Continuous weak-affinity immunosensing

On the Use of Surface Plasmon Resonance-Based Biosensors for Advanced Bioprocess Monitoring

Biomanufacturers are being incited by regulatory agencies to transition from a quality by testing framework, where they extensively test their product after their production, to more of a quality by design or even quality by control framework. This requires powerful analytical tools and sensors enabling measurements of key process variables and/or product quality attributes during production, preferably in an online manner. As such, the demand for monitoring technologies is rapidly growing. In this context, we believe surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-based biosensors can play a role in enabling the development of improved bioprocess monitoring and control strategies. The SPR technique has been profusely used to probe the binding behavior of a solution species with a sensor surface-immobilized partner in an investigative context, but its ability to detect binding in real-time and without a label has been exploited for monitoring purposes and is promising for the near future. In this review, we examine applications of SPR that are or could be related to bioprocess monitoring in three spheres: biotherapeutics production monitoring, vaccine monitoring, and bacteria and contaminant detection. These applications mainly exploit SPR’s ability to measure solution species concentrations, but performing kinetic analyses is also possible and could prove useful for product quality assessments. We follow with a discussion on the limitations of SPR in a monitoring role and how recent advances in hardware and SPR response modeling could counter them. Mainly, throughput limitations can be addressed by multi-detection spot instruments, and nonspecific binding effects can be alleviated by new antifouling materials. A plethora of methods are available for cell growth and metabolism monitoring, but product monitoring is performed mainly a posteriori. SPR-based biosensors exhibit potential as product monitoring tools from early production to the end of downstream processing, paving the way for more efficient production control. However, more work needs to be done to facilitate or eliminate the need for sample preprocessing and to optimize the experimental protocols.

A surface plasmon field-enhanced fluorescence reversible split aptamer biosensor

Surface plasmon field-enhanced fluorescence is reported for the readout of a heterogeneous assay that utilizes low affinity split aptamer ligands. Weak affinity ligands that reversibly interact with target analytes hold potential for facile implementation in continuous monitoring biosensor systems. This functionality is not possible without the regeneration of more commonly used assays relying on high affinity ligands and end-point measurement. In fluorescence-based sensors, the use of low affinity ligands allows avoiding this step but it imposes a challenge associated with the weak optical response to the specific capture of the target analyte which is also often masked by a strong background. The coupling of fluorophore labels with a confined field of surface plasmons is reported for strong amplification of the fluorescence signal emitted from the sensor surface and its efficient discrimination from the background. This optical scheme is demonstrated for time-resolved analysis of chosen model analytes - adenoside and adenosine triphosphate - with a split aptamer that exhibits an equilibrium affinity binding constant between 0.73 and 1.35 mM. The developed biosensor enables rapid and specific discrimination of target analyte concentration changes from low μM to mM in buffer as well as in 10% serum.

Entire-Dataset Analysis of NMR Fast-Exchange Titration Spectra: A Mg2+ Titration Analysis for HIV-1 Ribonuclease H Domain

This article communicates our study to elucidate the molecular determinants of weak Mg²⁺ interaction with the ribonuclease H (RNH) domain of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase in solution. As the interaction is weak (a ligand-dissociation constant >1 mM), nonspecific Mg²⁺ interaction with the protein or interaction of the protein with other solutes that are present in the buffer solution can confound the observed Mg²⁺-titration data. To investigate these indirect effects, we monitored changes in the chemical shifts of backbone amides of RNH by recording NMR ¹H-¹⁵N heteronuclear single-quantum coherence spectra upon titration of Mg²⁺ into an RNH solution. We performed the titration under three different conditions: (1) in the absence of NaCl, (2) in the presence of 50 mM NaCl, and (3) at a constant 160 mM Cl^- concentration. Careful analysis of these three sets of titration data, along with molecular dynamics simulation data of RNH with Na⁺ and Cl^- ions, demonstrates two characteristic phenomena distinct from the specific Mg²⁺ interaction with the active site: (1) weak interaction of Mg²⁺, as a salt, with the substrate-handle region of the protein and (2) overall apparent lower Mg²⁺ affinity in the absence of NaCl compared to that in the presence of 50 mM NaCl. A possible explanation may be that the titrated MgCl₂ is consumed as a salt and interacts with RNH in the absence of NaCl. In addition, our data suggest that Na⁺ increases the kinetic rate of the specific Mg²⁺ interaction at the active site of RNH. Taken together, our study provides biophysical insight into the mechanism of weak metal interaction on a protein.

Purification and characterization of Fab fragments with rapid reaction kinetics against myoglobin

Myoglobin is an early biomarker for acute myocardial infarction. Recently, we isolated the antibody IgG-Myo2-7ds, which exhibits unique rapid reaction kinetics toward human myoglobin antigen. Antibodies with rapid dissociation kinetics are thought to be premature IgG forms that are produced during the early stage of in vivo immunization. In the present study, we identified the epitope region of the IgG-Myo2-7ds antibody to be the C-terminal region of myoglobin, which corresponds to 144-154 aa. The Fab fragment was directly purified by papain cleavage and protein G affinity chromatography and demonstrated kinetics of an association constant of 4.02 × 10(4) M(-1) s(-1) and a dissociation constant of 2.28 × 10(-2) s(-1), which retained the unique reaction kinetics of intact IgG-Myo2-7ds antibodies. Because a rapid dissociation antibody can be utilized for antibody recycling, the results from this study would provide a platform for the development of antibody engineering in potential diagnostic areas such as a continuous monitoring system for heart disease.

Refolded scFv antibody fragment against myoglobin shows rapid reaction kinetics

Myoglobin is one of the early biomarkers for acute myocardial infarction. Recently, we have screened an antibody with unique rapid reaction kinetics toward human myoglobin antigen. Antibodies with rapid reaction kinetics are thought to be an early IgG form produced during early stage of in vivo immunization. We produced a recombinant scFv fragment for the premature antibody from Escherichia coli using refolding technology. The scFv gene was constructed by connection of the V(H)-V(L) sequence with a (Gly4Ser)3 linker. The scFv fragment without the pelB leader sequence was expressed at a high level, but the solubility was extremely low. A high concentration of 8 M urea was used for denaturation. The dilution refolding process in the presence of arginine and the redox reagents GSH and GSSH successfully produced a soluble scFv protein. The resultant refolded scFv protein showed association and dissociation values of 9.32 × 10⁻⁴ M⁻¹·s⁻¹ and 6.29 × 10⁻³ s⁻¹, respectively, with an affinity value exceeding 10⁷ M⁻¹ (k(on)/k(off)), maintaining the original rapid reaction kinetics of the premature antibody. The refolded scFv could provide a platform for protein engineering for the clinical application for diagnosis of heart disease and the development of a continuous biosensor.

Premature antibodies with rapid reaction kinetics and their characterization for diagnostic applications

In this study, rapidly reversible antibodies were produced and the binding kinetics, stability, and utility as an analytical binder were evaluated. The number of times the animals were immunized with the antigen (myoglobin as marker for acute myocardial infarction [AMI]) was limited to two, increasing the chances of producing premature antibodies that rapidly reacted with the binding partner in both association and dissociation. The rate constants were higher than 1×10(6)M(-1)s(-1) and 1×10(-3)s(-1), respectively, and the affinity exceeded 10(8)M(-1). They responded to an abrupt environmental change (acidic pH in this study) where the reaction kinetics was changed to slow binding, particularly for dissociation, resulting in a 10-fold increase in affinity. The binding characteristic before and after the transition were stable at 37°C for longer than 1 month, suggesting that the rapidly reversible antibody was the intermediate of the slow binder. The rapid kinetic antibody was used as the primary binder in the conventional competitive immunoassay, which displayed a lower sensitivity than the transformed antibody due to its lower affinity. We further demonstrated that, on combination with a microfluidic label-free sensor, the reaction could be continuously monitored in serum medium by recycling the same antibody without employing the regeneration step.

Note: Simultaneous measurement of surface plasmon resonance and surface-enhanced Raman scattering

A surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) microspectrometer was designed to obtain the incident angle dependence of SERS signals excited by the evanescent field. By simultaneous measurement of the SERS and SPR spectra of analytes, the highest SERS signal intensities were found to appear at the vicinity of the resonance angle. The enhancement factor was about 2.0x10(6). The simulated angle of the maximal SERS intensity based on Fresnel equation was found to be in good agreement with the experimental results. The SERS and SPR spectra captured simultaneously not only directly confirm the correlation between the SERS and SPR but also present a potential technique for obtaining the structure information about the analytes in molecule level with recording their SPR curves.

Immunochemical binding assays for detection and quantification of trace impurities in biotechnological production

New, highly sensitive, biosensor concepts make it possible to assay biomacromolecules at concentrations that previously were far below the limit of detection. The previous generation of assays used in quality control situations during biotechnological production was designed primarily for monitoring target molecules, which typically appeared in high concentrations. Hence, novel analytical techniques with high sensitivity should become increasingly important in meeting the demands from regulatory agencies with regard to declaring levels of impurities in biopharmaceuticals. Such techniques also open up opportunities for a range of other challenging measurements, for example, in the area of biohazards. This review describes the development of immuno-based biosensors and exemplifies these by presenting analyses of common impurities in biopharmaceutical production.

Measurement of monovalent and polyvalent carbohydrate-lectin binding by back-scattering interferometry

Carbohydrate-protein binding is important to many areas of biochemistry. Here, backscattering interferometry (BSI) has been shown to be a convenient and sensitive method for obtaining quantitative information about the strengths and selectivities of such interactions. The surfaces of glass microfluidic channels were covalently modified with extravidin, to which biotinylated lectins were subsequently attached by incubation and washing. The binding of unmodified carbohydrates to the resulting avidin-immobilized lectins was monitored by BSI. Dose-response curves that were generated within several minutes and were highly reproducible in multiple wash/measure cycles provided adsorption coefficients that showed mannose to bind to concanavalin A (conA) with 3.7 times greater affinity than glucose consistent with literature values. Galactose was observed to bind selectively and with similar affinity to the lectin BS-1. The avidities of polyvalent sugar-coated virus particles for immobilized conA were much higher than monovalent glycans, with increases of 60-200 fold per glycan when arrayed on the exterior surface of cowpea mosaic virus or bacteriophage Qbeta. Sugar-functionalized PAMAM dendrimers showed size-dependent adsorption, which was consistent with the expected density of lectins on the surface. The sensitivity of BSI matches or exceeds that of surface plasmon resonance and quartz crystal microbalance techniques, and is sensitive to the number of binding events, rather than changes in mass. The operational simplicity and generality of BSI, along with the near-native conditions under which the target binding proteins are immobilized, make BSI an attractive method for the quantitative characterization of the binding functions of lectins and other proteins.

Monitoring of influenza virus hemagglutinin in process samples using weak affinity ligands and surface plasmon resonance

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was used to screen the interaction between a variety of affinity ligands and hemagglutinin (HA) from human influenza virus, with the aim of identifying low affinity ligands useful for the development of a rapid bioanalytical sensor. Three sialic acid-based structures and four lectins were evaluated as sensor ligands. The sialic acid-based ligands included a natural sialic acid-containing glycoprotein, human alpha1-acid glycoprotein (alpha1-AGP), and two synthetic 6'-sialyllactose-conjugates, with varying degree of substitution. The interaction of HA with the four lectin-based ligands, concanavalin A (Con A), wheat germ agglutinin (WGA), Maackia amurensis lectin (MAL), and Sambucus nigra agglutinin (SNA), showed a wide variation of affinity strengths. Affinity and kinetics data were estimated. Strong affinities were observed for Con A, WGA, alpha1-AGP, and a 6'-sialyllactose-conjugate with a high substitution degree, and low affinities were observed for MAL and a 6'-sialyllactose-conjugate with low substitution. The main objective, to identify a low affinity ligand which could be used for on-line monitoring and product quantification, was met by a 6'-sialyllactose-ovalbumin conjugate that had 0.6 mol ligand per mol carrier protein. The apparent affinity of this ligand was estimated to be 1.5+/-0.03 microM (K(D)) on the SPR surface. Vaccine process samples containing HA were analyzed in the range 10-100 microg HA mL(-1) and correlated with single-radial immunodiffusion. The coefficient of variation on the same chip was between 0.010 and 0.091.

Screening for transient biological interactions as applied to albumin ligands: A new concept for drug discovery

The notion that many biological interactions are based on transient binding (dissociation constants (K(d)) in the range of 10-0.01 mM) is familiar, yet the implications for biological sciences have been realized only recently. An important area of biological sciences is drug design, where the traditional "lock and key" view of binding has prevailed and drug candidates are usually selected on their merits as being tight binders. However, the rationale that transient interactions are of importance for drug discovery is slowly gaining acceptance. These interactions may relate not only to the desired target interaction but also to unwanted interactions creating, for example, toxicity problems. Here we demonstrate, in a high-throughput screening format, affinity selection of weak binders to a model target of albumin by zonal retardation chromatography. It is perceived that this approach can define the "transient drug" as a complement to current drug discovery procedures.

A label-free continuous total-internal-reflection-fluorescence-based immunosensor

In this study, we continuously monitored, second-by-second, concentration changes of two different carbohydrates (maltose and panose) by using monoclonal antibodies in an optical immunosensor based on total internal reflection fluorescence. Earlier studies have demonstrated that these antibodies increase their intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence upon binding of carbohydrate antigens. Using the four immobilized monoclonal antibodies with low affinities (K(d)>10(-6)M), fast kinetics (k(off)>1s(-1)), and high reversibility gave opportunities for developing a continuous immunosensor without any need for regeneration. Since intrinsic fluorescence was used, no extrinsic labeling was necessary. Sensitivity was in the range of 1-5 microM for panose, and 10-15 microM for maltose and the loss of intensity was as low as 3.5% per hour during measurements. Calculations of DeltaH degrees and DeltaS degrees from the temperature dependence of K(d) indicated an enthalpic driven antigen-antibody binding event that is diminished upon antibody immobilization. We feel certain that weakly interacting antibodies can be used in future applications for continuous monitoring where there is a need to achieve instantaneous information on the concentration of an analyte.

Detection of weakly interacting anti-carbohydrate scFv phages using surface plasmon resonance

Methods to characterise and confirm specificity of scFv displayed on phages are important during panning procedures, especially when selecting for antibody fragments with weak affinities in the millimole to micromole range. In this report the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor was used to study and verify specificity of phages displaying weak anti-carbohydrate scFvs. The variable immunoglobulin light (VL) and heavy (VH) chain genes of the weak monoclonal antibody 39.5 were amplified and cloned into a phagemid and displayed as a scFv-pIII fusion protein on filamentous phage. This monoclonal antibody recognises with weak affinity the structural sequence Glcalpha1-4Glc present in a variety of carbohydrate molecules. Injection of the 39.5 phages over a biosensor chip immobilised with a (Glc)4-BSA conjugate confirmed selective binding of the scFv to its antigen. Inhibition studies verified the specificity. These results clearly show that SPR technology can be used to evaluate in terms of binding and specificity weakly interacting scFv displayed on the phage surface.

Transiently binding antibody fragments against Lewis x and sialyl-Lewis x

Biomolecular recognition is often characterised by low affinity where many weak interactions work either alone or in concert, resulting in an inherent dynamic situation. For example the well-studied weak binding of cell-cell interactions is predominantly based on a range of carbohydrates that interact with numerous (protein) ligands. Finding appropriate binders to these carbohydrate structures may pave the way for new analytical strategies based on low affinity, and recombinant antibody technology is a promising approach to the development of such reagents. We have in the present study characterised two low affinity human single chain antibody fragments (scFv) by surface plasmon resonance for use in such applications. The two clones, LeX1 and sLeX10, had been selected from a naive phage display library against Lewis x (Le(x)) and sialyl Le(x) (sLe(x)), respectively. Both LeX1 and sLeX10 showed low affinity, with K(D) values of 3.5+/-0.7 x 10(-5) M for Le(x) and 2.6+/-0.7 x 10(-5) M for sLe(x), respectively. Kinetic studies revealed the scFvs to be associated with fast dissociation rates, with Kd values higher than 0.1 s(-1) for both LeX1 and sLeX10. Apart from the Lewis structures Le(x) and sLe(x), we investigated the conformational isomers Lewis a and sialyl-Lewis a together with the monosaccharide units of the Lewis structures, and both scFvs showed high specificity for their respective carbohydrate. Taking these observations together we have demonstrated that scFv with fast reaction kinetics and low affinity have the necessary characteristics for further development as specific tools in analytical strategies, e.g. differentiation of cells based on the various configurations of carbohydrate epitopes.

Analysis of the specificity and thermodynamics of the interaction between low affinity antibodies and carbohydrate antigens using fluorescence spectroscopy

The purpose of this work has been to examine whether fluorescence spectroscopy can be used to investigate weak or transient binding between monoclonal antibodies and carbohydrate antigens. In earlier studies we have demonstrated that the three monoclonal antibodies 39.4 (IgG2b), 39.5 (IgG2b) and 61.1(IgG3) bind weakly to the glycosidic alpha(1-4) bond present in e.g. maltose and panose. In this study these antibodies showed an enhancement in the fluorescence intensity of tryptophan upon binding in solution to these two carbohydrate antigens. Using a structural analog to maltose, cellobiose, no fluorescence intensity change was induced. Dissociation constants for these antibodies at different temperatures (5-40 degrees C) were obtained in the range of 0.003-0.2 mM and they were in accordance with earlier data from studies on affinity chromatography and surface plasmon resonance. Almost a doubling of the dissociation constants was observed for every 10 degrees C increase in temperature, giving an exothermal reaction with standard enthalpy change of -51 kJ/mol, for the association between antibody and carbohydrate antigen. It was seen that the extra glycosyl ring in panose increased the affinity more than eight times for the monoclonal antibody 39.5. A standard entropy increase of 21%, probably due to hydrophobic effects, is introduced by the extra glycosyl ring, while the enthalpy stays unaffected. This direct fluorescence approach to measure the binding and thermodynamics of an interacting antigen-antibody pair is simple and accurate since measurements are performed in solution and no immobilization or fluorophore labeling of the components is required. Introduction of fluorescence techniques will be a useful complement to current procedures to measure interaction of antibody with antigen and in particular they will offer solutions to detect transiently binding antigens.

Rapid monitoring of recombinant protein products: a comparison of current technologies

Specific measurement of recombinant protein titer in a complex environment during industrial bioprocessing has traditionally relied on labor-intensive and time-consuming immunoassays. In recent years, however, developments in analytical technology have resulted in improved methods for protein product monitoring during bioprocessing. The choice of product-monitoring technology for a particular bioprocess will depend on a variety of assay factors and instrument-specific factors. In this article, we have compiled an overview of the advantages and disadvantages of the most commonly used technologies used: electrochemiluminescence, optical biosensors, rapid chromatography and nephelometry. The advantages of each technology for measuring both small and large recombinant therapeutic proteins are compared with a conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) technique.

Using receptor conformational change to detect low molecular weight analytes by surface plasmon resonance

Small molecules are difficult to directly detect using commercially available surface plasmon resonance (SPR) instruments. This is because low molecular weight compounds do not have sufficient mass to cause a measurable change in refractive index. Refractive index is sensitive, however, to other properties besides the mass of the analyte. Recently the detection of substantial conformational changes for immobilized proteins using SPR has been reported. However, this property has not yet been exploited for the detection of low molecular weight ligand binding to immobilized protein receptors. Here we demonstrate that ligand-induced conformational changes can be used to monitor the binding of small molecules to immobilized maltose-binding protein and tissue transglutaminase. Ligand binding to a receptor that decreases in hydrodynamic radius yielded a net decrease in refractive index. A net positive change in refractive index was observed for a receptor that increases in hydrodynamic radius. Refractive index changes could not be explained by addition of analyte molecular mass to the surface. These SPR responses were a result of specific receptor-ligand interactions, as judged by the reversibility of the response and the similarities between the SPR-determined equilibrium dissociation constants and reported dissociation constants. Additionally, this technique proved to be effective at detecting specific ligands from a panel of small molecules. This SPR method required no alterations in widely used and commercially available instrumentation yet allowed direct detection of very small molecules such as calcium ions (40 Da). Use of receptor conformation to detect low molecular weight analytes has potential applications in the high-throughput screening of small molecule drug libraries and the development of biosensors.

Survey of the year 2000 commercial optical biosensor literature

We have compiled a comprehensive list of the articles published in the year 2000 that describe work employing commercial optical biosensors. Selected reviews of interest for the general biosensor user are highlighted. Emerging applications in areas of drug discovery, clinical support, food and environment monitoring, and cell membrane biology are emphasized. In addition, the experimental design and data processing steps necessary to achieve high-quality biosensor data are described and examples of well-performed kinetic analysis are provided.

Prediction of affinity and kinetics in biomolecular interactions by affinity chromatography

Computer simulation of affinity chromatography is a valuable tool for accurate prediction of column performance. In our study affinity pairs based on lectin and antibody interactions with carbohydrates have been used as model systems. In this well-characterized system we have demonstrated the usefulness of the simulation approach for determination of affinity and kinetics. These properties are typically difficult to obtain for many weakly interacting molecular species (i.e., when dissociation constants (K(D)) are greater than 10(-5) M). The influence of affinity and kinetics on peak broadening in affinity chromatography has also been investigated.

Analysis of carbohydrates using liquid chromatography--surface plasmon resonance immunosensing systems

An immunosensing system based on surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was used for on-line detection and characterization of carbohydrate molecules separated by high-performance liquid chromatography. These analytes, with or without serum, were continuously separated and analyzed in the combined liquid chromatography-surface plasmon resonance (LC-SPR) system. By using weak and readily reversible monoclonal antibodies, the SPR system allowed specific on-line monitoring of the substances. To increase the specificity of the immunosensor, nonrelevant antibodies were used as reference in a serial flow cell. The sensitivity of the LC-SPR system was dependent on molecular weight of the carbohydrate, affinity of binding, and design of the sensor.

Specific interaction of CCR5 amino-terminal domain peptides containing sulfotyrosines with HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120

The HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120 interacts consecutively with CD4 and the CCR5 coreceptor to mediate the entry of certain HIV-1 strains into target cells. Acidic residues and sulfotyrosines in the amino-terminal domain (Nt) of CCR5 are crucial for viral fusion and entry. We tested the binding of a panel of CCR5 Nt peptides to different soluble gp120/CD4 complexes and anti-CCR5 mAbs. The tyrosine residues in the peptides were sulfated, phosphorylated, or unmodified. None of the gp120/CD4 complexes associated with peptides containing unmodified or phosphorylated tyrosines. The gp120/CD4 complexes containing envelope glycoproteins from isolates that use CCR5 as a coreceptor associated with Nt peptides containing sulfotyrosines but not with peptides containing sulfotyrosines in scrambled Nt sequences. Finally, only peptides containing sulfotyrosines inhibited the entry of an R5 isolate. Our data show that proper posttranslational modification of the CCR5 Nt is required for gp120 binding and viral entry. More importantly, the Nt domain determines the specificity of the interaction between CCR5 and gp120s from isolates that use this coreceptor.