Further evidence for the rodent bone marrow micronucleus assay acting as a sensitive predictor of the possible germ cell mutagenicity of chemicals

Germ cell mutagens: risk assessment challenges in the 21st century

Heritable mutations may result in a wide variety of detrimental outcomes, from embryonic lethality to genetic disease in the offspring. Despite this, today's commonly used test batteries do not include assays for germ cell mutation. Current challenges include a lack of practical assays and concrete evidence for human germline mutagens, and large data gaps that often impede risk assessment. Moreover, most regulatory assessments are based on the assumption that somatic cell mutation assays also protect the germline by default, which has not been adequately confirmed. The field is also faced with new challenges aimed at dramatically reducing animal testing, and attempts to rapidly classify thousands of chemicals using high throughput in vitro assays. These approaches may not adequately capture effects that may be particular to gametes, since many aspects of the germline are unique. In light of these challenges, an urgent need exists to develop new approaches to evaluate the potential of toxicants to cause germline mutation. The application of new technologies will greatly enhance our understanding of mutation in humans exposed to environmental mutagens. However, we must be poised to collect and interpret these data, and facilitate risk translation to regulators and the public. Genetic toxicologists must also become actively involved in the development of high-throughput tools to study germline mutation. Appropriate attention to these areas will result in the development of policies that prioritize the protection of the germline and future generations from DNA sequence mutations.

Female-specific reproductive toxicities following preconception exposure to xenobiotics

Females do differ from males in their germ cell and general reproductive responses to toxicants. Chromatin structure is perhaps one factor that contributes to sex differences in germ cell response to toxicants. Differences in available targets likely contribute to response differences between sexes as well as to within sex differences between germ cell stages. It is important to consider these differences when conducting reproductive toxicity studies and interpreting the results.

Mouse bone marrow micronucleus test results do not predict the germ cell mutagenicity of N-hydroxymethylacrylamide in the mouse dominant lethal assay

N-Hydroxymethylacrylamide (NHMA), a mouse carcinogen inactive in the Salmonella assay and mouse micronucleus (MN) assay, was tested for reproductive effects in a mouse continuous breeding study. In that study, increased embryonic deaths were observed after 13 weeks exposure of parental animals to NHMA via drinking water (highest dose, 360 ppm); the results indicated the possible induction of chromosome damage in germ cells of treated males. An additional mouse MN test was conducted using a 31-day treatment period to better match the dosing regimen used in the breeding study; the results were negative. Additional studies were conducted to explore the germ cell activity of NHMA. A male mouse dominant lethal study was conducted using a single intraperitoneal injection of 150 mg/kg NHMA; the results were negative. A follow-up study was conducted using fractionated dosing, 50 mg/kg/day for 5 days; again, no increase in dominant lethal mutations was observed. NHMA (180-720 ppm) was then administered to male mice in drinking water for 13 weeks, during which three sets of matings occurred. Two weeks after mating, females were killed and the uterine contents were analyzed. Large, dose-related increases in dominant lethal mutations were observed with increasing length of exposure. The magnitude of the increases stabilized after 8 weeks of treatment. However, the frequency of micronucleated peripheral blood erythrocytes was not elevated in mice treated for 13 weeks with NHMA in drinking water. Thus, NHMA appears to be unique in inducing genetic damage in germ cells but not somatic cells of male mice.