Significance of chronic transplant nephropathy on early protocol biopsies for graft outcome in pediatric renal transplantation

Clinical Significance of Renal Allograft Protocol Biopsies: A Single Tertiary Center Experience in Malaysia

Background

The role of protocol renal allograft biopsy in kidney transplantation is controversial due to the concern with procedural-related complications; however, its role is slowly evolving. Recent evidence suggests that protocol biopsy is useful in detecting subclinical renal pathology. Early recognition and treatment of renal pathologies can improve long-term outcomes of renal allografts.

Methodology

A total of 362 renal allograft protocol biopsies were performed in adult recipients of kidney transplantation between 2012 and 2017. After excluding those with poor quality or those performed with a baseline serum creatinine level >200 umol/L, we analyzed 334 (92.3%) biopsies. Histology reports were reviewed and categorized into histoimmunological and nonimmunological changes. The immunological changes were subcategorized into the following: (1) no acute rejection (NR), (2) borderline changes (BC), and (3) subclinical rejection (SCR). Nonimmunological changes were subcategorized into the following: (1) chronicity including interstitial fibrosis/tubular atrophy (IFTA), chronic T-cell-mediated rejection (TCMR), unspecified chronic lesions, and arterionephrosclerosis, (2) de novo glomerulopathy/recurrence of primary disease (RP), and (3) other clinically unsuspected lesions (acute pyelonephritis, calcineurin inhibitors toxicity, postinfective glomerulonephritis, and BK virus nephropathy). Risk factors associated with SCR were assessed.

Results

For the histoimmunological changes, 161 (48.2%) showed NR, 145 (43.4%) were BC, and 28 (8.4%) were SCR. These clinical events were more pronounced for the first 5 years; our data showed BC accounted for 59 (36.4%), 64 (54.2%), and 22 (40.7%) biopsies within <1 year, 1-5 years, and > 5 years, respectively (p = 0.011). Meanwhile, the incidence for SCR was 6 (3.7%) biopsies in <1 year, 18 (15.3%) in 1-5 years, and 4 (7.4%) in >5 years after transplantation (p=0.003). For the nonimmunological changes, chronicity, de novo glomerulopathy/RP, and other clinically unsuspected lesions were seen in 40 (12%), 10 (3%), and 12 (3.6%) biopsies, respectively. Living-related donor recipients were associated with decreased SCR (p=0.007).

Conclusions

Despite having a stable renal function, our transplant recipients had a significant number of subclinical rejection on renal allograft biopsies.

Protocol biopsies in pediatric renal transplantation: a precious tool for clinical management

BACKGROUND

Kidney transplantation is the best treatment for children with end-stage kidney disease. Early results have improved, but late graft loss is still a major problem. Non-invasive, fully reliable early biomarkers of acute rejection are currently missing.

METHODS

Our aim was to evaluate the efficacy of protocol biopsies (PBXs) in a pediatric population. During 11 years, 209 renal transplantations were performed in 204 pediatric patients. Biopsies were performed 3-6 months, 1 year, and 5 years after transplantation. Procedure-related complications were systematically looked for by means of ultrasound scans.

RESULTS

Unexpected findings (mainly subclinical rejections) requiring therapeutic intervention were found in 19.3% biopsies performed at 3-6 months, in 18.4% in 12-month biopsies and in none of those performed after 5 years. The 13.6% patients at 12-month biopsies and 23.6% at 5-year biopsies showed calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) toxicity. Interstitial fibrosis and tubular atrophy (IF/TA) was found in 17.6 and 83.6% of patients at 12-month and 5-year biopsies, respectively. Complications of the PBX were infrequent. Five-year estimated glomerular filtration rate (GFR) was not significantly different in patients who received treatment for any cause and patients with normal histology.

CONCLUSIONS

Although we do not have a control group, we may speculate that patients who received treatment returned to a "standard" condition possibly improving final outcome. Protocol biopsies are a powerful diagnostic tool for the management of pediatric renal transplant recipients. In view of the lack of evidence that biopsies taken 5 years after transplantation lead to any therapeutic change, their use should be reconsidered.

Surveillance biopsies after paediatric kidney transplantation: A review

Kidney transplantation is the most effective means of treating children with end-stage kidney disease, and yet, there continues to be a limited "life span" of transplanted kidneys in paediatric recipients. Early graft monitoring, using the surveillance biopsy, has the potential to extend renal allograft survival in paediatric recipients. The surveillance biopsy provides important and timely information about acute and chronic graft pathology, particularly SCR and calcineurin inhibitor-induced nephrotoxicity, which can subsequently guide management decisions and improve long-term graft survival. The ostensible value of the surveillance biopsy is furthered by the limitations of conventional renal functional studies. However, there is still much debate surrounding the surveillance biopsy in paediatric recipients, particularly in regard to its overall utility, safety and timing. This review discusses the current literature regarding the utility, safety, and potential predictive value of surveillance biopsies for guiding post-transplant management in paediatric renal allograft recipients, as well as the viability of other potentially newer non-invasive strategies for renal allograft monitoring.

Safety and efficacy of alemtuzumab in the treatment of late acute renal allograft rejection

Safety and efficacy of alemtuzumab in the treatment of AR in children after renal transplantation is unknown. Five episodes of refractory late AR in three children (three episodes in patient 1 and a single episode in patients 2 and 3 occurring after 7-23 months of transplantation) were treated with one dose of alemtuzumab as a rescue therapy. Four episodes (Banff IA-IB) in patients 1 and 2 reversed fully or partially with alemtuzumab, whereas patient 3 with Banff IB-IIA AR failed to respond. Patient 1 had recurrent AR 5, 13, and 15 months later; first two episodes responded to retreatment with alemtuzumab, and the last episode was not treated causing allograft failure. Patient 2 had steroid-responsive AR after two months and had a functioning allograft 25 months later. A transient reduction in all lymphocyte subsets except natural killer cells occurred in all patients. Patient 3 (treated with steroids, Thymoglobulin(R) , intravenous immunoglobulin, and rituximab prior to alemtuzumab) suffered many bacterial infections during one-yr period after therapy. However, symptomatic viral infections were not observed in any of the children. Treatment with alemtuzumab may prolong allograft survival in multidrug-resistant AR but may not prevent recurrent AR in non-adherent children.

Chronic allograft nephropathy

Chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) is the leading cause of renal allograft loss in paediatric renal transplant recipients. CAN is the result of immunological and nonimmunological injury, including acute rejection episodes, hypoperfusion, ischaemia reperfusion, calcineurin toxicity, infection and recurrent disease. The development of CAN is often insidious and may be preceded by subclinical rejection in a well-functioning allograft. Classification of CAN is histological using the Banff classification of renal allograft pathology with classic findings of interstitial fibrosis, tubular atrophy, glomerulosclerosis, fibrointimal hyperplasia and arteriolar hyalinosis. Although improvement in immunosuppression has led to greater 1-year graft survival rates, chronic graft loss remains relatively unchanged and opportunistic infectious complications remain a problem. Protocol biopsy monitoring is not current practice in paediatric transplantation for CAN monitoring but may have a place if new treatment options become available. Newer immunosuppression regimens, closer monitoring of the renal allograft and management of subclinical rejection may lead to reduced immune injury leading to CAN in the paediatric population but must be weighed against the risk of increased immunosuppression and calcineurin inhibitor nephrotoxicity.

Evaluating the accuracy of functional biomarkers for detecting histological changes in chronic allograft nephropathy

The most common cause of late kidney transplant failure is chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN). Much research has focused on identifying biomarkers (or correlates) that would predict subsequent CAN and allow timely intervention. Functional biomarkers such as serum creatinine and estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) have been widely adopted, even though they have not been rigorously evaluated as surrogate markers. This study evaluated serum creatinine and eGFR for predicting the early histopathological changes seen in transplant protocol biopsies (TPB). We prospectively followed 289 kidney transplant patients in the Southern Alberta Transplant Program who had TPB at 6-12 months post-transplant. Tissue samples (n = 280) were independently examined by renal pathologists. The ability of serum creatinine or eGFR to predict the threshold level for abnormal histopathology was evaluated by calculating the area under the receiver operator characteristic curve. Serum creatinine and eGFR had poor predictive value (most confidence intervals included 0.5, indicating no predictive ability) for ten individual histological measurements (Banff 97 scores), and the Chronic Allograft Damage Index. We conclude that serum creatinine and eGFR have a limited clinical role in predicting the early histopathological changes that precede CAN and should not be used for this purpose.

Chronic allograft nephropathy in paediatric renal transplantation

Chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) is now the leading cause of renal transplant loss in paediatric transplant recipients. Despite improvements in immunosuppression, which have significantly reduced the incidence of acute rejection, the rates of chronic kidney loss have remained unchanged in paediatric transplant patients over the last 20 years. Chronic allograft nephropathy is a pathological diagnosis of which the key features are tubular atrophy and interstitial fibrosis. More consistent definitions and grading of these through the Banff classification have allowed more rigorous study of the development of chronic allograft nephropathy along with further identification of specific lesions associated with the underlying aetiologies. While initially thought to be primarily due to immune injury, it is now evident that CAN is the end result of a variety of immune and non-immune injuries including ischaemia reperfusion injury, calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) toxicity and infections. Protocol biopsy studies have demonstrated rates of CAN development in children similar to those in adults with comparable underlying pathological processes. This review outlines the current knowledge of CAN within the context of paediatric renal transplantation.

Protocol Transplant Biopsies: Are They Really Needed?

Studies suggest that surveillance or protocol biopsies that are performed during the first year after kidney transplantation may be clinically useful in identifying early acute rejection or chronic allograft nephropathy at a point when they may be amenable to treatment. Although the benefit of this approach has yet to be evaluated in large, multicenter, prospective trials, numerous studies suggest that implementation of protocol biopsies may improve long-term graft function. In particular, a number of reports suggest that detection of chronic allograft nephropathy in early protocol biopsies is predictive of subsequent graft function and loss and that early treatment may have a dramatic effect on the outcome of the graft. Protocol biopsies also have the potential to be of great value in high-risk patients, such as those with delayed graft function, by allowing for early intervention for acute rejection. Furthermore, the procedure seems to be relatively straightforward and safe. Nevertheless, paucity of data has meant that clear proof of a benefit of early treatment of subclinical rejection and chronic allograft nephropathy detected by protocol biopsy is lacking. Moreover, the optimal timing of protocol biopsies and reliable methods to quantify the histologic changes observed in biopsy specimens have yet to be determined. This review discusses the pros and cons of protocol biopsies and considers the place of this procedure in the routine treatment of kidney transplant patients.

Mast cell numbers and protease expression patterns in biopsy specimens following renal transplantation from living-related donors predict long-term graft function

In human kidney transplantation the main cause of declining long-term graft function is chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN). Recent studies have implicated human mast cells (MC) in chronic inflammation and fibrosis, MC can be subtyped according to protease content: MC(T) containing tryptase only and MC(TC) containing both tryptase and chymase. We investigated immunohistochemically whether numbers and subtypes of MC in biopsy specimens 100 d after transplantation could predict subsequent fibrosis and graft dysfunction. The total number of MC/high-power field at 100 d after transplantation correlated significantly with change in creatinine clearance (DeltaCcr), defined as (Ccr at 100 d) - (Ccr at 3 yr) (R = 0.597, p = 0.0021); fibrosis index (FI) at 100 d (R = 0.583, p = 0.0066); and DeltaFI, defined as (FI at 3 yr) - (FI at 100 d) (R = 0.406, p < 0.05). The ratio of MC(TC) to total MC at 100 d also correlated with DeltaCcr (R = 0.491, p = 0.0148), FI at 100 d (R = 0.527, p = 0.0081), and DeltaFI (R = 0.417, p < 0.05). Thus, increases in number of total MC and the ratio of MC(TC) to total MC in early biopsy specimens were related to decline of long-term graft function and fibrosis.

Protocol Biopsies in Kidney Transplant Recipients: Histologic Findings as Prognostic Markers for Graft Function and Outcome

The aim of the present study was to identify subclinical and borderline rejections as well as histological markers of chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN) among protocol biopsies performed at 1 and 6 months after living related kidney transplantation to assess their possible implications for graft function. Twenty paired allograft biopsies performed at 1 and 6 months were reviewed according to the Banff scoring scheme. The mean ages of donors and recipients were 59.6 +/- 13.8 and 34.4 +/- 8.7 years, respectively. Among all biopsies only 10% (4/40) showed no histopathological lesions. At the first month borderline rejection was shown in 35% and subclinical rejection in 10% of patients. At 6 months the proportion of findings was even higher, namely, 40% and 30%, respectively. When divided according to donor age, donors above 55 years showed a mean CAN score of 2.33 +/- 1.56 which increased to 5.0 +/- 2.26 on the 6 month biopsy (214.3%). Unexpectedly, the proportion of these changes in the younger donor group also increased by 173.3%, which might have been explained by the greater number of borderline and subclinical rejections in the younger donor group at the 1 month biopsy. In conclusion, 1 month biopsy may be valuable to determine borderline and subclinical rejection and to prognosticate the outcome of renal allograft function. Our findings suggest a greater susceptibility of histological deterioration among the older donor population. However, the presence of an untreated rejection in the younger donor pool leads to a rapid impairment of the graft function accelerating the process of chronic allograft nephropathy.

Transforming growth factor-beta1 expression in early biopsy specimen predicts long-term graft function following pediatric renal transplantation

The main cause of late graft loss or declining long-term graft function is chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN), characterized by progressive interstitial fibrosis. Transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta1 plays a key role in fibrogenesis. We immunohistochemically investigated whether the degree of TGF-beta1 expression in early biopsy specimens routinely obtained from stable allografts at 100 d could predict fibrosis and graft dysfunction in the late phase. Patients were children with grafts from related donors. We immunohistochemically determined intracellular and extracellular expression of TGF-beta1 in the graft using LC antibody (LC) for intracellular TGF-beta1 and CC antibody (CC) for extracellular TGF-beta1. The change in creatinine clearance between 100 d and 3 yr after transplantation (DeltaCcr) was used as an index of long-term graft function. We also used image analysis to calculate the relative area involved by interstitial fibrosis in the trichrome-stained section of graft biopsy specimens at 100 d and 3 yr, designating the change as DeltaFI. DeltaCcr was -4.2+/-9.4 mL/min in subjects with minimal early immunoreactivity for CC and -20.5+/-15.9 mL/min in subjects with strong reactivity (p<0.05). DeltaCcr was -14.5+/-18.6 mL/min in subjects with minimal early immunoreactivity for LC and -11.7+/-12.8 mL/min in those with strong reactivity. DeltaFI in subjects with minimal CC reactivity (1.28+/-4.11%) tended to be lower than that in subjects with strong reactivity (8.45+/-15.47%). Neither fibrosis at 100 d nor DeltaFI differed between subjects with minimal and strong LC reactivity. Thus, strong extracellular TGF-beta1 expression in grafts at 100 d after transplantation is associated with a long-term decline in graft function and tends to be associated with increased graft fibrosis at 3 yr.