Overcoming rejection in pig-to-primate cardiac xenotransplantation

Disordered regulation of coagulation and platelet activation in xenotransplantation

Rejection of xenografts is associated with vascular-based inflammation, thrombocytopenia and the consumption of coagulation factors that may evolve into disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC). Similarly, bone marrow-derived cellular xenotransplantation procedures are associated with endothelial cell activation and thrombotic microangiopathic injury. These complications generally develop despite the best available measures for depletion of xenoreactive natural antibody, inhibition of complement activation and suppression of T- and B-cell mediated immune responses. The mechanisms underlying the DIC and thrombotic microangiopathy associated with xenotransplantation are unclear. A proposed primary biological dysfunction of xenografts with respect to regulation of clotting could amplify vascular injury, promote immunological responses and independently contribute to graft failure. Disordered thromboregulation could have deleterious effects, comparable to unregulated complement activation, in the pathogenesis of xenograft rejection and may therefore represent a substantive barrier to xenotransplantation.

Complement inhibition with an anti-C5 monoclonal antibody prevents hyperacute rejection in a xenograft heart transplantation model

BACKGROUND

The present study was undertaken to determine whether anti-complement 5 (C5) monoclonal antibodies (mAb) prevent hyperacute rejection (HAR) in a rat-to-presensitized mouse heart transplantation model and whether these mAb, combined with cyclosporine (CsA) and cyclophosphamide (CyP), can achieve long-term graft survival.

METHODS

BALB/c mice were presensitized with 2x10(7) splenocytes from Lewis rats 14 days before grafting. Heart grafts from Lewis rats were heterotopically transplanted into BALB/c mice. Presensitized mice were treated with either anti-C5 mAb or a combination of anti-C5 mAb, CsA, and CyP. Controls included: presensitized mice with no treatment, presensitized mice treated with either CsA + CyP or IgG, and nonpresensitized mice with either no treatment or with CsA + CyP treatment.

RESULTS

Although typical features of HAR were evident in the presensitized grafts, the mAb completely inhibited complement activation and successfully prevented HAR. Despite complement inactivation, the graft was rejected on postoperative day 6 with acute vascular rejection (AVR) also known as delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). Notably, this type of rejection cannot be effectively overcome by CsA and CyP.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that (1) anti-C5 mAb prevents HAR, (2) AVR/DXR still occurs when HAR is prevented by complement inactivation, and (3) AVR/DXR cannot be overcome by conventional immunosuppression. These data suggest that anti-C5 mAb may be valuable for preventing HAR in future clinical xenotransplantation and that additional interventions may be required to address AVR/DXR.

Factors in xenograft rejection

Important mechanisms underlying immediate xenograft loss by hyperacute rejection (HAR), in the pig-to-primate combination, have been recently delineated. There are now several proposed therapies that deal with the problem of complement activation and xenoreactive natural antibody (XNA) binding to the vasculature that have been shown to prevent HAR. However, vascularized xenografts are still lost, typically within days, by delayed xenograft rejection (DXR), alternatively known as acute vascular rejection (AVR). This process is characterized by endothelial cell (EC) perturbation, localization of XNA within the graft vasculature, host NK cell and monocyte activation with platelet sequestration and vascular thrombosis. Alternative immunosuppressive strategies, additive anti-complement therapies with the control of any resulting EC activation processes and induction of protective responses have been proposed to ameliorate this pathological process. In addition, several potentially important molecular incompatibilities between activated human coagulation factors and the natural anticoagulants expressed on porcine EC have been noted. Such incompatibilities may be analogous to cross-species alterations in the function of complement regulatory proteins important in HAR. Disordered thromboregulation is potentially relevant to the progression of inflammatory events in DXR and the disseminated intravascular coagulation seen in primate recipients of porcine renal xenografts. We have recently demonstrated the inability of porcine tissue factor pathway inhibitor (TFPI) to adequately neutralize human factor Xa (FXa), the aberrant activation of both human prothrombin and FXa by porcine EC and the failure of the porcine natural anticoagulant, thrombomodulin to bind human thrombin and hence activate human protein C. The enhanced potential of porcine von Willebrand factor to associate with human platelet GPIb has been demonstrated to be dependent upon the isolated A1 domain of von Willebrand factor. In addition, the loss of TFPI and vascular ATPDase/CD39 activity following EC activation responses would potentiate any procoagulant changes within the xenograft. These developments could exacerbate vascular damage from whatever cause and enhance the activation of platelets and coagulation pathways within xenografts resulting in graft infarction and loss. Analysis of these and the other putative factors underlying DXR should lead to the development and testing of genetic approaches that, in conjunction with selected pharmacological means, may further prolong xenograft survival to a clinically relevant extent.

Disseminated intravascular coagulation in association with the delayed rejection of pig-to-baboon renal xenografts

BACKGROUND

Intravascular fibrin deposition and platelet sequestration occur with porcine xenograft rejection by baboons. Disseminated intravascular coagulopathy may arise either as a direct consequence of the failure to fully deplete xenoreactive natural antibodies and block complement, or because of putative cross-species molecular incompatibilities in this discordant species combination.

METHODS

Three baboons were conditioned with retrovirally transduced autologous bone marrow to induce tolerance to swine antigens. Xenoreactive natural antibodies and complement were depleted by plasmapheresis and the use of Gal alpha1-3Gal column adsorptions; baboons were then splenectomized and underwent renal xenografting from inbred, miniature pigs. Soluble complement receptor type-1 with protocol immunosuppression (mycophenolate mofetil, 15-deoxyspergualin, steroids, and cyclosporine) was administered.

RESULTS

A bleeding diathesis was clinically evident from days 5 to 12 after transplantation in two baboons. Low levels of circulating C3a, C3d, and iC3b were measured despite the absence of functional circulating complement components. Profound thrombocytopenia with abnormalities in keeping with disseminated intravascular coagulopathy were observed. Prolongation of prothrombin and partial thromboplastin times was accompanied by evidence for tissue factor-mediated coagulation pathways, high levels of thrombin generation (prothrombin fragment F(1+2) production and thrombin-antithrombin complex formation), fibrinogen depletion, and production of high levels of the fibrin degradation product D-dimer. Importantly, these disturbances resolved rapidly after the excision of the rejected xenografts in two surviving animals. Histopathological examination of the rejected xenografts confirmed vascular injury, fibrin deposition, platelet deposition, and localized complement activation.

CONCLUSIONS

Systemic coagulation disturbances are associated with delayed xenograft rejection.

Discordant organ xenotransplantation in primates: world experience and current status

The pig-to-primate model is increasingly being utilized as the final preclinical means of assessing therapeutic strategies aimed at allowing discordant xenotransplantation. We review here the world experience of both pig-to-human and pig-to-nonhuman primate organ transplantation. Eight whole organ transplants using discordant mammalian donors have been carried out in human recipients; only one patient was reported (in 1923) to have survived for longer than 72 hr. Therapeutic approaches in the experimental laboratory setting have included pharmacologic immunosuppression, antibody and/or complement depletion or inhibition, the use of pig organs transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins, and conditioning regimens aimed at inducing a state of tolerance or specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness. The greatest success to date has been obtained with methods that inhibit complement-mediated injury, either by the administration of cobra venom factor or soluble complement receptor I to the recipient (with organ survival up to 6 weeks) or by the use of donor organs transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor (with organ survival up to 2 months). The future of xenotransplantation may lie in the judicious combination of current approaches.