Studies on the antigenic structure of Bacteroides nodosus

Investigation of immunity in sheep following footrot infection and vaccination

Ovine footrot is a major disease affecting sheep welfare and production. The anaerobic Gram-negative bacterium Dichelobacter nodosus is the essential transmitting agent. Monovalent or bivalent vaccines induce high levels of D. nodosus antibodies and are the basis of several successful footrot treatment, control and eradication programs. Due to the rapid rate of disease transmission within a flock, the presence of therapeutic vaccination non-responders has major implications for a control program. The aim of this study was to assess the immunological basis of a therapeutic vaccination non-response. Sheep (n=120) were infected with D. nodosus in an artificial pen challenge. Once disease had established, animals were vaccinated with a serogroup specific D. nodosus fimbrial vaccine. Based on the response to therapeutic vaccination, animals were allocated into one of three groups: (i) TVNR where disease persisted despite vaccination (ii) non-diseased, where disease never established and (iii) TVR, where disease was established but resolved with vaccination. Factors related to both the innate and adaptive immune pathways were assessed. These included antigen-specific serum antibodies, interferon-γ, interleukin-10, proliferation of lymphocyte subsets and phagocytic activity of leukocytes. There was no significant difference between the three groups of sheep for any of these parameters. All three groups of sheep produced antibody in excess of a previously published minimum antibody titre required for protection. Opsonising activity in sera from the three groups of sheep was also not significantly different and phagocytic cells from sheep from all three groups were able to destroy D. nodosus intracellularly. These findings show that the measured systemic adaptive and innate immune responses were unlikely to be the cause of a therapeutic vaccination non-response. They also show that the accepted minimum protective titre may be incorrect and may need further examination.

Protection of sheep against experimental footrot by vaccination with pili purified fromBacteroidesnodosus

Merino sheep vaccinated with either whole Bacteroides nodosus organisms, a crude surface antigen preparation or highly purified pili (>99% homogeneity) in oil adjuvant, developed significant resistance to artificial footrot infection when compared with unvaccinated control sheep inoculated with saline-in-oil emulsion (Freund;s incomplete adjuvant) alone. The pili-vaccinated sheep generally had higher K-agglutinating antibody titres than sheep vaccinated with whole B. nodosus. These results confirmed the role of B. nodosus pilus protein both as a protective antigen and the K-agglutinogen. Vaccines prepared with Freund;s incomplete adjuvant containing either purified pili, crude pili or B. nodosus whole cells did not produce significantly different injection-site reactions.

Duration of resistance to experimental footrot infection in Romney and Merino sheep vaccinated withBacteroides nodosusoil adjuvant vaccine

Groups of 10-12 Romney and Merino wethers were challenged simultaneously with homologous experimental footrot infection after having received the second of 2 doses of Bacteroides nodosus (strain 198) vaccine 0, 4, 8, 12, 16 and 20 weeks previously. Inoculations were carried out 28 days apart and unvaccinated sheep of both breeds were challenged as controls. Most Romneys that had been vaccinated up to 16 weeks prior to challenge were resistant to footrot whereas 8 of 10 controls were susceptible. This resistance was lost by about 20 weeks after vaccination. By contrast, protection against challenge in vaccinated Merinos lasted only about 4-5 weeks, although residual benefits of vaccination were apparent after longer intervals from the reduced number and severity of foot lesions among vaccinates compared with controls. Agglutinin titres, which did not differ markedly after similar intervals between Romneys and Merinos, reached maximum levels between 4 and 8 weeks after the second vaccine dose and subsequently declined. Although peak titres were generally recorded at the time of maximum protection in Merinos, the relationship between agglutinin levels and resistance in the Romneys was ill-defined.

Antigenic competition in a multivalent foot rot vaccine

The antigenic competition that occurs when pilus antigens of different serogroups are combined in multivalent vaccines for foot rot has been investigated using recombinant pilus antigens. Our prototype vaccine contains pili from nine serogroups of Dichelobacter nodosus which are expressed in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Sheep inoculated with this multivalent vaccine were not as well protected against foot rot as those given the monovalent vaccine. Levels of agglutinating and total antibody specific for any particular pili serogroup were found to be significantly reduced in sheep vaccinated with six or more closely related pili. This effect was more pronounced for agglutinating antibody, which is thought to mediate protection, but was also observed with total antibody levels measured by ELISA. The antigenic competition was not associated with the total antigen load as a tenfold higher dose of monovalent pili induced high titres of antibody. Furthermore, distributing the vaccine to four sites, each draining to a different lymph node, failed to overcome the competition. Experiments with mixtures of monospecific sera indicate that the phenomenon is unlikely to be due to blocking of serogroup-specific protective antibodies by an excess of cross-reactive non-protective antibody elicited by heterologous pili.

The effects of antigenic competition on the efficacy of multivalent footrot vaccines

A multivalent footrot vaccine has been developed, containing pilus antigens produced in recombinant Pseudomonas aeruginosa and representing all nine serogroups of Dichelobacter (Bacteroides) nodosus commonly recognised in the field. The responses of sheep to the multivalent vaccine have been compared with those to monovalent vaccines representing only a single serogroup. Antigenic competition between serogroups occurred in sheep immunised with the multivalent formation, but high levels of protection were still achieved. The study showed that in multivalent footrot vaccines, antigenic competition is predominantly due to the presence of a family of immunologically-related pilus antigens rather than to interference by extraneous proteins.

Cross-protective immunity and the serological classification system for Bacteroides nodosus

The relationship between the serological classification system for serogroup B and for serogroup H of Bacteroides nodosus and cross-protection between subgroups within these serogroups was examined. Protection against ovine footrot following vaccination was achieved against other subgroup strains provided sufficient cross-reactive antibody was induced by shared pilus antigens. Within serogroup B, better cross-protection against one subgroup was obtained with a pili vaccine than a whole cell vaccine which correlated with higher pilus antibody titres induced by the former. For serogroup H, a lack of cross-protection and serological reactivity between subgroups was demonstrated, which indicates that the prototype strain of subgroup H2 should be designated a new serogroup.

Monoclonal antibodies defining immunogenic regions of pili from Bacteroides nodosus strains 198 (A1), 265 (H1) and 336 (F1)

A total of 17 monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) were used to analyse the antigenic structure of pilus protein from three serogroups of Bacteroides nodosus. The four MoAb which agglutinated pili were serogroup (and subgroup) specific, and the agglutinating epitope was present on the pili monomer and dependent on the intra-chain disulfide bond. Non-agglutinating MoAb identified two further non-linear and serogroup-restricted epitopes on strain 198 (A1) pili and two linear epitopes on 336 (F1) and 265 (H1) pili. Three MoAb cross-reacted with pili from six of the eight major serogroups and recognized an epitope in the N-terminal region of the molecule. This panel of MoAb has therefore identified at least four epitopes on pilus protein and will facilitate serotopic analyses of the immunogenicity of each epitope in sheep during vaccination against footrot.

Nucleotide sequence of the gene encoding the two-subunit pilin of Bacteroides nodosus 265

The nucleotide sequence of the gene encoding pilin from Bacteroides nodosus 265 has been determined. The pilin is encoded by a single-copy gene, from which can be predicted a prepilin comprising a single protein chain of Mr 16,637. The prepilin sequence differs in several respects from the mature protein sequence. Seven additional N-terminal amino acid residues are present in prepilin, whereas residue 8, phenylalanine, undergoes posttranslational modification to become the N-methylated amino-terminal residue of mature pilin. In addition, further processing occurs through internal cleavage to produce two noncovalently linked subunits characteristic of pilins from serogroup H of B. nodosus, of which strain 265 is a member. The position of cleavage has been identified between alanine residues at positions 72 and 73 of the mature 149-residue pilin protein. The predicted pilin sequence of B. nodosus 265 shows extensive N-terminal amino acid sequence homology with other pilins of the N-methylphenylalanine type. In addition this sequence also shows homology with these N-methylphenylalanine-type pilins in the C-terminal region of the molecule, especially with pilin from Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAK.

Variation in the structural subunit and basal protein antigens of Bacteroides nodosus fimbriae

The fimbriae of Bacteroides nodosus play a major role in protective immunity against ovine footrot and are an important determinant in the serological classification system that divides field isolates into at least eight serogroups and 16 serotypes. Purified fimbriae contain two polypeptide antigens, the structural subunit of the fimbrial strand (molecular weight about 17,000) and a basal protein (molecular weight about 80,000), both of which exhibit structural variation. Fimbriae were prepared from all prototype strains, as well as from a number of other isolates representative of each of the B. nodosus serotypes, and analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Substantial variation was observed in the electrophoretic mobility of the fimbrial subunits from the prototypes of each of the eight serogroups. With the exception of serogroup H, which is an unusual case, the apparent molecular weights of the fimbrial subunits ranged from about 16,500 in serogroup D to 19,000 in serogroup F (serotype 1); in serogroup A, B, C and E, the apparent molecular weights were clustered in the range of 17,000 to 17,500, whereas serogroup G was about 18,500. Serogroup H fimbriae appeared to consist of two smaller polypeptides, which in the prototype (H1) had apparent molecular weights of about 6,000 and 10,000 and which seem to have arisen as a consequence of an internal proteolytic nick in the original subunit. Electrophoretic variation in the fimbrial subunit was also observed between different serotypes, although with the exceptions of serogroups F and H, this was not as pronounced as between the serogroups. Examination of a number of isolates classified within the same serotypes showed that some variation, although minor, also occurred at this level. The basal antigen exhibited significant variation at all levels of the serotypic hierarchy in a manner apparently unrelated to the classification system. Among the range of isolates examined, the apparent molecular weight of this antigen varied from about 77,000 to 88,000.

Cross-protection from Bacteroides nodosus vaccines and the interaction of pili and adjuvants

The effects of vaccination of Merino sheep with the purified pili or the whole cells of Bacteroides nodosus strain 198, either in oil or alum-oil adjuvant, on the severity of foot-rot induced with the homologous strain (198) and a heterologous strain (217) were determined in a field experiment, on flood irrigated pasture. The efficacy of the whole cell vaccines was comparable to that of purified pili vaccines, against homologous challenge, when both had a similar content of pilus antigen although the purified pili vaccines induced significantly greater homologous pilus agglutinating antibody titres than the whole cell vaccines. However, against heterologous challenge, the whole cell vaccines in oil (CO) or alum-oil (CAO) provided significantly greater protection than a purified pili-in-oil (PPO) vaccine, the number of severely affected feet in sheep vaccinated with PPO being similar to that of the unvaccinated group. The group vaccinated with purified pili in alum-oil (PPAO) was intermediate between these two extremes. The superior performance of the PPAO in comparison to the PPO vaccine, against heterologous challenge, was associated with significantly higher mean ELISA titres to the outer membrane complex. Western blot analyses implicated a role in cross-protection for outer membrane proteins, in particular a protein Mr 78,000. The PPO vaccine produced fewer, smaller and less persistent vaccination reactions at the inoculation sites than did the other vaccines. Bodyweight gains in the period prior to challenge were much lower for the groups vaccinated with CO and CAO than for the controls and those vaccinated with purified pili, due presumably to the larger vaccination reactions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Isolation and characterization of Bacteroides nodosus fimbriae: structural subunit and basal protein antigens

We examined the isolation of fimbriae from Bacteroides nodosus. It was found that the best preparations were obtained from the supernatant of washed cells cultured on solid medium, from which fimbriae could be recovered in high yield and purity by a simple one-step procedure. Analysis of such preparations by sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis showed that greater than 98% of the protein consisted of fimbrial structural subunits whose molecular weight was ca. 17,000. These preparations also usually exhibited minor contamination with a polypeptide of ca. 80,000 molecular weight, as well as trace amounts of lipopolysaccharide. Attempts to release additional fimbriae by the traditional means of subjecting the bacterial cells to physical stress, such as shearing or heating, resulted primarily in an increase in the level of contamination, without significant gain in the yield of fimbriae. Removal of the 80,000-dalton component could not be achieved by any of a variety of techniques normally used in fimbriae purification, including isoelectric precipitation, MgCl2 precipitation, and CsCl gradient ultracentrifugation, implying a direct physical association with the fimbrial strand. Electron micrographs of fractions containing this protein show cap-shaped structures attached to the ends of what appeared to be fimbrial stubs. These observations suggest that the 80,000-dalton polypeptide may actually constitute the basal attachment site which anchors the fimbria to the outer membrane, analogous to a similar protein recently described in enterotoxigenic strains of Escherichia coli. In B. nodosus, this 80,000-dalton protein is a major surface antigen, and like the fimbrial subunit, exhibited variation in electrophoretic mobility between serotypically different isolates.

Cloning and expression in Escherichia coli of the gene encoding the structural subunit of Bacteroides nodosus fimbriae

Bacteroides nodosus is the primary causative agent of ovine foot rot. Virulent isolates of this bacterium contain fimbriae which appear to play a major role in both infectivity and protective immunity. This paper presents the cloning and expression in Escherichia coli of the gene encoding the structural subunit of the fimbriae of B. nodosus. Total DNA was isolated from B. nodosus VCS 1001 (serogroup A), digested with HindIII, and inserted into the positive-selection vector pTR262. Recombinant E. coli clones were screened directly with anti-fimbrial antiserum by using a colony immunoassay. Several positive colonies were identified, each of which contained the same 5.5-kilobase HindIII insert. The prototype has been designated pBA101. Some clones also contained additional flanking sequences from the B. nodosus genome. Western transfer analyses verified that the positive clones were producing the B. nodosus fimbrial structural subunit, molecular weight ca. 17,500. The level of expression of the antigen in E. coli was comparable to that in B. nodosus itself and was unaffected by the insertion site or orientation of the cloned fragment, indicating that synthesis was being directed from an internal promoter. Restriction mapping and deletion analyses localized the fimbrial subunit gene to the vicinity of a PvuII site near the central region of the original HindIII insert. The expressed antigen was located in the membrane-cell wall fraction and may be exposed on the surface of the recombinant E. coli cells.

Analysis of the outer membrane proteins of Bacteroides nodosus, the causal organism of ovine footrot

Examination by SDS-PAGE of lithium acetate extracts of several strains of depiliated Bacteroides nodosus revealed 6 major outer membrane proteins (including pilin). The 5 membrane proteins exhibited approximate molecular weights of 75000, 50000, 38000, 34500 and 26500 whereas pilin had a MW of 17500 for the majority of strains. All proteins were accessible to lactoperoxidase-catalysed iodination and proteins 1, 2 and 5 were shown to be glycoproteins. Several attempts to isolate individual OMC proteins in pure form by selective solubilization and gel filtration were unsuccessful, but electroelution of individual outer membrane complex proteins resolved by SDS-PAGE provided sufficient quantities of antigen for immunization of sheep and for immunochemical analysis.

Classification of Bacteroides nodosus by agglutination tests

One thousand two hundred and sixty seven isolates of Bacteroides nodosus from 292 sheep in 58 flocks were examined. Of these, 1260 could be classified by slide agglutination into 8 serogroups designated A to H. Up to 6 serogroups were detected in individual flocks, with up to 4 serogroups being detected in a single foot. Of the 292 sheep examined, 38 (13%) carried mixed serogroup infections. Determination of the range of serological types infecting a flock frequently required the examination of a number of isolates from each of a number of sheep. Cross-tube agglutination tests carried out on 44 isolates and their antiserums indicated that members of some serogroups could be divisible into subgroups or serotypes. These results suggested that 16 or more serotypes of B. nodosus might exist. The nature of the antigens responsible for both slide and tube agglutination reactions needs to be determined.