Résultats à long terme des greffes cortico-spongieuses non vascularisées pour pseudarthrose du scaphoïde carpien

Long-term clinical and radiological results after scaphoid non-union treatment: a retrospective study about 60 cases

PURPOSE

Scaphoid non-union treatment remains nonconsensual and is based on vascularized or non-vascularized bone grafting. This study aimed to evaluate with a long follow-up the functional, clinical, and radiological outcomes, reported complications and reoperations and studied non-union treatment prognostic factors.

METHODS

Patients who had undergone bone graft surgery for scaphoid non-union were retrospectively reviewed. The evaluated outcomes were pain, qDASH, PRWE and MWS scores, active range of motion, grip strength, union rate, scapholunate angle, carpal height, and presence of arthrosis. Complications and reinterventions were also reported.

RESULTS

This study included 60 scaphoid non-union treatments with a mean follow-up of 7.7 (1.5-20.3) years. Twenty (33.3%) non-unions were located at the proximal pole, including 6 (10%) with preoperative avascular necrosis (AVN). Union occurred in 51 patients (85%). The functional, clinical, and radiological results were good. The complication rate was 21.3% and the reintervention rate was 16.7%. Subgroup union rate analysis found no difference if the non-union is localized in the proximal pole or if there is AVN.

CONCLUSION

With a representative sample of the population and a long follow-up, we have found a good union rate, clinical and functional results regardless of the treatment method chosen. Scaphoid non-union treatment is still controversial and more studies are needed to accurate indications of each graft according to the patient and non-union characteristics.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

Retrospective cohort study.

Success of scaphoid nonunion surgery is independent of proximal pole vascularity

We followed 35 consecutive patients with scaphoid nonunions in a prospective longitudinal registry. All nonunions were treated with curettage, non-vascularized autogenous grafting and headless screw fixation. Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging, intraoperative bleeding points and histopathological analysis of cancellous bone in the proximal pole were recorded as measures of viability. Healing was categorized as ≥50% bony bridging on computed tomographic images in the plane of the scaphoid. Nine of 23 proximal poles demonstrated ischaemia on magnetic resonance imaging but none were interpreted as infarcted. Twenty-eight of 33 were found to have impaired vascularity as assessed by intraoperative bleeding. Fourteen of 32 demonstrated ≥50% trabecular necrosis and four of 33 demonstrated ≥50% tissue necrosis on histopathological analysis. Thirty of 33 demonstrated focal or robust remodelling activity. Despite pathological evidence of impaired vascularity in over half of the patients, 33 of the 35 scaphoids had healed by 12 weeks. We conclude that proximal pole infarction is decidedly rare and that vascularized bone grafting is seldom required.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Vascularized bone graft pedicled on the volar carpal artery from the volar distal radius as primary procedure for scaphoid non-union

INTRODUCTION

The treatment of scaphoid non-union with non-vascularized bone graft leads to non-union in 10 to 20% of cases and up to 50% in case of proximal pole necrosis. Vascularized bone graft improves consolidation rates, but is generally restricted to secondary scaphoid non-union.

HYPOTHESIS

This study assessed the value of a primary vascularized bone graft pedicled on the transverse volar carpal artery from the volar aspect of the distal radius as donor site.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This retrospective study included 111 cases of vascularized bone graft for scaphoid non-union as primary procedure in 73 cases and secondarily in 38. The procedures were performed through a single incision.

RESULTS

Mean delay before surgery was 25.5 and 33 months respectively, with union rates of 96% and 89.5%. Results showed improvement in both groups, but were better in primary surgery in terms of range of motion, strength, pain, function, satisfaction and return to work. There were more complications with secondary surgery.

DISCUSSION

All reports agree that union is better with vascularized bone graft. This technique performed as a day of admission surgery through a single incision under locoregional anesthesia seems feasible as a primary intervention.

[Long-term results of surgical treatment of scaphoid non union: influence of the correction of dorsal intercalated segment instability]

OBJECTIVES

The publications dealing with scaphoid non-union emphasize importance of correction of the Dorsal Intercalated Segment Instability (DISI) to achieve good functional results and to prevent osteoarthritis. The purpose of this study was to assess, over 10 years follow-up, the functional outcomes of 25 patients with scaphoid non-union surgery. X-ray and DISI deformity were assessed.

METHODS

Between 1994 and 1998, 53 patients underwent surgery for scaphoid non-union. Over 10 years follow-up, functional evaluation based on pain, QuickDASH and Mayo Wrist Score was performed, and a physical examination including mobility, strength and pain on the region of the scaphoid. Outcomes on X-rays were assessed by searching osteoarthritis damages and by measuring carpal height index and intracarpal angles.

RESULTS

Eight patients had pain on the scaphotrapeziotrapezoidal joint without degenerative lesions on radiography. Compared to other patients, they had worse functional results, decrease of scapholunate angle, decrease of the DISI and increase of carpal height.

CONCLUSIONS

The correction of the DISI is not always associated with good functional results. Although there were no osteoarthritic changes on the radiography, residual pain may be related to affection of the scapho-trapezo-trapezoidal joint. Surgical treatment with osteotomy of the scaphoid seems to be dangerous because of the moderate impact on function for these patients.