Effects of follicular status at treatment on follicular development and ovulation in response to FSH in Spanish merino ewes

Repeated superovulation using a simplified FSH/eCG treatment for in vivo embryo production in sheep

This study investigated the efficacy of a simplified repeated superovulation treatment (eCG plus FSH in a single dose, rather than the usual protocol of six decreasing doses of FSH) in the in vivo embryo production in Ojalada donor ewes during the breeding season. In vitro viability after vitrification and warming of embryos recovered from both treatments was also assessed. In addition, the study examined the effects of the concentration of anti-eCG antibodies before each eCG/FSH treatment on in vivo embryo production. Thirty-eight females at the end of their reproductive lives were given the decreasing (n = 19) or simplified (n = 19) superovulatory treatment up to three times at intervals of ≥ 50 d. The onset of estrus was 5 h earlier (P < 0.05) among ewes that received the eCG/FSH protocol (25.2 ± 0.80 h) than it was among those that received the decreasing superovulatory treatment (30.1 ± 1.0 h), but the two treatments did not differ significantly in ovulation rates or the number and viability of embryos recovered. Both of the superovulatory protocols were significantly (P < 0.05 to P < 0.01) less effective after the first application. After three superovulatory treatments, the average number of viable embryos per ewe was 14.1 ± 2.3 and 13.7 ± 2.5 in the decreasing and simplified protocols, respectively. High anti-eCG antibody concentrations just before the superovulatory treatment with eCG/FSH were associated with a significant decrease (P < 0.05) in the rates of fertilization, viability, and freezability, especially in the second and third recoveries. Repeated superovulatory treatments with eCG/FSH can provide an efficient means of producing high quality embryos in the ewes of endangered breeds at the end of their reproductive lives, although further studies are needed to characterize the response associated with high concentrations of anti-eCG antibodies.

Simplified superovulatory treatments in Corriedale ewes

Two experiments were designed to evaluate the possibility of simplifying superovulatory treatments in Corriedale ewes with use of ovine FSH (oFSH). Ewes received intravaginal progestogen sponges for 14 days. In Experiment 1, several simplified schedules were tested. Ewes were treated with 176 NIH-FSH-S1 units' oFSH given as a single injection in saline, along with 500 IU eCG 48 h before sponge removal (Group A1), in four equal doses (B1), or given as a single injection in a polyvinylpyrrolidone vehicle (C1) 24 h before sponge removal. In Experiment 2, the simplified protocol that exhibited the most desirable results in Experiment 1 (A2) was compared with the same protocol, but using less oFSH (132 units) (B2) and with the most conventional protocol (176 units of oFSH in eight decreasing doses; C2). Estrus was detected and ewes were naturally mated. The ovarian response and embryo production were assessed on Day 6 after estrus. LH was measured at 6h intervals from pessary withdrawal. The onset of estrus and the pre-ovulatory LH surge were advanced (P<0.05) in ewes treated with FSH and eCG. In Experiment 1, protocol A1 produced a greater percentage of superovulated ewes compared to C1 (100.0 compared with 58.3%; P<0.05), increased ovulation rate (13.8 corpora lutea compared with 6.2 and 4.7 for B1 and C1, respectively; P<0.05), and tended to increase the number of transferable embryos compared to B1 (P=0.08). In Experiment 2, percentages of superovulated ewes and ovulation rates were similar among groups; however, Group A2 tended to have more large follicles (P=0.07) than C2. The number of transferable embryos was similar among the three treatments. In conclusion, the reduced-dose oFSH given once along with eCG is the most appropriate superovulatory treatment because it combines simplicity and a lesser dose of gonadotropin, which also implies a reduction in cost, without reducing embryo production.

Features of follicle-stimulating hormone-stimulated follicles in a sheep model: keys to elucidate embryo failure in assisted reproductive technique cycles

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the individual functionality of gonadotropin-stimulated preovulatory follicles, for understanding embryo failure in assisted reproductive technique cycles, in a sheep model.

DESIGN

Observational, model study.

SETTING

Public research unit.

ANIMAL(S)

Fifteen adult Manchega ewes.

INTERVENTION(S)

Synchronization of the estrous cycle with intravaginal progestagens and ovarian stimulation with FSH; evaluation of reproductive activity, plasma sampling, ovarian ultrasonography, and ovariectomies.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Determination of estrus behavior, plasma and intrafollicular concentrations of E(2) and inhibin A, number and size of ovarian follicles, and developmental competence of oocytes.

RESULT(S)

These results support the usefulness of serial measurements of plasma inhibin A for assessment of follicular growth during the FSH treatment, rather than of E(2) assays commonly used. Functionality of FSH-stimulated preovulatory follicles is clearly disturbed, as confirmed by a negative correlation between follicular size and intrafollicular concentrations of inhibin A and E(2) in preovulatory follicles after individual dissection; moreover, the ability of their oocytes to resume meiosis was diminished.

CONCLUSION(S)

Functionality of follicles in controlled ovarian stimulation (COS), and developmental competence of their oocytes, is disturbed by the high doses of gonadotropin supplied and finally determined by follicular sizes at starting FSH treatment.

Association between numbers of ovarian follicles in the first follicle wave and superovulatory response in ewes

The aim of this study was to examine the variability in the number of ovarian follicles in sheep and to determine if the average number of follicles per day influences the response to superovulation and resulting embryo quality. Ewes (n=83) were synchronized and the number of follicles (> or =2 mm diameter) in the ovaries were counted daily between Days 0 and 4 of the oestrous cycle using transrectal ultrasonography. Fourteen to 21 days later, 47 ewes were randomly chosen from the group and were treated with an intravaginal progestagen pessary for 12 days and superovulated with 1500 IU eCG administered as a single injection 10 days after sponge insertion. Ewes were mated and reproductive tracts were recovered after slaughter on Day 6 of pregnancy. The number of corpora lutea was counted, uterine horns were flushed and the morphology and developmental stage of the recovered oocytes/embryos was assessed. The mean daily number (+/-S.D.) (> or =2 mm diameter) of follicles per ewe was 8.5+/-2.8 (ranging between 3 and 16). After superovulation animals with few follicles (Low group: <8 follicles/day; n=21) had fewer (P<0.005) corpora lutea, total structures (unfertilized oocytes and embryos), good quality and total embryos compared to animals with many follicles (High group: > or =8 follicles/day; n=23). No difference was found in the proportion of good quality embryos (relative to the total number; Low 0.68+/-0.11 versus High 0.79+/-0.08; P=0.21) between the two groups, or the recovery rate, the number of unfertilized oocytes or the number of poor quality embryos per animal. We conclude that ewes with a higher number of follicles (> or =8) during the first follicular wave had a better superovulatory response (in terms of corpora lutea and high quality embryos) 2-3 weeks later; however, there was no relationship between the number of follicles and the proportion of good quality embryos per animal.

The effects of previous ovarian status on ovulation rate and early embryo development in response to superovulatory FSH treatments in sheep

A total of 64 ewes was used to determine if the changes in superovulatory yields related to the ovarian status at the start of superovulatory treatment are due to differences in the population of gonadotrophin-responsive follicles, alterations in the processes of ovulation or transport of embryos from oviduct to uterus and/or developmental competence of the oocyte/embryo. Ovarian status at the start of a superovulatory FSH step-down treatment, administered coincidentally with a progestagen, was assessed by ultrasonography. On Day 4 after progestagen withdrawal, embryos were recovered from oviduct and their viability was determined by assessing development in vitro culture (IVC) until the hatched blastocyst stage. In all the ewes, the ovulation rate was related positively to the number of 2-3 mm follicles at first FSH injection (P<0.005). However, the total number of embryos and their viability were related to the more limited category of 3 mm follicles (P<0.05), whereas a higher degeneration rate was related to the number of 2mm follicles. The presence of a corpus luteum (CL) at the start of superovulatory treatment exerted a protective effect on embryonic viability, decreasing the degeneration of embryos. On the other hand, the presence of a dominant follicle at first FSH dose affected the mean size of the pool of follicles responding to the superovulation treatment, because ovulation arose from 3 to 5 mm follicles in absence of large follicles (P<0.05), but from 2 to 3 mm follicles when large follicles were present (P<0.005), indicating atresia in medium sized follicles in the presence of a large follicle.

Multiple factors affecting the efficiency of multiple ovulation and embryo transfer in sheep and goats

This review offers an overview of the basic characteristics of in vivo embryo technologies, their current status, the main findings and the advances gained in recent years, and the outstanding subjects for increasing their efficiency. The use of superovulation and embryo transfer procedures remains affected by a high variability in the ovulatory response to hormonal treatment and by a low and variable number of transferable embryos and offspring obtained. This variability has been classically identified with both extrinsic (source, purity of gonadotrophins and protocol of administration) and intrinsic factors (breed, age, nutrition and reproductive status), which are reviewed in this paper. However, emerging data indicate that the main causes of variability are related to endocrine and ovarian factors, and so the number of studies and procedures addressing a better understanding and control of these factors may be increased in the future. The accomplishment of this objective, the improvement of procedures for embryo conservation and for the selection and management of recipient females, will allow further development and application of this technology.

Ovarian follicle growth and consequences for fertility in sheep

Understanding the pattern of ovarian follicle development is seen as an important step leading to the development of techniques that maximise fertility in sheep. Repeated observations of the growth of individual follicles have led to the understanding that follicles develop in a wave-like pattern during the oestrous cycle, with two to four waves per cycle being the most common. The ease with which follicle waves are described seems to depend on the their frequency and the number of follicles per wave. There is evidence for the largest follicle(s) of a follicle wave inhibiting the development of other follicles; however, in some cases this is not apparent as other follicle waves emerge when a previous large, healthy follicle is still present. Follicle development can be manipulated using exogenous gonadotrophins or progestagens and these have been shown to alter the number or age profile of developing follicles. The ovulation of aged follicles in cattle clearly has a detrimental effect on fertility, but this relationship is less clear and seems to be less critical in sheep. Recent findings at the molecular level show that the bone morphogenetic proteins (BMP) and their receptors are critically involved in the control of ovulation rate, but fully understanding their mechanism remains to be described. This highlights the potential for the integration of molecular and physiological findings to better develop methods to manipulate follicle development and reproduction in sheep.

Effects of a 6-day treatment with medroxyprogesterone acetate after prostaglandin F2 alpha-induced luteolysis at midcycle on antral follicular development and ovulation rate in nonprolific Western white-faced ewes

Medroxyprogesterone acetate (MAP) from intravaginal sponges prolongs the lifespan of large ovarian follicles when administered after prostaglandin F2alpha (PGF2alpha)-induced luteolysis early in the luteal phase of ewes. The present study was designed to determine whether a PGF2alpha/MAP treatment applied at midcycle would alter the pattern of antral follicle growth and increase ovulation rate in nonprolific ewes. A single injection of PGF2alpha (15 mg, i.m.) was given, and an intravaginal MAP (60 mg) sponge was inserted for 6 days, on approximately Day 8 after ovulation, in 7 (experiment 1), 8 (experiment 2) or 11 (experiment 3) ultrasonographically monitored, cycling Western white-faced ewes; seven ewes (experiment 1) served as untreated controls. Blood samples were collected each day and also every 12 min for 6 h, halfway through the period of treatment with MAP (experiment 1), or every 4 h, from 1 day before to 1 day after sponging (experiment 2). Seventeen of 26 treated ewes (experiment 1, n = 6; experiment 2, n = 5; experiment 3, n = 6) ovulated 1 to 6 days after PGF2alpha, but this did not affect the emergence of ensuing follicular waves (experiments 1 and 2). These ovulations, confirmed by laparotomy and histological examinations of the ovaries (experiment 3), were not preceded by an increase in LH/FSH secretion and did not result in corpora lutea, as evidenced by transrectal ultrasonography and RIA of serum progesterone (experiments 1 and 2). Following the removal of MAP sponges, the mean ovulation rate was 3.1 +/- 0.4 in treated ewes and 2.0 +/- 0.3 in control ewes (experiment 1; P < 0.05). In experiments 1 and 2, the ovulation rate after treatment (3.1 +/- 0.4 and 2.8 +/- 0.4) was also greater than the pretreatment rate (1.9 +/- 0.3 and 1.9 +/- 0.1, respectively). Ovulations of follicles from two consecutive waves before ovulation were seen in five treated but only in two control ewes (experiment 1), and in seven ewes in experiment 2. There were no significant differences between the MAP-treated and control ewes in mean daily serum concentrations of FSH and estradiol, and no differences in the parameters of LH/FSH secretion, based on frequent blood sampling. Treatment of nonprolific Western white-faced ewes with PGF2alpha and MAP at midcycle changed follicular dynamics and increased ovulation rate by approximately 50%. These effects of MAP, in the absence of luteal progesterone, may not be mediated by changes in gonadotropin secretion.

Patterns of follicular growth in superovulated sheep and influence on endocrine and ovarian response

Objectives of this study were to characterize patterns of follicular development in sheep superovulated with purified follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) (OVAGEN, ICP, Auckland, New Zealand) and to determine its influence on preovulatory events (onset of the oestrus behaviour and timing of the preovulatory luteinizing hormone surge) and ovarian response (ovulation rate and embryo yield). Number and size of all >/= 23 mm follicles from the first FSH injection to withdrawal of progestagen sponges was determined by transrectal ultrasonography just prior to every FSH injection in nine Manchega ewes superovulated with eight decreasing doses (ml) (1.5 x 3, 1.25 x 2 and 1 x 3) of OVAGEN injected twice daily from 60 h before to 24 h after the withdrawal of 40 mg fluorogestone acetate sponges. Oestrous detection and jugular blood sampling for LH radioimmunoassay were performed every 3 h from 14 to 53 h after sponge removal and ovulation rate and number of embryos were determined 4 days after progestagen withdrawal. Administration of OVAGEN induced a significant rise (p < 0.0005) in the number of follicles >/= 4 mm in size because of an increased growth in size of follicles from the first FSH injection to sponge removal, an increase in the number of newly detected follicles from 12 to 36 h of the first FSH dose (p < 0.005) and a decrease in regression rate from 24 h (p < 0.001). The number of follicles 2-3 mm in size at first FSH dose (10.4 +/- 1.5) was positively correlated with the number of >/= 4 mm follicles at 0 h (19.0 +/- 2.7, p < 0.01). A higher number of >/= 4 mm follicles at 0 h was related with an earlier appearance of oestrus (31.5 +/- 1.5 h, p = 0.08) and LH surge (45.0 +/- 2.3 h, p < 0.005), and a higher ovulation rate (18.2 +/- 3.8, p < 0.005). On the other hand, the rate of embryo recovery was decreased in ewes with earlier preovulatory LH peaks (p < 0.005), with a shorter interval between oestrus and LH peak (p < 0.05).

Measurement of inhibin A and follicular status predict the response of ewes to superovulatory FSH treatments

Variability in superovulatory response to FSH stimulation is common to most mammals and imposes practical problems for assisted reproduction. In sheep, we have studied if this response is related to the ovarian follicular population and activity before the stimulation. During the breeding season, 30 ewes were treated with 40 mg FGA sponges for 14 days and 125 microg cloprostenol injection on Day 12, considering Day 0 as the day of progestagen insertion. Superovulatory response was induced with two different FSH regimes using the same total dose (8.8 mg), administered twice daily from 60 h before to 24 h after progestagen withdrawal. At the first FSH injection, all follicles > or = 2 mm were observed by transrectal ultrasonography and plasma FSH and inhibin A levels were determined. The number of corpora lutea and the number of and viability of recovered embryos in response to the treatment were determined on Day 7 after sponge withdrawal. No significant differences were found between treatments. The total mean number of corpora lutea (11.5 +/- 1.2) and recovered embryos (7.9 +/- 1.1) were positively correlated (P < 0.05 and <0.01, respectively) with the number of small antral follicles (2-3 mm: 9.2 +/- 0.7) and inhibin A concentration (240 +/- 18 pg/ml; P < 0.05 for corpora lutea and P < 0.005 for recovered embryos) observed at the onset of the superovulatory treatment, which was also positively correlated with the number of viable embryos (5.8 +/- 0.9, P < 0.005). In 18 ewes with follicles > or = 6 mm prior to FSH treatment, the ovulation rate was unaffected but the number of embryos (6.1 +/- 0.9 versus 11.6 +/- 2; P < 0.05) and their viability (4.5 +/- 0.8 versus 8.5 +/- 2; P < 0.05) was reduced. The lower number of embryos produced when a large follicle is present suggest that a proportion of the smaller follicles are in early stages of atresia and the developmental competence of their oocyte is compromised.

Effects of FSH commercial preparation and follicular status on follicular growth and superovulatory response in Spanish Merino ewes

Ovarian follicular development was characterized in 24 Spanish Merino ewes to study effects of the follicular status and the FSH commercial product used on follicular growth and subsequent superovulatory response. Estrus was synchronized using 40 mg fluorogestone acetate sponges. The superovulatory treatment consisted in 2 daily i.m. injections of FSH from 48 h before to 12 h after sponge removal. Sheep were assigned randomly to 2 groups treated with 6 decreasing doses (4, 4, 3, 3, 2, 2 mg) of FSH-P or with 6 doses of 1.25 mL of OVAGEN. Growth and regression of all follicles > or = 2 mm were observed by transrectal ultrasonography, and recorded daily from Day 6 before sponge insertion to the first FSH injection, and then twice daily until estrus was detected with vasectomized rams. Differences were detected in follicular development from the first FSH injection to detection of estrus (-48 to 36 h from sponge removal) between groups. Administration of FSH-P increased the appearance of new follicles with respect to OVAGEN (6.3 +/- 0.7 vs 4.8 +/- 0.4; P < 0.05), and the mean number of medium (4 to 5 mm) follicles (8.9 +/- 1.2 vs 6.6 +/- 0.9; P < 0.05). However, the mean number of follicles that regressed in size after sponge removal (5.9 +/- 0.4 vs 3.3 +/- 0.4) and the number of preovulatory sized follicles that did not ovulate (60 vs 42.4%) were also higher in FSH-P treated ewes (P < 0.05). So, finally, there were no differences in ovulation rate, as determined by laparoscopy on Day 7 after sponge removal, between ewes treated with FSH-P or OVAGEN (6.3 +/- 1.9 vs 7.0 +/- 1.7 CL). In all the ewes, the ovulatory response was related (P < 0.05) both to the number of small follicles (2 to 3 mm in diameter) present in the ovaries at the start of treatment with exogenous FSH and to the number of follicles that reached > or = 4 mm in size at estrus, despite differences in the pattern of follicular development when using different commercial products.