Vitamins and neural tube defects

An updated history of the Teratology Society

BACKGROUND

The 49-year history of the Teratology Society is reviewed. An abbreviated history is outlined in table form, with listings of the Warkany Lectures, the Continuing Education Courses, and officers of the society. The original article was updated to include the years 2000 to 2010.

METHODS

A year-by-year description of the events is given, including the scientific and social content of the annual meetings and changes in the business of the society, in many cases using comments from the past presidents. The valuable and unique diversity of the members is discussed and illustrated, presenting the disciplines and main research areas of the presidents. The number of submitted abstracts and the various categories are tabulated, averaging the number and type over successive periods. A significant increase in the number of abstracts dealing with epidemiology and developmental biology is evident. The society's development is compared to that of a human, and the question was asked by Shephard et al. (2000): Have we reached the maturational stage of old age or senescence, or is the society still maturing gracefully? This question needs further discussion by all the members. By 2010, many positive changes are happening to revitalize the society.

RESULTS

During the past 50 years, we have developed the scientific basis to prevent birth defects caused by rubella, alcoholism, and folate deficiency, as well as other prenatal exposures. We are now taking advantage of advances in many fields to begin shaping the Teratology Society of the 21st century.

CONCLUSIONS

We must now engage in political battles to obtain the resources needed to conduct further research and to implement prevention programs, as well as to provide care and rehabilitation for persons with birth defects.

The scientific basis for eliminating folic acid-preventable spina bifida: a modern miracle from epidemiology

One of the most remarkable successes of epidemiology was the demonstration in the late twentieth century that spina bifida and anencephaly-two of the most common and severe birth defects-are caused primarily by folate deficiency. This article reviews the descriptive epidemiological studies that began when we did not have a clue about etiology. The paper tells the success story of the trials that proved that folic acid would prevent folic-acid-preventable spina bifida. Finally, it will tell how difficult it is to get prevention policy implemented, even when the scientific evidence is compelling. It concludes by noting that the inaction or inappropriate actions of food regulatory bodies in so many countries means that only 10% of folic-acid-preventable spina bifida is actually being prevented--a serious failure of public health policy.

A history of the Teratology Society

BACKGROUND

The 39-year history of the Teratology Society is reviewed. An abbreviated history is outlined in table form, along with listings of the Warkany Lectures, the postgraduate courses, and officers of the Society.

METHODS

A year-by-year description of the events, including the scientific and social content of the annual meetings and changes in the business of the Society, is given, in many cases using comments from the past presidents. The valuable and unique diversity of the members is discussed and illustrated, presenting the disciplines and main research area of the presidents. The number of submitted abstracts and the various categories are tabulated, averaging the number and type over four periods. Within the past 10 years, a significant increase in the number of abstracts dealing with epidemiology and developmental biology is evident. The Society's development is compared with that of a human, and the question is asked: Have we reached the maturational stage of old age or senescence, or is the Society still maturing gracefully? This question needs further discussion by all the members.

RESULTS

During the past 40 years, we have developed the scientific basis to prevent birth defects caused by rubella, alcoholism, and folate deficiency, as well as many other prenatal exposures.

CONCLUSIONS

We must now engage in the political battles to obtain the resources needed to conduct further research and to implement the prevention programs, as well as to provide care and rehabilitation for persons with birth defects.

Dietary folate as a risk factor for neural-tube defects: evidence from a case-control study in Western Australia

A population-based case-control study was conducted to test the hypothesis that the risk of the occurrence of neural-tube defects in infants with no other birth defects (isolated neural-tube defects) is associated inversely with the maternal dietary intake of free and/or total folate in early pregnancy. Information was collected from the mothers of 77 case subjects with isolated neural-tube defects who were born in Western Australia from 1982 to 1984, from the mothers of 77 control subjects with birth defects other than neural-tube defects (control group 1) and from the mothers of 154 control subjects with no birth defects (control group 2). The case and control subjects were matched individually by the date of the mother's last menstrual period. Odds ratios were adjusted for a number of potentially-confounding variables, such as the country of birth of the parents, paternal social class, previous pregnancy outcome, interval between index and previous pregnancy and pregnancy order. Crude and adjusted odds ratios showed a protective effect of an increasing intake of free folate in the first six weeks of pregnancy. Adjusted odds ratios, with reference to the lowest quartile of intake, (and their 95% confidence intervals) were 0.72 (0.25-2.08), 0.37 (0.11-1.23) and 0.31 (0.10-0.97) for quartiles 2-4 when control group 1 was used, and 0.44 (0.17-1.13), 0.34 (0.13-0.90) and 0.16 (0.06-0.49) when control group 2 was used. Similar, but weaker, trends were seen when total folate intake was the exposure variable. These findings support the hypothesis that the dietary intake of folate in early pregnancy protects against the occurrence of isolated neural-tube defects in infants. Measures of postpartum dietary folate and of postpartum serum and red-cell folate levels showed no association with the occurrence of neural-tube defects in infants.

Neural tube defects: epidemiology, detection, and prevention

Neural tube defects are common congenital malformations of the central nervous system and include anencephaly, spina bifida, and encephalocele. Prenatal detection by amniotic fluid analysis of alpha-fetoprotein is possible in those women known to be at high risk for neural tube defects. Maternal serum screening for increased alpha-fetoprotein levels is now available nationally and has the potential to identify women who otherwise would not be known to be at risk. The epidemiology, detection, screening, and prevention of neural tube defects are discussed, and an explanation of alpha-fetoprotein and its use in screening is offered.

Recurrent neural tube defects, risk factors and vitamins

Data from our trial of periconceptional vitamin supplementation for the prevention of neural tube defects have been analysed to assess the influence of various factors on recurrence rates of neural tube defect. Our data suggest that the risk of recurrence of neural tube defect is influenced by the number of previous neural tube defects, area of residence, immediately prior miscarriage, and interpregnancy interval. None of these factors, however, contributed any significant differential risk between supplemented and unsupplemented mothers. Hence we conclude that the highly significant difference in recurrence rates of neural tube defect between supplemented and unsupplemented mothers was due to vitamin supplementation.

Neural-tube defects and vitamins: the need for a randomized clinical trial

It has been suggested that taking extra vitamins around the time of conception may reduce the risk of fetal neural-tube defects. We have examined the evidence for this and conclude that there is considerable doubt about the efficacy of such a regimen. Also, it cannot be assumed that the taking of extra vitamins has no adverse medical effects. We give reasons for our view that a large randomized clinical trial is ethical and the only satisfactory way of resolving the matter. The Medical Research Council is currently conducting such a study in centres in Britain and abroad, involving women who have already had a pregnancy with a fetal neural-tube defect. The design of the Medical Research Council study is described briefly.