The Big Blue(R) transgenic mouse mutation detection assay: the mutation pattern of sectored mutant plaques

Workshop report: The medaka model for comparative assessment of human disease mechanisms

Results of recent studies showing the utility of medaka as a model of various human disease states were presented at the 7th Aquatic Models of Human Disease Conference (December 13-18, 2014, Austin, TX). This conference brought together many of the most highly regarded national and international scientists that employ the medaka model in their investigations. To take advantage of this opportunity, a cohort of established medaka researchers were asked to stay an extra day and represent the medaka scientific community in a workshop entitled "The Medaka Model for Comparative Assessment of Human Disease Mechanisms." The central purpose of this medaka workshop was to assess current use and project the future resource needs of the American medaka research community. The workshop sought to spur discussions of issues that would promote more informative comparative disease model studies. Finally, workshop attendees met together to propose, discuss, and agree on recommendations regarding the most effective research resources needed to enable US scientists to perform experiments leading to impacting experimental results that directly translate to human disease. Consistent with this central purpose, the workshop was divided into two sessions of invited speakers having expertise and experience in the session topics. The workshop hosted 20 scientific participants (Appendices 1 and 2), and of these, nine scientists presented formal talks. Here, we present a summary report stemming from workshop presentations and subsequent round table discussions and forward recommendations from this group that we believe represent views of the overall medaka research community.

Early-life exposure to benzo[a]pyrene increases mutant frequency in spermatogenic cells in adulthood

Children are vulnerable to environmental mutagens, and the developing germline could also be affected. However, little is known about whether exposure to environmental mutagens in childhood will result in increased germline mutations in subsequent adult life. In the present study, male transgenic lacI mice at different ages (7, 25 and 60 days old) were treated with a known environmental mutagen (benzo[a]pyrene, B[a]P) at different doses (0, 50, 200 or 300 mg/kg body weight). Mutant frequency was then determined in a meiotic cell type (pachytene spermatocyte), a post-meiotic cell type (round spermatid) and epididymal spermatozoa after at least one cycle of spermatogenesis. Our results show that 1) mice treated with B[a]P at 7 or 25 days old, both being pre-adult ages, had significantly increased mutant frequencies in all spermatogenic cell types tested when they were 60 days old; 2) spermatogenic cells from mice treated before puberty were more susceptible to B[a]P-associated mutagenesis compared to adult mice; and 3) unexpectedly, epididymal spermatozoa had the highest mutant frequency among the spermatogenic cell types tested. These data show that pre-adult exposure to B[a]P increases the male germline mutant frequency in young adulthood. The data demonstrate that exposure to environmental genotoxins at different life phases (e.g., pre-adult and adult) can have differential effects on reproductive health.

Male-driven de novo mutations in haploid germ cells

At the sequence level, genetic diversity is provided by de novo transmittable mutations that may act as a substrate for natural selection. The gametogenesis process itself is considered more likely to induce endogenous mutations and a clear male bias has been demonstrated from recent next-generation sequencing analyses. As new experimental evidence accumulates, the post-meiotic events of the male gametogenesis (spermiogenesis) appear as an ideal context to induce de novo genetic polymorphism transmittable to the next generation. It may prove to be a major component of the observed male mutation bias. As spermatids undergo chromatin remodeling, transient endogenous DNA double-stranded breaks are produced and trigger a DNA damage response. In these haploid cells, one would expect that the non-templated, DNA end-joining repair processes may generate a repertoire of sequence alterations in every sperm cell potentially transmittable to the next generation. This may therefore represent a novel physiological mechanism contributing to genetic diversity and evolution.

A novel Escherichia coli-derived mutation detected with the Big Blue cII mutant selectable assay

Transgenic mouse mutation detection systems allow investigation of the origins and mechanisms of mutation associated with exogenous and endogenous mutagen exposures in individual tissues and cell types. In the past, selection assays for transgenic mutants have been contaminated with nonmurine-derived mutations and assay validation is critical to ensure murine in vivo origins of mutations. This is critical in studies of spontaneous mutations and extrapolation to endogenous mammalian genes. Herein, we provide one measure of the contribution of Escherichia coli (E. coli)-derived mutations to the Big Blue(R) cII transgene mutant selection assay. We report the first direct evidence of an E. coli-derived cII mutation identified among mutations recovered in the cII selective assay. An E. coli transposable 5 (Tn5) element IS50R inverted repeat (1,534 bp) was identified at base pair 414 in the cII transgene and the insertion generated a 9 bp target site duplication typical of this type of transposition. The bacterial transposition occurred only once in the assay of 25 x 10(6) plaque forming units and sequencing of 1,177 cII mutants. The observed frequency of this type of mutation is 4 x 10(-8) in retrieved lambda phage and 8.5 x 10(-4) in harvested cII mutants and thus a very rare occurrence in typical analyses of spontaneous in vivo mutations. Given that the frequency of transposition is equal to, or an order of magnitude higher, than the frequency of point mutations in E. coli, this article provides excellent validation for the murine origins of mutations detected using the cII mutant selection assay.

A novel germline mutation in Big Blue mice

The Big Blue lacI mutation detection assay is well validated and has permitted detailed analysis of spontaneous mutations in individual tissues over the lifespan of the mouse. In a recent assay of spontaneous mutations, a novel lacI mutation (C354T) recurred in six of seven mutants with a second mutation. The frequency of spontaneous doublets (mutants with two nontandem mutations) was elevated 2.7-fold over that previously reported (Hill KA et al., [2004b]: Mutat Res 554:223-240) for normal tissues (6.3 x 10(-7) herein vs. 2.36 x 10(-7)). The average spacing between mutations in the doublets (237 bp) was greater than previously reported for spontaneous doublets. The frequency of C354T as a "hitchhiker" mutation in doublets was consistent with a germline mutation in one of 38 mutation targets in the Big Blue mouse genome. C354T is a missense mutation at a CpG dinucleotide producing a conservative amino acid change (Ala109Val) and a very light blue mutant phenotype. Mutant phenotypes of doublets with C354T were typical of the second mutation. C354T was observed in mutants from five tissues of five Big Blue mice. A bidirectional-PCR amplification of specific alleles (Bi-PASA) assay detected C354T in genomic DNA from multiple tissues of five Big Blue mice. These observations are consistent with a novel lacI C354T germline mutation in Big Blue mice that introduces a significant artifact in the analysis of spontaneous mutations. This finding reiterates the importance of identifying all mutations and examining new mutations in the context of our increasingly detailed knowledge of features of spontaneous murine mutations.

Database of somatic mutations in EGFR with analyses revealing indel hotspots but no smoking-associated signature

We created an Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (EGFR) Mutation Database (http://www.cityofhope.org/cmdl/egfr_db) that curates a convenient compilation of somatic EGFR mutations in non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and associated epidemiological and methodological data, including response to the tyrosine kinase inhibitors Gefitinib and Erlotinib. Herein, we analyze 809 mutations collected from 26 publications. Four super hotspots account for 70% of reported mutations while two-thirds of 131 unique mutations have been reported only once and account for only 11% of reported mutations. Consistent with strong biological selection for gain of function, the reported mutations are virtually all missense substitutions or in-frame microdeletions, microinsertions, or microindels (colocalized insertion and deletion with a net gain or loss of 1-50 nucleotides). Microdeletions and microindels are common in a region of exon 19. Microindels, which account for 8% of mutations, have smaller inserted sequences (95% are 1 to 5 bp) and are elevated 16-fold relative to mouse somatic microindels and to human germline microindels. Microdeletions/microindels are significantly more frequent in responders to Gefitinib or Erlotinib (P = 0.003). In addition, EGFR mutations in smokers do not carry signatures of mutagens in cigarette smoke. Otherwise, the mutation pattern does not differ significantly with respect to gender, age, or tumor histology. The EGFR Mutation Database is a central resource of EGFR sequence variant data for clinicians, geneticists, and other researchers. Authors are encouraged to submit new publications with EGFR sequence variants to be included in the database or to provide direct submissions via The WayStation submission and publication process (http://www.centralmutations.org).

Evidence for mutation showers

Mutants in the Big Blue transgenic mouse system show spontaneous clustered multiple mutations with unexpectedly high frequency, consistent with chronocoordinate events. We tested the prediction that the multiple mutations seen within the lacI mutation target sometimes occur in the context of chronocoordinate multiple mutations spanning multiple kilobases (mutation showers). Additional sequencing of mutants was performed in regions immediately flanking the lacI region (total of 10.7 kb). Nineteen additional mutations were found outside the lacI region ("ectomutations") from 10 mutants containing two or more lacI mutations, whereas only one ectomutation was found in 130 mutants with a single mutation (P < 0.0001). The mutation showers had an average of approximately one mutation per 3 kb. Four mutants showed closely spaced double mutations in the new sequence, and analysis of the spacing between these mutations revealed significant clustering (P = 0.0098). To determine the extent of the mutation showers, regions (8.5 kb total) remote from the lacI region (approximately 16-17 kb away) were sequenced. Only two additional ectomutations were found in these remote regions, consistent with mutation showers that generally do not extend more than approximately 30 kb. We conclude that mutation showers exist and that they constitute at least 0.2% and possibly 1% or more of mutational events observed in this system. The existence of mutation showers has implications for oncogenesis and evolution, raising the possibilities of "cancer in an instant" and "introns as sponges to reduce the deleterious impact of mutation showers."

Spontaneous multiple mutations show both proximal spacing consistent with chronocoordinate events and alterations with p53-deficiency

Analysis of spontaneous multiple mutations in normal and tumor cells may constrain hypotheses about the mechanisms responsible for multiple mutations and provide insight into the mutator phenotype. In a previous study, spontaneous doublets in Big Blue mice were dramatically more frequent than expected by chance and exhibited a mutation pattern similar to that observed for single mutations [Mutat. Res. 452 (2000) 219]. The spacing between mutations in doublets was generally closer than expected by chance and the distribution of mutation spacing fit an exponential, albeit with substantial scatter. We now analyze 2658 additional mutants and confirm that doublets are enhanced dramatically relative to chance expectation. The spacing, frequency and pattern of spontaneous doublets and multiplets (domuplets) are examined as a function of age, tissue type, p53-deficiency and neoplasia in the new and combined data. The new and combined data confirm that the distribution of the spacing between mutations in doublets is non-random with the mutations more closely spaced than expected by chance (P < 0.0005; combined data), consistent with temporally coordinate (chronocoordinate) events. An exponential provides an excellent fit to the distribution (R2 = 0.98) and estimates that half of doublets have mutations separated by 120 nucleotides or less (the "half-life of mutation spacing"). We make several novel observations: (i) singlets and doublets show similar overall increases in frequency with age (ii) doublet frequency may be lower in the male germline, consistent with the generally reduced mutation frequency in the male germline (iii) doublet frequencies are elevated in somatic tissues of p53-deficient mice (Li-Fraumini cancer syndrome model; P = 0.005) and (iv) doublets and singlets in tumors from p53-deficient mice have a different mutation pattern (P = 0.007). The observations are consistent with chronocoordinate occurrence of spontaneous doublets and multiplets due to a transient error-prone condition and do not suggest a major role for the recently discovered Y family of error-prone polymerases. The enhancement of doublets in p53-deficient mice may contribute to cancer risk.

Spontaneous mutagenesis is enhanced in Apex heterozygous mice

Germ line DNA directs the development of the next generation and, as such, is profoundly different from somatic cell DNA. Spermatogenic cells obtained from young adult lacI transgenic mice display a lower spontaneous mutant frequency and greater in vitro base excision repair activity than somatic cells and tissues obtained from the same mice. However, spermatogenic cells from old lacI mice display a 10-fold higher mutant frequency. This increased spontaneous mutant frequency occurs coincidentally with decreased in vitro base excision repair activity for germ cell and testicular extracts that in turn corresponds to a decreased abundance of AP endonuclease. To directly test whether a genetic diminution of AP endonuclease results in increased spontaneous mutant frequencies in spermatogenic cell types, AP endonuclease heterozygous (Apex(+/-)) knockout mice were crossed with lacI transgenic mice. Spontaneous mutant frequencies were significantly elevated (approximately twofold) for liver and spleen obtained from 3-month-old Apex(+/-) lacI(+) mice compared to frequencies from Apex(+/+) lacI(+) littermates and were additionally elevated for somatic tissues from 9-month-old mice. Spermatogenic cells from 9-month-old Apex(+/-) lacI(+) mice were significantly elevated twofold compared to levels for 9-month-old Apex(+/+) lacI(+) control mice. These data indicate that diminution of AP endonuclease has a significant effect on spontaneous mutagenesis in somatic and germ line cells.

Spontaneous mutation in Big Blue mice from fetus to old age: tissue-specific time courses of mutation frequency but similar mutation types

Transgenic mouse mutation detection systems permit rapid determination of the frequency and type of mutations allowing direct examination of mutational markers for aging, neurodegeneration, and cancer. The Big Blue transgenic mouse mutation detection system was used to determine the frequency and nature of spontaneous mutations versus age in multiple tissue types. Nuclear DNA was extracted from whole fetus at 13.5 days postcoitus (dpc) and from six tissues postbirth (cerebellum, forebrain, thymus, liver, adipose tissue, and male germline) of Big Blue transgenic mice at four ages: 10 days and at 3, 10, and 25 months postbirth. Forty million total plaque-forming units (pfu) were screened. The time course of mutation frequency with age had a significantly different shape in different tissues (P < 10(-6)). By 13.5 dpc, the whole fetus mutation frequency had already started increasing from the theoretical zero at conception to a value that was about one-half the mid-adulthood (3-10 months) average. From 10 days to 3 months, mutation frequency increased significantly in liver (P = 0.007) and showed an increasing trend in cerebellum, forebrain, and thymus. From 3 to 10 months, there was no significant change in mutation frequency in any tissue examined. From 10 to 25 months, the mutation frequency increased significantly in liver (P < 10(-6)) and adipose tissue (P = 0.002), but not in the other tissues examined (cerebellum, forebrain, and male germline). It is of interest that the mutation frequency in the male germline is consistently the lowest, remaining essentially unchanged in old age. The spectrum of mutation types was unaltered with age, tissue type and gender, although, as previously reported, tandem GG-->TT mutations are tissue specific and show significant increases with age and certain hotspots (Buettner VL et al. [1999]: Environ Mol Mutagen 33:320-324; Hill KA et al. [2003]: Mutat Res 534:173-186). The spectrum of mutation types was generally the same for all tissue types, despite the tissue-specific increases in mutation frequency with age. These data provide a useful reference for future studies of endogenous and exogenous mutagenesis.

Spontaneous tandem-base mutations (TBM) show dramatic tissue, age, pattern and spectrum specificity

To supplement a previous analysis of spontaneous tandem-base mutations (TBM) in the lacI gene of Big Blue((R)) mice, 2658 additional mutants were sequenced from 13 tissues and 44 spontaneous TBM were identified (tripling the sample size). Previous findings were confirmed and generalized and several new observations were made. TBM differ from single and other double mutations in that TBM frequency varies dramatically with tissue type. In certain tissues, most notably male germ cells, no TBM are observed despite screening as many as 26 million plaque forming units. TBM are most frequent in kidney and liver (3.45 and 2x10(-6), respectively), accounting for 7.6 and 4.8% of all mutational events in kidney and liver, respectively. There is a trend for elevated TBM frequency in thymic lymphomas in p53-deficient mice. TBM are more frequent in old age in both liver and kidney. TBM differ from single mutations and other double mutations because they display a marked difference in pattern and dramatic tissue specificity for target sequence. Five of the 78 possible TBM outcomes comprise 79% of those observed, and mutations at GG/CC predominate. TBM in mice were compared with TBM found in human mutation databases. TBM are also rare in the human germline (one in 5133 germline mutations reported in five human mutation databases). In general, the types of somatic TBM are similar in mice and humans except for an excess of TG/CA to CA/TG TBM in humans (TBM related to ultraviolet light-induced skin cancer were excluded). TBM may be the result of unknown mechanisms that may have some similarities in mice and humans.

Spontaneous microdeletions and microinsertions in a transgenic mouse mutation detection system: analysis of age, tissue, and sequence specificity

A total of 3497 independent spontaneous mutations were examined using the Big Blue transgenic mouse mutation detection system. Base substitutions predominate, although 16% of somatic and germline mutations are microdeletions, microinsertions, or deletions combined with insertions. The pattern of microdeletions and microinsertions is similar in both the lacI transgene and the human p53 gene. Single-base deletions (D1) and insertions (I1) are evenly distributed in the lacI transgene, whereas microdeletions from 2 to 50 bp are clustered at two regions (bp 129-228 and 529-628). The pattern of microdeletions and microinsertions is similar between young (< or =3 months) and old (25 months) mice. Brain tissue has a paucity of deletions combined with insertions when compared with that of thymus and nine other tissues (P = 0.01). A 16-bp deletion at lacI base position 272 is a tissue-specific hotspot preferentially occurring in brain. Approximately 68 and 93% of D1 and I1, respectively, occur at mononucleotide repeats. The frequencies of D1 and I1 in mononucleotide repeats increase in an exponential manner with the length of the repeat. The lacI transgene shows similarity to the human p53 gene in the pattern of microdeletions and microinsertions and the size distribution of microdeletions.

Mutagenic properties of a nitrofuran, 7-methoxy-2-nitronaphtho[2, 1-b]furan (R7000), in lacI transgenic mice

The in vivo mutagenic properties of a 5-nitrofuran, the 7-methoxy-2-nitronaphtho[2,1-b]furan (R7000), already well known in bacteria, was evaluated in lacI transgenic mice (Big Blue). The mutation frequency was determined in various organs of i.p. - treated mice and the nature of induced mutations was determined for the target organs in which mutation induction was significant. It was found that R7000 is mutagenic in mice, although, on the basis of the number of induced mutants per unit mass in comparison with other known mutagenic chemicals, R7000 appears to be considerably less mutagenic in mice than in bacteria. The most affected organs, small intestine, caecum and colon organs belong to the digestive apparatus. The distribution of R7000-induced mutations in the lacI gene recovered from small intestine of transgenic mice was very similar to that which had been found in E. coli. The difference between mouse and E. coli in the R7000 induced mutational spectra are mainly in the proportion of single base frameshifts versus base substitutions. Since R7000 induced mutations seemed to arise in the population of stem cells and that the stem cells are important for carcinogenesis, our results are compatible with a possible carcinogenic effect of R7000 and other nitrofurans.

High plating density improves Big Blue system efficiency without loss of sensitivity

To increase efficiency in the Big Blue system, the plating density was increased from 15000 to 30000 or 45000 plaque forming units (pfus) per plate by increasing the density of the E. coli lawn and decreasing individual plaque size. Small plaque size ensured minimal overlap of the plaques. Liver from one 3- and one 25-month-old mouse (low and high mutation frequencies, respectively) was analyzed and neither plating density nor plaque size affected mutant/mutation frequency and pattern. The color intensity of particular mutant plaques was not affected by plaque size or plating density. Optimal sensitivity is achieved by sequencing mutants to calculate the mutation frequency from the mutant frequency and to identify altered patterns of mutation. Detailed effort and cost accounting of the Big Blue system (including mouse handling, DNA extraction, plaque screening, plaque purification, and DNA sequencing) reveals that one-quarter of the total effort is devoted to plating and screening of plates. This effort is reduced two fold with high plating density. The total cost of the Big Blue system is reduced by 17%. The total cost of the High Plating Density Big Blue system is now only 12% more costly than a selectable assay and offers an extensively validated system with a large mutation database representing a decade of effort.