children were compared with published results of endo-urological procedures.

RESULTS

Sixty-six pyeloplasties were performed in 61 children in a 6-year period. During a similar period, 63 primary endo-urological procedures were reported in the literature. The success rate after pyeloplasty was 95.5% compared with 65% after endo-urology.

CONCLUSIONS

Conventional pyeloplasty is superior to endo-urology and should remain the gold standard for the treatment of primary PUJ obstruction in children.

Endopyelotomy. Prognostic factors and patient selection

Although clearly a valid alternative to dismembered pyeloplasty for ureteropelvic junction obstruction in adults, endo(uretero)pyelotomy has not been universally accepted in the general urologic community because of the 10% to 30% inferior success rate and the concern regarding hemorrhagic complications. Identification of prognostic factors for success and complications are therefore of primary importance. The length of stricture, the grade of hydronephrosis, and the level of renal function are well recognized prognostic factors. Crossing vessels also play a role, and in association with the grade of hydronephrosis, they seem to be a major prognosticator of outcome. With attention to such prognostic factors, and appropriate patient selection, results can now approach the gold standard of dismembered pyeloplasty.

Retrograde balloon cautery incision of ureteropelvic junction obstruction

Retrograde balloon endopyelotomy has produced durable success rates of approximately 80% for all patients with UPJ obstruction. Patients with poor renal function, high-grade hydronephrosis, or stricture lengths of more than 2 cm fair worse, and these factors should be considered prior to balloon endopyelotomy. The debate concerning the functional significance of crossing vessels continues. However they are probably more important in terms of the risk of postoperative bleeding than in regards to overall success rates. With the use of endoluminal ultrasound, angiography, or spiral CT, patients with significant size crossing vessels can be identified preoperatively. The retrograde approach to UPJ obstruction using a cutting balloon is a quick and relatively inexpensive (shorter operative time and hospital stay, and no percutaneous nephrostomy) method for accomplishing an endopyelotomy incision. With the development of the 5-F balloon catheter and the use of a 7-F post-endopyelotomy stent, the need to stent the ureter for 7 days prior to the procedure is overcome. In this regard, the entire retrograde endopyelotomy may be performed in a one-step outpatient procedure.

Endopyelotomy. Retrograde ureteroscopic approach

Ureteroscopy is a natural extension of a urologist's practice. This article describes technical details and results using the ureteroscopic approach to treat ureteropelvic junction obstruction. With a variety of treatment options available, this approach compared favorably.