Epigenetic variability and the evolution of human cancer

Multiplatform Molecular Profiling Reveals Epigenomic Intratumor Heterogeneity in Ependymoma

Ependymomas exist within distinct genetic subgroups, but the molecular diversity within individual ependymomas is unknown. We perform multiplatform molecular profiling of 6 spatially distinct samples from an ependymoma with C11orf95-RELA fusion. DNA methylation and RNA sequencing distinguish clusters of samples according to neuronal development gene expression programs that could also be delineated by differences in magnetic resonance blood perfusion. Exome sequencing and phylogenetic analysis reveal epigenomic intratumor heterogeneity and suggest that chromosomal structural alterations may precede accumulation of single-nucleotide variants during ependymoma tumorigenesis. In sum, these findings shed light on the oncogenesis and intratumor heterogeneity of ependymoma.

Tumor heterogeneity poses a barrier to cancer treatment. Liu etal. investigate radiographically distinct regions of an ependymoma tumor using transcriptomic, genetic, and epigenomic profiling and discover axes of gene expression programs that recapitulate normal brain development in addition to phylogenies that shed light on the tumorigenesis of ependymoma.

Understanding breast cancer heterogeneity through non-genetic heterogeneity

Intricacy in treatment and diagnosis of breast cancer has been an obstacle due to genotype and phenotype heterogeneity. Understanding of non-genetic heterogeneity mechanisms along with considering role of genetic heterogeneity may fill the gaps in landscape painting of heterogeneity. The main factors contribute to non-genetic heterogeneity including: transcriptional pulsing/bursting or discontinuous transcriptions, stochastic partitioning of components at cell division and various signal transduction from tumor ecosystem. Throughout this review, we desired to provide a conceptual framework focused on non-genetic heterogeneity, which has been intended to offer insight into prediction, diagnosis and treatment of breast cancer.

Epigenetic modulators, modifiers and mediators in cancer aetiology and progression

This year is the tenth anniversary of the publication in this journal of a model suggesting the existence of 'tumour progenitor genes'. These genes are epigenetically disrupted at the earliest stages of malignancies, even before mutations, and thus cause altered differentiation throughout tumour evolution. The past decade of discovery in cancer epigenetics has revealed a number of similarities between cancer genes and stem cell reprogramming genes, widespread mutations in epigenetic regulators, and the part played by chromatin structure in cellular plasticity in both development and cancer. In the light of these discoveries, we suggest here a framework for cancer epigenetics involving three types of genes: 'epigenetic mediators', corresponding to the tumour progenitor genes suggested earlier; 'epigenetic modifiers' of the mediators, which are frequently mutated in cancer; and 'epigenetic modulators' upstream of the modifiers, which are responsive to changes in the cellular environment and often linked to the nuclear architecture. We suggest that this classification is helpful in framing new diagnostic and therapeutic approaches to cancer.

Dynamic chromatin loops bridge health and disease in the nuclear landscape

The genome is dynamically organized in the nuclear space in a manner that reflects and influences nuclear functions. Developmental processes that govern the formation and maintenance of epigenetic memories are also tightly linked to adaptive changes in the physical and functional landscape of the nuclear architecture. Biological and biophysical principles governing the three-dimensional folding of chromatin are therefore central to our understanding of epigenetic regulation during adaptive responses and in complex diseases, such as cancer. Accumulating evidence points to the direction that global alterations in nuclear architecture and chromatin folding conspire with unstable epigenetic states of the primary chromatin fiber to drive the phenotypic plasticity of cancer cells.

Cell type and context-specific function of PLAG1 for IGF2 P3 promoter activity

The fetal transcription factor PLAG1 is found to be overexpressed in cancers, and has been suggested to bind the insulin like growth factor 2 (IGF2) P3 promoter, and to activate the IGF2 gene. The expression of IGF2 has partly been linked to loss of CTCF-dependent chromatin insulator function at the H19 imprinting control region (ICR). We investigated the role of PLAG1 for IGF2 regulation in Hep3B and JEG-3 cell lines. Chromatin immunoprecipitation revealed cell type-specific binding of PLAG1 to the IGF2 P3 promoter, which was substantially insensitive to recombinant PLAG1 overexpression in the endogenous context. We hypothesized that the H19 chromatin insulator may be involved in the cell type-specific PLAG1 response. By using a GFP reporter gene/insulator assay plasmid construct with and without the H19 ICR and/or an SV40 enhancer, we confirm that the effect of the insulator is specifically associated with the activity of the IGF2 P3 promoter in the GFP reporter system, and furthermore, that the reporter insulator is functional in JEG-3 but not in Hep3B cells. FACS analysis was used to assess the function of PLAG1 in low endogenously expressing, but Zn-inducible stable PLAG1 expressing JEG-3 cell clones. Considerable increase in IGF2 expression upon PLAG1 induction with a partial insulator overriding activity was found using the reporter constructs. This is in contrast to the effect of the endogenous IGF2 gene which was insensitive to PLAG1 expression in JEG-3, while modestly induced the already highly expressed IGF2 gene in Hep3B cells. We suggest that the PLAG1 binding to the IGF2 P3 promoter and IGF2 expression is cell type-specific, and that the PLAG1 transcription factor acts as a transcriptional facilitator that partially overrides the insulation by the H19 ICR.

Beyond the oncogene paradigm: understanding complexity in cancerogenesis

In the past decades, an enormous amount of precious information has been collected about molecular and genetic characteristics of cancer. This knowledge is mainly based on a reductionistic approach, meanwhile cancer is widely recognized to be a 'system biology disease'. The behavior of complex physiological processes cannot be understood simply by knowing how the parts work in isolation. There is not solely a matter how to integrate all available knowledge in such a way that we can still deal with complexity, but we must be aware that a deeply transformation of the currently accepted oncologic paradigm is urgently needed. We have to think in terms of biological networks: understanding of complex functions may in fact be impossible without taking into consideration influences (rules and constraints) outside of the genome. Systems Biology involves connecting experimental unsupervised multivariate data to mathematical and computational approach than can simulate biologic systems for hypothesis testing or that can account for what it is not known from high-throughput data sets. Metabolomics could establish the requested link between genotype and phenotype, providing informations that ensure an integrated understanding of pathogenic mechanisms and metabolic phenotypes and provide a screening tool for new targeted drug.

Agelastatin A: a novel inhibitor of osteopontin-mediated adhesion, invasion, and colony formation

Effective inhibitors of osteopontin (OPN)-mediated neoplastic transformation and metastasis are still lacking. (-)-Agelastatin A is a naturally occurring oroidin alkaloid with powerful antitumor effects that, in many cases, are superior to cisplatin in vitro. In this regard, past comparative assaying of the two agents against a range of human tumor cell lines has revealed that typically (-)-agelastatin A is 1.5 to 16 times more potent than cisplatin at inhibiting cell growth, its effects being most pronounced against human bladder, skin, colon, and breast carcinomas. In this study, we have investigated the effects of (-)-agelastatin A on OPN-mediated malignant transformation using mammary epithelial cell lines. Treatment with (-)-agelastatin A inhibited OPN protein expression and enhanced expression of the cellular OPN inhibitor, Tcf-4. (-)-Agelastatin A treatment also reduced beta-catenin protein expression and reduced anchorage-independent growth, adhesion, and invasion in R37 OPN pBK-CMV and C9 cell lines. Similar effects were observed in MDA-MB-231 and MDA-MB-435s human breast cancer cell lines exposed to (-)-agelastatin A. Suppression of Tcf-4 by RNA interference (short interfering RNA) induced malignant/invasive transformation in parental benign Rama 37 cells; significantly, these events were reversed by treatment with (-)-agelastatin A. Our study reveals, for the very first time, that (-)-agelastatin A down-regulates beta-catenin expression while simultaneously up-regulating Tcf-4 and that these combined effects cause repression of OPN and inhibition of OPN-mediated malignant cell invasion, adhesion, and colony formation in vitro. We have also shown that (-)-agelastatin A inhibits cancer cell proliferation by causing cells to accumulate in the G(2) phase of cell cycle.

Colorectal cancer epigenetics: the role of environmental factors and the search for molecular biomarkers

This review presents an evenhanded evaluation of the role of epigenetics in the development of colorectal cancer, and investigates the extent of environmental influences on modulating this disease. Advances in our understanding of chromatin structure, histone modification, transcriptional activity and DNA methylation have lead to an integrated approach to the role of epigenetics in carcinogenesis. Epigenetic mechanisms appear to permit response of individuals to environment through change in gene expression and are involved in inactivating one of the two X chromosomes in women. Epigenetic changes play an important role in development and can also arise stochastically as individuals age. Because epigenetic alterations are potentially reversible, thereby allowing malignant cells to revert to the normal state, there is potential to develop effective strategies to prevent or even reverse this curable cancer. Moreover, because the methylation status of a specific sequence or the pattern of methylation across the genome can now be measured accurately, molecular biomarkers of screening, diagnosis, prognosis, prediction of treatment and those related to risk assessment can be developed using sophisticated molecular genetic technologies. Although in many cases a high sensitivity and specificity of the detection assays has been achieved, there still remains ample room for improvement in areas of sample preparation, assay design and marker selection.

Epigenetics of prostate cancer: beyond DNA methylation

Epigenetic mechanisms permit the stable inheritance of cellular properties without changes in DNA sequence or amount. In prostate carcinoma, epigenetic mechanisms are essential for development and progression, complementing, amplifying and diversifying genetic alterations. DNA hypermethylation affects at least 30 individual genes, while repetitive sequences including retrotransposons and selected genes become hypomethylated. Hypermethylation of several genes occurs in a coordinate manner early in carcinogenesis and can be exploited for cancer detection, whereas hypomethylation and further hypermethylation events are associated with progression. DNA methylation alterations interact with changes in chromatin proteins. Prominent alterations at this level include altered patterns of histone modification, increased expression of the EZH2 polycomb histone methyltransferase, and changes in transcriptional corepressors and coactivators. These changes may make prostate carcinoma particularly susceptible to drugs targeting chromatin and DNA modifications. They relate to crucial alterations in a network of transcription factors comprising ETS family proteins, the androgen receptor, NKX3.1, KLF, and HOXB13 homeobox proteins. This network controls differentiation and proliferation of prostate epithelial cells integrating signals from hormones, growth factors and cell adhesion proteins that are likewise distorted in prostate cancer. As a consequence, prostate carcinoma cells appear to be locked into an aberrant state, characterized by continued proliferation of largely differentiated cells. Accordingly, stem cell characteristics of prostate cancer cells appear to be secondarily acquired. The aberrant differentiation state of prostate carcinoma cells also results in distorted mutual interactions between epithelial and stromal cells in the tumor that promote tumor growth, invasion, and metastasis.

Positive selection in the evolution of cancer

We hypothesize that forms of antagonistic coevolution have forged strong links between positive selection at the molecular level and increased cancer risk. By this hypothesis, evolutionary conflict between males and females, mothers and foetuses, hosts and parasites, and other parties with divergent fitness interests has led to rapid evolution of genetic systems involved in control over fertilization and cellular resources. The genes involved in such systems promote cancer risk as a secondary effect of their roles in antagonistic coevolution, which generates evolutionary disequilibrium and maladaptation. Evidence from two sources: (1) studies on specific genes, including SPANX cancer/testis antigen genes, several Y-linked genes, the pem homebox gene, centromeric histone genes, the breast cancer gene BRCA1, the angiogenesis gene ANG, cadherin genes, cytochrome P450 genes, and viral oncogenes; and (2) large-scale database studies of selection on different functional categories of genes, supports our hypothesis. These results have important implications for understanding the evolutionary underpinnings of cancer and the dynamics of antagonistically-coevolving molecular systems.

The epigenetic progenitor origin of human cancer

Cancer is widely perceived as a heterogeneous group of disorders with markedly different biological properties, which are caused by a series of clonally selected genetic changes in key tumour-suppressor genes and oncogenes. However, recent data suggest that cancer has a fundamentally common basis that is grounded in a polyclonal epigenetic disruption of stem/progenitor cells, mediated by 'tumour-progenitor genes'. Furthermore, tumour cell heterogeneity is due in part to epigenetic variation in progenitor cells, and epigenetic plasticity together with genetic lesions drives tumour progression. This crucial early role for epigenetic alterations in cancer is in addition to epigenetic alterations that can substitute for genetic variation later in tumour progression. Therefore, non-neoplastic but epigenetically disrupted stem/progenitor cells might be a crucial target for cancer risk assessment and chemoprevention.

Causes and consequences of DNA hypomethylation in human cancer

While specific genes are hypermethylated in the genome of cancer cells, overall methylcytosine content is often decreased as a consequence of hypomethylation affecting many repetitive sequences. Hypomethylation is also observed at a number of single-copy genes. While global hypomethylation is highly prevalent across all cancer types, it often displays considerable specificity with regard to tumor type, tumor stage, and sequences affected. Following an overview of hypomethylation alterations in various cancers, this review focuses on 3 hypotheses. First, hypomethylation at a single-copy gene may occur as a 2-step process, in which selection for gene function follows upon random hypo methylation. In this fashion, hypomethylation facilitates the adaptation of cancer cells to the ever-changing tumor tissue microenvironment, particularly during metastasis. Second, the development of global hypomethylation is intimately linked to chromatin restructuring and nuclear disorganization in cancer cells, reflected in a large number of changes in histone-modifying enzymes and other chromatin regulators. Third, DNA hypomethylation may occur at least partly as a consequence of cell cycle deregulation disturbing the coordination between DNA replication and activity of DNA methyltransferases. Finally, because of their relation to tumor progression and metastasis, DNA hypomethylation markers may be particularly useful to classify cancer and predict their clinical course.

Conditional Expression of the CTCF-Paralogous Transcriptional Factor BORIS in Normal Cells Results in Demethylation and Derepression of MAGE-A1 and Reactivation of Other Cancer-Testis Genes

Brother of the Regulator of Imprinted Sites (BORIS) is a mammalian CTCF paralog with the same central 11Zn fingers (11ZF) that mediate specific interactions with varying approximately 50-bp target sites. Regulated in vivo occupancy of such sites may yield structurally and functionally distinct CTCF/DNA complexes involved in various aspects of gene regulation, including epigenetic control of gene imprinting and X chromosome inactivation. The latter functions are mediated by meCpG-sensitive 11ZF binding. Because CTCF is normally present in all somatic cells, whereas BORIS is active only in CTCF- and 5-methylcytosine-deficient adult male germ cells, switching DNA occupancy from CTCF to BORIS was suggested to regulate site specificity and timing of epigenetic reprogramming. In addition to 11ZF-binding paternal imprinting control regions, cancer-testis gene promoters also undergo remethylation during CTCF/BORIS switching in germ cells. Only promoters of cancer testis genes are normally silenced in all somatic cells but activated during spermatogenesis when demethylated in BORIS-positive germ cells and are found aberrantly derepressed in various tumors. We show here that BORIS is also expressed in multiple cancers and is thus itself a cancer-testis gene and that conditional expression of BORIS in normal fibroblasts activates cancer-testis genes selectively. We tested if replacement of CTCF by BORIS on regulatory DNA occurs in vivo on activation of a prototype cancer-testis gene, MAGE-A1. Transition from a hypermethylated/silenced to a hypomethylated/activated status induced in normal cells by 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine (5-azadC) was mimicked by conditional input of BORIS and is associated with complete switching from CTCF to BORIS occupancy at a single 11ZF target. This site manifested a novel type of CTCF/BORIS 11ZF binding insensitive to CpG methylation. Whereas 5-azadC induction of BORIS takes only few hours, derepression of MAGE-A1 occurred 1 to 2 days later, suggesting that BORIS mediates cancer-testis gene activation by 5-azadC. Indeed, infection of normal fibroblasts with anti-BORIS short hairpin RNA retroviruses before treatment with 5-azadC blocked reactivation of MAGE-A1. We suggest that BORIS is likely tethering epigenetic machinery to a novel class of CTCF/BORIS 11ZF target sequences that mediate induction of cancer-testis genes.

Evolutionary biology of cancer

Cancer is driven by the somatic evolution of cell lineages that have escaped controls on replication and by the population-level evolution of genes that influence cancer risk. We describe here how recent evolutionary ecological studies have elucidated the roles of predation by the immune system and competition among normal and cancerous cells in the somatic evolution of cancer. Recent analyses of the evolution of cancer at the population level show how rapid changes in human environments have augmented cancer risk, how strong selection has frequently led to increased cancer risk as a byproduct, and how anticancer selection has led to tumor-suppression systems, tissue designs that slow somatic evolution, constraints on morphological evolution and even senescence itself. We discuss how applications of the tools of ecology and evolutionary biology are poised to revolutionize our understanding and treatment of this disease.

Chaotic tumors and 2 mistakes of molecular oncologists

The structure of DNA is wondrously appealing in its elegant simplicity combined with its captivating power. The power of DNA derives directly from, and solely from, the fact that it represents digital information. However, this delightful digital determinism does not carry over into the multitude of cellular processes, especially in a cancer cell. This means that the sequencing of the human genome has some limitations regarding furthering the understanding of details of cancer cell biochemistry. The fading of digital control in cells, however, seems not well comprehended by most. This factor, together with the loss of DNA stability that is an underpinning of cancer, virtually guarantees that chaotic dynamics are very important in cancer cells. Yet, chaos is very underappreciated in oncology. Failure to appreciate the significance of the dissolution of digital control in cell dynamics and the lack of perception of the importance of chaotic dynamics in the cancer cell are 2 errors that will tend to enhance the frequency of mistakes made in analyzing information from gene expression microarrays, proteomic microarrays, and other advances in molecular oncology. This article explains how these mistakes will come about and why, in some instances, they could result in adverse effects in patient therapy as the goals for targeted, individualized, and molecular-based treatments are sought.

Monoallelic Expression and Asynchronous Replication of p120 Catenin in Mouse and Human Cells

The number of autosomal mammalian genes subject to random monoallelic expression has been limited to genes highly specific to the function of chemosensory neurons or lymphocytes, making this phenomenon difficult to address systematically. Here we demonstrate that asynchronous DNA replication can be used as a marker for the identification of novel genes with monoallelic expression and identify p120 catenin, a gene involved in cell adhesion, as belonging to this class. p120 is widely expressed; its presence in available cell lines allowed us to address quantitative aspects of monoallelic expression. We show that the epigenetic choice of active allele is clonally stable and that biallelic clones express p120 at twice the level of monoallelic clones. Unlike previous reports about genes of this type, we found that expression of p120 can be monoallelic in one cell type and strictly biallelic in another. We show that in human lymphoblasts, the silencing of one allele is incomplete. These unexpected properties are likely to be wide-spread, as we show that the Tlr4 gene shares them. Identification of monoallelic expression of a nearly ubiquitous gene indicates that this type of gene regulation is more common than previously thought. This has important implications for carcinogenesis and definition of cell identity.

Monoallelic methylation of the APC promoter is altered in normal gastric mucosa associated with neoplastic lesions

Adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) promoter hypermethylation has been reported frequently in normal gastric mucosa, but it remained to be clarified whether this occurs in every individual. In this study, methylation of the APC promoter was analyzed in histologically normal-appearing gastric mucosa samples by methylation-sensitive single-strand conformation analysis and by a methylation-sensitive dot blot assay. Epithelial cell samples were collected by microdissection from tissue sections. Equal amounts of methylated and unmethylated APC alleles were found in all gastric mucosa samples from patients without any gastric lesions (20 samples). Allele-specific methylation analysis showed that the methylation of the APC promoter was monoallelic; however, which allele was methylated depended on the cell type. Increased or decreased methylation was found in 10 of 36 (28%) normal gastric mucosa samples adjacent to a gastric or esophageal adenocarcinoma. No allelic loss was found at the APC locus. Modification of the methylation status was also found in 3 of 21 (14%) normal-appearing gastric mucosa samples adjacent to intestinal metaplasia. In contrast, all normal mucosa samples in cases with chronic gastritis but without metaplasia or dysplasia showed a monoallelic methylation pattern. Our results indicate the following: (a) In normal gastric mucosa, the APC promoter shows monoallelic methylation, which is not due to imprinting but most likely due to allelic exclusion; (b) the excluded allele differs between foveolar and glandular epithelial cells; (c) the APC methylation pattern is frequently altered in normal-appearing gastric mucosa of gastric or esophageal adenocarcinoma patients; and (d) such alterations also occur in normal gastric mucosa adjacent to intestinal metaplasia.