Validating studies for panic disorder in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries

The association between panic disorder and coronary artery disease among primary care patients presenting with chest pain: an updated literature review

CONTEXT

Although panic disorder is linked to hypertension and smoking, the relationship between panic disorder and coronary artery disease (CAD) is unclear.

OBJECTIVE

To extend our understanding about the strength of the association between panic disorder and coronary artery disease and known cardiovascular risk factors.

DATA SOURCES

Potential studies were identified via a computerized search of MEDLINE and PsycINFO databases and review of bibliographies. MeSH headings used included panic disorder with chest pain, panic disorder with coronary disease or cardiovascular disorders or heart disorders, and panic disorder with cholesterol or essential hypertension or tobacco smoking.

STUDY SELECTION

The diagnosis of panic disorder in eligible studies was based on DSM-IV criteria, and studies must have used objective criteria for CAD and risk factors. Only case-control and cohort studies were included.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Concerning the relationship between panic disorder and CAD, studies conducted in emergency departments found a relative risk [RR] of 1.25 (95% CI = 0.87 to 1.80), while those conducted in cardiology settings found an inverse relationship (RR = 0.19, 95% CI = 0.10 to 0.37). However, there is an inverse relationship between the prevalence of CAD in the study and the RR (r = -.554, p = .097), suggesting that, in primary care settings in which the prevalence of CAD is low, there may be a significant association between panic disorder and CAD.

CONCLUSION

The association between panic disorder and CAD has several implications for primary care physicians managing patients with chest pain. When comorbid, the panic attacks may cause the patient with coronary disease to seek care but could also provoke a cardiac event. If one condition is recognized, a search for the other may be warranted because of the potential consequences if left undetected. The treatment approach to the panic disorder should be adjusted in the presence of comorbid CAD.

Clinical characteristics and follow-up of patients with chest pain and normal coronary arteries

The authors identified 160 men and women from all 3,700 patients with anginal pain between 1990 and 1994 who were subsequently found to have normal coronary arteries at diagnostic cardiac catheterization with follow-up to the present (mean follow-up 2.5 years). The group comprised 50 women and 110 men. Mean age was significantly greater in women (53.1 +/- 7.7 vs 47.2 +/- 9.2 years, p<0.001). Forty percent of the women but only 10% of the men had a positive exercise test. At follow-up, a larger proportion of patients continue to experience chest pain (95 patients, 59%) of whom 65 patients (41%) continue antianginal therapy. Furthermore one patient suffered a sudden cardiac death and two patients had a nonfatal myocardial infarction. Of patients referred with chest pain, women were more likely to have normal coronary arteries, compared with men. All patients have an excellent prognosis. A large proportion of women had a positive exercise test in the absence of coronary artery disease. On the other hand, morbidity remains high in these patients, despite the reassurance of a normal-appearing coronary arteriogram.

Hypocapnia associated with cardiac stress scintigraphy in chest pain patients with panic disorder

OBJECTIVE

Patients with recurrent chest pain but no evidence of coronary artery disease often meet diagnostic criteria for panic disorder (PD). However, it can be argued that the phenomenological diagnosis of PD may not be valid in these normal coronary chest pain (NCCP) patients. The purpose of this study is to additionally validate the diagnosis of PD in chest pain patients by comparing PCO2 levels before and during myocardial stress scintigraphy in those with and without PD.

METHOD

End-tidal PCO2 was measured before and during myocardial stress scintigraphy in 22 patients being evaluated for chest pain. Psychiatric diagnoses were assessed by structured interview.

RESULTS

Eleven of the 19 patients (58%) with negative scintigrams met DSM-III-R diagnostic criteria for current panic disorder. Prestress PCO2 levels were significantly lower in these patients. Eight of the nine NCCP patients with prestress PCO2 < 34 mm Hg had PD.

CONCLUSIONS

The finding of stress-related hypocapnia associated with PD in NCCP patients provides additional support for the validity of the diagnosis of PD in this population. The potential value of PCO2 measurements in screening for PD in patients with chest pain merits additional study.

Panic disorder associated with gastrointestinal disease: review and hypotheses

An association between panic disorder and functional gastrointestinal disease has emerged since the introduction of reliable diagnostic criteria, first for psychiatric disorders and more recently for functional gastrointestinal disorders. At the same time, a more rigorous review of methodology of older reports linking structural gastrointestinal diseases such as peptic ulcer and inflammatory bowel disease to psychiatric illness has cast doubt on the validity of their association. In this review original articles reporting an association between panic disorder and globus, functional chest pain of presumed esophageal origin, functional dyspepsia, and irritable bowel syndrome are critically reviewed and it is concluded that panic disorder is overrepresented in noncardiac chest pain and irritable bowel syndrome. Original reports of the prevalence of panic disorder in structural gastrointestinal disease are reviewed and it is concluded that they do not support an association with panic. Hypotheses explaining the statistical link of panic disorder and functional gastrointestinal disease are discussed.

Cardiac rehabilitation and secondary prevention after a myocardial event

In the current era, cardiac rehabilitation after a myocardial event involves physical training in conjunction with optimizing the use of medications to control myocardial ischemia and prevent cardiac complications. It is also the time to identify and treat concomitant psychiatric problems and to develop an individualized program in secondary risk factor modification through counseling, behavior modification, nutritional counseling, and a properly selected drug program. This review attempts to deal with the above matters pragmatically.

The prevalence of rheumatologic disorders in patients with chest pain and angiographically normal coronary arteries

The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of musculoskeletal disorders in patients with chest pain and angiographically normal coronary arteries. The authors studied 40 consecutive patients with chest pain presenting at an Internal Medicine Clinic who had undergone coronary angiography and were found to have < 30% stenosis of all major coronary arteries. Patients with any known noncardiac cause of chest pain were excluded from the study. Each patient underwent a complete rheumatologic examination with x-rays and blood tests when indicated. The diagnosis of fibromyalgia was based on the presence of at least eight paired tender points. The diagnosis of costochondritis was made when palpation of the costal cartilages elicited tenderness. In the normal coronary artery group, 30% of the patients had fibromyalgia and 10% had costochondritis. In the control group of 40 patients with coronary artery disease, only 1 patient had fibromyalgia and none had costochondritis (P < 0.04). Other rheumatologic disorders were uncommon, with no statistical difference between the two groups. The authors conclude that many patients with chest pain and angiographically normal coronary arteries suffer from rheumatologic disorders with fibromyalgia being the most common.

Panic disorder in the families of patients with normal coronary arteries and non-fear panic disorder

Patients with non-fear panic disorder (NFPD) meet DSM-III-R criteria for panic disorder, but do not report subjective fear or anxiety. Although apparently common in medical settings, this controversial group is in need of further diagnostic validation. This study assessed family history of panic disorder in patients with chest pain and normal coronary arteries (CP/NCA) and either NFPD, panic disorder with fear, or no panic. It was hypothesized that the two panic disorder groups would have similar, elevated rates of panic disorder in their first-degree relatives, compared to patients without panic. The results support the hypothesis; about 17% of the first-degree relatives of both NFPD and panic disorder patients were diagnosable with panic disorder according to proband interviews, whereas only 4.6% of the first-degree relatives of patients without panic were so diagnosable. These results support the diagnostic validity of NFPD in CP/NCA patients, because such patients had a family history of panic disorder similar to patients with a more classical panic disorder presentation. The lack of fear symptoms and behavior in NFPD may cause panic disorder to be overlooked as a potential cause of somatic symptoms in patients with no medical explanation for their condition.

Psychosocial and psychophysical assessments of patients with unexplained chest pain

It is imperative to assess the psychosocial factors that may influence the subjective experiences and pain behavior of persons with chronic unexplained chest pain. Both psychologists and physicians tend to rely on self-report measures of psychological distress, which provide little unique information about patients with chronic chest pain to differentiate them from patients with other painful disorders such as irritable bowel syndrome, gastroesophageal reflux disease, or coronary artery disease. However, assessment of pain-coping strategies, spouse responses to the patient's pain behaviors, and pain thresholds for esophageal balloon distention do differentiate patients with chronic chest pain from healthy controls and patients with various other chronic pain disorders. Specifically, chronic chest pain patients tend to use relatively passive pain-coping strategies such as praying and hoping, and to report relatively high levels of spouse reinforcement of pain behaviors. Finally, in response to esophageal balloon distention, chronic chest pain patients display low pain thresholds that do not generalize to stimulation by mechanical finger pressure. Preliminary evidence suggests these low thresholds are due primarily to a tendency to set low standards for making pain judgments regarding esophageal stimuli of moderate-to-high intensity levels.

Chest pain in generalized anxiety disorder

OBJECTIVES

The objectives of the current study were to evaluate the prevalence of chest pain and related medical utilization in patients with generalized anxiety disorder and to investigate the possible relationship between the occurrence of chest pain in these patients and the episodes of excessive worry which characterize this disorder.

METHOD

The presence of a history of chest pain in patients with generalized anxiety disorder was investigated in an outpatient psychiatric sample using a structured interview which also assessed related medical utilization and the relationship of chest pain to panic attacks and episodes of excessive worry.

RESULTS

Of fifty sequentially evaluated patients meeting DSM-III R criteria for G.A.D., twenty-four (48%) reported a history of chest pain. Seven of these patients also had a history of panic attacks, however, four of the seven reported that their pain occurred independently of their panic attacks. Sixteen patients with G.A.D. reported that their chest pain episodes were associated with episodes of excess worry. Eleven had sought medical evaluation for their pain. Patients with chest pain and normal coronary arteries are frequently found to have panic disorder. The pattern of utilization of medical care was comparable in this sample of patients with G.A.D. and a group of patients with panic disorder recruited in a similar manner.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that in addition to panic disorder, G.A.D. may also be a common diagnosis in chest pain patients with no demonstrable coronary disease. Future studies of coronary artery disease negative patients with chest pain should include assessments for the presence of G.A.D. Our results also suggest that chest pain may be a common symptom in G.A.D. The possibility that chest pain should be included in the diagnostic criteria for this disorder should be the subject of further investigation.