Longitudinal survey of voice quality after pediatric laryngotracheoplasty

Characterizing Dysphonia After Pediatric Open Airway Reconstruction: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Pediatric laryngotracheal stenosis often requires open airway reconstruction. While these surgeries establish an airway for adequate ventilation, many patients develop subsequent dysphonia. Numerous studies have reported outcomes related to voice.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to evaluate dysphonia in pediatric patients following open airway reconstruction, focusing on acoustic parameters, perceptual voice quality, and voice-related quality of life.

METHODS

A comprehensive search using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines across 6 databases identified articles involving pediatric patients who underwent open airway reconstruction and reported postoperative vocal acoustic parameters, perceptual voice quality, voice-related quality of life, or vocal mechanics. Articles were assessed for bias risk, and common outcomes were synthesized qualitatively and quantitatively using meta-analyses.

RESULTS

Among 4089 articles, 21 were included, involving 497 pediatric patients. Laryngotracheoplasty was the most common procedure followed by cricotracheal resection. The Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice (CAPE-V) scale was frequently used to assess voice quality, with a mean score of 55.6 [95% confidence intervals (CIs): 47.9-63.3]. Voice-related quality of life was measured using the pediatric Voice Handicap Index (pVHI) and Pediatric Voice-Related Quality of Life Survey, with mean scores of 35.6 (95% CI: 21.4-49.7) and 83.7 (95% CI: 74.1-93.2), respectively. The fundamental frequency was 210.5 (95% CI: 174.6-246.3). Other common findings included supraglottic phonation, anterior commissure blunting, posterior glottic diastasis, and abnormal vocal cord mobility.

CONCLUSION

Pediatric patients experiencing dysphonia after open airway reconstruction exhibited moderately decreased voice quality and reduced voice-related quality of life. However, there was inconsistency in study protocols and outcome measures used. Preserving voice quality during airway reconstruction is crucial to avoid negative impacts on quality of life.

Cross-sectional follow-up of voice outcomes in children who have a history of airway reconstruction surgery

OBJECTIVES

This study reports vocal function in a cross-section of children with subglottic stenosis. Each child had a history of laryngotracheal reconstruction and/or cricotracheal resection surgery. Vocal function was measured using laryngoscopy, acoustic analysis, perceptual evaluation and impact of voice on quality of life.

DESIGN

All patients aged >5 years with history of laryngotracheal reconstruction and/or cricotracheal resection surgery at the Scottish National Complex Airways service were invited to participate.

SETTING

Data were gathered in the Royal Hospital for Children in Glasgow in a single outpatient appointment.

PARTICIPANTS

Twelve of 56 former patients (aged 5-27) provided a voice sample and eleven consented to awake laryngoscopy. All consented for detailed evaluation of their medical records.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Acoustic analysis of fundamental frequency and pitch perturbation was conducted on sustained vowel [a]. Perceptual evaluation was conducted by 4 trained listeners on a series of spoken sentences. Impact on quality of life was measured using the paediatric voice-related quality of life questionnaire. Laryngeal function was descriptively evaluated.

RESULTS

Four children had normal voice acoustically, perceptually and in relation to voice-related quality of life. One of these had vocal fold nodules unrelated to surgical history. Two other children had "near normal" vocal function, defined where most voice measurements fell within the normal range.

CONCLUSIONS

Normal or "near normal" voice is a possible outcome for children who have had this surgery. Where there is an ongoing complex medical condition, voice outcome may be poorer.

Quality of Life and Voice Outcomes after Thyroid Ala Graft Laryngotracheal Reconstruction in Young Children

Objectives. (1) To assess the long-term impact of thyroid ala cartilage laryngotracheal reconstruction (TAC-LTR) on health-related quality of life (QOL) in infants using 4 validated instruments: Health Utility Index version 3 (HUI3), Pediatric Voice-Related QOL (PVRQOL), Impact on Family Questionnaire, and a visual analog scale and (2) to perform acoustic and perceptual voice assessments to evaluate long-term voice quality outcomes.

Study Design. Prospective study.

Setting. Tertiary academic pediatric hospital.

Subjects. Eligible children who received TAC-LTR before the age of 24 months between 1995 and 2007.

Methods. Interviews with parents and children using 4 validated instruments, voice analyses, and endoscopic evaluation were performed.

Results. Twelve patients (7 male, 5 female, median age 10 years) were enrolled over a 6-month period. The mean age at LTR was 5 months (range, 1-20 months), and the mean study follow-up period was 9 years (range, 2-14 years). The average speech HUI3, PVRQOL, and Impact on Family scores were 0.83 (95% confidence interval = 0.74, 0.92), 0.93 (interquartile range [IQR] = 0.81, 1.00), and 0.65 (IQR = 0.54, 0.92), respectively. All acoustic scores were either normal or mildly abnormal for the variables jitter, shimmer, noise-to-harmonic ratio, peak amplitude variation, and fundamental frequency. The Consensus Auditory-Perceptual Evaluation of Voice overall severity score was in the normal to mildly abnormal range for 8 of 9 patients.

Conclusion. This is the first study to explore and quantify long-term QOL and voice quality in children following LTR with thyroid ala graft at a very young age. Most patients had very good functional voice outcome as evidenced by the HUI3 and PVRQOL scores. This was corroborated by acoustic and perceptual voice assessments.

Phonomicrosurgery in singers and performing artists: treatment outcomes, management theories, and future directions

Phonomicrosurgery in performing artists has historically been approached with great trepidation, and vocal outcome data are sparse. The vocal liability of surgically disturbing the superficial lamina propria (SLP) and epithelium must be balanced with the inherent detrimental vocal effect of the lesion(s). A prospective investigation was performed on 185 performing artists who underwent phonomicrosurgical resection of 365 lesions: 201 nodules, 71 polyps, 66 varices and ectasias, 13 cysts, 8 keratotic lesions, 2 granulomas, 2 Reinke's edema, and 2 papillomas. Nearly all patients with SLP lesions reported improvement in their postsurgical vocal function. This subjective result was supported by objective acoustic and aerodynamic measures. All postsurgical objective vocal function measures fell within normal limits, including a few that displayed presurgical abnormalities. However, given the relative insensitivity of standard objective measures to assess higher-level vocal performance-related factors, it is even more noteworthy that 8 of 24 objective measures displayed statistically significant postsurgical improvements in vocal function. Such changes in objective measures mostly reflect overall enhancement in the efficiency of voice production. Phonomicrosurgical resection of vocal fold lesions in performing artists is enjoying an expanding role because of a variety of improvements in diagnostic assessment, surgical instrumentation and techniques, and specialized rehabilitation. Most of these lesions are the result of phonotrauma and arise within the SLP. Successful management depends on prudent patient selection and counseling, ultraprecise technique, and vigorqus vocal rehabilitation. Furthermore, an understanding of the vocal function and dysfunction of this high-performance population provides all otolaryngologists who manage laryngeal problems with valuable information that they can extrapolate for use in their practices.

Improved airway healing using transforming growth factor beta-3 In a rabbit model

Laryngeal wound healing is essential following laryngotracheal surgery. Patients with poor wound healing develop poor epithelial closure and increased granulation tissue which cause a stenosis of the repaired airway. Transforming growth factor-beta3 has been shown to enhance wound healing in cutaneous wounds, but has never been used in the airway. This study utilized a rabbit laryngeal wound-healing model that has been shown to be reproducible with limited morbidity. Thirty-four rabbits underwent a cricoid-split operation with collagen sponge insertion. All animals were classified randomly into three groups: local administration of placebo (Group G1, n = 13), 0.18 microg transforming growth factor-beta3 (Group G2, n = 11) and of 1.0 microg transforming growth factor-beta3 (Group G3, n = 10). All animals survived the postoperative period without respiratory distress. The airway was harvested six days after surgery and assessed by light microscopy. Histologic evidence for healing was subjectively graded by two blinded, independent investigators, and the results were statistically analyzed for significance. A significant improvement in the epithelial closure (p < 0.01) and subepithelial connective tissue closure (p < 0.005) was found in the 1.0 microg transforming growth factor-beta3 group (G3) compared with the placebo group (G1). Analysis of the 0.18 microg transforming growth factor-beta3 group (G2) did not reveal any significant differences compared with the placebo group (G1). These results suggest an application for transforming growth factor-beta3 in accelerating wound healing in the larynx.