Purification and assay of Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB

Single-molecule studies reveal the off-pathway early paused state intermediates as a target of streptolydigin inhibition of RNA polymerase and its dramatic enhancement by Gre factors

Antibiotic streptolydigin (Stl) inhibits bacterial transcription by blocking the trigger loop folding in the active center of RNA polymerase (RNAP), which is essential for catalysis. We use acoustic force spectroscopy to characterize the dynamics of transcription elongation in ternary elongation complexes (ECs) of RNAP in the presence of Stl at a single-molecule level. We found that Stl induces long-lived stochastic pauses while the instantaneous velocity of transcription between the pauses is unaffected. Stl enhances the short-lived pauses associated with an off-pathway early paused state intermediates of the RNAP nucleotide addition cycle. Unexpectedly, we found that transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB, which were thought to be Stl competitors, do not alleviate the Stl-induced pausing; instead, they synergistically increase transcription inhibition by Stl. This is the first known instance of a transcriptional factor enhancing antibiotic activity. We propose a structural model of the EC-Gre-Stl complex that explains the observed Stl activities and provides insight into possible cooperative action of secondary channel factors and other antibiotics binding at the Stl pocket. These results offer a new strategy for high-throughput screening for prospective antibacterial agents.

Single-molecule studies reveal the off-pathway elemental pause state as a target of streptolydigin inhibition of RNA polymerase and its dramatic enhancement by Gre factors

Antibiotic streptolydigin (Stl) inhibits bacterial transcription by blocking the trigger loop folding in the active center of RNA polymerase (RNAP), which is essential for catalysis. We use acoustic force spectroscopy to characterize the dynamics of transcription elongation in ternary elongation complexes of RNAP (ECs) in the presence of Stl at a single-molecule level. We found that Stl induces long-lived stochastic pauses while the instantaneous velocity of transcription between the pauses is unaffected. Stl enhances the short-lived pauses associated with an off-pathway elemental paused state of the RNAP nucleotide addition cycle. Unexpectedly, we found that transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB, which were thought to be Stl competitors, do not alleviate the streptolydigin-induced pausing; instead, they synergistically increase transcription inhibition by Stl. This is the first known instance of a transcriptional factor enhancing antibiotic activity. We propose a structural model of the EC-Gre-Stl complex that explains the observed Stl activities and provides insight into possible cooperative action of secondary channel factors and other antibiotics binding at the Stl-pocket. These results offer a new strategy for high-throughput screening for prospective antibacterial agents.

A universal transcription pause sequence is an element of initiation factor σ70-dependent pausing

The Escherichia coli σ70 initiation factor is required for a post-initiation, promoter-proximal pause essential for regulation of lambdoid phage late gene expression; potentially, σ70 acts at other sites during transcription elongation as well. The pause is induced by σ70 binding to a repeat of the promoter -10 sequence. After σ70 binding, further RNA synthesis occurs as DNA is drawn (or 'scrunched') into the enzyme complex, presumably exactly as occurs during initial synthesis from the promoter; this synthesis then pauses at a defined site several nucleotides downstream from the active center position when σ70 first engages the -10 sequence repeat. We show that the actual pause site in the stabilized, scrunched complex is the 'elemental pause sequence' recognized from its frequent occurrence in the E. coli genome. σ70 binding and the elemental pause sequence together, but neither alone, produce a substantial transcription pause.

Direct assessment of transcription fidelity by high-resolution RNA sequencing

Cancerous and aging cells have long been thought to be impacted by transcription errors that cause genetic and epigenetic changes. Until now, a lack of methodology for directly assessing such errors hindered evaluation of their impact to the cells. We report a high-resolution Illumina RNA-seq method that can assess noncoded base substitutions in mRNA at 10⁻⁴–10⁻⁵ per base frequencies in vitro and in vivo. Statistically reliable detection of changes in transcription fidelity through ∼10³ nt DNA sites assures that the RNA-seq can analyze the fidelity in a large number of the sites where errors occur. A combination of the RNA-seq and biochemical analyses of the positions for the errors revealed two sequence-specific mechanisms that increase transcription fidelity by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase: (i) enhanced suppression of nucleotide misincorporation that improves selectivity for the cognate substrate, and (ii) increased backtracking of the RNA polymerase that decreases a chance of error propagation to the full-length transcript after misincorporation and provides an opportunity to proofread the error. This method is adoptable to a genome-wide assessment of transcription fidelity.

WITHDRAWN: Stimulation of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis transcription elongation by MtbMfd

This article has been withdrawn at the request of the author(s). The Publisher apologizes for any inconvenience this may cause. The full Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal can be found at http://www.elsevier.com/locate/withdrawalpolicy.

An allosteric path to transcription termination

Transcription termination signals in bacteria occur in RNA as a strong hairpin followed by a stretch of U residues at the 3' terminus. To release the transcript, RNA polymerase (RNAP) is thought to translocate forward without RNA synthesis. Here we provide genetic and biochemical evidence supporting an alternative model in which extensive conformational changes across the enzyme lead to termination without forward translocation. In this model, flexible parts of the RNA exit channel (zipper, flap, and zinc finger) assist the initial step of hairpin folding (nucleation). The hairpin then invades the RNAP main channel, causing RNA:DNA hybrid melting, structural changes of the catalytic site, and DNA-clamp opening induced by interaction with the G(trigger)-loop. Our results envision the elongation complex as a flexible structure, not a rigid body, and establish basic principles of the termination pathway that are likely to be universal in prokaryotic and eukaryotic systems.

Analysis of promoter targets for Escherichia coli transcription elongation factor GreA in vivo and in vitro

Transcription elongation factor GreA induces nucleolytic activity of bacterial RNA polymerase (RNAP). In vitro, transcript cleavage by GreA contributes to transcription efficiency by (i) suppressing pauses and arrests, (ii) stimulating RNAP promoter escape, and (iii) enhancing transcription fidelity. However, it is unclear which of these functions is (are) most relevant in vivo. By comparing global gene expression profiles of Escherichia coli strains lacking Gre factors and strains expressing either the wild type (wt) or a functionally inactive GreA mutant, we identified genes that are potential targets of GreA action. Data analysis revealed that in the presence of chromosomally expressed GreA, 19 genes are upregulated; an additional 105 genes are activated upon overexpression of the wt but not the mutant GreA. Primer extension reactions with selected transcription units confirmed the gene array data. The most prominent stimulatory effect (threefold to about sixfold) of GreA was observed for genes of ribosomal protein operons and the tna operon, suggesting that transcript cleavage by GreA contributes to optimal expression levels of these genes in vivo. In vitro transcription assays indicated that the stimulatory effect of GreA upon the transcription of these genes is mostly due to increased RNAP recycling due to facilitated promoter escape. We propose that transcript cleavage during early stages of initiation is thus the main in vivo function of GreA. Surprisingly, the presence of the wt GreA also led to the decreased transcription of many genes. The mechanism of this effect is unknown and may be indirect.

Crystal structure of Thermus aquaticus Gfh1, a Gre-factor paralog that inhibits rather than stimulates transcript cleavage

Transcription elongation in bacteria is promoted by Gre-factors, which stimulate an endogenous, endonucleolytic transcript cleavage activity of the RNA polymerase. A GreA paralog, Gfh1, present in Thermus aquaticus and Thermus thermophilus, has the opposite effect on elongation complexes, inhibiting rather than stimulating transcript cleavage. We have determined the 3.3 angstroms-resolution X-ray crystal structure of T.aquaticus Gfh1. The structure reveals an N-terminal and a C-terminal domain with close structural similarity to the domains of GreA, but with an unexpected conformational change in terms of the orientation of the domains with respect to each other. However, structural and functional analysis suggests that when complexed with RNA polymerase, Gfh1 adopts a conformation similar to that of GreA. These results reveal considerable structural flexibility for Gfh1, and for Gre-factors in general, as suggested by structural modeling, and point to a possible role for the conformational switch in Gre-factor and Gfh1 regulation. The opposite functional effect of Gfh1 compared with GreA may be determined by three structural characteristics. First, Gfh1 lacks the basic patch present in Gre-factors that likely plays a role in anchoring the 3'-fragment of the back-tracked RNA. Second, the loop at the tip of the N-terminal coiled-coil is highly flexible and contains extra acidic residues compared with GreA. Third, the N-terminal coiled-coil finger lacks a kink in the first alpha-helix, resulting in a straight coiled-coil compared with GreA. The latter two characteristics suggest that Gfh1 chelates a magnesium ion in the RNA polymerase active site (like GreA) but in a catalytically inactive configuration.

Transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB act as transient catalytic components of RNA polymerase

Prokaryotic transcription elongation factors GreA and GreB stimulate intrinsic nucleolytic activity of RNA polymerase (RNAP). The proposed biological role of Gre-induced RNA hydrolysis includes transcription proofreading, suppression of transcriptional pausing and arrest, and facilitation of RNAP transition from transcription initiation to transcription elongation. Using an array of biochemical and molecular genetic methods, we mapped the interaction interface between Gre and RNAP and identified the key residues in Gre responsible for induction of nucleolytic activity in RNAP. We propose a structural model in which the C-terminal globular domain of Gre binds near the opening of the RNAP secondary channel, the N-terminal coiled-coil domain (NTD) protrudes inside the RNAP channel, and the tip of the NTD is brought to the immediate vicinity of RNAP catalytic center. Two conserved acidic residues D41 and E44 located at the tip of the NTD assist RNAP by coordinating the Mg2+ ion and water molecule required for catalysis of RNA hydrolysis. If so, Gre would be the first transcription factor known to directly participate in the catalytic act of RNAP.

Structure and function of the transcription elongation factor GreB bound to bacterial RNA polymerase

Bacterial GreA and GreB promote transcription elongation by stimulating an endogenous, endonucleolytic transcript cleavage activity of the RNA polymerase. The structure of Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase bound to GreB was determined by cryo-electron microscopy and image processing of helical crystals to a nominal resolution of 15 A, allowing fitting of high-resolution RNA polymerase and GreB structures. In the resulting model, the GreB N-terminal coiled-coil domain extends 45 A through a channel directly to the RNA polymerase active site. The model leads to detailed insights into the mechanism of Gre factor activity that explains a wide range of experimental observations and points to a key role for conserved acidic residues at the tip of the Gre factor coiled coil in modifying the RNA polymerase active site to catalyze the cleavage reaction. Mutational studies confirm that these positions are critical for Gre factor function.

The many conformational states of RNA polymerase elongation complexes and their roles in the regulation of transcription

Transcription is highly regulated both by protein factors and by specific RNA or DNA sequence elements. Central to this regulation is the ability of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to adopt multiple conformational states during elongation. This review focuses on the mechanism of transcription elongation and the role of different conformational states in the regulation of elongation and termination. The discussion centers primarily on data from structural and functional studies on Escherichia coli RNAP. To introduce the players, a brief introduction to the general mechanism of elongation, the regulatory proteins, and the conformational states is provided. The role of each of the conformational states in elongation is then discussed in detail. Finally, an integrated mechanism of elongation is presented, bringing together the panoply of experiments.

E. coli Transcription repair coupling factor (Mfd protein) rescues arrested complexes by promoting forward translocation

Transcription and DNA repair are coupled in E. coli by the Mfd protein, which dissociates transcription elongation complexes blocked at nonpairing lesions and mediates recruitment of DNA repair proteins. We show that Mfd influences the elongation state of RNA polymerase (RNAP); transcription complexes that have reverse translocated into the backtracked position, a potentially important intermediate in RNA proofreading and repair, are restored to the forward position by the activity of Mfd, and arrested complexes are rescued into productive elongation. Mfd may act through a translocase activity that rewinds upstream DNA, leading either to translocation or to release of RNA polymerase when the enzyme active site cannot continue elongation.

Transcription termination: primary intermediates and secondary adducts

In living organisms, stable elongation complexes of RNA polymerase dissociate at specific template positions in a process of transcription termination. It has been suggested that the dissociation is not the immediate cause of termination but is preceded by catalytic inactivation of the elongation complex. In vitro reducing ionic strength can be used to stabilize very unstable and catalytically inactive complex at the point of termination; the previous biochemical characterization of this complex has led to important conclusions regarding termination mechanism. Here we analyze in detail the complexes formed between DNA template, nascent RNA, and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase during transcription through the tR2 terminator of bacteriophage lambda. At low ionic strength, the majority of elongation complexes fall apart upon reaching the terminator. Released RNA and DNA efficiently rebind RNA polymerase (RNAP) and form binary RNAP.RNA and RNAP.DNA complexes, which are indistinguishable from binary complexes obtained by direct mixing of the purified nucleic acids and the enzyme. A small fraction of elongation complexes that reach termination point escapes dissociation because RNA polymerase has backtracked from the terminator to an upstream DNA position. Thus, transcription elongation to a terminator site produces no termination intermediates that withstand dissociation in the time scale appropriate for biochemical studies.

Conformational switching of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase-promoter binary complex is facilitated by elongation factor GreA and GreB

BACKGROUND

The initiation arrest at a modified lambdaPR promoter is caused by irreversible divergence of the reaction pathway into productive and arrested branches. Escherichia coli GreA and GreB induce cleavage of the nascent transcript and relieve arrest in elongation. They also reduce abortive synthesis at several promoters and relieve initiation arrest. Their mechanism of action during initiation, and its relationship to the branched initiation pathway are unknown.

RESULTS

The Gre factors mitigated initiation arrest only when they were added to the binary complex of the holoenzyme bound to the lambdaPR promoter, prior to RNA synthesis. They exerted little effect when they were added to ternary initiation complexes. They accelerated the exchange of the binary complex with its free components by 6-9-fold. When they are present, a high concentration of the initiating nucleotide increased yield of the full-length transcript, whereas a low concentration did not.

CONCLUSIONS

All the results presented above can be explained by a model where the productive and arrested pathways diverge at the binary complex stage. The Gre factors relieve the initiation arrest by introducing reversibility between subspecies of the binary complex that are precursors of the two pathways. RNA cleavage is unlikely to cause relief of initiation arrest.

Function of transcription cleavage factors GreA and GreB at a regulatory pause site

Gre proteins of prokaryotes, and SII proteins of eukaryotes and archaea, are transcription elongation factors that promote an endogenous transcript cleavage activity of RNA polymerases; this process promotes elongation through obstructive regions of DNA, including transcription pauses that act as sites of genetic regulation. We show that a regulatory pause in the early part of the late gene operon of bacteriophage lambda is subject to such cleavage and resynthesis. In cells lacking the cleavage factors GreA and GreB, the pause is prolonged, and RNA polymerase occupies a variant position at the pause site. Furthermore, GreA and GreB are required to mediate efficient function of the lambda gene Q antiterminator at this site. Thus, cleavage factors are necessary for the natural progression of RNA polymerase in vivo.

The functional role of basic patch, a structural element of Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB

The transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB of Escherichia coli are involved in the regulation of transcription elongation. The surface charge distribution analysis of their three-dimensional structures revealed that the N-terminal domains of GreA and GreB contain a small and large basic "patch," respectively. To elucidate the functional role of basic patch, mutant Gre proteins were engineered in which the size and charge distribution of basic patch were modified and characterized biochemically. We found that Gre mutants lacking basic patch or carrying basic patch of decreased size bind to RNA polymerase and induce transcript cleavage reaction in minimally backtracked ternary elongation complex (TEC) with the same efficiency as the wild type factors. However, they exhibit substantially lower readthrough and cleavage activities toward extensively backtracked and arrested TECs and display decreased efficiency of photocross-linking to the RNA 3'-terminus. Unlike wild type factors, basic patch-less Gre mutants are unable to complement the thermosensitive phenotype of GreA(-):GreB(-) E. coli strain. The large basic patch is required but not sufficient for the induction of GreB-type cleavage reaction and for the cleavage of arrested TECs. Our results demonstrate that the basic patch residues are not directly involved in the induction of transcript cleavage reaction and suggest that the primary role of basic patch is to anchor the nascent RNA in TEC. These interactions are essential for the readthrough and antiarrest activities of Gre factors and, apparently, for their in vivo functions.

Mapping interactions of Escherichia coli GreB with RNA polymerase and ternary elongation complexes

Escherichia coli GreA and GreB modulate transcription elongation by interacting with the ternary elongation complex (containing RNA polymerase, DNA template, and RNA transcript) to induce hydrolytic cleavage of the transcript and release of the 3'-terminal fragment. Hydroxyl radical protein footprinting and alanine-scanning mutagenesis were used to investigate the interactions of GreB with RNA polymerase alone and in a ternary elongation complex. A major determinant for binding GreB to both RNA polymerase and the ternary elongation complex was identified. In addition, the hydroxyl radical footprinting indicated major conformational changes of GreB, in terms of reorientations of the N- and C-terminal domains with respect to each other, particularly upon interactions with the ternary elongation complex.

Visualization of the binding site for the transcript cleavage factor GreB on Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

The structure of Escherichia coli core RNA polymerase (RNAP) complexed with the transcript cleavage factor GreB was determined from electron micrographs of negatively stained, flattened helical crystals. A binding assay was developed to establish that GreB was incorporated into the RNA polymerase crystals with high occupancy through interactions between the globular C-terminal domain and the RNA polymerase. Comparison of the core RNAP:GreB structure with the previously determined structure of core RNAP located the GreB binding site on one face of the RNA polymerase, next to but not in the 25 A-diameter channel of RNA polymerase.

Distinct functions of N and C-terminal domains of GreA, an Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factor

The prokaryotic transcription factors GreA and GreB are involved in the regulation of transcript elongation by RNA polymerase (RNAP). Their known activities include suppression of transcription arrest, enhancement of transcription fidelity, and facilitation of the transition from abortive initiation to productive elongation. Presumably, Gre proteins exert their functions by altering the conformation of the enzyme in ternary elongation complexes (TEC) and inducing the cleavage of nascent RNA. GreA and GreB have a similar structural organization and consist of two domains: a C-terminal globular and an extended N-terminal coiled-coil domain. To investigate the functional roles of Gre domains, we expressed separately the N and C-terminal domains of GreA (NTD and CTD, respectively) and characterized their activities with in vitro assays. We demonstrate that the NTD possesses the residual transcript cleavage activity of the wild-type GreA. The CTD does not display any nucleolytic activity; however, it substantially increases the cleavage activity of the NTD. In contrast to NTD, the CTD competes with GreA and GreB for binding to RNAP and inhibits their transcript cleavage and antiarrest activities. Both domains individually and together inhibit transcription elongation. From these results we conclude that the NTD is responsible for the GreA induction of nucleolytic activity while the CTD determines the binding of GreA to RNAP. Both domains are required for full functional activity of GreA.

Domain organization of Escherichia coli transcript cleavage factors GreA and GreB

The GreA and GreB proteins of Escherichia coli induce cleavage of the nascent transcript in ternary elongation complexes of RNA polymerase. Gre factors are presumed to have two biologically important and evolutionarily conserved functions: the suppression of elongation arrest and the enhancement of transcription fidelity. A three-dimensional structure of GreB was generated by homology modeling on the basis of the known crystal structure of GreA. Both factors display similar overall architecture and surface charge distribution, with characteristic C-terminal globular and N-terminal coiled-coil domains. One major difference between the two factors is the "basic patch" on the surface of the coiled-coil domain, which is much larger in GreB than in GreA. In both proteins, a site near the basic patch cross-links to the 3' terminus of RNA in the ternary transcription complex. GreA/GreB hybrid molecules were constructed by genetic engineering in which the N-terminal domain of one protein was fused to the C-terminal domain of the other. In the hybrid molecules, both the coiled-coil and the globular domains contribute to specific binding of Gre factors to RNA polymerase, whereas the antiarrest activity and the GreA or GreB specificity of transcript cleavage is determined by the N-terminal domain. These results implicate the basic patch of the N-terminal coiled-coil domain as an important functional element responsible for the interactions with nascent transcript and determining the size of the RNA fragment to be excised during the course of the cleavage reaction.