Linkage between ATP consumption and mechanical unfolding during the protein processing reactions of an AAA+ degradation machine

Proteolytic stability and aggregation in a key metabolic enzyme of bacteria

Proteins that are kinetically stable are thought to be less prone to both aggregation and proteolysis. We demonstrate that the classical lac system of Escherichia coli can be leveraged as a model system to study this relation. β-galactosidase (LacZ) plays a critical role in lactose metabolism and is an extremely stable protein that can persist in growing cells for multiple generations after expression has stopped. By attaching degradation tags to the LacZ protein, we find that LacZ can be transiently degraded during lac operon expression but once expression has stopped functional LacZ is protected from degradation. We reversibly destabilize its tetrameric assembly using α-complementation, and show that unassembled LacZ monomers and dimers can either be degraded or lead to formation of aggregates within cells, while the tetrameric state protects against proteolysis and aggregation. We show that the presence of aggregates is associated with cell death, and that these proteotoxic stress phenotypes can be alleviated by attaching an ssrA tag to LacZ monomers which leads to their degradation. We unify our findings using a biophysical model that enables the interplay of protein assembly, degradation, and aggregation to be studied quantitatively in vivo. This work may yield approaches to reversing and preventing protein-misfolding disease states, while elucidating the functions of proteolytic stability in constant and fluctuating environments.

Anthrax Toxin: Model System for Studying Protein Translocation

Dedicated translocase channels are nanomachines that often, but not always, unfold and translocate proteins through narrow pores across the membrane. Generally, these molecular machines utilize external sources of free energy to drive these reactions, since folded proteins are thermodynamically stable, and once unfolded they contain immense diffusive configurational entropy. To catalyze unfolding and translocate the unfolded state at appreciable timescales, translocase channels often utilize analogous peptide-clamp active sites. Here we describe how anthrax toxin has been used as a biophysical model system to study protein translocation. The tripartite bacterial toxin is composed of an oligomeric translocase channel, protective antigen (PA), and two enzymes, edema factor (EF) and lethal factor (LF), which are translocated by PA into mammalian host cells. Unfolding and translocation are powered by the endosomal proton gradient and are catalyzed by three peptide-clamp sites in the PA channel: the α clamp, the ϕ clamp, and the charge clamp. These clamp sites interact nonspecifically with the chemically complex translocating chain, serve to minimize unfolded state configurational entropy, and work cooperatively to promote translocation. Two models of proton gradient driven translocation have been proposed: (i) an extended-chain Brownian ratchet mechanism and (ii) a proton-driven helix-compression mechanism. These models are not mutually exclusive; instead the extended-chain Brownian ratchet likely operates on β-sheet sequences and the helix-compression mechanism likely operates on α-helical sequences. Finally, we compare and contrast anthrax toxin with other related and unrelated translocase channels.

Viral Genomic DNA Packaging Machinery

Tailed double-stranded DNA bacteriophage employs a protein terminase motor to package their genome into a preformed protein shell-a system shared with eukaryotic dsDNA viruses such as herpesviruses. DNA packaging motor proteins represent excellent targets for antiviral therapy, with Letermovir, which binds Cytomegalovirus terminase, already licensed as an effective prophylaxis. In the realm of bacterial viruses, these DNA packaging motors comprise three protein constituents: the portal protein, small terminase and large terminase. The portal protein guards the passage of DNA into the preformed protein shell and acts as a protein interaction hub throughout viral assembly. Small terminase recognises the viral DNA and recruits large terminase, which in turn pumps DNA in an ATP-dependent manner. Large terminase also cleaves DNA at the termination of packaging. Multiple high-resolution structures of each component have been resolved for different phages, but it is only more recently that the field has moved towards cryo-EM reconstructions of protein complexes. In conjunction with highly informative single-particle studies of packaging kinetics, these structures have begun to inspire models for the packaging process and its place among other DNA machines.

A proteolytic AAA+ machine poised to unfold a protein substrate

AAA+ proteolytic machines unfold proteins prior to degradation. Cryo-EM of a ClpXP-substrate complex reveals a postulated but heretofore unseen intermediate in substrate unfolding/degradation. The natively folded substrate is drawn tightly against the ClpX channel by interactions between axial pore loops and the substrate degron tail, and by contacts with the native substrate that are, in part, enabled by movement of one ClpX subunit out of the typically observed hexameric spiral.

A closed translocation channel in the substrate-free AAA+ ClpXP protease diminishes rogue degradation

AAA+ proteases degrade intracellular proteins in a highly specific manner. E. coli ClpXP, for example, relies on a C-terminal ssrA tag or other terminal degron sequences to recognize proteins, which are then unfolded by ClpX and subsequently translocated through its axial channel and into the degradation chamber of ClpP for proteolysis. Prior cryo-EM structures reveal that the ssrA tag initially binds to a ClpX conformation in which the axial channel is closed by a pore-2 loop. Here, we show that substrate-free ClpXP has a nearly identical closed-channel conformation. We destabilize this closed-channel conformation by deleting residues from the ClpX pore-2 loop. Strikingly, open-channel ClpXP variants degrade non-native proteins lacking degrons faster than the parental enzymes in vitro but degraded GFP-ssrA more slowly. When expressed in E. coli, these open channel variants behave similarly to the wild-type enzyme in assays of filamentation and phage-Mu plating but resulted in reduced growth phenotypes at elevated temperatures or when cells were exposed to sub-lethal antibiotic concentrations. Thus, channel closure is an important determinant of ClpXP degradation specificity.

Single-molecule dynamics show a transient lipopolysaccharide transport bridge

Gram-negative bacteria are surrounded by two membranes. A special feature of the outer membrane is its asymmetry. It contains lipopolysaccharide (LPS) in the outer leaflet and phospholipids in the inner leaflet1-3. The proper assembly of LPS in the outer membrane is required for cell viability and provides Gram-negative bacteria intrinsic resistance to many classes of antibiotics. LPS biosynthesis is completed in the inner membrane, so the LPS must be extracted, moved across the aqueous periplasm that separates the two membranes and translocated through the outer membrane where it assembles on the cell surface4. LPS transport and assembly requires seven conserved and essential LPS transport components5 (LptA-G). This system has been proposed to form a continuous protein bridge that provides a path for LPS to reach the cell surface6,7, but this model has not been validated in living cells. Here, using single-molecule tracking, we show that Lpt protein dynamics are consistent with the bridge model. Half of the inner membrane Lpt proteins exist in a bridge state, and bridges persist for 5-10 s, showing that their organization is highly dynamic. LPS facilitates Lpt bridge formation, suggesting a mechanism by which the production of LPS can be directly coupled to its transport. Finally, the bridge decay kinetics suggest that there may be two different types of bridges, whose stability differs according to the presence (long-lived) or absence (short-lived) of LPS. Together, our data support a model in which LPS is both a substrate and a structural component of dynamic Lpt bridges that promote outer membrane assembly.

Multi-pass, single-molecule nanopore reading of long protein strands with single-amino acid sensitivity

The ability to sequence single protein molecules in their native, full-length form would enable a more comprehensive understanding of proteomic diversity. Current technologies, however, are limited in achieving this goal. Here, we establish a method for long-range, single-molecule reading of intact protein strands on a commercial nanopore sensor array. By using the ClpX unfoldase to ratchet proteins through a CsgG nanopore, we achieve single-amino acid level sensitivity, enabling sequencing of combinations of amino acid substitutions across long protein strands. For greater sequencing accuracy, we demonstrate the ability to reread individual protein molecules, spanning hundreds of amino acids in length, multiple times, and explore the potential for high accuracy protein barcode sequencing. Further, we develop a biophysical model that can simulate raw nanopore signals a priori, based on amino acid volume and charge, enhancing the interpretation of raw signal data. Finally, we apply these methods to examine intact, folded protein domains for complete end-to-end analysis. These results provide proof-of-concept for a platform that has the potential to identify and characterize full-length proteoforms at single-molecule resolution.

Lon degrades stable substrates slowly but with enhanced processivity, redefining the attributes of a successful AAA+ protease

Lon is a widely distributed AAA+ (ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities) protease known for degrading poorly folded and damaged proteins and is often classified as a weak protein unfoldase. Here, using a Lon-degron pair from Mesoplasma florum (MfLon and MfssrA, respectively), we perform ensemble and single-molecule experiments to elucidate the molecular mechanisms underpinning MfLon function. Notably, we find that MfLon unfolds and degrades stably folded substrates and that translocation of these unfolded polypeptides occurs with a ∼6-amino-acid step size. Moreover, the time required to hydrolyze one ATP corresponds to the dwell time between steps, indicating that one step occurs per ATP-hydrolysis-fueled "power stroke." Comparison of MfLon to related AAA+ enzymes now provides strong evidence that HCLR-clade enzymes function using a shared power-stroke mechanism and, surprisingly, that MfLon is more processive than ClpXP and ClpAP. We propose that ample unfoldase strength and substantial processivity are features that contribute to the Lon family's evolutionary success.

Acyldepsipeptide Antibiotics and a Bioactive Fragment Thereof Differentially Perturb Mycobacterium tuberculosis ClpXP1P2 Activity in Vitro

Proteolytic complexes in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), the deadliest bacterial pathogen, are major foci in tuberculosis drug development programs. The Clp proteases, which are essential for Mtb viability, are high-priority targets. These proteases function through the collaboration of ClpP1P2, a barrel-shaped heteromeric peptidase, with associated ATP-dependent chaperones like ClpX and ClpC1 that recognize and unfold specific substrates in an ATP-dependent fashion. The critical interaction of the peptidase and its unfoldase partners is blocked by the competitive binding of acyldepsipeptide antibiotics (ADEPs) to the interfaces of the ClpP2 subunits. The resulting inhibition of Clp protease activity is lethal to Mtb. Here, we report the surprising discovery that a fragment of the ADEPs retains anti-Mtb activity yet stimulates rather than inhibits the ClpXP1P2-catalyzed degradation of proteins. Our data further suggest that the fragment stabilizes the ClpXP1P2 complex and binds ClpP1P2 in a fashion distinct from that of the intact ADEPs. A structure-activity relationship study of the bioactive fragment defines the pharmacophore and points the way toward the development of new drug leads for the treatment of tuberculosis.

The Ubiquitin-26S Proteasome Pathway and Its Role in the Ripening of Fleshy Fruits

The 26S proteasome is an ATP-dependent proteolytic complex in eukaryotes, which is mainly responsible for the degradation of damaged and misfolded proteins and some regulatory proteins in cells, and it is essential to maintain the balance of protein levels in the cell. The ubiquitin-26S proteasome pathway, which targets a wide range of protein substrates in plants, is an important post-translational regulatory mechanism involved in various stages of plant growth and development and in the maturation process of fleshy fruits. Fleshy fruit ripening is a complex biological process, which is the sum of a series of physiological and biochemical reactions, including the biosynthesis and signal transduction of ripening related hormones, pigment metabolism, fruit texture changes and the formation of nutritional quality. This paper reviews the structure of the 26S proteasome and the mechanism of the ubiquitin-26S proteasome pathway, and it summarizes the function of this pathway in the ripening process of fleshy fruits.

FtsH degrades kinetically stable dimers of cyclopropane fatty acid synthase via an internal degron

Targeted protein degradation plays important roles in stress responses in all cells. In E. coli, the membrane-bound AAA+ FtsH protease degrades cytoplasmic and membrane proteins. Here, we demonstrate that FtsH degrades cyclopropane fatty acid (CFA) synthase, whose synthesis is induced upon nutrient deprivation and entry into stationary phase. We find that neither the disordered N-terminal residues nor the structured C-terminal residues of the kinetically stable CFA-synthase dimer are required for FtsH recognition and degradation. Experiments with fusion proteins support a model in which an internal degron mediates FtsH recognition as a prelude to unfolding and proteolysis. These findings elucidate the terminal step in the life cycle of CFA synthase and provide new insight into FtsH function.

Ubiquitin modulates 26S proteasome conformational dynamics and promotes substrate degradation

The 26S proteasome recognizes thousands of appropriate protein substrates in eukaryotic cells through attached ubiquitin chains and uses its adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) motor for mechanical unfolding and translocation into a proteolytic chamber. Here, we used single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer measurements to monitor the conformational dynamics of the proteasome, observe individual substrates during their progression toward degradation, and elucidate how these processes are regulated by ubiquitin chains. Rapid transitions between engagement- and processing-competent proteasome conformations control substrate access to the ATPase motor. Ubiquitin chain binding functions as an allosteric regulator to slow these transitions, stabilize the engagement-competent state, and aid substrate capture to accelerate degradation initiation. Upon substrate engagement, the proteasome remains in processing-competent states for translocation and unfolding, except for apparent motor slips when encountering stably folded domains. Our studies revealed how ubiquitin chains allosterically regulate degradation initiation, which ensures substrate selectivity in a crowded cellular environment.

The activated ClpP peptidase forcefully grips a protein substrate

ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA+) proteases power the maintenance of protein homeostasis by coupling ATP hydrolysis to mechanical protein unfolding, translocation, and ultimately degradation. Although ATPase activity drives a large portion of the mechanical work these molecular machines perform, how the peptidase contributes to the forceful denaturation and processive threading of substrates remains unknown. Here, using single-molecule optical trapping, we examine the mechanical activity of the caseinolytic peptidase P (ClpP) from Escherichia coli in the absence of a partner ATPase and in the presence of an activating small-molecule acyldepsipeptide. We demonstrate that ClpP grips protein substrate under mechanical loads exceeding 40 pN, which are greater than those observed for the AAA+ unfoldase ClpX and the AAA+ protease complexes ClpXP and ClpAP. We further characterize substrate-ClpP bond lifetimes and rupture forces under varying loads. We find that the resulting slip bond behavior does not depend on ClpP peptidase activity. In addition, we find that unloaded bond lifetimes between ClpP and protein substrate are on a timescale relevant to unfolding times (up to ∼160 s) for difficult to unfold model substrate proteins. These direct measurements of the substrate-peptidase bond under load define key properties required by AAA+ proteases to mechanically unfold and degrade protein substrates.

ATP hydrolysis tunes specificity of a AAA+ protease

In bacteria, AAA+ proteases such as Lon and ClpXP degrade substrates with exquisite specificity. These machines capture the energy of ATP hydrolysis to power unfolding and degradation of target substrates. Here, we show that a mutation in the ATP binding site of ClpX shifts protease specificity to promote degradation of normally Lon-restricted substrates. However, this ClpX mutant is worse at degrading ClpXP targets, suggesting an optimal balance in substrate preference for a given protease that is easy to alter. In vitro, wild-type ClpXP also degrades Lon-restricted substrates more readily when ATP levels are reduced, similar to the shifted specificity of mutant ClpXP, which has altered ATP hydrolysis kinetics. Based on these results, we suggest that the rates of ATP hydrolysis not only power substrate unfolding and degradation, but also tune protease specificity. We consider various models for this effect based on emerging structures of AAA+ machines showing conformationally distinct states.

Single-molecule microscopy reveals diverse actions of substrate sequences that impair ClpX AAA+ ATPase function

AAA+ (ATPases Associated with diverse cellular Activities) proteases unfold substrate proteins by pulling the substrate polypeptide through a narrow pore. To overcome the barrier to unfolding, substrates may require extended association with the ATPase. Failed unfolding attempts can lead to a slip of grip, which may result in substrate dissociation, but how substrate sequence affects slippage is unresolved. Here, we measured single-molecule dwell time using TIRF (Total Internal Reflection Fluorescence) microscopy, scoring time-dependent dissociation of engaged substrates from bacterial AAA+ ATPase unfoldase/translocase ClpX. Substrates comprising a stable domain resistant to unfolding and a C-terminal unstructured tail, tagged with a degron for initiating translocase insertion, were used to determine dwell time in relation to tail length and composition. We found greater tail length promoted substrate retention during futile unfolding. Additionally, we tested two tail compositions known to frustrate unfolding. A poly-glycine tract (polyG) promoted substrate release, but only when adjacent to the folded domain, whereas glycine-alanine repeats (GAr) did not promote release. A high-complexity motif containing polar and charged residues also promoted release. We further investigated the impact of these and related motifs on substrate degradation rates and ATP consumption, using the unfoldase-protease complex ClpXP. Here, substrate domain stability modulates the effects of substrate tail sequences. Although polyG and GAr are both inhibitory for unfolding, they act in different ways. GAr motifs only negatively affected degradation of highly stable substrates, which is accompanied by reduced ClpXP ATPase activity. Together, our results specify substrate characteristics that affect unfolding and degradation by ClpXP.

FtsH degrades dihydrofolate reductase by recognizing a partially folded species

AAA+ proteolytic machines play essential roles in maintaining and rebalancing the cellular proteome in response to stress, developmental cues, and environmental changes. Of the five AAA+ proteases in Escherichia coli, FtsH is unique in its attachment to the inner membrane and its function in degrading both membrane and cytosolic proteins. E. coli dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) is a stable and biophysically well-characterized protein, which a previous study found resisted FtsH degradation despite the presence of an ssrA degron. By contrast, we find that FtsH degrades DHFR fused to a long peptide linker and ssrA tag. Surprisingly, we also find that FtsH degrades DHFR with shorter linkers and ssrA tag, and without any linker or tag. Thus, FtsH must be able to recognize a sequence element or elements within DHFR. We find that FtsH degradation of DHFR is noncanonical in the sense that it does not rely upon recognition of an unstructured polypeptide at or near the N-terminus or C-terminus of the substrate. Results using peptide-array experiments, mutant DHFR proteins, and fusion proteins suggest that FtsH recognizes an internal sequence in a species of DHFR that is partially unfolded. Overall, our findings provide insight into substrate recognition by FtsH and indicate that its degradation capacity is broader than previously reported.

Structure and function of ClpXP, a AAA+ proteolytic machine powered by probabilistic ATP hydrolysis

ClpXP is an archetypical AAA+ protease, consisting of ClpX and ClpP. ClpX is an ATP-dependent protein unfoldase and polypeptide translocase, whereas ClpP is a self-compartmentalized peptidase. ClpXP is currently the only AAA+ protease for which high-resolution structures exist, the molecular basis of recognition for a protein substrate is understood, extensive biochemical and genetic analysis have been performed, and single-molecule optical trapping has allowed direct visualization of the kinetics of substrate unfolding and translocation. In this review, we discuss our current understanding of ClpXP structure and function, evaluate competing sequential and probabilistic mechanisms of ATP hydrolysis, and highlight open questions for future exploration.

Chicken-Derived Pattern Recognition Receptor chLGP2 Inhibits the Replication and Proliferation of Infectious Bronchitis Virus

The widespread nature and economic importance of Infectious bronchitis virus (IBV) and interactions between IBV and the host immune response remain poorly understood. Understanding the mechanism of virus recognition via innate immunity can help resist IBV invasion. Retinoic acid-induced gene I-like receptor (RLRs) recognize virus RNA in virus infection, and LGP2 is a member of RLRs. According to the current studies, LGP2 exhibited certain inhibition in the virus, and there is a lack of investigation for chicken’s LGP2. It is important to figure out the role of chLGP2 in host immune recognition of IBV. Our results showed that chLGP2 inhibited the proliferation of IBV Beaudette in cells. Also, chLGP2 can identify and combine with IBV RNA. The domains of chLGP2 were separately expressed and inspired by related literature, and the chLGP2 K30A mutant was constructed. Our results suggested its structural integrity and the adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity are critical for IBV inhibiting activity. chTRBP was selected after CO-IP and Mass spectrometry test. We found chTRBP and chLGP2 are the interacting partners and promote mutual expression. Our study showed that chTRBP could also suppress IBV infections via chLGP2, which provided a basis for future innate immunity research for IBV.

AAA+ protease-adaptor structures reveal altered conformations and ring specialization

ClpAP, a two-ring AAA+ protease, degrades N-end-rule proteins bound by the ClpS adaptor. Here we present high-resolution cryo-EM structures of Escherichia coli ClpAPS complexes, showing how ClpA pore loops interact with the ClpS N-terminal extension (NTE), which is normally intrinsically disordered. In two classes, the NTE is bound by a spiral of pore-1 and pore-2 loops in a manner similar to substrate-polypeptide binding by many AAA+ unfoldases. Kinetic studies reveal that pore-2 loops of the ClpA D1 ring catalyze the protein remodeling required for substrate delivery by ClpS. In a third class, D2 pore-1 loops are rotated, tucked away from the channel and do not bind the NTE, demonstrating asymmetry in engagement by the D1 and D2 rings. These studies show additional structures and functions for key AAA+ elements. Pore-loop tucking may be used broadly by AAA+ unfoldases, for example, during enzyme pausing/unloading.

Division of labor between the pore-1 loops of the D1 and D2 AAA+ rings coordinates substrate selectivity of the ClpAP protease

ClpAP, an ATP-dependent protease consisting of ClpA, a double-ring hexameric unfoldase of the ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities superfamily, and the ClpP peptidase, degrades damaged and unneeded proteins to support cellular proteostasis. ClpA recognizes many protein substrates directly, but it can also be regulated by an adapter, ClpS, that modifies ClpA’s substrate profile toward N-degron substrates. Conserved tyrosines in the 12 pore-1 loops lining the central channel of the stacked D1 and D2 rings of ClpA are critical for degradation, but the roles of these residues in individual steps during direct or adapter-mediated degradation are poorly understood. Using engineered ClpA hexamers with zero, three, or six pore-1 loop mutations in each ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities superfamily ring, we found that active D1 pore loops initiate productive engagement of substrates, whereas active D2 pore loops are most important for mediating the robust unfolding of stable native substrates. In complex with ClpS, active D1 pore loops are required to form a high affinity ClpA•ClpS•substrate complex, but D2 pore loops are needed to “tug on” and remodel ClpS to transfer the N-degron substrate to ClpA. Overall, we find that the pore-1 loop tyrosines in D1 are critical for direct substrate engagement, whereas ClpS-mediated substrate delivery requires unique contributions from both the D1 and D2 pore loops. In conclusion, our study illustrates how pore loop engagement, substrate capture, and powering of the unfolding/translocation steps are distributed between the two rings of ClpA, illuminating new mechanistic features that may be common to double-ring protein unfolding machines.

The Non-dominant AAA+ Ring in the ClpAP Protease Functions as an Anti-stalling Motor to Accelerate Protein Unfolding and Translocation

ATP-powered unfoldases containing D1 and D2 AAA+ rings play important roles in protein homeostasis, but uncertainty about the function of each ring remains. Here we use single-molecule optical tweezers to assay mechanical unfolding and translocation by a variant of the ClpAP protease containing an ATPase-inactive D1 ring. This variant displays substantial mechanical defects in both unfolding and translocation of protein substrates. Notably, when D1 is hydrolytically inactive, ClpAP often stalls for times as long as minutes, and the substrate can back-slip through the enzyme when ATP concentrations are low. The inactive D1 variant also has more difficulty traveling in the N-to-C direction on a polypeptide track than it does moving in a C-to-N direction. These results indicate that D1 normally functions as an auxiliary/regulatory motor to promote uninterrupted enzyme advancement that is fueled largely by the D2 ring.

Bioenergetics in environmental adaptation and stress tolerance of aquatic ectotherms: linking physiology and ecology in a multi-stressor landscape

Energy metabolism (encompassing energy assimilation, conversion and utilization) plays a central role in all life processes and serves as a link between the organismal physiology, behavior and ecology. Metabolic rates define the physiological and life-history performance of an organism, have direct implications for Darwinian fitness, and affect ecologically relevant traits such as the trophic relationships, productivity and ecosystem engineering functions. Natural environmental variability and anthropogenic changes expose aquatic ectotherms to multiple stressors that can strongly affect their energy metabolism and thereby modify the energy fluxes within an organism and in the ecosystem. This Review focuses on the role of bioenergetic disturbances and metabolic adjustments in responses to multiple stressors (especially the general cellular stress response), provides examples of the effects of multiple stressors on energy intake, assimilation, conversion and expenditure, and discusses the conceptual and quantitative approaches to identify and mechanistically explain the energy trade-offs in multiple stressor scenarios, and link the cellular and organismal bioenergetics with fitness, productivity and/or ecological functions of aquatic ectotherms.

ATP utilization by a DEAD-box protein during refolding of a misfolded group I intron ribozyme

DEAD-box helicase proteins perform ATP-dependent rearrangements of structured RNAs throughout RNA biology. Short RNA helices are unwound in a single ATPase cycle, but the ATP requirement for more complex RNA structural rearrangements is unknown. Here we measure the amount of ATP used for native refolding of a misfolded group I intron ribozyme by CYT-19, a Neurospora crassa DEAD-box protein that functions as a general chaperone for mitochondrial group I introns. By comparing the rates of ATP hydrolysis and ribozyme refolding, we find that several hundred ATP molecules are hydrolyzed during refolding of each ribozyme molecule. After subtracting nonproductive ATP hydrolysis that occurs in the absence of ribozyme refolding, we find that approximately 100 ATPs are hydrolyzed per refolded RNA as a consequence of interactions specific to the misfolded ribozyme. This value is insensitive to changes in ATP and CYT-19 concentration and decreases with decreasing ribozyme stability. Because of earlier findings that ∼90% of global ribozyme unfolding cycles lead back to the kinetically preferred misfolded conformation and are not observed, we estimate that each global unfolding cycle consumes ∼10 ATPs. Our results indicate that CYT-19 functions as a general RNA chaperone by using a stochastic, energy-intensive mechanism to promote RNA unfolding and refolding, suggesting an evolutionary convergence with protein chaperones.

ClpAP proteolysis does not require rotation of the ClpA unfoldase relative to ClpP

AAA+ proteases perform regulated protein degradation in all kingdoms of life and consist of a hexameric AAA+ unfoldase/translocase in complex with a self-compartmentalized peptidase. Based on asymmetric features of cryo-EM structures and a sequential hand-over-hand model of substrate translocation, recent publications have proposed that the AAA+ unfoldases ClpA and ClpX rotate with respect to their partner peptidase ClpP to allow function. Here, we test this model by covalently crosslinking ClpA to ClpP to prevent rotation. We find that crosslinked ClpAP complexes unfold, translocate, and degrade protein substrates in vitro, albeit modestly slower than uncrosslinked enzyme controls. Rotation of ClpA with respect to ClpP is therefore not required for ClpAP protease activity, although some flexibility in how the AAA+ ring docks with ClpP may be necessary for optimal function.

Multistep substrate binding and engagement by the AAA+ ClpXP protease

Escherichia coli ClpXP is one of the most thoroughly studied AAA+ proteases, but relatively little is known about the reactions that allow it to bind and then engage specific protein substrates before the adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-fueled mechanical unfolding and translocation steps that lead to processive degradation. Here, we employ a fluorescence-quenching assay to study the binding of ssrA-tagged substrates to ClpXP. Polyphasic stopped-flow association and dissociation kinetics support the existence of at least three distinct substrate-bound complexes. These kinetic data fit well to a model in which ClpXP and substrate form an initial recognition complex followed by an intermediate complex and then, an engaged complex that is competent for substrate unfolding. The initial association and dissociation steps do not require ATP hydrolysis, but subsequent forward and reverse kinetic steps are accelerated by faster ATP hydrolysis. Our results, together with recent cryo-EM structures of ClpXP bound to substrates, support a model in which the ssrA degron initially binds in the top portion of the axial channel of the ClpX hexamer and then is translocated deeper into the channel in steps that eventually pull the native portion of the substrate against the channel opening. Reversible initial substrate binding allows ClpXP to check potential substrates for degrons, potentially increasing specificity. Subsequent substrate engagement steps allow ClpXP to grip a wide variety of sequences to ensure efficient unfolding and translocation of almost any native substrate.

Modular and coordinated activity of AAA+ active sites in the double-ring ClpA unfoldase of the ClpAP protease

Understanding of how ClpA and other double-ring AAA+ enzymes perform mechanical work is limited. Using site-specific cross-linking and mutagenesis, we introduced ATPase-inactive AAA+ modules at alternating positions in individual ClpA rings, or in both rings, to investigate potential active-site coordination during ClpAP degradation. ClpA variants containing alternating active/inactive ATPase modules processively unfolded, translocated, and supported ClpP degradation of protein substrates with energetic efficiencies similar to, or higher than, completely active ClpA. These results impact current models describing the mechanisms of AAA+ family enzymes. The cross-linking/mutagenesis method we employed will also be useful for answering other structure-function questions about ClpA and related double-ring enzymes.

ClpA is a hexameric double-ring AAA+ unfoldase/translocase that functions with the ClpP peptidase to degrade proteins that are damaged or unneeded. How the 12 ATPase active sites of ClpA, 6 in the D1 ring and 6 in the D2 ring, work together to fuel ATP-dependent degradation is not understood. We use site-specific cross-linking to engineer ClpA hexamers with alternating ATPase-active and ATPase-inactive modules in the D1 ring, the D2 ring, or both rings to determine if these active sites function together. Our results demonstrate that D2 modules coordinate with D1 modules and ClpP during mechanical work. However, there is no requirement for adjacent modules in either ring to be active for efficient enzyme function. Notably, ClpAP variants with just three alternating active D2 modules are robust protein translocases and function with double the energetic efficiency of ClpAP variants with completely active D2 rings. Although D2 is the more powerful motor, three or six active D1 modules are important for high enzyme processivity, which depends on D1 and D2 acting coordinately. These results challenge sequential models of ATP hydrolysis and coupled mechanical work by ClpAP and provide an engineering strategy that will be useful in testing other aspects of ClpAP mechanism.

The Intrinsically Disordered N-terminal Extension of the ClpS Adaptor Reprograms Its Partner AAA+ ClpAP Protease

Adaptor proteins modulate substrate selection by AAA+ proteases. The ClpS adaptor delivers N-degron substrates to ClpAP but inhibits degradation of substrates bearing ssrA tags or other related degrons. How ClpS inhibits degradation of such substrates is poorly understood. Here, we demonstrate that ClpS impedes recognition of ssrA-tagged substrates by a non-competitive mechanism and also slows subsequent unfolding/translocation of these substrates as well as of N-degron substrates. This suppression of mechanical activity is largely a consequence of the ability of ClpS to repress ATP hydrolysis by ClpA, but several lines of evidence show that ClpS's inhibition of substrate binding and its ATPase repression are separable activities. Using ClpS mutants and ClpS-ClpA chimeras, we establish that engagement of the intrinsically disordered N-terminal extension of ClpS by ClpA is both necessary and sufficient to inhibit multiple steps of ClpAP-catalyzed degradation. These observations reveal how an adaptor can simultaneously modulate the catalytic activity of a AAA+ enzyme, efficiently promote recognition of some substrates, suppress recognition of other substrates, and thereby affect degradation of its menu of substrates in a specific manner. We propose that similar mechanisms are likely to be used by other adaptors to regulate substrate choice and the catalytic activity of molecular machines.

Observing Protein Degradation by the PAN-20S Proteasome by Time-Resolved Neutron Scattering

The proteasome is a key player of regulated protein degradation in all kingdoms of life. Although recent atomic structures have provided snapshots on a number of conformations, data on substrate states and populations during the active degradation process in solution remain scarce. Here, we use time-resolved small-angle neutron scattering of a deuterium-labeled GFPssrA substrate and an unlabeled archaeal PAN-20S system to obtain direct structural information on substrate states during ATP-driven unfolding and subsequent proteolysis in solution. We find that native GFPssrA structures are degraded in a biexponential process, which correlates strongly with ATP hydrolysis, the loss of fluorescence, and the buildup of small oligopeptide products. Our solution structural data support a model in which the substrate is directly translocated from PAN into the 20S proteolytic chamber, after a first, to our knowledge, successful unfolding process that represents a point of no return and thus prevents dissociation of the complex and the release of harmful, aggregation-prone products.

Structures of the ATP-fueled ClpXP proteolytic machine bound to protein substrate

ClpXP is an ATP-dependent protease in which the ClpX AAA+ motor binds, unfolds, and translocates specific protein substrates into the degradation chamber of ClpP. We present cryo-EM studies of the E. coli enzyme that show how asymmetric hexameric rings of ClpX bind symmetric heptameric rings of ClpP and interact with protein substrates. Subunits in the ClpX hexamer assume a spiral conformation and interact with two-residue segments of substrate in the axial channel, as observed for other AAA+ proteases and protein-remodeling machines. Strictly sequential models of ATP hydrolysis and a power stroke that moves two residues of the substrate per translocation step have been inferred from these structural features for other AAA+ unfoldases, but biochemical and single-molecule biophysical studies indicate that ClpXP operates by a probabilistic mechanism in which five to eight residues are translocated for each ATP hydrolyzed. We propose structure-based models that could account for the functional results.

Protein knots provide mechano-resilience to an AAA+ protease-mediated proteolysis with profound ATP energy expenses

Knotted proteins are some of the most fascinating examples of how linear polypeptide chains can achieve intricate topological arrangements efficiently and spontaneously. The entanglements of polypeptide chains could potentially enhance their folding stabilities. We recently reported the unprecedented mechanostability of the Gordian (5₂) knotted family of human ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolases (UCHs) in the context of withstanding the mechanical unfolding of the bacterial AAA+ proteasome, ClpXP; a green fluorescence protein (GFP) was fused to the N-terminus of various UCHs as a reporter of the unfolding and degradation of these topologically knotted substrates, but it also limited the ability to examine the effect of untying the knotted topology via N-terminal truncation. In this study, we directly monitored the ClpXP-mediated degradation of UCH variants by electrophoresis and quantitative imaging analyses. We demonstrated that untying of the 5₂ knot in UCHL1 via N-terminal truncation (UCHL1_Δ11) significantly reduces its mechanostability. We further quantified the ATP expenditures of degrading different UCH variants by ClpXP. The unknotted UCHL1_Δ11 underwent accelerated ClpXP-dependent proteolysis, with a 30-fold reduction in ATP consumption compared to the knotted wild type. Unlike all other known ClpXP substrates, UCHL5, which is the most resilient substrate known to date, significantly slowed down the ATP turnover rate by ClpXP. Furthermore, UCHL5 required 1000-fold more ATP to be fully degraded by ClpXP compared to GFP. Our results underscored how the complex, knotted folding topology in UCHs may interfere with the mechano-unfolding processes of the AAA+ unfoldase, ClpX.

Regulation of Proteasome Activity by (Post-)transcriptional Mechanisms

Intracellular protein synthesis, folding, and degradation are tightly controlled processes to ensure proper protein homeostasis. The proteasome is responsible for the degradation of the majority of intracellular proteins, which are often targeted for degradation via polyubiquitination. However, the degradation rate of proteins is also affected by the capacity of proteasomes to recognize and degrade these substrate proteins. This capacity is regulated by a variety of proteasome modulations including (1) changes in complex composition, (2) post-translational modifications, and (3) altered transcription of proteasomal subunits and activators. Various diseases are linked to proteasome modulation and altered proteasome function. A better understanding of these modulations may offer new perspectives for therapeutic intervention. Here we present an overview of these three proteasome modulating mechanisms to give better insight into the diversity of proteasomes.

Interactions between a subset of substrate side chains and AAA+ motor pore loops determine grip during protein unfolding

Most AAA+ remodeling motors denature proteins by pulling on the peptide termini of folded substrates, but it is not well-understood how motors produce grip when resisting a folded domain. Here, at single amino-acid resolution, we identify the determinants of grip by measuring how substrate tail sequences alter the unfolding activity of the unfoldase-protease ClpXP. The seven amino acids abutting a stable substrate domain are key, with residues 2-6 forming a core that contributes most significantly to grip. ClpX grips large hydrophobic and aromatic side chains strongly and small, polar, or charged side chains weakly. Multiple side chains interact with pore loops synergistically to strengthen grip. In combination with recent structures, our results support a mechanism in which unfolding grip is primarily mediated by non-specific van der Waal's interactions between core side chains of the substrate tail and a subset of YVG loops at the top of the ClpX axial pore.

Proteolysis mediated by the membrane-integrated ATP-dependent protease FtsH has a unique nonlinear dependence on ATP hydrolysis rates

ATPases associated with diverse cellular activities (AAA+) proteases utilize ATP hydrolysis to actively unfold native or misfolded proteins and translocate them into a protease chamber for degradation. This basic mechanism yields diverse cellular consequences, including the removal of misfolded proteins, control of regulatory circuits, and remodeling of protein conformation. Among various bacterial AAA+ proteases, FtsH is only membrane-integrated and plays a key role in membrane protein quality control. Previously, we have shown that FtsH has substantial unfoldase activity for degrading membrane proteins overcoming a dual energetic burden of substrate unfolding and membrane dislocation. Here, we asked how efficiently FtsH utilizes ATP hydrolysis to degrade membrane proteins. To answer this question, we measured degradation rates of the model membrane substrate GlpG at various ATP hydrolysis rates in the lipid bilayers. We find that the dependence of degradation rates on ATP hydrolysis rates is highly nonlinear: (i) FtsH cannot degrade GlpG until it reaches a threshold ATP hydrolysis rate; (ii) after exceeding the threshold, the degradation rates steeply increase and saturate at the ATP hydrolysis rates far below the maxima. During the steep increase, FtsH efficiently utilizes ATP hydrolysis for degradation, consuming only 40-60% of the total ATP cost measured at the maximal ATP hydrolysis rates. This behavior does not fundamentally change against water-soluble substrates as well as upon addition of the macromolecular crowding agent Ficoll 70. The Hill analysis shows that the nonlinearity stems from coupling of three to five ATP hydrolysis events to degradation, which represents unique cooperativity compared to other AAA+ proteases including ClpXP, HslUV, Lon, and proteasomes.

The 26S Proteasome Utilizes a Kinetic Gateway to Prioritize Substrate Degradation

The 26S proteasome is the principal macromolecular machine responsible for protein degradation in eukaryotes. However, little is known about the detailed kinetics and coordination of the underlying substrate-processing steps of the proteasome, and their correlation with observed conformational states. Here, we used reconstituted 26S proteasomes with unnatural amino-acid-attached fluorophores in a series of FRET- and anisotropy-based assays to probe substrate-proteasome interactions, the individual steps of the processing pathway, and the conformational state of the proteasome itself. We develop a complete kinetic picture of proteasomal degradation, which reveals that the engagement steps prior to substrate commitment are fast relative to subsequent deubiquitination, translocation, and unfolding. Furthermore, we find that non-ideal substrates are rapidly rejected by the proteasome, which thus employs a kinetic proofreading mechanism to ensure degradation fidelity and substrate prioritization.

The AAA+ protease ClpXP can easily degrade a 31 and a 52-knotted protein

Knots in proteins are hypothesized to make them resistant to enzymatic degradation by ATP-dependent proteases and recent studies have shown that whereas ClpXP can easily degrade a protein with a shallow 3₁ knot, it cannot degrade 5₂-knotted proteins if degradation is initiated at the C-terminus. Here, we present detailed studies of the degradation of both 3₁- and 5₂-knotted proteins by ClpXP using numerous constructs where proteins are tagged for degradation at both N- and C-termini. Our results confirm and extend earlier work and show that ClpXP can easily degrade a deeply 3₁-knotted protein. In contrast to recently published work on the degradation of 5₂-knotted proteins, our results show that the ClpXP machinery can also easily degrade these proteins. However, the degradation depends critically on the location of the degradation tag and the local stability near the tag. Our results are consistent with mechanisms in which either the knot simply slips along the polypeptide chain and falls off the free terminus, or one in which the tightened knot enters the translocation pore of ClpXP. Results of experiments on knotted protein fusions with a highly stable domain show partial degradation and the formation of degradation intermediates.

Clostridium difficile ClpP Homologues are Capable of Uncoupled Activity and Exhibit Different Levels of Susceptibility to Acyldepsipeptide Modulation

Caseinolytic protease P (ClpP) has emerged as a promising new target for antibacterial development. While ClpPs from single isoform expressing bacteria have been studied in detail, the function and regulation of systems with more than one ClpP homologue are still poorly understood. Herein, we present fundamental studies toward understanding the ClpP system in C. difficile, an anaerobic spore-forming pathogen that contains two chromosomally distant isoforms of ClpP. Examination of proteomic and genomic data suggest that ClpP1 is the primary isoform responsible for normal growth and virulence, but little is known about the function of ClpP2 or the context required for the formation of functional proteases. For the first time in a pathogenic bacterium, we demonstrate that both isoforms are capable of forming operative proteases. Interestingly, ClpP1 is the only homologue that possesses characteristic response to small molecule acyldepsipeptide activation. On the contrary, both ClpP1 and ClpP2 respond to cochaperone activation to degrade an ssrA-tagged substrate. These observations indicate that ClpP2 is less susceptible to acyldepsipeptide activation but retains the ability to interact with a known cochaperone. Homology models reveal no obvious characteristics that would allow one to predict less efficient acyldepsipeptide binding. The reported findings establish the uniqueness of the ClpP system in C. difficile, open new avenues of inquiry, and highlight the importance of more detailed structural, genetic, and biological characterization of the ClpP system in C. difficile.

Hinge-Linker Elements in the AAA+ Protein Unfoldase ClpX Mediate Intersubunit Communication, Assembly, and Mechanical Activity

The ClpXP protease plays important roles in protein homeostasis and quality control. ClpX is a ring-shaped AAA+ homohexamer that unfolds target proteins and translocates them into the ClpP peptidase for degradation. AAA+ modules in each ClpX subunit-consisting of a large AAA+ domain, a short hinge-linker element, and a small AAA+ domain-mediate the mechanical activities of the ring hexamer. Here, we investigate the roles of these hinge-linker elements in ClpX function. Deleting one hinge-linker element in a single-chain ClpX pseudohexamer dramatically decreases unfolding and degradation activity, in part by compromising the formation of closed rings, protein-substrate binding, and ClpP binding. Covalently reclosing the broken hinge-linker interface rescues activity. Deleting one hinge-linker element from a single-chain dimer or trimer prevents assembly of stable hexamers. Mutationally disrupting a hinge-linker element preserves closed-ring assembly but reduces ATP-hydrolysis cooperativity and degradation activity. These results indicate that hinge-linker length and flexibility are optimized for efficient substrate unfolding and support a model in which the hinge-linker elements of ClpX facilitate efficient degradation both by maintaining proper ring geometry and facilitating subunit-subunit communication. This model informs our understanding of ClpX as well as the larger AAA+ family of motor proteins, which play diverse roles in converting chemical into mechanical energy in all cells.

ATPase and Protease Domain Movements in the Bacterial AAA+ Protease FtsH Are Driven by Thermal Fluctuations

AAA+ proteases are essential players in cellular pathways of protein degradation. Elucidating their conformational behavior is key for understanding their reaction mechanism and, importantly, for elaborating our understanding of mutation-induced protease deficiencies. Here, we study the structural dynamics of the Thermotoga maritima AAA+ hexameric ring metalloprotease FtsH (TmFtsH). Using a single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer approach to monitor ATPase and protease inter-domain conformational changes in real time, we show that TmFtsH-even in the absence of nucleotide-is a highly dynamic protease undergoing sequential transitions between five states on the second timescale. Addition of ATP does not influence the number of states or change the timescale of domain motions but affects the state occupancy distribution leading to an inter-domain compaction. These findings suggest that thermal energy, but not chemical energy, provides the major driving force for conformational switching, while ATP, through a state reequilibration, introduces directionality into this process. The TmFtsH A359V mutation, a homolog of the human pathogenic A510V mutation of paraplegin (SPG7) causing hereditary spastic paraplegia, does not affect the dynamic behavior of the protease but impairs the ATP-coupled domain compaction and, thus, may account for protease malfunctioning and pathogenesis in hereditary spastic paraplegia.

Regulated Proteolysis in Bacteria

Regulated proteolysis is a vital process that affects all living things. Bacteria use energy-dependent AAA+ proteases to power degradation of misfolded and native regulatory proteins. Given that proteolysis is an irreversible event, specificity and selectivity in degrading substrates are key. Specificity is often augmented through the use of adaptors that modify the inherent specificity of the proteolytic machinery. Regulated protein degradation is intricately linked to quality control, cell-cycle progression, and physiological transitions. In this review, we highlight recent work that has shed light on our understanding of regulated proteolysis in bacteria. We discuss the role AAA+ proteases play during balanced growth as well as how these proteases are deployed during changes in growth. We present examples of how protease selectivity can be controlled in increasingly complex ways. Finally, we describe how coupling a core recognition determinant to one or more modifying agents is a general theme for regulated protein degradation.

Topologically knotted deubiquitinases exhibit unprecedented mechanostability to withstand the proteolysis by an AAA+ protease

More than one thousand knotted protein structures have been identified so far, but the functional roles of these knots remain elusive. It has been postulated that backbone entanglement may provide additional mechanostability. Here, we employed a bacterial proteasome, ClpXP, to mechanically unfold 5₂-knotted human ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase (UCH) paralogs from their C-termini, followed by processive translocation into the proteolytic chamber for degradation. Our results revealed unprecedentedly slow kinetics of ClpXP-mediated proteolysis for the proteasome-associated UCHL5: ten thousand times slower than that of a green fluorescence protein (GFP), which has a comparable size to the UCH domain but much higher chemical and thermal stabilities. The ClpXP-dependent mechanostability positively correlates with the intrinsic unfolding rates of the substrates, spanning over several orders of magnitude for the UCHs. The broad range of mechanostability within the same protein family may be associated with the functional requirements for their differential malleabilities.

Folding-Degradation Relationship of a Membrane Protein Mediated by the Universally Conserved ATP-Dependent Protease FtsH

ATP-dependent protein degradation mediated by AAA+ proteases is one of the major cellular pathways for protein quality control and regulation of functional networks. While a majority of studies of protein degradation have focused on water-soluble proteins, it is not well understood how membrane proteins with abnormal conformation are selectively degraded. The knowledge gap stems from the lack of an in vitro system in which detailed molecular mechanisms can be studied as well as difficulties in studying membrane protein folding in lipid bilayers. To quantitatively define the folding-degradation relationship of membrane proteins, we reconstituted the degradation using the conserved membrane-integrated AAA+ protease FtsH as a model degradation machine and the stable helical-bundle membrane protein GlpG as a model substrate in the lipid bilayer environment. We demonstrate that FtsH possesses a substantial ability to actively unfold GlpG, and the degradation significantly depends on the stability and hydrophobicity near the degradation marker. We find that FtsH hydrolyzes 380-550 ATP molecules to degrade one copy of GlpG. Remarkably, FtsH overcomes the dual-energetic burden of substrate unfolding and membrane dislocation with the ATP cost comparable to that for water-soluble substrates by robust ClpAP/XP proteases. The physical principles elucidated in this study provide general insights into membrane protein degradation mediated by ATP-dependent proteolytic systems.

Structure of the mitochondrial inner membrane AAA+ protease YME1 gives insight into substrate processing

We present an atomic model of a substrate-bound inner mitochondrial membrane AAA+ quality control protease in yeast, YME1. Our ~3.4-angstrom cryo-electron microscopy structure reveals how the adenosine triphosphatases (ATPases) form a closed spiral staircase encircling an unfolded substrate, directing it toward the flat, symmetric protease ring. Three coexisting nucleotide states allosterically induce distinct positioning of tyrosines in the central channel, resulting in substrate engagement and translocation to the negatively charged proteolytic chamber. This tight coordination by a network of conserved residues defines a sequential, around-the-ring adenosine triphosphate hydrolysis cycle that results in stepwise substrate translocation. A hingelike linker accommodates the large-scale nucleotide-driven motions of the ATPase spiral relative to the planar proteolytic base. The translocation mechanism is likely conserved for other AAA+ ATPases.

Single-molecule peptide fingerprinting

Proteomic analyses provide essential information on molecular pathways of cellular systems and the state of a living organism. Mass spectrometry is currently the first choice for proteomic analysis. However, the requirement for a large amount of sample renders a small-scale proteomics study challenging. Here, we demonstrate a proof of concept of single-molecule FRET-based protein fingerprinting. We harnessed the AAA+ protease ClpXP to scan peptides. By using donor fluorophore-labeled ClpP, we sequentially read out FRET signals from acceptor-labeled amino acids of peptides. The repurposed ClpXP exhibits unidirectional processing with high processivity and has the potential to detect low-abundance proteins. Our technique is a promising approach for sequencing protein substrates using a small amount of sample.

Optimization of ClpXP activity and protein synthesis in an E. coli extract-based cell-free expression system

Protein degradation is a fundamental process in all living cells and is essential to remove both damaged proteins and intact proteins that are no longer needed by the cell. We are interested in creating synthetic genetic circuits that function in a cell-free expression system. This will require not only an efficient protein expression platform but also a robust protein degradation system in cell extract. Therefore, we purified and tested the activity of E. coli ClpXP protease in cell-free transcription-translation (TX-TL) systems that used E. coli S30 cell extract. Surprisingly, our studies showed that purified ClpXP added to the TX-TL system has very low proteolytic activity. The low activity of ClpXP was correlated with the rapid consumption of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) in cell extract. We improved the activity of ClpXP in cell extract by adding exogenous ATP and an energy regeneration system. We then established conditions for both protein synthesis, and protein degradation by ClpXP to occur simultaneously in the TX-TL systems. The optimized conditions for ClpXP activity will be useful for creating tunable synthetic genetic circuits and in vitro synthetic biology.