Chapter 7 In Vitro Protein Translocation into Escherichia coli Inverted Membrane Vesicles

Improving cell-free glycoprotein synthesis by characterizing and enriching native membrane vesicles

Cell-free gene expression (CFE) systems from crude cellular extracts have attracted much attention for biomanufacturing and synthetic biology. However, activating membrane-dependent functionality of cell-derived vesicles in bacterial CFE systems has been limited. Here, we address this limitation by characterizing native membrane vesicles in Escherichia coli-based CFE extracts and describing methods to enrich vesicles with heterologous, membrane-bound machinery. As a model, we focus on bacterial glycoengineering. We first use multiple, orthogonal techniques to characterize vesicles and show how extract processing methods can be used to increase concentrations of membrane vesicles in CFE systems. Then, we show that extracts enriched in vesicle number also display enhanced concentrations of heterologous membrane protein cargo. Finally, we apply our methods to enrich membrane-bound oligosaccharyltransferases and lipid-linked oligosaccharides for improving cell-free N-linked and O-linked glycoprotein synthesis. We anticipate that these methods will facilitate on-demand glycoprotein production and enable new CFE systems with membrane-associated activities.

Dissecting structures and functions of SecA-only protein-conducting channels: ATPase, pore structure, ion channel activity, protein translocation, and interaction with SecYEG/SecDF•YajC

SecA is an essential protein in the major bacterial Sec-dependent translocation pathways. E. coli SecA has 901 aminoacyl residues which form multi-functional domains that interact with various ligands to impart function. In this study, we constructed and purified tethered C-terminal deletion fragments of SecA to determine the requirements for N-terminal domains interacting with lipids to provide ATPase activity, pore structure, ion channel activity, protein translocation and interactions with SecYEG-SecDF•YajC. We found that the N-terminal fragment SecAN493 (SecA1-493) has low, intrinsic ATPase activity. Larger fragments have greater activity, becoming highest around N619-N632. Lipids greatly stimulated the ATPase activities of the fragments N608-N798, reaching maximal activities around N619. Three helices in amino-acyl residues SecA619-831, which includes the "Helical Scaffold" Domain (SecA619-668) are critical for pore formation, ion channel activity, and for function with SecYEG-SecDF•YajC. In the presence of liposomes, N-terminal domain fragments of SecA form pore-ring structures at fragment-size N640, ion channel activity around N798, and protein translocation capability around N831. SecA domain fragments ranging in size between N643-N669 are critical for functional interactions with SecYEG-SecDF•YajC. In the presence of liposomes, inactive C-terminal fragments complement smaller non-functional N-terminal fragments to form SecA-only pore structures with ion channel activity and protein translocation ability. Thus, SecA domain fragment interactions with liposomes defined critical structures and functional aspects of SecA-only channels. These data provide the mechanistic basis for SecA to form primitive, low-efficiency, SecA-only protein-conducting channels, as well as the minimal parameters for SecA to interact functionally with SecYEG-SecDF•YajC to form high-efficiency channels.

Biphasic actions of SecA inhibitors on Prl/Sec suppressors: Possible physiological roles of SecA-only channels

SecA is an essential component in the bacterial Sec-dependent protein translocation process. We previously showed that in addition to the ubiquitous, high-affinity SecYEG-SecDF·YajC protein translocation channel, there is a low-affinity SecA-only channel that elicits ion channel activity and promotes protein translocation. The SecA-only channels are less efficient, and like Prl suppressors, lack signal peptide specificity; they function in the absence of signal peptides. The presence of SecYEG-SecDF·YajC alters the sensitivity of ATPase inhibitor Rose Bengal. In this study, we found that the suppressor membranes are much more resistant to inhibition by Rose Bengal. Similar results have been found for a SecA-specific inhibitor. Moreover, biphasic responses of inhibition of ion current and protein translocation activities were observed for many PrlA/SecY and PrlG/SecE suppressor membranes, with a low IC₅₀ value similar to that of the SecA-only channels and a very high IC₅₀. However, the suppressor strains are as sensitive to the inhibitor as the parental strain, suggesting that SecA-only channels have some essential physiological function(s) in the cells that are inhibited by the specific SecA inhibitor.

Using Chemical Probes to Assess the Feasibility of Targeting SecA for Developing Antimicrobial Agents against Gram-Negative Bacteria

With the widespread emergence of drug resistance, there is an urgent need to search for new antimicrobials, especially those against Gram-negative bacteria. Along this line, the identification of viable targets is a critical first step. The protein translocase SecA is commonly believed to be an excellent target for the development of broad-spectrum antimicrobials. In recent years, we developed three structural classes of SecA inhibitors that have proven to be very effective against Gram-positive bacteria. However, we have not achieved the same level of success against Gram-negative bacteria, despite the potent inhibition of SecA in enzyme assays by the same inhibitors. In this study, we use representative inhibitors as chemical probes to gain an understanding as to why these inhibitors were not effective against Gram-negative bacteria. The results validate our initial postulation that the major difference in effectiveness against Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria is in the additional permeability barrier posed by the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. We also found that the expression of efflux pumps, which are responsible for multidrug resistance (MDR), have no effect on the effectiveness of these SecA inhibitors. Identification of an inhibitor-resistant mutant and complementation tests of the plasmids containing secA in a secAts mutant showed that a single secA-azi-9 mutation increased the resistance, providing genetic evidence that SecA is indeed the target of these inhibitors in bacteria. Such results strongly suggest SecA as an excellent target for developing effective antimicrobials against Gram-negative bacteria with the intrinsic ability to overcome MDR. A key future research direction should be the optimization of membrane permeability.

Characterization of the minimal length of functional SecA in Escherichia coli

Previous studies showed that certain regions of E. coli SecA can be deleted from its N- and/or C-termini to complement a SecA amber ts mutant. In this study, we determined and characterized the dispensability of both ends of SecA molecules. With N-terminal intact or 9-aa deleted, 826aa (SecA1-826 and SecA10-826, respectively) is the minimum for complementation activity, while with N-terminus deleted by 2-21aa, SecA22-829 is the minimum. Further deletion at the C-terminus of SecA1-826/SecA10-826/SecA22-829 abolished the complementation activity in the cells. A hydrophobic amino acid is required for the 826th residue in the minimal-length SecAs. Chemical crosslinking and gel filtration result showed that both purified SecA22-828 and SecA22-829 could form a dimer. Moreover, the in vitro ATPase and protein translocation activities of SecA22-828 and SecA22-829 were similar, though lower than wild-type SecA. The active mutants had more truncated SecA in soluble than membrane-bound form, but was more stably embedded in membranes. In contrast, the inactive mutants tended to have truncated SecA more membrane-bound than soluble form, and were more loosely bound and easily chased out. Thus, the loss of complementation appears to be related to their altered subcellular localization and stability in the membranes. This study defines the substantial regions of N- and C-termini of SecA that may be deleted without losing complementation activity.

Mechanisms of Rose Bengal inhibition on SecA ATPase and ion channel activities

SecA is an essential protein possessing ATPase activity in bacterial protein translocation for which Rose Bengal (RB) is the first reported sub-micromolar inhibitor in ATPase activity and protein translocation. Here, we examined the mechanisms of inhibition on various forms of SecA ATPase by conventional enzymatic assays, and by monitoring the SecA-dependent channel activity in the semi-physiological system in cells. We build on the previous observation that SecA with liposomes form active protein-conducting channels in the oocytes. Such ion channel activity is enhanced by purified Escherichia coli SecYEG-SecDF·YajC liposome complexes. Inhibition by RB could be monitored, providing correlation of in vitro activity and intact cell functionality. In this work, we found the intrinsic SecA ATPase is inhibited by RB competitively at low ATP concentration, and non-competitively at high ATP concentrations while the translocation ATPase with precursors and SecYEG is inhibited non-competitively by RB. The Inhibition by RB on SecA channel activity in the oocytes with exogenous ATP-Mg(2+), mimicking translocation ATPase activity, is also non-competitive. The non-competitive inhibition on channel activity has also been observed with SecA from other bacteria which otherwise would be difficult to examine without the cognate precursors and membranes.

Phospholipids induce conformational changes of SecA to form membrane-specific domains: AFM structures and implication on protein-conducting channels

SecA, an essential component of the Sec machinery, exists in a soluble and a membrane form in Escherichia coli. Previous studies have shown that the soluble SecA transforms into pore structures when it interacts with liposomes, and integrates into membranes containing SecYEG in two forms: SecA_S and SecA_M; the latter exemplified by two tryptic membrane-specific domains, an N-terminal domain (N39) and a middle M48 domain (M48). The formation of these lipid-specific domains was further investigated. The N39 and M48 domains are induced only when SecA interacts with anionic liposomes. Additionally, the N-terminus, not the C-terminus of SecA is required for inducing such conformational changes. Proteolytic treatment and sequence analyses showed that liposome-embedded SecA yields the same M48 and N39 domains as does the membrane-embedded SecA. Studies with chemical extraction and resistance to trypsin have also shown that these proteoliposome-embedded SecA fragments exhibit the same stability and characteristics as their membrane-embedded SecA equivalents. Furthermore, the cloned lipid-specific domains N39 and M48, but not N68 or C34, are able to form partial, but imperfect ring-like structures when they interact with phospholipids. These ring-like structures are characteristic of a SecA pore-structure, suggesting that these domains contribute part of the SecA-dependent protein-conducting channel. We, therefore, propose a model in which SecA alone is capable of forming a lipid-specific, asymmetric dimer that is able to function as a viable protein-conducting channel in the membrane, without any requirement for SecYEG.

Specificity of SecYEG for PhoA precursors and SecA homologs on SecA protein-conducting channels

Previous studies showed that Escherichia coli membranes depleted of SecYEG are capable of translocating certain precursor proteins, but not other precursors such as pPhoA, indicating a differential requirement for SecYEG. In this study, we examined the role of SecYEG in pPhoA translocation using a purified reconstituted SecA-liposomes system. We found that translocation of pPhoA, in contrast to that of pOmpA, requires the presence of purified SecYEG. A differential specificity of the SecYEG was also revealed in its interaction with SecA: EcSecYEG did not enhance SecA-mediated pOmpA translocation by purified SecA either from Pseudomonas aeruginosa or Bacillus subtilis. Neither was SecYEG required for eliciting ion channel activity, which could be opened by unfolded pPhoA or unfolded PhoA. Addition of the SecYEG complex did restore the specificity of signal peptide recognition in the ion-channel activity. We concluded that SecYEG confers specificity in interacting with protein precursors and SecAs.

Fluorescein analogues inhibit SecA ATPase: the first sub-micromolar inhibitor of bacterial protein translocation

SecA is a central component of the general secretion system that is essential for bacterial growth and thus an ideal target for antimicrobial agents. A series of fluorescein analogues were first screened against the ATPase activity using the truncated unregulated SecA catalytic domain. Rose bengal (RB) and erythrosin B (EB) were found to be potent inhibitors SecA with IC(50) values of 0.5 μM and 2 μM, respectively. RB and EB inhibit the catalytic SecA ATPase more effectively than the F(1) F(0) -proton ATPase. We used three assays to test the effect of these compounds on full-length SecA ATPase: in solution (intrinsic ATPase), in membrane preparation, and translocation ATPase. RB and EB show the following trend in terms of IC(50) values: translocation ATPase<membrane ATPase<intrinsic ATPase. Very importantly, the potency of these fluorescein analogues in inhibiting the truncated SecA ATPase correlates with their ability to inhibit the biologically relevant protein translocation activity of SecA. The in vitro translocation of proOmpA precursors into membrane vesicles is strongly inhibited by RB with IC(50) values of approximately 0.25 μM, making RB the most potent inhibitor of SecA ATPase and SecA-dependent protein translocation reported thus far. The ability of these compounds to inhibit SecA also directly translates into antibacterial effects. Our findings show the value of fluorescein analogues as probes for mechanistic studies of SecA functions and for the potential development of new antimicrobial agents with SecA as the target.

SecA alone can promote protein translocation and ion channel activity: SecYEG increases efficiency and signal peptide specificity

SecA is an essential component of the Sec-dependent protein translocation pathway across cytoplasmic membranes in bacteria. Escherichia coli SecA binds to cytoplasmic membranes at SecYEG high affinity sites and at phospholipid low affinity sites. It has been widely viewed that SecYEG functions as the essential protein-conducting channel through which precursors cross the membranes in bacterial Sec-dependent pathways, and that SecA functions as a motor to hydrolyze ATP in translocating precursors through SecYEG channels. We have now found that SecA alone can promote precursor translocation into phospholiposomes. Moreover, SecA-liposomes elicit ionic currents in Xenopus oocytes. Patch-clamp recordings further show that SecA alone promotes signal peptide- or precursor-dependent single channel activity. These activities were observed with the functional SecA at about 1-2 μM. The results show that SecA alone is sufficient to promote protein translocation into liposomes and to elicit ionic channel activity at the phospholipids low affinity binding sites, thus indicating that SecA is able to form the protein-conducting channels. Even so, such SecA-liposomes are less efficient than those with a full complement of Sec proteins, and lose the signal-peptide proofreading function, resembling the effects of PrlA mutations. Addition of purified SecYEG restores the signal peptide specificity and increases protein translocation and ion channel activities. These data show that SecA can promote protein translocation and ion channel activities both when it is bound to lipids at low affinity sites and when it is bound to SecYEG with high affinity. The latter of the two interactions confers high efficiency and specificity.

Electrophysiological studies in Xenopus oocytes for the opening of Escherichia coli SecA-dependent protein-conducting channels

Protein translocation in Escherichia coli requires protein-conducting channels in cytoplasmic membranes to allow precursor peptides to pass through with adenosine triphosphate (ATP) hydrolysis. Here, we report a novel, sensitive method that detects the opening of the SecA-dependent protein-conducting channels at the nanogram level. E. coli inverted membrane vesicles were injected into Xenopus oocytes, and ionic currents were recorded using the two-electrode voltage clamp. Currents were observed only in the presence of E. coli SecA in conjunction with E. coli membranes. Observed currents showed outward rectification in the presence of KCl as permeable ions and were significantly enhanced by coinjection with the precursor protein proOmpA or active LamB signal peptide. Channel activity was blockable with sodium azide or adenylyl 5'-(beta,gamma-methylene)-diphosphonate, a nonhydrolyzable ATP analogue, both of which are known to inhibit SecA protein activity. Endogenous oocyte precursor proteins also stimulated ion current activity and can be inhibited by puromycin. In the presence of puromycin, exogenous proOmpA or LamB signal peptides continued to enhance ionic currents. Thus, the requirement of signal peptides and ATP hydrolysis for the SecA-dependent currents resembles biochemical protein translocation assay with E. coli membrane vesicles, indicating that the Xenopus oocyte system provides a sensitive assay to study the role of Sec and precursor proteins in the formation of protein-conducting channels using electrophysiological methods.

Selective SecA association with signal sequences in ribosome-bound nascent chains: a potential role for SecA in ribosome targeting to the bacterial membrane

The role of SecA in selecting bacterial proteins for export was examined using a heterologous system that lacks endogenous SecA and other bacterial proteins. This approach allowed us to assess the interaction of SecA with ribosome-bound photoreactive nascent chains in the absence of trigger factor, SecB, Ffh (the bacterial protein component of the signal recognition particle), and the SecYEG translocon in the bacterial plasma membrane. In the absence of membranes, SecA photocross-linked efficiently to nascent translocation substrate OmpA in ribosome-nascent chain (RNC) complexes in an interaction that was independent of both ATP and SecB. However, no photocross-linking to a nascent membrane protein that is normally targeted by a signal recognition particle was observed. Modification of the signal sequence revealed that its affinity for SecA and Ffh varied inversely. Gel filtration showed that SecA binds tightly to both translating and non-translating ribosomes. When purified SecA.RNC complexes containing nascent OmpA were exposed to inner membrane vesicles lacking functional SecA, the nascent chains were successfully targeted to SecYEG translocons. However, purified RNCs lacking SecA were unable to target to the same membranes. Taken together, these data strongly suggest that cytosolic SecA participates in the selection of proteins for export by co-translationally binding to the signal sequences of non-membrane proteins and directing those nascent chains to the translocon.

Identification and characterization of protease-resistant SecA fragments: secA has two membrane-integral forms

We have identified and characterized the protease-resistant SecA fragments (X. Chen, H. Xu, and P. C. Tai, J. Biol. Chem. 271:29698-29706, 1996) through immunodetection with region-specific antibodies, chemical extraction, and sequencing analysis. The 66-, 36-, and 27-kDa proteolytic fragments in the membranes all start at Met1, whereas the 48-kDa fragment starts at Glu361. The overlapping of the sequences of the 66- and 48-kDa fragments indicates that they are derived from different SecA molecules. These two fragments were generated differently in response to ATP hydrolysis and protein translocation. Furthermore, the presence of membrane is required for the generation of the 48-kDa fragment but not for that of the 66-kDa fragment. These data suggest that there are two different integral forms of SecA in the membrane: SecA(S) and SecA(M). The combination of these two forms of SecA has several membrane-interacting domains. Both forms of SecA are integrated in the membrane, since both the 48- and 66-kDa fragments could be derived from urea- or Na2CO3-washed membranes. Moreover, all fragments are resistant to extraction with a high concentration of salt or with heparin, but the membrane-specific 48-kDa SecA domain is more sensitive to Na2CO3 or urea extraction. This suggests that this domain may interact with other membrane proteins in an aqueous microenvironment and therefore may form a part of the protein-conducting channel.

Targeting of GroEL to SecA on the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli

Chaperonin GroEL has been found to interact with isolated cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli. Interaction requires Mg ions, whereas MgATP inhibits, and inhibition is stronger in the presence of co-chaperonin GroES. "Heat-shock" of the membrane at 45 degrees C destroys irreversibly its ability to bind GroEL. The binding of GroEL is characterized by saturation with a maximum of about 100 pmol GroEL bound per mg of total membrane protein, indicating a limited capacity and specificity of the membrane to bind GroEL. According to results of immunoblotting analysis and cleavable photoactivable cross-linking, a membrane target of GroEL is SecA, a protein known as a central component of the translocation machinery. Moreover, in some cases GroEL could modulate a cycle of association of SecA with the membrane by stimulating release of SecA from the membrane. A physiological role of targeting of GroEL in or close to the protein-conducting membrane apparatus is discussed.

Differential translocation of protein precursors across SecY-deficient membranes of Escherichia coli: SecY is not obligatorily required for translocation of certain secretory proteins in vitro

SecY, a component of the protein translocation system in Escherichia coli, was depleted at a nonpermissive temperature in a strain which had a temperature-sensitive polar effect on the expression of its secY. Membrane vesicles prepared from these cells, when grown at the nonpermissive temperature, contained about 5% SecY and similarly low levels of SecG. As expected, translocation of alkaline phosphatase precursors across these SecY-deficient membranes was severely impaired and appeared to be directly related to the decrease of SecY amounts. However, despite such a dramatic reduction in SecY and SecG levels, these membranes exhibited 50 to 70% of the wild-type translocation activity, including the processing of the signal peptide, of OmpA precursor (proOmpA). This translocation activity in SecY-deficient membranes was still SecA and ATP dependent and was not unique to proOmpA, as lipoprotein and lambda receptor protein precursors were also transported efficiently. Membranes that were reconstituted from these SecY-depleted membranes contained undetectable amounts of SecY yet were also shown to possess substantial translocation activity for proOmpA. These results indicate that the requirement of SecY for translocation is not obligatory for all secretory proteins and may depend on the nature of precursors. Consequently, it is unlikely that SecY is the essential core channel through which all precursors traverse across membranes; rather, SecY probably contributes to efficiency and specificity.

SecE-depleted membranes of Escherichia coli are active. SecE is not obligatorily required for the in vitro translocation of certain protein precursors

Membrane vesicles were prepared from Escherichia coli cells in which SecE was depleted to 2% of wild-type membranes. SecE depletion had pleiotropic effects; SecD, SecF, SecG, and SecY were decreased 4-6-fold, whereas SecA was increased about 16-fold over that of wild-type membranes. These membranes were substantially active in the in vitro translocation of proOmpA, which was mediated by the SecA pathway since it was inhibited by azide. Similar substantial translocation activities were observed for proLamB and proLpp in the SecE-depleted membranes. However, the translocation of proPhoA was more severely impaired. These data indicate that SecE may enhance but is not obligatorily required for the translocation of at least certain precursors, and suggest that the effects of the SecE depletion on protein translocation may be precursor-dependent.

A significant fraction of functional SecA is permanently embedded in the membrane. SecA cycling on and off the membrane is not essential during protein translocation

SecA has been suggested to cycle on and off the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli during protein translocation. We have reconstituted 35S-SecA onto SecA-depleted membrane vesicles and followed the fate of the membrane-associated 35S-SecA during protein translocation. Some 35S-SecA was released from the membranes in a translocation-independent manner. However, a significant fraction of 35S-SecA remained on the membranes even after incubation with excess SecA. This fraction of 35S-SecA was shown to be integrated into the membrane and was active in protein translocation, indicating that SecA cycling on and off membrane is not required for protein translocation. Proteolysis experiments did not support the model of SecA insertion and deinsertion during protein translocation; instead, a major 48-kDa domain was found persistently embedded in the membrane regardless of translocation status. Thus, in addition to catalyzing ATP hydrolysis, certain domains of SecA probably play an important structural role in the translocation machinery, perhaps forming part of the protein-conducting channels.

Processing of colicin V-1, a secretable marker protein of a bacterial ATP binding cassette export system, requires membrane integrity, energy, and cytosolic factors

Extracellular secretion of the peptide antibiotic colicin V (ColV) in Escherichia coli is mediated by a dedicated exporter system consisting of host TolC protein and the products of two specific genes, cvaA and cvaB, the latter being a member of the ATP binding cassette (ABC) superfamily. An amino-terminal export signal of ColV is specific for the CvaA-CvaB-TolC exporter and is processed concomitant with secretion. In this study, we attempt to characterize this processing with a secretable marker protein, ColV-1, using a newly developed in vitro assay. Processing is found to be dependent on both CvaA-CvaB transporters and the TolC protein and to require membrane integrity. An additional cytoplasmic soluble factor(s) is also necessary for the processing. Although the sequence of the cleavage site suggests it could be a substrate, ColV-1 cannot be processed in vitro by the purified leader peptidase I. Moreover, ColV-1 processing is inhibited by antipain and N-ethylmaleimide. Furthermore, the processing requires energy in the form of nucleotide hydrolysis. These results indicate that the processing of ColV-1 is specific and more complex than expected, requiring the CvaA-CvaB-TolC transporter intact in the membrane, energy, and cytosolic factors for rapid cleavage.