Immunohistochemical evidence for IgA1 involvement in Graves ophthalmopathy

Eye muscle antibodies in Graves' ophthalmopathy: pathogenic or secondary epiphenomenon?

The extra ocular (eye) muscles are one of the principal tissues involved in the autoimmune-mediated inflammation of Graves' ophthalmopathy (GO). Several eye muscle proteins are targeted by autoantibodies or sensitized T lymphocytes, or both, and include: G2s, which is now identified as the terminal 141 amino acids of the winged-helix transcription factor FOXP1, the flavoprotein (Fp) subunit of the mitochondrial enzyme succinate dehydrogenase, the so-called "64kDa protein", a non-tissue specific membrane protein called 1D and the calcium binding protein calsequestrin. Of these, antibodies against G2s and Fp are the most sensitive markers of eye muscle damage in patients with thyroid autoimmunity even though neither antigen is specific to eye muscle and neither antibody is specific to GO. However, the recent finding that the calsequestrin gene is 4.7 times more expressed in eye muscles than other skeletal muscles suggests that we should reconsider the possible role of anti-calsequestrin autoantibodies in ophthalmopathy. GO may comprise two main subtypes with different pathogenetic mechanisms, namely ocular myopathy in which eye muscle inflammation predominates and congestive ophthalmopathy where inflammatory changes occur in the periorbital connective tissues in the absence of eye muscle dysfunction. Anti-G2s and anti-Fp antibodies are closely associated with the ocular myopathy subtype of GO while antibodies targeting type XIII collagen, the only member of the collagen family to have a transmembrane domain, are closely linked to congestive ophthalmopathy. Since both G2s and Fp are intracellular antigens it is unlikely that either antibody causes eye muscle fiber damage in GO, although a role in the later stages of the disease when the fiber has released its cellular contents has not been excluded. Eye muscle antibodies that are cytotoxic to eye muscle cells in antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity (ADCC) are more likely to play a role in eye muscle fiber damage since they target a putative eye muscle cell membrane antigen, the identity of which is currently being investigated. While anti-G2s and anti-Fp antibodies are probably secondary to an underlying reaction, such as cytotoxic T lymphocyte targeting of an eye muscle membrane antigen that has yet to be identified, they are reliable markers of immunologically mediated eye muscle fiber damage in patients with Graves' hyperthyroidism. In conclusion, while a pathogenic role for eye muscle antibodies has not been excluded, they are most likely secondary to cytotoxic T cell reactions in GO and, as such, good markers of this autoimmune disease.

Autoantibodies reactive with extracellular matrix proteins in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

Autoantibodies reacting with extracellular matrix proteins have been extensively studied in various autoimmune connective tissue diseases. Because of the possibility that such antibodies may play a role in orbital connective tissue inflammation in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO), we studied the humoral immune response against specific extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins, namely: collagen types I, III, IV, V (CI, CIII, CIV, CV), fibronectin (FN), and laminin (LM). Anti-ECM antibodies of immunoglobulin G (IgG), IgA, and IgM classes were determined by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Overall, sera from 50% of patients with TAO contained antibodies reactive against one or more ECM proteins, compared to 27% with Graves' disease (GD) without evident eye involvement, 28% with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), and 9% of normal subjects. Serum anti-CI, anti-CIII, anti-CV and anti-LM levels were significantly (p<0.05) higher in patients with TAO than in normals. Anti-CI, anti-CV and anti-LM reactivity was antigen-specific in most TAO sera, while anti-CIII antibodies cross-reacted with other antigens. Anti-collagen antibodies were mainly of the IgG class. To determine the structural epitopes of these proteins, we performed immunoblotting studies on cyanogenbromide (CNBr)-derived peptides of CI and CV. While sera from 9 of 10 patients with TAO reacted with CI peptides, the response was polyclonal and uniform in all patients. However, only 2 of 10 TAO sera reacted with CV peptides. In conclusion, our study suggests that a variety of ECM proteins (CI, CV, LM) may be secondary autoantigens that are recognized by antibodies in TAO. While these antibodies appear to react with epitopes expressed on both native and denatured proteins, and may therefore have the potential to bind to ECM in vivo, their pathogenic role in TAO remains unknown.

Failure to demonstrate cell-mediated immunity to orbital tissue antigens and epitopic fragments of a 64 kDa protein in the majority of patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

We have studied a possible role of T cell sensitization to eye muscle antigens in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmology (TAO). Peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) proliferation in response to crude porcine orbital tissue antigens, partially purified porcine eye muscle membrane proteins and predicted epitopic fragments of the recombinant 64 kDa protein 1D, was determined in patients with TAO and thyroid autoimmunity without eye disease. When membrane and cytosol fractions were used as antigen PBMC from 43% of patients with TAO but only 12.5% of normal subjects were responsive to a crude orbital connective tissue membrane fraction, although this difference was not significant. We were unable to demonstrate specific recognition of partially purified eye muscle membrane fractions; although most of the fractions tested were occasionally recognized by T cells from patients with ophthalmopathy, this was also the case for patients with autoimmune thyroid disease without ophthalmopathy and normal subjects. We did not clearly identify epitopic sequences within the 1D protein, most of the predicted peptides tested being recognized not only by T cells from a small proportion of patients with TAO, but also by those from some patients with autoimmune thyroid disease without ophthalmopathy and normal subjects. It is noteworthy however that approximately 22% of TAO patients, but no normal subjects, were positive to one or more of three peptides, suggesting that reactivity to the 1D protein may play a role in the pathogenesis of the eye disorder in some patients with TAO. The inconsistent and generally low T cell responses to crude and purified antigens noted in a few patients with TAO could be explained by low numbers of specifically sensitized lymphocytes in peripheral blood.

IgA autoantibodies against human eye muscle antigen detected by western blotting and immunohistochemical methods in Graves' disease

The presence of IgA autoantibodies against human eye muscle was investigated in 40 patients with Graves' disease (33 had ophthalmopathy). IgA anti-eye muscle antibodies could be demonstrated in sera of patients using western blotting and immunohistochemical methods. For the detection of sera possessing autoantibodies against eye muscle antigen the indirect immunosorbent assay had been used. IgA anti-eye muscle antibodies could be demonstrated in 25 cases and IgG types in 16 cases out of 40 patients. These anti-muscle autoantibodies were associated with eye muscle rather than skeletal muscle, the number of positive cases with the latter being 5/40 for IgG and 2/40 for IgA. Immunoreactive bands of IgA autoantibodies against eye cytosol were found at 84, 64, 45, 40 and 25-23 kDa in 22, 2, 16, 2 and 18 cases, respectively. A difference was observed in the staining of IgG and IgA types of autoantibodies by immunohistochemical analysis of eye muscle tissue. The IgA anti-eye muscle antibodies reacted with muscle fibers and the IgG types showed staining on endomysium. No sera of Graves' disease patients gave staining on skeletal muscle tissue. The results supported the presence of IgA anti-human eye muscle antibodies in patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy, which might play a relevant role in the development of eye disease.

Immunoglobulin class and subclass distribution of eye muscle and fibroblast antibodies in patients with thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy

OBJECTIVE

The investigation of the antibody response in thyroid-associated ophthalmopathy (TAO) using different antigens and assays has given inconsistent results. We have analysed antibodies against eye muscle and control antigens in a large group of TAO patients to assess whether specific eye muscle antibodies exist in TAO. We have also evaluated the presence of IgA and IgM class antibodies and examined IgG subclass distribution.

DESIGN

Sera were obtained from all patients (TAO, Graves' disease without ophthalmopathy and Hashimoto's thyroiditis) within one year of diagnosis. Sera were also collected from healthy controls, with no family history of autoimmune thyroid disease.

PATIENTS

Thirty-eight patients had Graves' disease with Grade III or greater TAO; 15 patients had Graves' disease without ophthalmopathy and nine had Hashimoto's thyroiditis without any eye signs. The control group consisted of 14 subjects.

MEASUREMENTS

Antibodies against porcine eye and skeletal muscle, human eye (membrane and soluble antigen) and skeletal muscle, human thyroid microsomal and thyroglobulin antigens and dermal and orbital fibroblast antigens were assessed using ELISA. Antibody isotypes and IgG subclasses were studied for porcine and human eye muscle antibodies. Eye muscle (porcine and human) and orbital fibroblast antibodies were further analysed by immunoblotting.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in the ability of either IgG or IgA in sera from the different groups to bind porcine and human eye muscle antigens. There was a significant correlation (P < 0.0001) between the binding to porcine eye muscle and skeletal muscle antigens (for both IgG and IgA). There was no difference between sera from TAO patients and control subjects in their binding to eye muscle fibroblasts for both IgG and IgA antibodies. However, IgA antibody activity against dermal fibroblasts differed significantly between TAO patients and controls (P < 0.05). By immunoblotting, the frequency of IgA antibodies recognizing 21 kDa (40% of patients) and 62 kDa (52%) bands in porcine eye muscle blots and 20, 24 and 38 kDa bands in blots of human eye muscle (soluble) antigen differed significantly between patients with TAO and controls (P < 0.05 in all cases). IgG antibodies recognizing 80 and 92 kDa bands in blots of the subcellular membrane antigen prepared from orbital fibroblasts were found more frequently in patients with TAO compared with controls (P < 0.05 in both cases).

CONCLUSIONS

We found no evidence that eye muscle membrane or fibroblast antibodies are present in a significant proportion of TAO patients, using ELISAs based on antigens prepared from several sources. We have also failed to demonstrate the presence of previously described specific, TAO-associated antibodies, including those directed against a 64 kDa protein in eye muscle and a 23 kDa protein in fibroblasts. IgA class antibodies reactive with orbital components appeared to be more strongly associated with TAO than those of the IgG class, though even this relationship is weak. These results suggest that antibodies are of secondary importance in the pathogenesis of TAO, which is most likely a T cell-mediated disorder.

Immunoglobulin A in Graves' orbital tissue: deoxyribonucleic acid amplification by polymerase chain reaction

A role for IgA autoantibodies in Graves' ophthalmopathy is suggested by the presence of immunoglobulins of this class in Graves' orbital tissue, as detected by immunohistochemistry. We, therefore, investigated the possibility of using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to amplify IgA immunoglobulin genes from plasma cells infiltrating Graves' eye tissue. Template cDNA was reverse-transcribed from orbital muscle (M) mRNA of one patient (#7) and from orbital connective tissue/fat (F) mRNA of two patients (#1 and #7), both undergoing surgery for exophthalmos because of severe infiltrative ophthalmopathy. Preliminary studies to establish the PCR procedure were performed for kappa light chain DNA amplification. With the very small amount of orbital tissue template available, the sensitive "hot start" modification of the PCR was necessary to amplify significant amounts of kappa light chain DNA. Using this procedure, IgA heavy chain DNA was amplified from both connective tissue/fat (F7) and muscle (M7) cDNA of patient #7. The DNA yield was less for IgA than for IgG using the same template. There was no significant IgA (or IgG) DNA product using the connective tissue/fat cDNA of patient #1. While not implying that IgA-infiltrating plasma cells are specific for Graves' orbital tissue, our studies nevertheless demonstrate the feasibility of amplifying the genes coding for IgA antibodies from Graves' orbital tissue plasma cells. Expression of these immunoglobulin genes in future studies will make it possible to determine the antigen specificity of the antibodies expressed by Graves' orbital tissue plasma cells.