Are anticonvulsants teratogenic?

Neurodevelopmental delay in children exposed to antiepileptic drugs in utero: a critical review directed at structural study-bias

INTRODUCTION

The general issue whether in utero exposure to antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) causes congenital malformations (teratogenicity) was raised as early as 1968. The 'congenital hydantoin syndrome' after intrauterine exposure to phenytoin (PHT) was first described in 1975. In 1984, DiLiberti proposed the label 'Fetal Valproate Syndrome' (FVS) for children with a cluster of minor congenital anomalies in the form of dysmorphic facial appearances with or without major abnormalities after intra-uterine exposure to valproate (VPA). Later, also the presence of central nervous system (CNS) dysfunction became part of the description. The question whether developmental delay, educational impairment, or behavioural disorders are also a characteristic of intrauterine exposure to AEDs and especially VPA, is of major importance to many women with epilepsy, parents and physicians involved.

METHODS

Literature was searched using MEDLINE and other relevant databases: 56 studies were identified and interpreted.

RESULTS

The identified studies do not allow definite conclusions. The possibility of neurodevelopmental delay, behavioural disorders, or learning disabilities as an outcome of in utero exposure to AEDs and especially VPA, needs to be considered seriously. The literature however does not provide evidence for a valid risk estimate. Moreover the evidence found for a specific increased risk for VPA could be structurally biased.

DISCUSSION

The major problem in this field is the methodology and in particular the existence of important confounding factors that complicate any attempt to correlate intra-uterine exposure to AEDs with neurodevelopmental delay. We propose a number of guidelines for studies on behavioural teratogenicity.

Epilepsy and pregnancy: Report of an Epilepsy Research Foundation Workshop

Pregnancy in women with epilepsy (WWE) is known to be associated with a higher risk of congenital malformations than is associated with pregnancy in non-epileptic women. Several factors have been identified to account for the increased risk, including the direct teratogenic effects of antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy, indirect effects of these drugs by interfering with folate metabolism, genetic abnormalities in drug or folate metabolism, and possibly an arrhythmogenic effect of maternal drug therapy on the embryonic heart, leading to ischaemia in developing tissues. A harmful effect of maternal seizures on the developing embryo has not been proven, although seizures and status epilepticus account for most of the excess maternal mortality in women with epilepsy. Abrupt withdrawal of drug therapy by the mother may be an important contributory factor. Less is known about the psychomotor development of children born to mothers with epilepsy because few studies have been designed to follow their progress throughout childhood. Retrospective studies suggest that impaired cognitive development may be associated with maternal drug therapy, particularly valproate. There is an urgent need to evaluate these risks and, with this in mind, several prospective registers have been set up to collect data from pregnancies in women with epilepsy.

Parental epilepsy, anticonvulsant drugs, and reproductive outcome: epidemiologic and experimental findings spanning three decades; 2: Human studies

Evidence accumulated over the past three decades has established AEDs as human teratogens. Important developments in the delineation of these compounds as human teratogens include: the demonstration of a consistent association between in utero exposure to AEDs and an increased occurrence of single major malformations, the description of AED-induced dysmorphogenic syndromes; demonstration of a dose-response relationship, both in terms of the number and dosage of AEDs; and evidence that pharmacogenetic differences in the metabolism of AEDs are strongly correlated with the occurrence of congenital malformations. Furthermore, the experimental animal findings, having accumulated in parallel to those of human studies, strongly support the teratogenic role of AEDs. Areas that require further amplification and clarification in future studies are the relative contribution of AEDs and other factors, such as genetic predisposition and maternal seizures, particularly with respect to the occurrence of minor anomalies, growth retardation, and developmental outcome; the relative teratogenicity of specific monotherapies and polytherapies; the predictive role of pharmacogenetic differences in the metabolism of AEDs in the occurrence of structural and functional abnormalities; and characterization of the precise nature of the pharmacogenetic defect underlying the aforementioned differences in AED metabolism. Attempts should also be made in future prospective studies to monitor metabolite levels of AEDs, particularly the oxidative metabolites, in order to further elucidate the relative contribution of individual differences in metabolism in the determination of adverse fetal outcome. Similarly, further efforts should be made to assess the clinical significance of decreased growth parameters in terms of mental and neurologic development, and to ascertain whether there is any risk for such abnormalities in children who do not display overt or persistent reductions in physical growth parameters. This is critically important in light of the animal studies that have shown functional abnormalities at doses that do not necessarily produce structural defects. Future investigations would be conducted through collaborative studies that would encompass sufficiently large numbers of women to provide adequate power to the statistical analyses of the data obtained. Care would have to be exercised to establish a uniform protocol for the collaborating centers. Regionally based investigations would be preferable to studies based at special centers, in order to assess the relative role of risk factors associated with abnormal pregnancy outcomes in the epileptic population at large.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Facial clefts and congenital heart defects in children of parents with epilepsy: genetic and environmental etiologic factors

Increased prevalence of cleft lip with or without cleft palate (CL(P], isolated cleft palate (CP), and congenital heart defects (CHD) in children of epileptic mothers have been ascribed to early fetal exposure to antiepileptic drugs (AED). However, common genetic factors responsible for both the malformations in question and the epileptic disorder might be of relevance for the increased rate of CL(P), CP, and CHD, rather than the influence of AED. The present review analyzes the literature on genetic and environmental etiologic factors (i.e. AED and epileptic seizures) that have been reported to increase the rate of CL(P), CP, and CHD in children of parents with epilepsy. Our data suggest that genetic factors are of minor importance for the etiology of facial clefts in offspring of epileptic patients. The rate of facial clefts was increased by a factor of 4.7 in children of AED-treated mothers with epilepsy compared with the background population values. Children of fathers with epilepsy and sibs of epileptic patients had no more facial clefts than expected. The rate of CHD in children of mothers and fathers with epilepsy was comparable to population figures. The role of epileptic seizures as a causative factor for CL(P), CP, and CHD is not settled, but seems to be of limited importance. Areas of future research are outlined concerning the teratogenic role of AED and their metabolites, especially on the postnatal intellectual development of the exposed children. Finally, the need for studies on prophylactic measures as well as the necessity of international surveillance systems on new AED teratogenicity are emphasized.

Teratogenicity of anticonvulsant drugs. IV: The association of clefting and epilepsy

Cleft lip with or without cleft palate (CL/P) is the most common congenital malformation reported among infants of epileptic mothers. This study sought to examine the relative roles of anticonvulsant teratogenicity and other factors responsible for this association. Among 175 families with a proband with isolated CL/P, there were 13 parents with epilepsy and a high frequency of other family members with CL/P and epilepsy. Evaluation of the 13 cases suggested that teratogenicity of anticonvulsant drugs was not the primary factor responsible for the observed association of maternal epilepsy and clefting. Among 140 families with a proband with clefting other than CL/P, there were no instances of parental epilepsy observed.

Multi-institutional study on the teratogenicity and fetal toxicity of antiepileptic drugs: a report of a collaborative study group in Japan

A multi-institutional collaborative study was conducted concerning the course of pregnancy and delivery and the incidence of abnormal infants delivered of epileptic women. Of 657 women receiving antiepileptic drugs, 73% delivered live infants, 14% had miscarriage or stillbirth, and 13% underwent induced abortion. In contrast to the above findings, 80% of 162 patients not receiving antiepileptic drugs delivered live infants and 4% had miscarriage or stillbirth. The latter outcome was significantly increased in the medicated patients. In this series, 63 (9.9%) of 638 live births were malformed, 55 (11.5%) being from medicated mothers and 3 (2.3%) from nonmedicated mothers. The incidence of fetal malformation in medicated mothers was thus five times as high as that in nonmedicated mothers. Cleft lip and/or palate and malformations involving the cardiovascular system were found frequently in the infants from medicated mothers. General background factors that might exert teratogenic effects on pregnant patients with epilepsy were studied, and the potential toxicity of antiepileptic drugs to the fetus was also analyzed. In this regard, consideration should be given to whether the patient has partial epileptic seizures, whether the patient herself exhibits any malformation, or whether her previous pregnancy resulted in an abnormal outcome. The incidence of fetal malformation was the highest (12.7%) in the medicated patients who had epileptic seizures during the pregnancy. It is presumed on the basis of the results of analysis of the data that a combination of more than three drugs and a daily dose greater than a certain minimal level is likely to produce malformed infants.

Palate morphology and fetal movements in mice after DPH

Effects of DPH on fetal development were studied using a dose which produced 65% cleft palate in the CD-1 strain. Generalized developmental retardation and diminution of fetal muscular movements occurred at the early fetal stage. Intermediate stages of palate closure persisted to term, indicating interference with palatine shelf rotation.

Diphenylhydantoin teratogenicity: ocular manifestations and related deformities

This patient illustrates a classical case of what many pediatricians call the diphenylhydantoin teratogenic syndrome. It suggests the possibility of an additional ocular finding of retinoschisis and optic nerve abnormalities which could conceivably have a teratogenic basis. The effects of epilepsy and diphenylhydantoin on these formations is discussed.

The fetal trimethadione syndrome

Three families are described in which each of the mothers took trimethadione during pregnancy. From a comparison of siblings in each family and of others exposed to trimethadione in utero, a specific phenotype is delineated. Features included in the fetal trimethadione syndrome are developmental delay, speech difficulty, V-shaped eyebrows, epicanthus, low-set ears with anteriorly folded helix, palatal anomaly, and irregular teeth. Additional anomalies in some of the patients include intrauterine growth retardation, short stature, microcephaly, cardiac anomaly, ocular anomaly, hypospadias, inguinal hernia, and simian creases.

Epilepsy and pregnancy: a report from the Oxford Record Linkage Study

The files of the Oxford Record Linkage Study were used to identify 223 infants delivered to 168 epileptic women as the result of 218 pregnancies. There were six stillbirths, two of which were grossly malformed. It was shown that the population of epileptic mothers differed significantly from the total reproducing population in respect of social class. Each pregnancy resulting in a livebirth was therefore matched exactly for social class, civil status, maternal age, parity, hospital, and year of delivery with three control deliveries resulting in livebirths. The defects noted at birth were abstracted from the Record Linkage files, and any subsequent hospital admissions or deaths of the children were also abstracted.There were highly significant excesses of congenital abnormalities among the infants born to epileptic mothers (13.8% of livebirths had some degree of defect of congenital origin compared with 5.6% of controls, P <0.0005). It was shown that neither the frequency with which the mother had fits nor the length of time she had had the epilepsy seemed to bear any relation to the frequency of defects in the offspring-with the exception of the two mothers who developed epilepsy in the first

[Chromosome studies on the effect of primidone (Mylepsinum) and its metabolites phenobarbital and phenylethylmalondiamide in vitro]

Primidone and its metabolites Phenobarbital and Phenylethylmalondiamide were tested in cultures of human lymphocytes on possible effects of inducing chromosome aberrations. The substances examined ranged from concentrations lower than the therapeutic serum level to 10-75 times this value, which differed with the various substances. Phenylethylmalondiamide shows, besides an increase of spiralization defects at higher concentrations, which was typical for all three substances, no reaction on the chromosome structure.

By using the Friedman-test a statistically significant difference (P< 5%) could be found between the average aberration rates of the controls and the cultures which had been treated with Primidone and Phenobarbital. The test according to Wilcoxon and Wilcox shows that there is a statistically significant (P< 5%) difference between the aberration rates of controls and the respectively treated cultures. The higher values for percentage of aberrant mitoses are caused by the increase of gaps and breaks. There was, however, no proof for a linear dependence of the percentage of aberrant mitoses on the increasing concentrations of the substances. The number of tetraploid mitoses, endoreduplications and hyperploid cells was within the normal range.

Since in these investigations the number of chromosome exchanges was not increased, it can certainly be said that Primidone and Phenobarbital are not highly mutagenic substances.