Hypospadias repair using laser welding of ventral skin flap in rabbits: comparison with sutured repair

Time Course and Histology of Urethrocutaneous Fistula Formation in a Porcine Model of Urethral Healing

OBJECTIVE

Urethrocutaneous fistula is a well-known complication of hypospadias surgery and is reported in 5-10% of repairs. Using a previously described juvenile pig model, we present a histological analysis of the healing of the ventral aspect of the urethral repair and describe the histological mechanism of fistula formation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twelve juvenile pigs underwent ventral, longitudinal urethral incision and closure over a 5-French feeding tube. The ventral aspect was closed in running fashion using two closure techniques and three suture types in each animal. Three animals were sacrificed on postoperative day 3, three on day 5, three on day 12, one on day 14, and two on day 21. Closure was one-layered incorporating urethral mucosa in the animals sacrificed on days 3, 5, and 21. An extra-mucosal suture technique was used in the group sacrificed on day 12. Sections of the penis were cut, paraffin embedded, and treated with Hematoxylin and Eosin staining.

RESULTS

Fistulae were seen in 12 specimens and in association with each suture type. Fewer sections of the extra-mucosal technique showed fistulization. Fistulae lined with immature epithelium were seen by day 5. Mature fistulae were observed by day 12. Skin epithelium and urethral mucosa migrated along suture tracts. By days 12 and 21, in addition to mature fistulae, several sections showed well-healed ventral repairs with clearly extramucosal suture tracts.

CONCLUSIONS

Fistula formation begins early in the healing process after ventral urethral repair. Incorporation of urethral mucosa in the ventral repair is a substrate for fistula formation with rapid migration of urethral mucosa and skin epithelium into suture tracts. The importance of a multi-layered repair and extra-mucosal suture technique are thus emphasized with respect to urethral repair. Whether the mucosal or dermal migration along suture tracts can be attenuated or prevented by changing the biochemical environment awaits further investigation.

Laser tissue soldering: applications in the genitourinary system

Within the past 25 years, lasers have transitioned from merely destructive or ablative tools to those with reconstructive uses. It has been shown that the application of laser thermal energy to tissue will result in welding of the approximated areas. Furthermore, the addition of protein solder and chromophores (tissue soldering) has increased wound tensile strength while decreasing peripheral tissue damage. Laboratory studies have demonstrated application of laser tissue soldering to virtually all components of the genitourinary system. Increasing human experience in recent years has reinforced the success of this technique.

Laser tissue soldering for hypospadias repair: results of a controlled prospective clinical trial

PURPOSE

Laser tissue soldering has been shown to provide safe and effective tissue closure by creating an immediate leak-free anastomosis with minimal scar formation. We compared the results of laser tissue soldering and conventional suturing for hypospadias repair.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A consecutive group of 138 boys 4 months to 8 years old (mean age 15 months) was divided into a standard suturing (84) and a sutureless laser (54) hypospadias repair group. Urethral repair was defined as simple (Thiersch-Duplay or Snodgrass) and complex (onlay island flap or tube) in 101 and 37 cases, respectively. Laser tissue soldering was performed with 50% human albumin solder doped with 2.5 mg./ml. indocyanine green dye using an 808 nm. diode laser at 0.5 W. In the laser group sutures were used for tissue alignment only. At surgery neourethral and penile length, operative time for neourethral construction and the number of sutures or throws were measured. Postoperatively patients were examined for complications of wound healing, stricture or fistula.

RESULTS

Mean patient age, urethral defect severity, type of repair, neourethral length and stenting time plus or minus standard error of mean were not significantly different in the 2 groups. Mean operative time was a fifth as long for laser tissue soldering in simple and complex hypospadias repair compared to controls (1.5 +/- 0.1 and 5.1 +/- 0.3 versus 8.5 +/- 0.8 and 26.7 +/- 1.7 minutes, respectively, p <0.001). The mean number of sutures used for tissue alignment in the laser group for simple and complex repair was significantly less than in controls (3.0 +/- 0.2 and 8.2 +/- 0.6 versus 8.5 +/- 0.8 and 23.2 +/- 1.5, respectively, p <0.001). All patients were followed a mean of 12 months (minimum 6, maximum 22). The complication rate was 4.7% in the laser group and 10.7% in controls with fistula in 2 of 54 cases, and fistula and meatal stenosis in 7 and 2 of 84, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

These preliminary results indicate that laser tissue soldering for hypospadias repair may be performed in almost sutureless fashion and more rapidly than conventional suturing. The ease of the laser technique and the lower complication rate in the laser group indicate that laser tissue soldering is an acceptable means of tissue closure in hypospadias repair.

Renal surgery in the new millennium

In the not too distant future, the minimally invasive renal surgeon will be able to practice an operation on a difficult case on a three-dimensional virtual reality simulator, providing all attributes of the real procedure. The patient's imaging studies will be imported into the simulator to better mimic particular anatomy. When confident enough of his or her skills, the surgeon will start operating on the patient using the same virtual reality simulator/telepresence surgery console system, which will permit the live surgery to be conducted by robots hundreds of miles away. The robots will manipulate miniature endoscopes or control minimally or noninvasive ablative technologies. Endoscopic/laparoscopic footage of the surgical procedure will be stored digitally in optical disks to be used later in telementoring of a surgery resident. All this and more will be possible in the not so distant third millennium.

Carbon dioxide laser tissue welding: an alternative technique for tubal anastomosis?

Microsurgical tubal anastomosis is the gold standard for treatment of tubal occlusion. The present study was performed to establish the feasibility of tubal anastomosis by welding tissue with a defocused CO2-laser beam during laparotomy and with an endoscope. In an animal experiment, 70 white New Zealand rabbits were randomized in 2 study groups (E1, E2) and 3 control groups (C1, C2, C3) as follows: C1, 10 animals, no operation, as controls for the efficiency of the insemination technique; C2, 5 animals, spontaneous healing after tubal segment resection, to quantify spontaneous recanalization of the tube; C3, 15 animals, microsurgical end-to-end adaption after tubal segment resection; E1, 20 animals, laser welded anastomosis after segment resection via laparotomy; E2, 20 animals, laparoscopic laser welded anastomosis after segment resection. The pregnancy rate in C1 was 80%. None of the animals in C2 but 60% of the rabbits in C3 conceived. After sutureless anastomosis by laser welding 50% of the laparotomized, and 40% of the laparoscopically operated group became pregnant. Morphological examination of the oviducts after relaparotomy showed comparable patency rates of 70% in C3, 70% in E1, and 65% in E2. Whereas no dehiscence of anastomoses was observed in C3, 20% of the welded tubes in E1 and 22.5% in E2 were dehiscent. Tubal anastomosis took approximately three times as long laparoscopically as during laparotomy. Thus, laser welding as a sutureless alternative technique of tubal anastomosis should be viewed critically. A reduction of sutures through laser-assisted anastomosis might, however, be considered.

Laser tissue welding

Laser tissue welding is a technologic innovation that is beginning to move from the theoretical laboratory environment to the reality of clinical application. This article reviews the concepts, potential advantages, and techniques involved in laser tissue welding as they apply to urology.

Hypospadias repair by laser tissue soldering: intraoperative results and follow-up in 30 children

OBJECTIVES

We examined the use of laser tissue soldering (LTS) as an adjunct to suturing of, as well as a primary means of, tissue closure in urethral reconstruction.

METHODS

Since June 1994, 26 boys ranging in age from 3 months to 14 years (mean 3.0 years) underwent hypospadias repair using LTS techniques. The classification of hypospadias was subcoronal in 13, midpenile in 5, penoscrotal in 7, and scrotal in 1. Laser tissue soldering was used in an additional 4 patients: tunica vaginalis patch graft corporoplasty in 2 (scrotal hypospadias), epispadias fistulae in 1, and urethral diverticulum in 1. Of these cases, 3 hypospadias repairs were completely sutureless. An intraoperative comparision was made between suturing and LTS with respect to operative time and degree of difficulty in performing LTS. Postoperatively, patients were examined to determine complications, including stricture, fistula, or impaired wound healing. An unselected group of 25 consecutive boys undergoing hypospadias repair between 1991 and 1992 served as a historical control group.

RESULTS

No intraoperative complications resulted from laser activation. In 5 of the 30 procedures (16.6%), suture disruption was noted to occur, with a higher incidence seen with finer, dyed suture material. For hypospadias repair, the average time to suture was 6.7 min/cm (n = 23), whereas it was 3.1 min/cm for adjunctive LTS (n = 23) and 1.4 min/cm for sutureless urethroplasty (n = 3). Follow-up ranged from 3 to 22 months (average 9.6). Four fistulae were noted (1 onlay, 2 skin tube grafts, 1 Thiersch tube) each following penoscrotal or scrotal hypospadias repair; a fifth fistula developed following a traumatic catheterization in a sutureless repair. The overall complication rate in the LTS group was 19% (5 of 26) versus 24% (6 of 25) for controls, whereas that for the distal forms of hypospadias was 11% (2 of 18) and 13.6% (3 of 22), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Tissue soldering with laser and chromophore-doped solder is feasible, safe, and easy to perform. Laser tissue soldering may be an alternative to standard microsuture technique for hypospadias repair.

Laser welding with albumin-based solder: experimental full-tubed skin graft urethroplasty

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Fistula and stricture formation at the site of sutured anastomoses are frequent complications of major urethroplasty. We performed urethroplasty using laser-welded skin tube grafts in the hope that in addition to being free of suture holes, grafts would be as strong as or stronger than sutured controls.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIAL AND METHODS

Scrotal skin was harvested from each of 11 rabbits and fashioned into tubes 3-4 cm in length using either conventional suture techniques or laser welding. Welding was performed using an 808-nm diode laser and a dye-enhanced solder composed of albumin and sodium hyaluronate. Laser power density was 15.9 watts/cm2. For each graft, leak pressure, and urethroplasty time (tube creation and anastomosis to native urethra) were measured.

RESULTS

Urethroplasty time was significantly shorter and initial leak pressures were seven times greater in the laser-welded group.

CONCLUSIONS

The near-uniform occurrence of strictures in both groups suggests that the rabbit is not an ideal model for free tube graft urethroplasty. However, our data indicate that laser welding with albumin-based solder, when used in the appropriate setting, may offer the potential for the rapid creation of watertight grafts in reconstructive urology.

Human albumin solder supplemented with TGF-beta 1 accelerates healing following laser welded wound closure

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

We examined the possibility that human albumin solder can be used as a vehicle for site specific delivery of growth factors for the purpose of accelerating tissue repair following laser welded wound closure. Certain human recombinant growth factors have been shown to accelerate wound healing in model systems. Pilot in vitro studies have established that several growth factors, including TGF-beta 1, maintain bioactivity following exposure to temperatures achieved during laser tissue welding. Using a temperature controlled laser delivery system (TCL) to precisely maintain welding temperatures, it is now possible to avoid thermal denaturation of exogenous bioactive molecules such as growth factors.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

HB-EGF, bFGF, and TGF-beta 1 were tested in vitro for maintenance of bioactivity after exposure to 80 degrees C. In vivo experiments using porcine skin determined the efficacy of solders augmented with growth factors. Incisions were repaired using human albumin alone or supplemented with HB-EGF (2 micrograms), bFGF (10 micrograms), or TGF-beta 1 (1 microgram). Wounds were excised at 3, 5, and 7 days post-operatively. Tensile strength, total collagen content, and histology were performed.

RESULTS

At 3 days, tensile strength (TS) of TGF-beta 1 wounds were 36% (P < 0.05) and 20% (n.s.) stronger than laser alone and suture closures, respectively. By 5 days the TS of the TGF-beta 1 group increased by 50% (P < 0.05) and 59% (P < 0.02) over laser alone and suture groups, respectively. At 7 days the TGF-beta 1 group was 50% (P < 0.05) and 79% (P < 0.01) stronger than laser solder alone or suture, respectively. The HB-EGF and bFGF groups were equivalent to the laser solder group at all time points. Total collagen TGF-beta 1 Accelerates Healing Following Laser Welding content at 7 days increased in the TGF-beta 1 group by 7% (n.s.) over the suture group and 21% (P < 0.05) in the laser group.

CONCLUSION

Human albumin solder supplemented with TGF-beta 1 increases the early post-operative strength of laser welded wounds. This novel application of laser tissue soldering augmented with a growth factor has the potential to bring about immediate fluid tight seals while providing site specific delivery of biological modifiers. This may lead to an overall improvement in post-operative convalescence, wound infections, and hospital costs.

Laser tissue soldering in urinary tract reconstruction: first human experience

OBJECTIVES

Laser tissue soldering (LTS) in the urinary tract provides an immediate leak-free seal and may avoid complications seen with conventional repair (such as fistula and stricture). We have begun a Phase I clinical trial investigating the use of LTS in performing urologic reconstructive surgery.

METHODS

Ten patients (aged 3 months to 38 years) underwent urologic reconstruction using LTS with a protein solder composed of human albumin (42%) and indocyanine green dye. In each case standard microsuture repair preceded laser-soldered suture line reinforcement. Anastomotic closure time and immediate leak pressure were measured. Postoperatively, all patients were evaluated for evidence of complications, including stricture, fistula formation, or impaired healing.

RESULTS

Using LTS as an adjunct to suturing added an average of 7.9 +/- 3.0 minutes (28%) to the overall mean anastomotic time of 28.3 +/- 9.4 minutes. Intraoperative leak pressure measurements for laser-soldered anastomoses (> or = 94.2 +/- 24.2 mm Hg) were significantly higher (P < 0.001) than primarily sutured anastomoses (20 +/- 2.9 mm Hg). Two instances of suture disruption (20%) occurred during laser activation, neither of which were repaired with sutures. Average follow-up for all patients was 7.1 + - 2.2 months. There were no intraoperative or postoperative complications, including the 2 patients with suture disruption.

CONCLUSIONS

These initial clinical results indicate that LTS is safe, easy to perform, and, contrary to conventional suturing, provides an immediate leak-free closure. Follow-up in these and other patients, as well as those undergoing sutureless and stent-free procedures, will determine whether our method of LTS benefits patients undergoing urologic reconstruction.

Laser tissue welding in genitourinary reconstructive surgery: assessment of optimal suture materials

OBJECTIVES

Laser tissue welding in genitourinary reconstructive surgery has been shown in animal models to decrease operative time, improve healing, and decrease postoperative fistula formation when compared with conventional suture controls. Although the absence of suture material is the ultimate goal, this has not been shown to be practical with current technology for larger repairs. Therefore, suture-assisted laser tissue welding will likely be performed. This study sought to determine the optimal suture to be used during laser welding.

METHODS

The integrity of various organic and synthetic sutures exposed to laser irradiation were analyzed. Sutures studied included gut, clear Vicryl, clear polydioxanone suture (PDS), and violet PDS. Sutures were irradiated with a potassium titanyl phosphate (KTP)-532 laser or an 808-nm diode laser with and without the addition of a light-absorbing chromophore (fluorescein or indocyanine green, respectively). A remote temperature-sensing device obtained real-time surface temperatures during lasing. The average temperature, time, and total energy at break point were recorded.

RESULTS

Overall, gut suture achieved significantly higher temperatures and withstood higher average energy delivery at break point with both the KTP-532 and the 808-nm diode lasers compared with all other groups (P < 0.05). Both chromophore-treated groups had higher average temperatures at break point combined with lower average energy. The break-point temperature for all groups other than gut occurred at 91 degrees C or less. The optimal temperature range for tissue welding appears to be between 60 degrees and 80 degrees C.

CONCLUSIONS

Gut suture offers the greatest margin of error for KTP and 808-nm diode laser welding with or without the use of a chromophore.

Laser tissue welding: a comprehensive review of current and future clinical applications

Laser techniques for joining tissue, in combination with other surgical technologies, will be a hallmark of surgery in the next century. At present, there are many clinical applications of tissue welding and soldering which are beginning to achieve wide spread acceptance. These exciting clinical developments are the result of many advances which have been made in the past few years in our understanding of the mechanism of laser tissue welding. Also contributing to this progress are many important technical refinements such as tissue solders and feedback control of the laser device. In this article, we describe in depth the history and development of laser tissue welding including key theoretical concepts as well as crucial experiments which have added to our insight into this phenomenon. We also review the evolving concepts of its clinical application and indicate clinical applications which are likely to become more important in the future.

Preliminary results of laser tissue welding in extravesical reimplantation of the ureters

One exciting potential use of laparoscopic technology is the extravesical reimplantation of the ureters. We have assessed the efficacy of laser-activated fibrinogen solder to close vesical muscle flaps over submucosal ureters (Lich-Gregoir technique) in a canine model. Four dogs were subjected to unilateral flap closures via a protein solder (indocyanine green and fibrinogen) applied to the bladder serosa and exposed to 808 nm. continuous wave diode laser energy. Contralateral reimplantation was performed using 4-zero vicryl muscle flap closures (controls). At 7, 14 and 28 days postoperatively, intravenous pyelograms confirmed bilateral ureteral patency. At intravesical pressures above 100 cm. H2O, there was no evidence of wound disruption in either group. Nondisrupted wound closures were sectioned and strained until ultimate breakage to determine tensile strength. At each study interval the laser-welded closures withstood greater stress than the controls. Although these data represent single tissue samples and are not amenable to statistical analysis, laser-welded closures appeared to be stronger at each study interval. In conclusion, laser-welded vesical wound closures appear at least as strong as suture closures in the canine model.

Clinical applications of lasers in otolaryngology--head and neck surgery

The use of lasers in otolaryngology--head and neck surgery is described from the invention of the laser in 1960, through the current uses of the laser, and concludes with a summary for the future directions of laser surgery. The various lasers, including the argon, the KTP, and the carbon dioxide lasers used in otolaryngology, are briefly described. The applications of lasers in the larynx, sinuses, and the ear are separately covered, as well as pediatric otolaryngology. In addition to a brief description of the procedure, the complications and limitations are given. Anesthetic considerations are also covered.