Antiviral drug susceptibility assays: going with the flow

Flow Cytometry: A Multipurpose Technology for a Wide Spectrum of Global Biosecurity Applications

Flow cytometry, and its offspring-flow sorting, are extremely useful technologies for biosecurity and public health studies related to infectious disease. Applications range from environmental surveillance of pathogens to diagnosis and the development of vaccines and therapeutics for prevention and control of infectious diseases. Flow cytometers have been developed for laboratory analysis and field deployment. The current state of the art could enjoy more widespread use if instruments and data analysis were made simpler and had more automated functions, and if technology was modified to reduce biosafety concerns related to analysis and sorting of infectious organisms. The full spectrum of possible applications of flow cytometry technology to global biosecurity challenges has not yet been realized.

Phenotypic drug susceptibility assay for influenza virus neuraminidase inhibitors

A flow cytometric (fluorescence-activated cell sorter [FACS]) assay was developed for analysis of the drug susceptibilities of wild-type and drug-resistant influenza A and B virus laboratory strains and clinical isolates for the neuraminidase (NA) inhibitors oseltamivir carboxylate, zanamivir, and peramivir. The drug susceptibilities of wild-type influenza viruses and those with mutations in the hemagglutinin (HA) and/or NA genes rendering them resistant to one or more of the NA inhibitors were easily determined with the FACS assay. The drug concentrations that reduced the number of virus-infected cells or the number of PFU by 50% as determined by the FACS assay were similar to those obtained with the more time-consuming and labor-intensive virus yield reduction assay. The NA inhibition (NAI) assay confirmed the resistance patterns demonstrated by the FACS and virus yield assays for drug-resistant influenza viruses with mutations in the NA gene. However, only the FACS and virus yield assays detected NA inhibitor-resistant influenza viruses with mutations in the HA gene but not in the NA gene. The FACS assay is more rapid and less labor-intensive than the virus yield assay and just as quantitative. The FACS assay determines the drug susceptibilities of influenza viruses with mutations in either the HA or NA genes, making the assay more broadly useful than the NAI assay for measuring the in vitro susceptibilities of influenza viruses for NA inhibitors. However, since only viruses with mutations in the NA gene that lead to resistance to the NA inhibitors correlate with clinical resistance, this in vitro assay should not be used in the clinical setting to determine resistance to NA inhibitors. The assay may be useful for determining the in vivo susceptibilities of other compounds effective against influenza A and B viruses.

Use of a single monoclonal antibody to determine the susceptibilities of herpes simplex virus type 1 and type 2 clinical isolates to acyclovir

This report describes a flow cytometry drug susceptibility assay that uses a single fluorochrome-labeled monoclonal antibody to determine the acyclovir susceptibilities of herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 1 or type 2 clinical isolates. This assay yields 50% effective doses (drug concentrations that reduce the number of antigen-positive cells by 50%) for HSV clinical isolates that are equivalent to those obtained with the plaque reduction assay.

Inhibition of ganciclovir-susceptible and -resistant human cytomegalovirus clinical isolates by the benzimidazole L-riboside 1263W94

The average 50% inhibitory concentration (IC(50)) values for AD169 were 0.22 +/- 0.09 microM 1263W94 and 5.36 +/- 0.12 microM ganciclovir. For 35 human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) clinical isolates the average IC(50) was 0.42 +/- 0.09 microM 1263W94, and for 26 ganciclovir-susceptible HCMV clinical isolates the average IC(50) was 3.78 +/- 1.62 microM ganciclovir. Nine HCMV clinical isolates that were resistant to ganciclovir were completely susceptible to 1263W94.

Susceptibilities of human cytomegalovirus clinical isolates to BAY38-4766, BAY43-9695, and ganciclovir

BAY38-4766 and BAY43-9695 are nonnucleosidic compounds with activities against human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). Two phenotypic assays were used to determine the drug susceptibilities of 36 HCMV clinical isolates to the BAY compounds and ganciclovir. Using either assay, both BAY compounds at a concentration of approximately 1 microM inhibited the replication of all 36 HCMV clinical isolates, including 11 ganciclovir-resistant clinical isolates, by 50%.

A rapid assay for evaluation of antiviral activity against coxsackie virus B3, influenza virus A, and herpes simplex virus type 1

In order to identify new potential antiviral drugs, small amounts of extracts or compounds have to be examined for cytotoxicity and antiviral activity in primary screening using a rapid, easy, inexpensive, and highly standardised test system. In this study, high-throughput cytopathic effect (CPE) inhibitory assays were established for coxsackie virus B3 on HeLa Ohio cells, influenza virus A on Madin-Darby canine kidney cells, and herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) on green monkey kidney cells that meet these requirements. The cytotoxic and the antiviral effects were quantified using a crystal violet uptake assay allowing automated handling of large numbers of candidate agents. To ensure comparable results with plaque reduction assays, the 50 and 90% plaque inhibitory concentrations of guanidine, amantadine, and phosphonoformic acid were used to standardise the anti-coxsackie virus B3, anti-influenza virus A, and anti-HSV-1 tests, respectively. The strong correlation between the antiviral activity determined by CPE-inhibitory assays and plaque reduction assay was further proved for other antivirals. In summary, low amounts of large numbers of compounds may be tested inexpensively and standardised within 24 h (coxsackie virus B3 and influenza virus A) or 48 h (herpes simplex virus type 1) post-infection using CPE inhibitory assays.

Susceptibility of human herpesvirus 6 to antiviral compounds by flow cytometry analysis

BACKGROUND

The emergence of human herpesvirus 6 (HHV-6) as a human pathogen led to the possibility of specific therapy against HHV-6 and the development of standardized susceptibility assays of HHV-6 to antivirals.

METHODS

We have developed a flow cytometry method to analyze the multiplication of the HST strain of human herpesvirus 6 (HHV-6) variant B in vitro using monoclonal antibodies specific to virus proteins. This method was subsequently used to determine the sensitivity of HST multiplication in MT4 cells to four antiviral compounds of three different classes: acyclovir (ACV) and ganciclovir (GCV), two acyclic guanosine analogs; cedofovir (CDV), an acyclic nucleoside phosphonate; and phosphonoformic acid (PFA), a pyrophosphate analog.

RESULTS

The 50% inhibitory concentrations (IC(50)) of ACV, GCV, CDV, and PFA determined by flow cytometry assay were 25.3, 6.4, 0.95, and 6.0 microM, respectively (5.7, 1.6, 0.3, and 1.8 microg/ml, respectively). These data together with the results of cytotoxicity assays confirmed the high efficiency and selectivity of CDV and PFA against HHV-6 B in vitro, suggested by previous results.

CONCLUSIONS

Our flow cytometric assay appeared as a reproducible specific method to characterize HHV-6 susceptibility to antiviral compounds. It can be considered as a convenient alternative to the other immunologic and DNA hybridization assays used for that purpose.

Applications of flow cytometry to clinical microbiology

Classical microbiology techniques are relatively slow in comparison to other analytical techniques, in many cases due to the need to culture the microorganisms. Furthermore, classical approaches are difficult with unculturable microorganisms. More recently, the emergence of molecular biology techniques, particularly those on antibodies and nucleic acid probes combined with amplification techniques, has provided speediness and specificity to microbiological diagnosis. Flow cytometry (FCM) allows single- or multiple-microbe detection in clinical samples in an easy, reliable, and fast way. Microbes can be identified on the basis of their peculiar cytometric parameters or by means of certain fluorochromes that can be used either independently or bound to specific antibodies or oligonucleotides. FCM has permitted the development of quantitative procedures to assess antimicrobial susceptibility and drug cytotoxicity in a rapid, accurate, and highly reproducible way. Furthermore, this technique allows the monitoring of in vitro antimicrobial activity and of antimicrobial treatments ex vivo. The most outstanding contribution of FCM is the possibility of detecting the presence of heterogeneous populations with different responses to antimicrobial treatments. Despite these advantages, the application of FCM in clinical microbiology is not yet widespread, probably due to the lack of access to flow cytometers or the lack of knowledge about the potential of this technique. One of the goals of this review is to attempt to mitigate this latter circumstance. We are convinced that in the near future, the availability of commercial kits should increase the use of this technique in the clinical microbiology laboratory.

Applications of flow cytometry to clinical microbiology

Classical microbiology techniques are relatively slow in comparison to other analytical techniques, in many cases due to the need to culture the microorganisms. Furthermore, classical approaches are difficult with unculturable microorganisms. More recently, the emergence of molecular biology techniques, particularly those on antibodies and nucleic acid probes combined with amplification techniques, has provided speediness and specificity to microbiological diagnosis. Flow cytometry (FCM) allows single- or multiple-microbe detection in clinical samples in an easy, reliable, and fast way. Microbes can be identified on the basis of their peculiar cytometric parameters or by means of certain fluorochromes that can be used either independently or bound to specific antibodies or oligonucleotides. FCM has permitted the development of quantitative procedures to assess antimicrobial susceptibility and drug cytotoxicity in a rapid, accurate, and highly reproducible way. Furthermore, this technique allows the monitoring of in vitro antimicrobial activity and of antimicrobial treatments ex vivo. The most outstanding contribution of FCM is the possibility of detecting the presence of heterogeneous populations with different responses to antimicrobial treatments. Despite these advantages, the application of FCM in clinical microbiology is not yet widespread, probably due to the lack of access to flow cytometers or the lack of knowledge about the potential of this technique. One of the goals of this review is to attempt to mitigate this latter circumstance. We are convinced that in the near future, the availability of commercial kits should increase the use of this technique in the clinical microbiology laboratory.