Restriction of prenatal gas exchange impairs memory consolidation in the chick

Effects of stress during commercial hatching on growth, egg production and feather pecking in laying hens

Every year, billions of egg layer chicks around the world are hatched under highly stressful, industrial circumstances. Here, it is investigated how the stressful procedure in the commercial hatchery, including incubation, hatching, processing, and transport affects the chicks with regards to traits relevant for the egg production industry. These traits were compared to those of a control group hatched in a small incubator and handled gently och quietly in a quiet room without any processing and transport. The chicks were weighed at hatch and at eight additional time points: 4 days, 1 week (w), 2 w, 3 w, 5 w, 8 w, 20 w and 25 w of age. Feather pecking was studied at 15 w of age and damages to the feathers and injuries on the comb and wattle were assessed at 25 w of age. From 19 w of age, eggs were collected on three days per week, counted and weighed. Chicks from a commercial hatchery had a lower hatch weight than control chicks (p<0.001). At 20 w of age, the weight of the commercial hatched chicks was still numerically lower, although this did not reach statistical significance. Commercially hatched chicks tended to show more feather pecking behaviour at 15 w of age compared to control chicks (p<0.1), although feather condition at 25 w of age showed the opposite pattern. Regarding production, commercially hatched chickens laid fewer (p<0.05) and smaller (p<0.05) eggs than chicks hatched and handled under calm circumstances. From this experiment, it is concluded that the stressful experience in the commercial hatchery has an overall negative effect on traits relevant for the industry.

Effects of Prenatal Hypoxia on Nervous System Development and Related Diseases

The fetal origins of adult disease (FOAD) hypothesis, which was proposed by David Barker in the United Kingdom in the late 1980s, posited that adult chronic diseases originated from various adverse stimuli in early fetal development. FOAD is associated with a wide range of adult chronic diseases, including cardiovascular disease, cancer, type 2 diabetes and neurological disorders such as schizophrenia, depression, anxiety, and autism. Intrauterine hypoxia/prenatal hypoxia is one of the most common complications of obstetrics and could lead to alterations in brain structure and function; therefore, it is strongly associated with neurological disorders such as cognitive impairment and anxiety. However, how fetal hypoxia results in neurological disorders remains unclear. According to the existing literature, we have summarized the causes of prenatal hypoxia, the effects of prenatal hypoxia on brain development and behavioral phenotypes, and the possible molecular mechanisms.

Incubation, hatchery practice and the welfare of layer hens

For modern layers to achieve optimum production performance and welfare state, the entire production process needs to be managed to achieve target bodyweight, body composition and flock uniformity. In addition to genetic improvements, flock health, environment, nutrition and on-farm husbandry practices, incubation and hatchery practices have become a focal point for producing optimum chick quality. Chick quality is a collective term involving chick size and anatomical features, physiology, robustness and liveability over the first week after placement. Chick quality is a key focus for hatcheries as this has been positively correlated with overall flock performance, especially egg production, shell quality, liveability and animal welfare. Recent advances in incubation have focussed on the benefits of all-in–all-out (single-stage) machines. Innovation in incubation systems is completely conducted today by international manufacturers, and is largely driven by the meat chicken industry. Disposal of male layer chicks has increased as a consumer welfare concern, and while investment in research and legislation changes are focussed towards providing or driving new solutions, there are currently no commercial options for industry to deal with this problem before incubation or hatch. Chick transport systems and equipment have also significantly improved in recent years, providing optimum conditions to ensure temperature uniformity and minimal moisture loss during transit before placement, thus optimising chick quality. Together, recent improvements in incubation equipment and hatchery practice can produce commercial layer chicks that are healthy, of high quality, and are then in an optimal physiological state and condition to achieve their genetic potential.

Incubation and hatching conditions of laying hen chicks explain a large part of the stress effects from commercial large-scale hatcheries

In commercial egg production, laying hen chicks are exposed to several stressful events during incubation, hatching, and their first hours in life. We have previously shown that hatching and processing are associated with increased corticosterone concentration and further affect behavior and stress sensitivity in a short- as well as long-term perspective. However, it is not known whether these long-term stress effects are caused by the hatchery processing (sex sorting, vaccination, conveying, and loading for transport) or if they are mainly caused by potentially stressful events before processing, during incubation and hatching. In the present study, the aim was to assess the effects of incubation and hatching only, compared to stress effects from the entire hatchery processing. We compared Lohmann LSL chicks incubated, hatched, and processed in a commercial hatchery with chicks incubated and hatched at the same time but not further processed. We studied behavior in a novel arena and during tonic immobility, as well as weight development and corticosterone reaction during a stress challenge. Processed chicks had poorer weight development and were more active in the novel arena test. However, there were no significant differences between the groups in corticosterone reactivity or tonic immobility. When comparing with previous data, both groups had elevated corticosterone concentrations compared to what we had previously reported from chicks hatched under calm and non-stressful conditions. In conclusion, incubation and hatching alone caused long-term stress effects in chickens, but further processing exacerbated these effects to some extent.

Effects of commercial hatchery processing on short- and long-term stress responses in laying hens

In commercial egg production, chicks are exposed to a potentially stressful procedure during their first day of life. Here, we investigated how this procedure affects the chickens in a short- as well as long-term perspective by conducting two behaviour tests and measuring corticosterone (CORT) and sex hormone levels at different time points. These results were compared with a group of control chickens from the same hatchery and incubator that did not go through the commercial hatchery routine. Chickens were continuously weighed, egg production data was collected and feather scoring was performed. We found that chicks have a significant increase in CORT during the hatchery process, which implies they are exposed to stress. During first weeks of life, these chicks were more fearful, had a higher CORT reactivity during restraint and weighed more than control chicks. Later in life, hatchery treated chickens had more feather damages and injuries on combs and wattles, a faster onset of egg laying and higher levels of estradiol. We conclude that processing at the commercial hatchery was a stressful event with short- and long-term effects on behaviour and stress reactivity, and potentially also positive effects on production. The results are relevant for a large number of individuals, since the chicken is by far the globally most common farm animal.

Early experiences matter: a review of the effects of prenatal environment on offspring characteristics in poultry

Early life experiences can be important in determining offspring phenotypes and may influence interaction with the environment and hence health, welfare, and productivity. The prenatal environment of poultry can be divided into the pre-lay environment and the egg storage/incubation environment, both of which can affect offspring outcomes. The ability to separate maternal and egg/incubation effects makes birds well suited to this type of research. There are many factors, including feeding and nutrition, environmental conditions, husbandry practices, housing system, social environment, infectious environment, and maternal health status, that can influence both the health and performance and behavior and cognition of the offspring. There are some aspects of the environments that can be changed to produce beneficial effects in the offspring, like addition of certain additives to feed or short changes in incubation temperatures, while other aspects should be avoided to reduce negative effects, such as unpredictable feeding and lighting regimens. Measures of offspring characteristics may prove to be a useful method of assessing parent stock welfare if known stressors result in predictable offspring outcomes. This has the advantage of assessing the parent environment without interfering with the animals and possibly affecting their responses and could lead to improved welfare for the animals.

Effects of lanthanum chloride administration in prenatal stage on one-trial passive avoidance learning in chicks

Lanthanum cations (La 3+) are well known for their inhibitory actions on calcium channels. Prenatal lanthanum exposure may affect the development of embryo and alter the capacity for learning and memory in adults, and the one-trial passive avoidance learning paradigm with day-old chicks is an excellent model to study several mechanisms of memory formation. In the present study, we examined the effects of prenatal lanthanum chloride exposure on memory consolidation using one-trial passive avoidance learning task in day-old chicks. The data suggest that chicks injected with lanthanum chloride (2 mg/kg) daily from E9 to E16 had significantly impaired long-term memory at 120 min after training (p < 0.05) but not the chicks injected with lanthanum chloride (0.1 mg/kg) daily from E9 to E16.

Importance of adrenergic receptors in prenatally induced cognitive impairment in the domestic chick

In the domestic chick, mild hypoxia (24h of 14% oxygen) at two stages of embryonic development results in post-hatch memory deficiencies tested using a discriminated bead avoidance task. The nature of the memory loss depends on the gestational age at which the hypoxia occurs. Hypoxia on embryonic day 10 (E10) of a 21 day incubation results in chicks with no short-term memory 10 min after training, whereas hypoxia on day 14 (E14) results in chicks with good labile memory 30 min after training but no consolidation of memory into permanent storage (120 min). Hypoxia at E14 is associated with increased plasma levels of noradrenaline and therefore we suggest that altered catecholamine exposure within the brain contributes to cognitive problems by modifying the responsiveness of brain beta-adrenoceptors. In ovo administration of noradrenaline, or the beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonist formoterol, at E14 had the same effect on memory consolidation as hypoxia. Following hypoxia at E14, memory could be rescued after training by central injection of a beta(3)-adrenoceptor agonist, but not by a beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonist. The differences in the responsiveness of memory processing to beta(2)-adrenoceptor agonists suggests alterations to the receptors or downstream of the receptor activation. However, both types of beta-adrenoceptor agonists rescued memory in E10 treated chicks implying that at this age hypoxia does not affect the receptors. In summary, hypoxia or increased levels of stress hormones during incubation alters beta-adrenoceptor responsiveness; the outcome of the insult depends upon the cellular developmental processes at a given embryonic stage.

The effect of hypoxia at different embryonic ages on impairment of memory ability in chicks

Hypoxia during the prenatal period is a principal antecedent to cognitive impairment after birth. In this study we have investigated the duration, severity and timing of acute hypoxia during chick embryonic development to elucidate the relative importance of these factors. Our results show that 24h of hypoxia (exposure to 14% oxygen) at embryonic day 10 (E10) results in significant impairment of intermediate and long-term memory in the post-hatch chick, which is the same as we observed with 4 days of hypoxia. At E14, 24h of hypoxia, 5min of anoxia, but not 1h of hypoxia, resulted only in impaired long-term memory; the same as 4 days of hypoxia from E14. Corticosterone levels, measured post-hatch as an indicator of a stress response, were significantly elevated in response to E10 hypoxia, and E14 hypoxia (both 1 and 24h) and anoxia. In a separate experiment we exposed embryos to 24h of hypoxia from E6 to E16, and found that memory deficits resulted from hypoxia at E9 and E10, and E13-E15, while corticosterone concentrations at hatch were significantly raised following E10-E16 hypoxia. These results demonstrate that the developmental age when the insult occurs determines the nature of the cognitive deficit and, if the severity of the insult is sufficient, then the outcome, or deficits in memory ability, are consistent whether the insult is acute or chronic. Importantly, there are two critical stages in development, which in the chick are around E10 and E14, when acute hypoxia results in significant adverse cognitive effects after hatch. These time-points correspond to two different stages in growth and development.

The role of corticosterone in prehatch-induced memory deficits in chicks

We have previously shown that prehatch hypoxia (14% oxygen for 24 h), at E10 or E14 of chick embryonic development, produces significant memory deficits, with E10 hypoxia significantly affecting short-term memory and the subsequent formation of long-term memory, whereas E14 hypoxia only affects long-term memory. One of the consequences of hypoxia is the release of stress hormones and we found in this study that hypoxia at E10 or E14 induced a significant increase in circulating corticosterone immediately after the cessation of hypoxia (E11 and E15, respectively). Corticosterone levels remained significantly elevated at hatch in the E14 hypoxia group. This study describes the effect of a single, in ovo, injection of corticosterone on subsequent memory ability in hatched chicks. It was found that corticosterone (0.2 nmol/egg) at E10 or E14 mimicked the memory deficits produced by hypoxia at the same prehatch ages. Embryos treated with corticosterone at E10 had poor short-term memory at hatch, whereas corticosterone administration at E14 resulted in poor long-term memory. Embryos treated with corticosterone at E16 had raised circulating corticosterone levels at hatch, but did not have impaired memory. Treatment with corticosterone at E10, E12, E14 and E16 produced the same cognitive outcomes as hypoxia at the same prehatch ages. However, elevated plasma corticosterone levels at hatch did not necessarily cause the impaired memory processing. Raised levels were observed after treatment at E14 when memory processing was impaired, at E16 when memory was not impaired and not at E10 when memory was impaired. This suggests that an acute rather than sustained increase in plasma corticosterone at particular developmental ages is the cause of impaired memory processing seen at hatch.

Neonatal exposure to intermittent hypoxia enhances mice performance in water maze and 8-arm radial maze tasks

Hypoxia has generally been reported to impair learning and memory. Here we established a hypoxia-enhanced model. Intermittent hypoxia (IH) was simulated at 2 km (16.0% O2) or 5 km (10.8% O2) in a hypobaric chamber for 4 h/day from birth to 1, 2, 3, or 4 week(s), respectively. Spatial learning and memory ability was tested in the Morris water maze (MWM) task at ages of postnatal day 36 (P36)-P40 and P85-89, respectively, and in the 8-arm maze task at P60-68. The long-term potentiation (LTP), synaptic density, and phosphorylated cAMP-responsive element-binding protein (p-CREB) level in the hippocampus were measured in mice at P36 under the IH for 4 weeks (IH-4w). The results showed that IH for 3 weeks (IH-3w) and IH-4w at 2 km significantly reduced the escape latencies of mice at P36-40 in the MWM task with significantly enhanced retention, and this spatial enhancement was further confirmed by the 8-arm maze test in mice at P60-68. The improvement in MWM induced by IH-4w at 2 km was still maintained in mice at P85-89. IH-4w at 2 or 5 km significantly increased amplitude of LTP, the number of synapse, and the p-CREB level in the hippocampus of P36 mice. These results indicated that IH (4 h/day) exposure to neonatal mice at 2 km for 3 or 4 weeks enhanced mice spatial learning and memory, which was related to the increased p-CREB, LTP, and synapses of hippocampus in this model.

Growth restriction and the cerebral metabolic response to acute hypoxia of chick embryos in-ovo: a proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy study

INTRODUCTION

Perinatal brain injury is more common in growth-restricted (GR) than normally grown (NG) fetuses. This study addresses the hypothesis that chronic oxygen and substrate deprivation during pregnancy will engender an abnormal fetal cerebral metabolic response to acute hypoxia.

METHOD

Cerebral metabolite resonance amplitudes relative to that of creatine were measured by proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy in chick embryos on day 19 of incubation. Measurements were obtained before, during and after acute hypoxia (8% ambient oxygen concentration for 44 min) in NG and GR embryos (10% albumen extracted day 0 and 14% oxygen exposure from day 10 of incubation).

RESULTS

In both NG and GR embryos, the cerebral lactate/creatine increased during acute hypoxia and slowly recovered after restoration of normoxia. However, the mean (+/-SD) increase in lactate/creatine was significantly less in GR compared to NG embryos (0.51 +/- 0.36 vs. 0.94 +/- 0.36; P = 0.02, t test). Alanine increased during acute hypoxia in NG but not GR embryos. Mean beta-hydroxybutyrate was increased only in GR embryos (0.63 +/- 0.01 vs. 0.22 +/- 0.01; P < 0.001, ANOVA).

CONCLUSIONS

Acute hypoxia increases cerebral lactate and alanine in NG chick embryos; these increases are reduced by pre-exposure to substrate deprivation and chronic hypoxia.

Prenatal hypoxia impairs memory function but does not result in overt structural alterations in the postnatal chick brain

We showed previously that hypoxia in ovo impairs memory consolidation in the chick tested 2 days after hatching. Our present aim was to investigate whether we could detect any morphological effects of the same prenatal hypoxia. Hypoxia was induced by half-wrapping the egg with an impermeable membrane from either days 10-18 (W10-18 chicks) or days 14-18 (W14-18 chicks) of incubation (hatching approximately 21 days). Measurement of blood gases showed that reducing the surface area of the egg for gas exchange resulted in reduced pO2 and increased pCO2 2 days after wrapping. Although this hypoxia was sufficient to impair cognitive processing in the postnatal chick, our data suggest that it did not produce overt structural alterations or changes in the number of neurons, glutamine synthetase-immunoreactive cells or immunoreactivity to synaptophysin in the presynaptic vesicles in the multimodal integration (cortical) area compared to controls. Hence, we found no differences in the astrocyte to neuron ratio, synaptic density and/or vesicle number. Analysis of the ontogeny of astrocytes during the prenatal period of hypoxia showed them to be present at embryonic day 12, but not at the earlier ages examined. Although we found cognitive deficits in chicks from embryos made hypoxic during incubation, our regimen of prenatal hypoxia did not alter any of the parameters measured in the brains. This does not preclude the possibility that changes have occurred at the cellular or molecular levels or in specific neurotransmitter systems.

The effect of prenatal morphine exposure on memory consolidation in the chick

The central nervous system exhibits remarkable plasticity in early life and can be altered significantly by prenatal morphine exposure. Previous studies show that prenatal morphine exposure may alter the capacity for learning and memory in post-partum chicks. The one-trial passive avoidance learning paradigm with 1-day-old chicks is an excellent model to study several mechanisms of memory formation, including STM, ITM, and LTM. The following represents our investigation of the effect of prenatal morphine exposure on learning and memory deficits in the chick. In these experiments, morphine was injected into the airspace of eggs (20 mg/kg) and the one-trial passive avoidance learning paradigm was used to test the effect of prenatal morphine exposure on memory consolidation. The data suggest that chicks injected with morphine daily from E12 to E16 had significantly impaired long-term memory at 120 min after training (p<0.001) but not intermediate-term memory at 30 min after training.

Fetal consequences of chronic substrate deprivation

The aim of this paper is to review the mechanisms by which animal and human fetuses survive prolonged periods of substrate deprivation in utero. Two reasons why such information is important for those who care for growth-restricted fetuses and neonates are as follows. (1) Understanding the physiology is central to designing appropriate tests for determining fetal well-being. For instance, most currently available techniques for monitoring fetal well-being are actually better designed to detect acute than chronic fetal hypoxaemia. (2) There is increasing interest in the medium- and long-term consequences of fetal growth restriction on cardiovascular, neurological and lung function. As an example, the reasons why chronic oxygen deprivation may influence cerebral structure and function are discussed.

The effect of prenatal hypoxia and malnutrition on memory consolidation in the chick

The contribution of hypoxia and malnutrition to cognitive impairments was investigated in chicks incubated in conditions of reduced gas exchange. Previous research has shown that reducing gas exchange during incubation by wrapping half the eggshell with an impermeable membrane results in impaired cognitive ability in young chicks. The results were interpreted within a three stage sequential model of memory using discriminated bead avoidance learning. Reducing gas exchange for 4 days from day 10 or 14, of the 21-day incubation, inhibits memory formation and consolidation into permanent storage. The nature of the cognitive deficit depended on the timing of the insult. Environmental hypoxia (14% oxygen), induced from days 10 to 14 and from days 14 to 18, replicated the memory deficits found previously when eggs were partially wrapped with a membrane. Oxygen is necessary to break down food and to provide energy to build tissue proteins, and therefore hypoxia (partial wrapping or environmental incubation) may indirectly cause malnutrition. Malnutrition, induced by removing 5%, 7.5% or 10% albumin from the egg prior to incubation, had no significant effect on memory consolidation. Raised corticosterone levels occurred in chicks malnourished by 5% and 7.5%, but brain sparing was only evident in chicks with 7.5% albumin removal. Hatch rates were very low in 10% malnourished chicks. Using the chick as a model of prenatal stress, we have been able to isolate the effects of hypoxia from contributing maternal factors.

The role of catecholamines in memory impairment in chicks following reduced gas exchange in ovo

We have shown previously that reducing gas exchange to chick embryos by half wrapping eggs with an impermeable membrane from either days 14-18 (W14-18) or days 10-18 (W10-18) of the 21 day incubation results in post-hatch memory deficits. In the W10-18 chicks, short-term memory following training is impaired, whereas in the W14-18 chicks, memory is intact for 30 min but does not consolidate into long-term storage. The reduction in gas exchange caused by half wrapping eggs resulted in alterations in hematocrit, O2 and CO2 tensions suggesting that the embryos are hypoxic and hypercapnic. Our aim was to test the hypothesis that increases in circulating levels of catecholamines in ovo, as a result of hypoxia, lead to a disturbance of the central noradrenergic pathways resulting in cognitive impairment. Noradrenaline is critical for memory consolidation and a disturbance during development could compromise cognitive ability. In the present study, plasma noradrenaline levels were significantly elevated compared with control levels 2 days after hatch in W14-18 chicks. There was also a decrease in tissue noradrenaline concentration in the anterior forebrain in both W14-18 and W10-18 chicks. The differential ability of centrally administered beta2- and beta3-adrenoceptor agonists to overcome the memory deficit post-training, suggests altered responsiveness of central beta2-adrenoceptors to noradrenaline in W14-18 chicks. By comparing the W10-18 and W14-18 chicks with those from eggs wrapped from W10-14 we show that it is the timing of the prenatal hypoxia, rather than its duration, that determines the nature of cognitive dysfunction. We conclude that prenatal hypoxia induced by restriction of gas exchange can disrupt or alter central noradrenergic transmission causing cognitive impairment.