Diagnostic dilemma. The goiter

Need for an Individualized and Aggressive Management of Multinodular Goiters of Endemic Zones by Specially Trained Surgeons: Experience in Western Nepal

BACKGROUND

The goals of the present study were to explore the presentation of multinodular goiter (MNG) and solitary thyroid nodules (STN) in the sub-Himalayan belt, including the risk of malignancy, and to evaluate whether specialized surgeon training in endocrine surgery has an effect on reducing complications.

METHODS

This retrospective study (1998-2003) analyzed 624 patients with thyroid disorders seen in the thyroid clinic of a tertiary care hospital in western Nepal. The findings included 67.7% (n = 423: euthyroid, 297, toxic, 126) multinodular goiters (MNG) and 18.5% (n = 116) STN. Rest of patients of other thyroid disorders were excluded from the study. Ultrasonography and fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) were the available diagnostic adjuncts. To evaluate the role of surgeon training, outcomes were compared between patients cared for by surgeons specially trained in endocrine surgery and those who were not. Prognostic markers indicated aggressiveness of cancers.

RESULTS

Of the 539 MNG and STN patients in this series, 236 underwent operation. Of these, 25.7% (139/539) were toxic, and 11.31% had associated carcinoma. Aggressive cancers, like poorly differentiated (4.9%) and anaplastic types (18%), were more common than in series of patients from iodine-sufficient regions. Patients 40-55 years of age were more likely to have toxicity, and those > 60 years of age were more likely to have aggressive cancers. Postoperative complication rates were lower in the group treated by surgeons who had special training in endocrine surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a higher incidence of toxicity and malignancy in MNG in an endemic goiter zone. The limited diagnostic and therapeutic facilities in the region under study warrant a high degree of clinical suspicion and judgment, sound knowledge of thyroid physiology, thorough interpretation of hormone test results, and meticulous surgical techniques. The treatment must be individualized with consideration of humanitarian and socioeconomic factors, without compromising the quality of care and its long-term consequences. Aggressive management of malignancy and toxicity with total thyroidectomy is needed as primary therapy in many instances. However, subtotal excision is more useful in carefully selected cases with a small remnant. Specialized training in thyroid surgery appears to be valuable in reducing complications.

A prospective study of thyroid nodular disease in children and adolescents in western Poland from 1996 to 2000 and the incidence of thyroid carcinoma relative to iodine deficiency and the Chernobyl disaster

BACKGROUND

In Poland, where soil is deficient in iodine, supplementation of iodine was introduced in 1935, discontinued in 1980, and then re-introduced in 1997. One of the effects of inadequate iodine intake, prior to 1997, was an increase in the prevalence of thyroid nodular disease (TND) in children. Chernobyl, located in the neighbouring country of Ukraine, suffered a catastrophic nuclear explosion in April 1986.

PROCEDURE

A total of 411 children with TND (an incidence of 7.53/100,000) were diagnosed and registered in western Poland between 1996 and 2000 and further evaluated as a population-based study.

RESULTS

Based on the patient's clinical status, ultrasound examination, scintiscan, laboratory tests, cytology and the family history, many of the patients qualified for surgery and, as a result, histopathologic data were obtained from 155 of the 411 patients operated on to date (37.7% of all TND). Thyroid carcinoma was detected in 37 of the operated children, i.e. 23.9% or 9.0% of all children with TND with a median incidence of 0.68/100,000. Papillary carcinoma was the predominant histologic type (26-70.3%) compared to follicular carcinoma (10-27.0%) and medullary carcinoma (1-2.7%). Retrospective analysis of the figures for the 23 years (1972-1995) showed that in that period a total of 23 thyroid carcinomas were registered. However, only 12 of these were detected in the 20-year period between 1972 and 1991, none in the years 1992-1993 and, significantly, 11 from 1994 to 1995.

CONCLUSIONS

Thyroid carcinoma appears to be an ongoing and increasing problem in the children and adolescents of our region, and it is developing more intensively when compared, both to other parts of Poland and to previous statistics (2000 vs. 1985; P<0.002). Iodine deficiency and radiation resulting from the Chernobyl disaster might be important risk factors in the development of thyroid carcinoma in the young population analysed in our region in the period since 1994. The high percentage of follicular carcinoma and follicular adenoma with an undetermined prognosis (19 out of 46) indicates that the long-term iodine deficiency in our region may be more significant in the pathogenesis of malignant transformation than has previously been postulated.

The Sardinian Autoimmunity Study: 3. Studies on circulating antithyroid antibodies in Sardinian schoolchildren: relationship to goiter prevalence and thyroid function

The relationship among iodine intake, goiter prevalence, and thyroid autoimmunity remains controversial. In the present article, we report the prevalence of antithyroid antibodies (ATA) in relation to iodine intake, frequency of goiter, and thyroid function in a large group of Sardinian schoolchildren living in areas with borderline iodine sufficiency, or mild to moderate iodine deficiency. A total of 8,040 schoolchildren (4,194 males, 3,846 females, ages 6-15 years) from 29 communities were examined between 1986-1994. Thyroid size was assessed by palpation, according to the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) criteria. In all cases antimicrosomal (MAb) or antithyroid peroxidase antibodies (TPOAb) and thyrotropin (TSH) were assayed. Urinary iodine was determined in a subgroup of 820 children. ATA was detected in 235 (2.92%) sera (88 males, 2.12%; 147 females, 3.82%; chi2 = 20.41, p < 0.0001). ATA prevalence ranged between 0.0%-7.3% in the 29 communities without any geographical correlation with goiter prevalence and urinary iodine excretion. However, ATA was more frequently detected in goitrous children, especially in females. The presence of ATA was not age-dependent in males, whereas a significant increase of ATA was observed in females older than 11 years of age. Seventy-seven (0.96%) children showed borderline to slightly increased serum TSH (>5.2-32 mU/L). Increased serum TSH concentration was more frequently found in children with ATA, especially at higher titers. In summary, our study in Sardinian schoolchildren indicates: (1) ATA display geographical heterogeneity, which seems to be unrelated to goiter prevalence and/or to iodine supply; (2) ATA are more frequently detected in females older than 11 years of age, suggesting that puberty has a role in determining the predominance in females of thyroid autoimmunity; (3) although most goitrous children are ATA-negative, the prevalence of ATA is increased in children with enlarged glands; (4) ATA is associated with an increased prevalence of subclinical hypothyroidism.

The diagnosis of diffuse goitre by ultrasound imaging in children

In order to find an easy and accurate procedure for diagnosis of diffuse goitre in children, we examined 50 patients with diffuse goitre using fine needle aspiration biopsy cytology, thyroid antibody detection, thyroid hormone analysis and ultrasound imaging. In the meantime, 109 healthy children (control) were examined by ultrasound imaging. The results showed that thyroid imaging in health children was a smooth echo pattern with stronger homogenous echogram than surrounding muscle tissues. The patients with diffuse goitre showed an abnormally enlarged thyroid volume. In 22 (84.6%) of 26 children with chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis, a varied patch hypoechogenicity was found, of whom 18 (81.8%) had positive results of antibody testing. On the contrary, echo-pattern was normal in 17 (70.8%) of 24 patients with diffuse thyroid proliferation and only the remainder (7/24, 29.1%) had abnormal echo-pattern as well as elevated auto-antibody titers, of whom 2 were confirmed as chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis by a repeat fine needle aspiration biopsy 1 year later. By using combined ultrasound imaging and antibody determination, 92% of the cases with chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis could be diagnosed. Our study suggests that ultrasonic imaging is an easy, non-invasive, reproducible and effective procedure in the differential diagnosis of chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis in children.

Childhood goitre in Saudi Arabia

Thirty-two Saudi children (aged 1.5-14 years) with goitre were seen over a 6.5-year period in a paediatric endocrinology clinic. There was a female to male ratio of 1.9:1. Of these, 27 (84.3%) had diffuse thyroid enlargement and five (15.7%) nodular goitre. The commonest causes were dyshormonogenesis (37.5%) followed by Hashimoto's thyroiditis (34.4%). Three boys and one girl had Graves' disease. There were three (9.4%) with simple goitre and one case each of iodine deficiency goitre and tuberculous thyroiditis. Further study of the prevalence and causes of goitre, including iodine deficiency goitre, in Saudi Arabia is suggested.

Goitre in southern Chinese children in Hong Kong

In a 9-year retrospective review of goitre in Chinese children in Hong Kong, 84 children and adolescents were identified. There was a female predominance with a male:female ratio of 1:5.5. The majority of patients (95%) were found to have diffuse enlargement of the thyroid gland. Forty-nine were found to have Graves' disease. The mean age of presentation of patients with Graves' disease was 11.34 years. Forty-three of them were found to have thyroid autoantibodies. Only two cases of autoimmune thyroiditis with thyroid autoantibodies were diagnosed. The other causes of goitre include simple colloid goitre, multinodular goitre and suppurative thyroiditis. The spectrum of disease causing goitre in Chinese children is thus quite different from that reported in Caucasian children in developed countries. Further studies are necessary to define the genetic or environmental factors resulting in the observed differences.