Intermittent clean catheterization: an alternative to diversion in continent transplant recipients with lower urinary tract dysfunction

Favorable Outcomes of Renal Transplant in Children With Abnormal Lower Urinary Tract

OBJECTIVES

Chronic kidney disease caused by lower urinary tract abnormalities is a significant complication in pediatric care. Although there are conflicting reports about clinical outcomes in the past, favorable outcomes have been reported in recent years. Despite this, many centers still refrain from performing renal transplant in these patients. Here, we compared clinical outcomes of renal transplant recipients with and without lower urinary tract abnormalities.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our study included 71 renal transplant recipients who were divided into 3 groups: 17 patients with abnormal lower urinary tracts having vesicoureteral reflux (group 1), 7 patients with abnormal lower urinary tracts having bladder dysfunction (group 2), and 47 patients with anatomically and functionally normal lower urinary tracts (group 3). We retrospectively compared demographic features, clinical course, graft survival, pre- and posttransplant incidence of urinary tract infections, and final graft function among the groups.

RESULTS

There were no statistically significant differences among groups regarding median age at time of transplant, graft survival, median creatinine level, and median glomerular filtration rate (P > .05). Significant differences were shown in incidence of urinary tract infections between patients in groups 1 and 2 (abnormal lower urinary tracts) and group 3 (normal lower urinary tracts) before transplant (P < .05). Although frequency of urinary tract infections in groups 1 and 2 were moderately higher than shown in group 3 after transplant, this difference was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the children with abnormal lower urinary tracts had slightly higher incidence of urinary tract infections, there were no differences between patients with abnormal and normal lower urinary tracts regarding allograft survival and function. In addition, proper follow-up of patients before and after transplant, based on our experience, should include educating patients and their parents about potential complications after transplant for the best outcome of renal transplant.

Long-term results of pediatric renal transplantation into a dysfunctional lower urinary tract

BACKGROUND

The authors reviewed their long-term experience with pediatric renal transplantation into a dysfunctional lower urinary tract to evaluate the results of contemporary lower urinary tract evaluation and management on graft survival and function.

METHODS

Between 1990 and 1996, 21 renal transplants were performed in 20 children with dysfunctional lower urinary tracts and 61 transplants were performed in 61 patients with normal lower urinary tracts. The minimum follow-up was 36 months (mean, 62.0 +/- 19.6 months). The cause of lower urinary tract dysfunction included posterior urethral valves (n=13), prune belly syndrome (n=4), meningomyelocele (n=2), and urogenital sinus abnormality (n=1). Urodynamics were performed on all children with dysfunctional lower urinary tracts. Using these perioperative assessments, lower tract management strategies were devised, including timed voiding alone (n=6), clean intermittent catheterization (n=8), bladder augmentation (n=4), and supravesical urinary diversion (n=2).

RESULTS

Overall 5-year actuarial patient and graft survival rates were 100% versus 95% (P=not significant [NS]) and 83% versus 69% in the dysfunctional and normal urinary tract groups (P=NS), respectively. Mean serum creatinine levels in dysfunctional and normal urinary tract patients with functioning grafts at 3 years were 1.3 +/- 0.5 and 1.3 +/- 0.7 mg/dL, respectively (P=NS). However, 35% of patients with a dysfunctional lower urinary tract experienced urologic complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Pediatric renal transplantation into a dysfunctional lower urinary tract yields outcomes comparable to transplantation into the normal lower urinary tract. Because of the high urologic complication rates, careful surveillance of lower urinary tract function by urodynamic evaluation is essential to optimize these outcomes.

Experience with kidney transplantation in children and adolescents

BACKGROUND

Paediatric kidney transplantation has different aspects in adults in terms of underlying primary renal disease, surgical technique, perioperative care and graft prognosis. Significant urological problems are present in a high percentage of paediatric recipients. This study was undertaken to characterize paediatric kidney transplantation as performed at our institutes.

METHODS

Twenty-eight patients (age range 4-17 years, 10 girls, 18 boys) were included in this study. We analyzed (1) urologic procedures performed prior to or simultaneously with transplantation, (2) intraoperative changes in haemodynamics, (3) postoperative complications and (4) acute allograft rejection and graft prognosis.

RESULTS

Of 4 patients with lower urinary tract abnormalities (neurogenic bladder in 3, posterior urethral valve in 1), 2 underwent augmentation ileocystoplasty prior to transplantation. The Mitrofanoff procedure as a diversion for neourethra was also performed in 2 of the 4 patients. All these 4 patients were managed with clean intermittent catheterization. Central venous pressure changes before and after graft vessel declamping were much greater in patients with body weight below 25 kg than in those above 25 kg. Five surgical complications and 6 infections were encountered postoperatively and hypertension was lasting in 6. Thirteen patients experienced 19 periods of acute allograft rejection. All of the 24 patients in the cyclosporin era (1986-) overcame rejections and they are all alive with good graft function.

CONCLUSIONS

As long as proper pretransplant patient evaluation and management, and intensive perioperative care are undertaken, good prognosis of renal allograft can be achieved in young patients.

Renal transplantation into augmented bladders

BACKGROUND

Urinary bladder augmentation is gaining popularity for the treatment of dysfunctional bladders in renal transplant patients. Although reported cases of adult and pediatric transplants into the augmented bladder have been favorable, the potential risk of urinary tract infection and graft failure under immunosuppression is still disputable. We report our experiences with 4 patients who underwent renal transplantation into an augmented bladder.

METHODS

Between 1971 and 1996, 1275 renal transplants were performed at our institution. Of these transplants, 4 patients underwent renal transplantation into an augmented urinary bladder. Augmentation cystoplasty was performed before transplantation in 3 patients and 7 years after transplantation in the other patient. The bladder was augmented with an ileal segment in 3 patients and a ureter in the fourth patient. Graft function was assessed by the serum creatinine level. Fluorocystometrograms were performed in all patients at fixed intervals.

RESULTS

Posttransplant renal function was satisfactory overall and no patient exhibited proteinuria. All patients except 1 acquired a large capacity low pressure bladder and remained continent with clean intermittent catheterization. One patient who underwent ureterocystoplasty is still incontinent because of his relatively small bladder capacity. Posttransplant pyelonephritis was documented in 3 patients during the follow-up period, but no other complications were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates that renal transplantation into extensively reconstructed bladders can be safely performed with good success. Although urinary tract infection is a major consideration, we recommend pretransplant reconstruction not only to preserve graft function, but also to achieve urinary continence.

Evaluation of voiding cystourethrography prior to renal transplantation

In many centers, voiding cystourethrography is a routine part of pretransplantation assessment of the lower urinary tract. To assess the value of this investigation, a retrospective review of transplant candidates evaluated in our center over 2 years was undertaken. A total of 517 patients were fully evaluable. Only 13 voiding cystourethrograms (VCUGs) (2.5%) of 517 were found to be abnormal. Three patients with reflux alone did not require intervention before transplantation. Four patients with decreased bladder capacity underwent hydrodistention. Two patients increased their capacity to over 150 ml and two patients failed distention, one requiring an ileal conduit and the other requiring an augmentation cystoplasty. Three patients had increased postvoid residual (PVR). Two patients started clean intermittent catheterization. One required prostate resection for benign prostatic hypertrophy. One patient with reflux and decreased bladder capacity refused treatment. One patient with reflux combined with increased PVR started clean intermittent catheterization and was cleared for transplant surgery. One patient with decreased bladder capacity and increased PVR had a stroke and was excluded from transplantation. All 13 patients with abnormal VCUGs had a prior urologic history. In total, only 56 of 517 patients evaluated had a prior urological history. Each VCUG costs approximately $500. Limiting VCUG studies to those patients with a prior urological history would have resulted in a significant cost savings. Hence, we recommend that only patients with a prior urological history should undergo this costly and often distressing examination.

Clean intermittent catheterization and urinary diversion in the management of renal transplant recipients with lower urinary tract dysfunction

Renal transplant recipients with lower urinary tract dysfunction may be managed by urinary diversion or clean intermittent catheterization. To evaluate the comparative problems associated with each mode of therapy we studied 13 patients managed by clean intermittent catheterization (group 1, 6 patients) or urinary diversion (group 2, 7 patients). All 6 and 2 of 7 recipients in groups 1 and 2, respectively, had a neuropathic bladder. Mean followup was 3.7 +/- 1.5 (group 1) and 5.7 +/- 4.9 (group 2) years. Three allografts were lost in group 2 due to rejection (2) and death (1). Two patients each in groups 1 and 2 had febrile urinary tract infections requiring hospitalization and intravenous antibiotics. Complications related to urinary diversion developed in 4 patients in group 2. The serum creatinine at 1 and 3 years, number of hospital days per patient, total number of rejection episodes and number of patients employed in a full-time job following transplantation were similar in both groups. In summary, clean intermittent catheterization appears to have more morbidity in immunosuppressed transplant versus nontransplant patients but it may be preferable in renal transplant recipients due to the overall simplicity, positive psychological effect and comparable morbidity to other forms of management.

The efficiency of bladder emptying in the prune belly syndrome

From 1956 to 1991, 49 cases of the prune belly syndrome were seen at our institution. Voiding information and/or 1 or more urodynamic studies were available in 30 male and 4 female patients. Analysis of multiple urodynamic studies during long-term followup periods ranging from 6 months to 19 years, with particular regard to any reconstructive procedures performed, revealed that voiding in the prune belly syndrome is variable, with 44% of the patients achieving spontaneous voiding and 56% requiring clean intermittent catheterization. The ability to void or need for clean intermittent catheterization was by no means permanent, indicating the need for meticulous followup. The 3 distinct voiding patterns observed included an approximately normal pattern, prolonged voiding with a low peak and an intermittent pattern. These 3 voiding patterns did not correlate with residual volumes. Comparison of urodynamic voiding parameters between reconstructed voiding patients and nonreconstructed voiding patients did not show significant differences.

The outcome of renal transplantation in children with the prune belly syndrome

Children with the prune belly syndrome are at high risk for renal failure. The effect of the prune belly syndrome on the outcome of renal transplantation was evaluated in a retrospective study in which 8 transplant recipients with this syndrome were randomly matched with 13 control, nondiabetic transplant patients. The parameters evaluated were patient and graft survival, renal function and interval until transplantation. The patients were matched by computer for age at transplantation, date of transplantation, immunosuppressive therapy used and type of donor. Data were analyzed by the Gehan test. There was no statistically significant difference in patient deaths (1 versus 3), graft survival (75 versus 69%) or graft function between patients with the prune belly syndrome and controls. Patients with the prune belly syndrome waited a shorter interval for transplantation than did controls (no statistically significant difference) because the distensible abdominal wall characteristic of the syndrome permits placement of an adult kidney in a young child. The prune belly syndrome did not adversely affect the outcome of renal transplantation in these patients.

Renal transplantation and Kock pouch: a case report

We report on a young woman with anuric, terminal renal insufficiency whose bladder could not be used for renal transplantation. A Kock pouch was implanted during stage 1 of treatment and the capacity of the pouch was increased artificially with physiological saline solution. The patient subsequently underwent renal transplantation. Results were excellent with regard to continence and ease of catheterization. No complications due to infection were observed despite immunosuppression and electrolyte disorders were minor.

The outcome of renal transplantation in children with posterior urethral valves

The effect of vesical dysfunction on the survival and function of renal transplants was evaluated by a retrospective study in which 18 children with posterior urethral valves and 18 children with vesicoureteral reflux were randomly matched with 36 children used as controls. There was no statistically significant difference in patient survival among the 3 groups. Five years after transplantation 50 per cent of the grafts in children with posterior urethral valves were functioning, while 73 and 75 per cent, respectively, of the grafts were functioning in children with vesicoureteral reflux and in the control group. Renal function during the 5 years was significantly better in children in the control group and in those with vesicoureteral reflux than in children with posterior urethral valves. We believe that the presence of an abnormal bladder may alter graft survival and adversely affect the function of the transplanted kidney.

Renal transplantation in end stage renal disease patients with existing urinary diversion

From 1971 to 1984 renal transplantation was performed in 20 patients with end stage renal disease who presented with an existing form of urinary diversion. These patients were evaluated with a cystometrogram, voiding cystourethrogram and cystoscopy. In some cases bladder function was studied further by cycling through a suprapubically placed catheter. The bladder was considered unstable in 13 patients and undiversion was done at transplantation. The period of prior diversion ranged from 3 to 20 years (mean 12.7 years). There were no surgical complications postoperatively and normal bladder function returned in all patients. Currently, 8 patients have a functioning renal allograft 16 months to 9 years after transplantation (mean 4.2 years). Seven patients were considered to have a nonusable bladder owing to severe neurogenic disease or refractory contracture. In these patients transplantation was done into a pre-fashioned intestinal conduit (5) or cutaneous ureterostomy (2). Currently, 4 patients have a functioning renal allograft 16 months to 6.2 years after transplantation (mean 3.8 years). Transplantation candidates who present with an existing form of urinary diversion should be evaluated carefully, since many will have a usable bladder. Regardless of whether the bladder is usable, transplantation can be performed safely with no increased surgical or immunological risk.

Bilateral rectus femoris pedicle flaps for detrusor augmentation in the prune belly syndrome

A 20-year-old patient with the prune belly syndrome presented with urinary retention and renal failure. In preparation for renal transplantation bladder rehabilitation, consisting of urethral dilation, reduction cystoplasty and detrusor augmentation with paired rectus femoris pedicle flaps, was undertaken. This procedure enabled the patient to empty the bladder totally by spontaneous voiding. Successful renal transplantation was performed subsequently and he has not required intermittent or continuous catheterization. The surgical approach and technique are described, and their application to other conditions of detrusor hypotonicity is discussed.

Long-term clean intermittent self-catheterization in renal transplant recipients

Eight renal transplant recipients with neurogenic bladders or lower urinary tract dysfunction were managed with clean intermittent self-catheterization after transplantation instead of urinary diversion. A total of 85 treatment months was reviewed. Of the patients 5 continue to do well after 10 to 17 months of intermittent catheterization and 3 suffered immunological graft failures. In selected renal transplant recipients with lower urinary tract dysfunction clean intermittent catheterization is a reasonable alternative to urinary diversion.