In-vitro lymphoproliferative response to Mycobacterium leprae of HLA-D-identical siblings of lepromatous leprosy patients

Leprosy and immunity: genetics and immune function in multiple case families

Genetic susceptibility to infection with M. leprae was studied in 10 multiple case families of Australian Aborigines. Of the 87 members available for study, 24 had proven stable clinical leprosy which had been or was still being treated with diamino diphenyl sulphone. Evidence of contact with M. leprae in the remaining 63 members as assessed by ELISA to M. leprae sonicate and phenolic glycolipid (PGL) or by indirect immunofluorescence antibody assay was found in 78%, 64% and 71%, respectively. By contrast, in vitro assays of T cell function (LMAT and LTT) were less reliable indicators of exposure. Evidence was sought for possible linkages between human leucocyte antigen (HLA) or non-HLA genes and four marker phenotypes including clinical leprosy, clinical subtype of leprosy and lymphocyte transformation or leucocyte migration inhibition factor (LIF) production in response to M. leprae antigen. No associations were found with any particular HLA or non-HLA gene. On the other hand, sequential analysis of the data from the 10 families was strongly suggestive of a linkage between HLA haplotype and non-responsiveness to M. leprae as manifest by lack of LIF production but not lymphocyte transformation. The model which best fits the data is for a gene on chromosome 6 in close linkage with the HLA haplotype, with two alleles, autosomal recessive inheritance and penetrance of 90%. On this basis, it can be suggested that disease type (lepromatous leprosy) rather than disease susceptibility may be controlled by genes within or closely linked to the major histocompatibility gene complex.

Genetically restricted suppressor T-cell clones derived from lepromatous leprosy lesions

Leprosy is a spectral disease in which immune responses to Mycobacterium leprae correlate with the clinical, bacteriological and histopathological manifestations of disease, so study of its pathology provides insights into immunoregulatory mechanisms in man. At the tuberculoid pole, patients have few lesions in the skin which contain rare organisms and are able to mount strong cell-mediated immune responses to M. leprae antigens. In contrast, at the lepromatous pole, patients have disseminated skin lesions containing large numbers of acid-fast bacilli and are selectively unresponsive to antigens of M. leprae. M. leprae-induced suppressor cells derived from peripheral blood have been reported to be active in vitro, yet their in vivo significance has remained unclear. Because the focal point of the immune response to M. leprae is the skin lesion consisting of lymphocytes and macrophages, we have recently developed methods for isolating lymphocytes from skin biopsies of leprosy patients. We report here that two T8 clones derived from lepromatous leprosy skin biopsies, in the presence of lepromin, suppress concanavalin A (Con-A) responses both of peripheral blood mononuclear cells and of T4 clones in an HLA-D (HLA, histocompatibility locus antigen)-restricted manner. Moreover, these T8 clones suppressed responses of HLA-D-matched, but not HLA-D-mismatched antigen-responsive T4 clones to M. leprae antigens, indicating that T-cell suppression is major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted at some level in man.

Mycobacterium leprae-induced alterations in macrophage Fc receptor expression and monocyte-lymphocyte interaction in familial contacts of leprosy patients

Macrophage Fc receptor expression and monocyte-lymphocyte interaction in the presence of Mycobacterium leprae were examined in familial contacts of leprosy patients. Defective M phi functions similar to those of borderline and lepromatous patients could be observed in approximately 71% of consanguineous contacts and 43% of spouses of index patients. Although the values in the latter group were markedly lower than those of the consanguineous contacts, they tended to be higher than those of normal individuals (20%). These in vitro M phi functions were independent of age, sex, and age at onset of exposure and were only weakly associated with duration of exposure. The outcome of the monocyte-lymphocyte interaction test paralleled to a large extent the in vivo Mitsuda lepromin response. Four contacts with defective M phi functions also showed signs of leprosy. The value of these in vitro tests as markers of 'susceptibility' could therefore prove significant.

Immunological unresponsiveness in leprosy

The various forms of leprosy form a clinical and immunological spectrum which offers extraordinary possibilities for insight into immunoregulatory mechanisms in man. At one pole, tuberculoid leprosy, patients develop high levels of cell-mediated immunity which ultimately results in killing of bacilli in the tissues, albeit often with damage to nerves. At the lepromatous pole, patients exhibit selective immunological unresponsiveness to antigens of M. leprae. Even though all currently known protein species of M. leprae and BCG are cross-reactive, lepromatous patients unreactive to M. leprae antigens frequently respond strongly to tuberculin. In vitro experiments suggest the existence of lepromin-induced suppressor activity, mediated by both monocytes and T cells. The T suppressor cells have the T8 phenotype of which 50% express the activation markers, Ia and FcR. The one unique species of antigen of the leprosy bacillus is a phenolic glycolipid, and it appears that the TS cells largely recognize the terminal trisaccharide of this unique antigen. Depletion of the TS cells restores in vitro reactivity of lymphocytes to lepromin in a portion of lepromatous patients, and addition of IL-2-containing supernatants partially restores responsiveness to M. leprae antigens. Vaccination of lepromatous patients with a mixture of M. leprae and live BCG restores cell-mediated immunity in the majority of lepromatous patients, and concomitantly reduces the in vitro suppressor activity and number of activated T8 cells. These experiments suggest the existence of stage-of-disease related suppressor cells in leprosy which appear to block the responsiveness of TH capable of responding to either specific or cross-reactive mycobacterial antigens. The mode of action of these TS appears to be the inhibition of production of IL-2 and other lymphokines. Successful immunotherapeutic vaccination appears to overcome this block in the majority of patients.

An approach to study in vitro the expression of HLA-encoded genetic factors predisposing to tuberculoid leprosy

The existence of HLA-encoded genetic factors controlling susceptibility to tuberculoid leprosy in humans has been firmly established. Furthermore HLA-DR2 has been recognized as a marker for tuberculoid leprosy in India. At this moment, however, the gene products involved and the mechanism by which they confer susceptibility to tuberculoid leprosy remain only speculative. In an attempt to detect in vitro the expression of these HLA-encoded factors, we studied 12 tuberculoid leprosy patients and 22 healthy family members in a lymphocyte transformation test (LTT). All individuals were derived from multi-case Indian families, previously reported to show the presence of HLA-linked susceptibility genes. Although the responder-status of the healthy contact siblings was shown to behave independently from the fact whether they were HLA-identical with the patient-siblings or not, some evidence for in vitro expression of HLA-DR2 associated factors could be obtained. Nevertheless, it is concluded that the standard LTT seems not to be a test-system of first choice to detect the in vitro expression of the genes under study.

HLA and susceptibility to leprosy

This review examines the evidence for involvement of MHC-associated factors in host immune response to Mycobacterium leprae, by collating HLA studies of sporadic and familial leprosy and discussing possible HLA-related immunological mechanisms in determining host response. Formal linkage analysis of 109 multiple-case families with data available for HLA haplotype segregation showed that under a three-allele recessive model for susceptibility to leprosy, linkage was observed between the HLA complex and a leprosy susceptibility locus at a recombination fraction of 20%. The significance of the linkage relationship was confined to families with at least two tuberculoid leprosy offspring and neither parent affected. When one parent was affected, with leprosy of any clinical type, lod scores could neither implicate nor exclude linkage between HLA and leprosy susceptibility and this apparent paradox can be explained by the presence of an additional, non-HLA linked susceptibility locus for leprosy.

Leprosy, an overview

Leprosy is both a public health problem and a model for host-parasite relationship. There is much progress in many areas, and in most, hurdles are not only scientific but also social and financial. The following are goals to reach: 1) progress of growth of M. leprae in animals (to be able to breed armadillos in captivity or to substitute them with other animals); 2) to develop methods for in vitro culture of M. leprae; 3) to obtain antigens from M. leprae and characterize them immunologically; 4) to achieve techniques for objective diagnosis of infection with M. leprae and of leprosy (these techniques will most likely be serologic); 5) to develop methods to direct and manipulate immune response. This should include a better definition of immunologically active cells, their characterization by reliable methods, and an understanding of their functions. Immune control mechanisms and ways to channel them should also be understood; and 6) to have better methods of treatment including flexible adaptable schedules. It will be clear that "solving" the problem of leprosy requires "solving" the social problems in developing countries, as well as unraveling the mystery of the precise control of immune response. As I pointed out, the problems that we face are basically similar to those of autoimmune disorders and of cancer immunology. Research in autoimmune diseases or cancer might provide answers to questions posed by leprosy. It may also be that research in leprosy could supply answers to questions concerning cancer and autoimmunity.

Studies on the defect in cell-mediated immunity in lepromatous leprosy using HLA-D-identical siblings. Absence of circulating suppressor cells and evidence that the defect is in the T-lymphocyte, rather than the monocyte, population

Sixteen healthy siblings were identified as HLA-D-identical to 12 borderline lepromatous or polar lepromatous leprosy patients by the absence of a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). The peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBM) of the healthy siblings showed a lymphoproliferative response (delta cpm) to Mycobacterium leprae antigens which was about fivefold or more greater than that of the lepromatous patients. Lepromatous PBM, with or without mitomycin C treatment, were co-cultured with a constant number of normal PBM. In other experiments the two cell types were co-cultured in various proportions, with the total cell number kept constant. Neither approach revealed suppressor cells in lepromatous PBM capable of suppressing the lymphoproliferative response to M. leprae. On the contrary, we found that lepromatous PBM can respond to M. leprae antigens if the sensitized lymphocyte is provided by mitomycin-C treated normal PBM. Additionally, experiments in which isolated adherent cells and non-adherent cells of sibling pairs were recombined failed to reveal a defect in the M. leprae antigen-presenting function of lepromatous adherent cells. Since we found no evidence that sensitized cells are present in lepromatous PBM with their function unexpressed (due to a monocyte defect) or suppressed (due to suppressor cells), we conclude that lepromatous patients simply lack sufficient numbers of antigen-specific T lymphocytes to initiate a lymphoproliferative response to M. leprae antigens. The reason for their absence remains an important unanswered question.

Antigen-specific suppressor cells in subclinical leprosy infection

A two-stage in-vitro culture system was used to assay cells which suppress the lympho-proliferative response to Mycobacterium leprae (ML). Responses to ML, purified protein derivative of tuberculin, and streptokinase-streptodornase were preferentially suppressed by mitomycin-treated cells which had been primed with the same antigen in a 7-day primary culture. Healthy subjects exposed to leprosy for more than 3 years showed strong suppression of the response to ML antigens (11 of 12 showed more than 40% suppression), whereas those exposed for 3 months to 3 years showed much less suppression (12 of 15 showed less than 40% suppression). The in-vitro generation of strong ML-specific suppression may reflect the maturation of a well-regulated and protective immune response. However, premature induction and in-vivo activation of these suppressor cells could predispose to disseminated (lepromatous) forms of leprosy. With this assay it would be possible to assess the ability of proposed leprosy vaccines to engage strongly the regulatory network controlling the immune response to ML in the same way as long-term exposure to the natural infection.

Importance of the neural predilection of Mycobacterium leprae in leprosy

It is suggested that continuous leakage of bacilli into the circulation from a primary focus of intraneural infection may simultaneously initiate bacillary dissemination and the suppression of cell-mediated immunity. Both these features are essential for the development of lepromatous leprosy. Nerve involvement in leprosy, previously thought of as a diagnostic feature of the disease and as a complication of therapy, may represent an essential phase in the cycle of infection and reinfection by Mycobacterium leprae.