Noninvasive assessment of impotence

The link between smoking and impotence: two decades of evidence

BACKGROUND

Anti-tobacco advertisements now feature the risk of impotence as a reason to avoid or cease tobacco use. The scientific evidence, however, is mixed. To shed light on the controversy, we compiled 2 decades of published data on the link between smoking and impotence.

METHODS

We searched MEDLINE from 1980 to the present for studies that reported smoking prevalence among impotent male subjects. For each study we recorded the age of subjects, their state of residence, the percentage that were current smokers, and the time period over which study data were collected. For comparison purposes, we estimated age-, state-, and year-specific smoking rates in the general male population using the Behavioral Risk Factors Surveillance System. We performed a meta-analysis using a random effects model.

RESULTS

Among the 1008 journal articles examined, we identified 19 studies that reported the smoking habits of 3819 impotent men. Of these 19 studies, 16 indicated a smoking prevalence exceeding that of the general population. The 6 largest studies all revealed a higher prevalence of smoking among impotent men. Meta-analysis reveals that 40% of impotent men were current smokers compared with 28% of men in the general population. CONCLUSIONSBased on almost 2 decades of evidence, tobacco use is an important risk factor for impotence. Anti-tobacco advertisements featuring impotence as a reason to avoid or cease tobacco use are well grounded in scientific fact.

Bulbocavernosus reflex studies and autonomic testing in the diagnosis of erectile dysfunction

The electrophysiologic evaluation of patients with erectile dysfunction presents an important diagnostic challenge. The bulbocavernosus reflex (BCR) latency has been commonly used to evaluate these disorders. However, it is a measure of somatic penile innervation, whereas erection is primarily dependent on autonomic function. We evaluated 195 men with erectile dysfunction over a 3 year period. Each had electrophysiologic studies, nerve conduction studies and a BCR. BCR studies were abnormal in only 7%, of which most had diabetes or pelvic trauma. The BCR was the sole electrophysiologic abnormality in only 2%. Autonomic testing (AT) was additionally performed in 19 diabetic and 23 non-diabetic patients. This included sympathetic skin responses and measurement of the Valsalva ratio and heart rate variability with 6/min breathing. In the diabetic group, AT was positive in 63%, and most often was the sole abnormality. The bulbocavernosus reflex is relatively insensitive in the diagnosis of erectile dysfunction. Brief autonomic testing may provide valuable additional data, particularly in diabetics.

Vascular interventions for impotence: lessons learned

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to analyze the results of vascular interventions for impotence in men with this complaint.

METHODS

Between September 1983 and March 1993, 1094 men with the chief complaint of impotence (average age 54.5 years) were screened by use of penile plethysmography and penile brachial indexes: 635 were considered to have normal flow, and 459 were considered to have abnormal arterial flow, 12.2% of whom were found to have aortoiliac disease. Based on negative neural screening results, absence of erectile responses on increasing doses of intracavernously injected papaverine or prostaglandin E1 (ICI), surgical candidates for microvascular procedures were referred for dynamic infusion cavernosography (DICC) and pudendal arteriography. Operations for men discovered to have aortoiliac disease were based on conventional indications including aneurysm size or limb ischemia. None of the subjects had diabetes. Only those patients without diabetes and those not requiring blood pressure medications were selected for microvascular procedures. We report our experience and surgical outcomes at average follow-ups of 33 to 48 months. Four types of operations were performed on 67 men (age 18 to 79 years). These included 17 aortoiliac reconstructions, 11 dorsal penile artery bypasses, 12 dorsal vein arterializations, and 27 venous interruptions. Follow-up data were obtained by direct examination and noninvasive Doppler examinations; repeat arteriography (4 of 11); repeat DICC after venous ablation procedures (18 of 27) and postoperative ICI response. Mail questionnaires completed postoperative surveillance.

RESULTS

Among 17 men undergoing aortoiliac intervention for aneurysms in eight and occlusive disease in nine, 58% functioned spontaneously after operation and 18% used ICI or vacuum constrictor devices at an average follow-up time of 38 months. Among 11 men with dorsal penile artery bypasses, 27% functioned spontaneously and 45% used ICI at an average follow-up time of 34.5 months. Among 12 men with dorsal vein arterialization, 33% functioned spontaneously, and 47% used ICI at an average follow-up time of 48 months. Among 27 with venous interruption, 33% functioned spontaneously and 44% used ICI. In seven of eight aneurysms of 4.5 to 6.0 cm in size, impotence workup led to discovery; probable embolic mechanisms existed in three. Venous interruption efficacy correlated with postoperative DICC results when flow to maintain erection was 40 ml or less. Apart from two cases of glans hyperemia, no surgical complications occurred in the microvascular procedures. There was one episode of bleeding caused by DICC after aortic reconstruction. There were no deaths.

CONCLUSIONS

With prospective screening criteria, 6% to 7% of impotent men became candidates for vascular intervention. Including those functioning with ICI or vacuum constriction devices, about 70% of these men were functional after operation. Men undergoing aortoiliac reconstruction has a significantly higher rate (58%) of spontaneous function as compared with those undergoing microvascular procedures.

Assessment and treatment of impotence

Impotence is a common problem. History is primarily relied on to diagnose psychogenic impotence. Sex therapy is an effective treatment. Antihypertensive and psychiatric medicines often cause impotence, but most medicines should be considered a cause if this is supported by the history. Hormonal causes should be suspected in a patient with decreased libido or decreased testicular size, and testosterone should be measured in these cases. Hormone replacement may restore sexual function in hypogonadal men. Doppler sonogram or arteriography should be used to diagnose vascular impotence for men who would be good surgical candidates. Only young men without other illness are considered. There is little need to test neurologic function because there is no specific treatment for neurogenic impotence. These patients and patients who do not respond to the aforementioned treatments should be offered the vacuum erection device, penile self-injection therapy, or penile prosthesis. Choice depends on comorbid illness as well as patient preference. A basic algorithm for the evaluation and treatment of impotence is given in Figure 2.

Accuracy of the initial history and physical examination to establish the etiology of erectile dysfunction

OBJECTIVES

Because of its implications for possible therapy, the ability to establish a diagnosis of erectile dysfunction (ED) solely on the basis of history and physical examination has been a matter of controversy. The determination of the etiology of ED based on history and physical examination is evaluated in this present study.

METHODS

Consecutive patients presenting for evaluation of ED were evaluated by careful history, physical examination, psychologic evaluation, and RigiScan monitoring. They were then stratified into either organic or psychogenic groups based on each of these modalities. These diagnoses were then compared to a final diagnosis obtained through additional testing.

RESULTS

History and physical examination had a 95% sensitivity but only a 50% specificity in diagnosing organic ED. The accuracy rates of history and physical examination in diagnosing ED were 80% and 60%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A multifaceted comprehensive approach is required to evaluate fully and to diagnose ED.