Neurolaryngology: past, present, and future

[The possibilities for the restoration of the laryngeal function: the current state-of-the-art]

The restoration of the functional competence of the larynx following bilateral laryngeal nerve damage and vocal fold paralysis is a serious challenge for the surgeon that has thus far no satisfactory solution. Physiological re-innervation that occurs naturally with time is non-selective and, in the majority of the cases, leads to synkinesis. Laryngeal pacing achieved with the application of the implantable microchips appears to be a promising approach. The animal experiments have demonstrated the possibility of successful restoration of all the functions of the larynx by means of laryngeal pacing but simultaneously revealed a number of technical issues that have to be addressed if the further progress in this field is to be achieved including the choice of the proper materials for implantation, solution of problems pertaining to the neuromuscular mapping during pacer implantation, etc.). The results of the first prospective clinical trial involving the human patients gave evidence suggesting that the laryngeal electrostimulation technology is both safe and efficient. Nevertheless, further investigations and modification of the method are needed before it can be recommended for the wider application in the routine clinical practice.

Recurrent Laryngeal Nerve Regeneration through a Silicone Tube Produces Reinnervation without Vocal Fold Mobility in Rats

Objectives:

We established an animal model of recurrent laryngeal nerve reinnervation with persistent vocal fold immobility following recurrent laryngeal nerve injury.

Methods:

In 36 rats, the left recurrent laryngeal nerve was transected and the stumps were abutted in a silicone tube with a 1-mm interspace, facilitating regeneration. The mobility of the vocal folds was examined endoscopically 5, 10, and 15 weeks later. Electromyography of the thyroarytenoid muscle was performed. Reinnervation was assessed by means of a quantitative immunohistologic evaluation with anti-neurofilament antibody in the nerve both proximal and distal to the silicone tube. The atrophy of the thyroarytenoid muscle was assessed histologically.

Results:

We observed that all animals had a fixed left vocal fold throughout the study. The average neurofilament expression in the nerve both distal and proximal to the silicone tube, the muscle area, and the amplitude of the compound muscle action potential recorded from the thyroarytenoid muscle on the treated side increased significantly (p < 0.05) over time, demonstrating regeneration through the silicone tube.

Conclusions:

Recurrent laryngeal nerve regeneration through a silicone tube produced reinnervation without vocal fold mobility in rats. The efficacy of new laryngeal reinnervation treatments can be assessed with this model.

Laryngeal pacing for bilateral vocal fold immobility

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

This article reviews literature on the scientific background of functional electric stimulation of the immobile larynx, the status of animal pacing trials, and first clinical attempts to establish laryngeal pacing.

RECENT FINDINGS

Impaired vocal fold motion is seen following recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis and is a result of inadequate or synkinetic reinnervation. The term vocal fold paralysis should only be used after verification using laryngeal electromyography. A variety of animal trials give clear evidence supporting the feasibility of laryngeal pacing as a new dynamic approach for the rehabilitation of patients with bilateral vocal fold motion impairment. Laryngeal pacing has become clinically applicable with minimal invasive electrode insertion and newly designed stimulation circuits.

SUMMARY

Laryngeal pacing seems to be on the right path to open up a dynamic rehabilitation of the bilaterally motion-impaired larynx.

Granulomatous Inflammation and Nerve Necrosis in a Case of Apparent Idiopathic Vocal Fold Paralysis: Report of a Case

OBJECTIVES

We will present clinical and pathologic findings of the recurrent laryngeal nerve of a 54-year-old man with apparent idiopathic vocal fold paralysis and discuss clinical and scientific implications of these findings.

STUDY DESIGN

Our design is in the format of a case report with emphasis on the clinical, intraoperative, histologic, and neuropathologic findings, followed by a discussion of contemporary theories of idiopathic unilateral vocal fold immobility and the implications of our findings.

METHODS

A 54-year-old man presented with a 2-year history of unilateral vocal fold motion impairment (VFMI) after an upper respiratory infection. Radiographic and laboratory data revealed no organic cause. The patient clinically appeared to have a classical unilateral vocal fold paralysis and had previously undergone collagen injection and medialization thyroplasty, each with only temporary improvement of voice. We performed ansa cervicalis-recurrent laryngeal nerve anastomosis.

RESULTS

Intraoperative dissection revealed an indurated and thickened section of nerve approximately 15 mm in length, located at the beginning of the intralaryngeal segment, near the cricothyroid joint. Segments of this nerve were submitted for histologic evaluation, revealing necrosis with granulomatous inflammation. Postoperative electromyography and videostrobolaryngoscopy were consistent with successful reinnervation from the ansa procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

The diagnosis of "idiopathic VFMI" likely represents a number of distinct pathologic entities. This case highlights our lack of understanding of idiopathic VFMI and raises many important questions regarding our current theories of this diagnosis. The clinical and pathologic implications are discussed, and continued investigation is recommended.

Vocal cord paralysis, synkinesis and vocal fold motion impairment

Felix Semon's 'laws' of vocal cord paralysis were conceived over a century ago, based on the simple concept that abductor function of the recurrent laryngeal nerve was more vulnerable than adductor function. It is now clear that the neuromuscular pathology of laryngeal innervation is much more complex. Whether the nerve has been cut, crushed, stretched, cauterized or otherwise injured, it is seldom completely transected. There might be no detectable vocal cord movement at laryngoscopy, yet, electromyography usually shows at least some activity because of incomplete denervation and/or developing synkinesis. Electrical silence hardly ever persists forever. Disordered vocal fold movement following nerve injury appears to depend on laryngeal synkinesis with disorganized neuromuscular function caused by misdirected regeneration and aberrant reinnervation, sometimes by adjacent nerves. The severity of the injury, abnormal random reinnervation, scar tissue formation and nerve growth-stimulating and inhibiting factors influence the final position of the vocal fold. For a better understanding of neurolaryngological disorders it is no longer sufficient to think merely in terms of 'vocal cord paralysis'.