Children conceived by intracytoplasmic sperm injection

Cognitive development of singletons born after intracytoplasmic sperm injection compared with in vitro fertilization and natural conception

OBJECTIVE

To investigate cognitive development of singletons conceived by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) at 5-8 years of age.

DESIGN

Follow-up study.

SETTING

University medical center, assessments between March 2004 and May 2005.

PATIENT(S)

Singletons born between June 1996 and December 1999 after ICSI at the Leiden University Medical Center were compared with matched singletons born after IVF and natural conception (NC).

INTERVENTION(S)

Mode of conception.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Intelligence quotient (IQ) was measured with the Revised Amsterdam Child Intelligence Test (short form). The investigators were blinded to conception mode.

RESULT(S)

Singletons conceived by ICSI (n = 83) achieved lower IQ scores than IVF singletons (n = 83) (adjusted mean difference IQ: 3.6 [95% confidence interval (CI) -0.8, 8.0]). After categorizing IQ outcomes (<85, 85-115, >115), no significant difference in the distribution of IQ was found. Singletons conceived by ICSI (n = 86) achieved lower IQ scores than NC singletons (n = 85); the adjusted mean difference varied between 5 and 7 points (5.6 [95% CI 0.9, 10.3]; 7.1 [95% CI 1.7, 12.5]) depending on the covariates included in the model. Adjustment for prematurity did not change the results. Percentages in IQ categories <85, 85-115, and >115 were 12%, 64%, and 24% for ICSI and 6%, 54%, and 40% for NC, respectively.

CONCLUSION(S)

In the relatively limited sample investigated, cognitive development among ICSI singletons was lower than among IVF and NC singletons. Infertility factors or unmeasured confounders may play a role.

Outcome of assisted reproduction

In-vitro fertilisation has been done for nearly 30 years; in developed countries at least 1% of births are from assisted reproductive therapies (ART). These children now represent a substantial proportion of the population but little is known about their health. Some of the morbidity associated with ART does not result from the techniques but from the underlying health risks of being subfertile. Much of the amplified risk associated with ART is related to high birth order. However, risk of intrauterine and subsequent perinatal complications is enhanced after ART, and urogenital malformations can be present in boys, even in singleton infants. No increase in discord or other difficulties within families has been recorded. Long-term follow-up of children born after ART to reproductive age and beyond is necessary.

Post-neonatal health and development of children born after assisted reproduction: A systematic review of controlled studies

Long-term follow-up studies on the health and the development of children conceived by assisted reproduction (ART) are mandatory to assess the safety of ART. Meanwhile, different aspects of health of these children have been studied. To put these results together, we performed a systematic review of these publications. A Pubmed search and a hand-search of the abstract books from the annual meeting of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology and the American Society of Reproductive Medicine were performed for controlled studies on the developmental outcome of children after ART, which include a matching for plurality of gestation. Regarding general health, growth, mental and psychomotor development IVF children do not differ from spontaneously conceived (SC) children. An increased need for surgical interventions may be due to an increase in the malformation rate. However, a lower birth weight and lower gestational age compared to matched controls may contribute to some health problems observed. The increased risk of neurological problems found in some large registry-based studies can partly be explained by the higher frequency of twins born, by low birth weight, and by low gestational age also found in singletons. But an effect of IVF, the parents' infertility or other factors not adjusted for in the studies cannot be excluded. In addition to this reporting bias caused by concerned parents cannot be excluded, either. To conclude, children born after assisted reproductive techniques are generally healthy and are developmentally similar to children born after SC. However, low birth weight and prematurity contributes to health care problems. An increase of neurological problems by IVF cannot be excluded. Further prospective studies on the neurological outcome are needed.

A retrospective case-control study of developmental and other outcomes in a cohort of Australian children conceived by intracytoplasmic sperm injection compared with a similar group in the United Kingdom

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the possibility that children born after ICSI were at increased risk for neurodevelopmental delay.

DESIGN

Retrospective case-control study.

SETTING

IVF clinic.

PATIENT(S)

Fifty-eight singleton children born after ICSI and 38 normally conceived singleton children (controls), matched for relevant sociodemographic characteristics, from Australia and 208 case-patients and 221 controls from the United Kingdom.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Antenatal and perinatal, and sociodemographic characteristics; physical health, including congenital abnormalities; and neurodevelopment by using the Griffiths scales of mental development.

RESULT(S)

Eighty-five percent of case-patients and 96% controls were assessed at a mean age of 13 months. Neurodevelopmental scores were similar in all children. Perinatal outcome was similar, apart from more caesarean sections in the case-patients. Rates of congenital anomalies were similar (5.6% among case-patients vs. 5.7% among controls). Children from fathers with oligozoospermia showed no extra problems. Children born after ICSI in the United Kingdom and Australia were similar.

CONCLUSION(S)

Children conceived after ICSI did not differ from their naturally conceived peers in physical health or development at ages up to 15 months.

Outcome in the second year of life after in-vitro fertilisation by intracytoplasmic sperm injection: a UK case-control study

BACKGROUND

There have been reports suggesting that children born after in-vitro fertilisation by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) are at increased risk of neurodevelopmental delay. We have undertaken a case-control study of this issue.

METHODS

We studied 208 singleton children conceived by ICSI and a control group of 221 normally conceived singleton children. Children were recruited from 22 fertility centres and local nurseries throughout the UK. Controls were selected to match cases as closely as possible for social class, maternal educational attainment, region, sex, and race. The primary outcome measure was neurodevelopmental scoring; secondary measures were perinatal outcomes, postnatal health, and congenital abnormalities. A single examiner assessed all the children.

FINDINGS

A follow-up rate of 90% for the ICSI group was achieved at a mean age of 17 months. No difference between the study children and controls was found in mean neurodevelopmental scores (98.08 [SD 10.93] vs 98.69 [9.99]) or any subscales on the Griffiths' scales of mental development. Perinatal outcome was similar apart from a higher rate of caesarean section (73 [35.1%] vs 53 [24.0%], p=0.015) and a lower mean birthweight (3163 [SD 642] vs 3341 [606] g, p=0.013) in the study group. Rates of major congenital abnormality were also similar overall (ten [4.8%] study vs ten [4.5%] control), although there were significantly more congenital anomalies among children born to fathers with oligozoospermia than in other children.

INTERPRETATION

This population study did not show any significant difference between children conceived after ICSI and their naturally conceived peers in terms of physical health and development.