Indications for surgical treatment in small cell carcinoma of the lung

Surgical Resection in the Treatment of Stages I-II of Small Cell Lung Carcinoma (SCLC)

From 1981 to 1986, 17 patients with resected small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) staged as I or II according to the new TNM classification were recruited for a prospective study to evaluate the effctiveness of surgery and postoperative chemotherapy (plus locoregional radiotherapy only when a nonradical resection was accomplished) in the treatment of early stages of the disease. Six patients received full protocol chemotherapy (6 courses) and 8 a mean of 79.1% of the planned courses. Three patients received non adjuvant treatment. Locoregional radiotherapy for residual disease was administered in 2 cases. One patient died for myelosuppression due to chemotherapy and 10 for recurrences of cancer, all within the 20th postoperative month. Metastases accounted 80% of overall recurrences. Six patients were alive and tumor-free at 18, 22, 39, 44, 47 and 51 months from resection. Actuarial observed 3-year survival was 32%.

Can surgery improve local control in small cell lung cancer?

Current therapy for small cell lung cancer (SCLC) consists of chemotherapy with or without radiotherapy. Radiotherapy is generally accepted as an essential treatment component of limited stage disease. However, the local failure rate after chemo- and radiotherapy is still high and ranges from 30 to 70%. Furthermore, despite having obtained a complete radiographic response, up to 75% of these patients will have residual disease in the tumor specimen, if resection is performed. Therefore, more effective means are needed to eradicate the primary tumor and to obtain an improved local disease control. Recent phase two trials of multimodal regimens for stage I-IIIA SCLC demonstrate that in selected patients with early stage SCLC the combination of surgery and chemotherapy with or without radiotherapy is feasible with low morbidity and mortality rates. The combination therapy results in satisfying long term outcome depending on the pathological tumor stage and a local disease control is achieved in almost all patients. It is remarkable that the pneumonectomy rate has decreased over the past decades from almost 100 to 27-39%. In order to confirm these promising results, a German multicenter prospective randomized phase III trial has been designed for patients with stage I-IIIA SCLC consisting of induction chemotherapy, followed by surgery, adjuvant thoracic radiotherapy and prophylactic cranial radiation compared to thoracic radiotherapy and prophylactic cranial radiation.

Surgery in limited stage small cell lung cancer

The role of surgery in small cell lung cancer (SCLC) is controversial. Surgery has several potential advantages because it may reduce the frequency of local relapses, it does not impede the intensity of chemotherapy, it does not affect the bone marrow, and surgical staging may be of prognostic significance. Several smaller retrospective studies which focus on surgery alone, surgery with adjuvant chemotherapy or radiotherapy, or chemotherapy followed by adjuvant surgery have been reported. Five-year survival data have ranged from 10-50% according to stage, both T-status and nodal status appearing to be significant prognostic factors. Only one prospective randomized trial has been reported concerning the addition of surgery to chemotherapy alone. This trial does not favour surgery. The reason for this could be a selection bias in the smaller non-randomized studies or a result of stage migration. Nevertheless, surgery may yet play an important role in SCLC, especially in diagnosis and staging, and with new improved non-invasive staging procedures, such as positron emission tomography, resection may lead to cure in selected patients. Prospective randomized studies are needed to settle this issue.

Clinical applications of the pathological properties of small cell carcinoma, large cell carcinoma, and adenoid cystic carcinoma of the lung

Lung cancer has considerable treatment problems, with a poor 5-yr survival rate after surgery. Application of histopathological and immunohistopathological subtyping have proven to be powerful tools for the assessment of prognosis. Results in 33 patients with small cell carcinoma, 44 with large cell carcinoma, and five with adenoid cystic carcinoma of the lung are discussed. The 5-yr survival rates in patients with small cell carcinoma of the oat cell type and intermediate type were 24 and 44%, respectively. Argyrophilic granules and neuron-specific enolase, neuroendocrine markers, were detected more frequently in the oat cell type rather than in the intermediate type. In contrast, keratin, epithelial membrane antigen, and carcinoembryonic antigen, epithelial origin markers, were present more frequently in the intermediate type than in the oat cell type. The 5-yr survival rates with large cell carcinoma of the compact growth type and the loose structure type were 46 and 28%, respectively, based on evidence of morphologically intercellular cohesion. The epithelial origin markers were detectable and more frequent in the compact growth type than in the loose structure type. The growth patterns of adenoid cystic carcinoma are classified as tubular, cribriform, and solid. The solid pattern was the most aggressive with extensive perineural invasion. We propose that the pathological properties of lung cancer should be examined as a prognostic implication of subtyping.

Long term survival after pulmonary resection for small cell carcinoma of the lung

A retrospective review was undertaken of the long term survival of 97 patients with histologically proved small cell carcinoma of the lung resected during the 10 years January 1977-December 1986. Twenty seven patients (28%) had stage I disease, 29 (30%) stage II, and 41 (42%) stage III. Patients with stage I and II tumours were managed by resection alone. Patients with stage III disease received adjuvant chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and vincristine). Pneumonectomy was undertaken in 75 patients, lobectomy in 21, and wedge resection in one patient. Three patients died within 30 days of operation. The cumulative five year survival of all patients, irrespective of tumour stage, was 17%. The cumulative five year survival was 35% for patients with stage I disease, 23% for stage II, and zero for stage III. The median survival for patients with stage III tumours was 17 months. There was no significant difference in cumulative survival between patients with stage I and II disease. Cumulative survival, however, was significantly better for patients with stage I and II disease than for those with stage III disease. The data suggest that for patients with stage I and stage II disease surgery offers the prospect of long term survival.

The role of ifosfamide and cyclophosphamide in the multi-modality treatment after surgery for cure for small-cell bronchial carcinomas (SCLC)

For the optimisation of the therapy for small cell bronchial carcinomas (SCLC), surgery is used to eliminate the primary tumor and its regional lymph nodes and chemo- and radiotherapy for the general treatment of micrometastasis. After patho-histological examination of the operation specimen, randomization for two arms is performed for a standard chemotherapy (CAV) or a sequential chemotherapy using three different drug combinations. Thereafter all disease-free patients receive prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI). Preliminary evaluations in December 1987, of 112 patients from 19 cooperating departments show that the survival rate projected for 2 yr of 43 patients at stage pT1-3 N0 M0 is 76%, of 43 patients at stage pT1-3 N1 M0 it is 63% and of 26 patients at stage pT1-3 N2 M0 it is 38%.

Evolving role of surgical treatment in limited-disease small cell lung carcinoma

The diagnostic role of surgical procedures in small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) is well established. The therapeutic role of surgery has changed over the years. At present, curative resection is the treatment of choice in peripheral T1-2 N0M0 SCLC, and adjuvant chemotherapy may be beneficial. Surgery is also indicated in SCLC patients diagnosed by a limited pathologic sample in whom the clinical course suggests nonsmall cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). The resection may reveal either a mixed tumor or an alternate diagnosis and may be potentially curative. Surgery, at the time of maximal response to chemotherapy in T3N0M0 SCLC, may be curative and reveal the presence of NSCLC elements. The best survival is in patients found to be tumor-free at surgery, and the worst survival is in N2 patients.

Surgical treatment of patients with small cell carcinoma of the lung: a histochemical and immunohistochemical study

Thirty-three patients with small cell carcinoma of the lung were treated surgically, and immunohistochemistry of the cell differentiations was examined in detail. The overall 5-year survival rate was 38% and the rates in patients with stage I or stage III were 57% and 11%, respectively (P less than 0.05). Survival rates in patients with the oat cell type and intermediate type were 24% and 44%, respectively, but with no significant difference. This carcinoma seemed to originate from primitive multipotential stem cells, i.e., those of a neuroendocrine or epithelial nature. Histochemically and immunohistochemically, argyrophilic granules and neuron-specific enolase, neuroendocrine markers, were detected more frequently in the oat cell type rather than in the intermediate type. In contrast, keratin, epithelial membrane antigen, and carcinoembryonic antigen, epithelial origin markers, were present more frequently in the intermediate type than in oat cell type. However, the difference was significant only in case of detection of argyrophilic granules and the carcinoembryonic antigen (P less than 0.05). Our current recommendation is that surgical resection should be done in the earlier stage in both subtypes. A more favorable prognosis can be expected when adjuvant chemotherapy is prescribed.

Prognosis after Nonradical Resections for Small Cell Lung Carcinoma (SCLC)

Out of 52 consecutive patients resected for small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) from 1976 to 1986, 19 were selected because they underwent nonradical surgery, 10 of them for locoregional spread and 9 for distant metastases. Of the former subset all received postoperative radiotherapy and 8 chemotherapy also. Three patients are alive and disease-free 37, 56 and 91 months after resection. Four patients had a distant recurrence, and 3 a locoregional failure. Patients of the latter subgroup received chemotherapy in 7 instances. None survived more than 16 months, distant metastases being the cause of death. In these patients NO status was associated with 13.3 months of mean survival, N1 with 8.5 months, and N2 with 6.7 months. Surgery and adjuvant treatments seem effective in achieving local control of SCLC despite nonradical resections. Tumor burden at locoregional sites does not preclude the possibility of long term survival.