Sequential multi-agent chemotherapy and whole abdominal irradiation for stage III ovarian carcinoma

Is there place for radiotherapy in the treatment of advanced ovarian cancer?

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Irradiation of advanced ovarian cancer has been performed during the years 1976-1984 with six-field technique. Results of this treatment in a long follow-up have never before been evaluated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Seventy-five patients with stage IIb-IV of invasive ovarian cancer have been treated with a combination of surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy. The results of the treatment were compared with 98 patients treated during the year 1991-1992 with surgery and chemotherapy only.

RESULTS

After controlling for the differences in background factors between the groups considered, there was still a significantly better survival rate for the patients treated with radiotherapy.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that the role of radiotherapy in advanced ovarian cancer should be investigated in a prospective randomized trial.

Ovarian cancer

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for cancer originating in the ovaries is based on 74 scientific articles, including 12 randomized studies, 18 prospective studies, and 36 retrospective studies. These studies involve 6,140 patients. Treatment for patients at early stages of ovarian cancer (stages I and II) is surgery. The value of adjuvant treatment, ie, chemotherapy or radiotherapy, is not demonstrated. Tumor volume is decisive to the success of radiotherapy. Microscopic or small macroscopic cancer residuals, remaining after surgery, may respond to radiotherapy, thereby promoting survival. The importance of radiotherapy for advanced ovarian cancer is controversial, and studies frequently show contradictory results. Two studies have shown the favorable role played by radiotherapy in consolidation treatment of patients if they become cancer-free at advanced stages. The role of radiotherapy in treating larger volumes of residual cancer has not been demonstrated, except for strictly palliative treatment.

Stage III ovarian carcinoma: an analysis of treatment results and complications following hyperfractionated abdominopelvic irradiation for salvage

PURPOSE

Patients with persistent disease found at laparotomy following platinum-based chemotherapy for Stage III ovarian carcinoma have a remote chance of cure with second-line chemotherapy or conventional radiotherapy. To decrease relapse rates and improve tolerance, we have used twice-daily radiotherapy in 28 such patients.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Twenty-eight patients with Stage III epithelial ovarian carcinoma were treated with curative intent at the University of Florida with hyperfractionated, continuous-course radiotherapy for persistent disease at laparotomy after administration of platinum-based chemotherapy. All patients received .8 Gy per fraction, twice daily, to a mean total dose of 30.2 Gy to the whole abdomen and pelvis; 20 patients had additional radiotherapy to the pelvis (mean, 14.54 Gy). All patients had undergone two to four (mean, 2.6) laparotomies for ovarian carcinoma and had received 6-28 (mean, 12) cycles of chemotherapy before irradiation.

RESULTS

With a 2-year minimum follow-up, survival rates at 1, 2, and 5 years were as follows: absolute survival, 79%, 50%, 21%; relapse-free survival, 52%, 36%, 19%. For the 11 patients with no evidence of gross residual disease after the second-look laparotomy, the absolute survival rates were 100%, 73%, and 27%. This was superior to the rates of 65%, 34%, and 18% for the 17 patients who had gross residual disease. Only two patients required treatment breaks. Four patients required surgical intervention for small-bowel obstruction, which in two cases revealed recurrent disease. Two patients died of treatment-related complications. Twenty-two of 23 failures occurred in the abdomen and/or pelvis.

CONCLUSION

Although most patients eventually relapse, a small percentage have had a prolonged disease-free interval. Since treatment was relatively well tolerated, escalation of the dose of hyperfractionated abdominopelvic irradiation is being investigated.

Complications of whole abdominal and pelvic radiotherapy following chemotherapy for advanced ovarian cancer

We examined the records of 105 patients with advanced ovarian cancer who had been treated with cisplatin combination chemotherapy followed by abdominopelvic radiotherapy. The purpose was to define the morbidity of this approach, and identify those factors predictive of toxicity. Acute toxicity resulting in delay or failure to complete treatment was most commonly due to myelosuppression. Nine of 105 patients (8.6%) required surgery for bowel obstruction that was not due to recurrent disease, 3 had an episode of bowel obstruction that settled conservatively, and a further 5 underwent surgery for obstruction due to recurrent tumor. The presence of both a dose of abdominopelvic radiotherapy over 2250 cGy, as well as a second-look laparotomy prior to radiotherapy, was associated with an increased risk of serious bowel complications. The increased frequency of late bowel morbidity seen in the combined modality group is likely explained by the presence of these two factors, rather than the exposure to chemotherapeutic agents per se. These observations are supported by the published literature.

Twice-daily, split-course abdominopelvic radiation therapy after chemotherapy and positive second-look laparotomy for epithelial ovarian carcinoma

Between July 1983 and December 1988, 34 patients with ovarian carcinoma received whole abdominal irradiation in an attempt to eliminate residual disease following second-look laparotomy. Three additional patients who had initial complete responses to chemotherapy were treated for a recurrence of their disease. All patients had been treated with chemotherapy that included cisplatin and cyclophosphamide. Three patients had also received doxorubicin with some or all chemotherapy cycles. Thirty Gray of abdominopelvic radiation therapy (APRT) was delivered using a twice-daily, split-course schedule. Eleven patients also had a boost of 9-20 Gy to sites of residual disease. Treatment was well tolerated. Only one patient did not complete therapy and two patients had 1-week prolongations of treatment because of hematologic toxicity. Thirty-two percent of patients had grade 2 neoplasms and 61% had grade 3 disease. Three patients with grade 1 tumors continue to have no evidence of disease 20-50 months after irradiation. Patients with grade 2 and 3 neoplasms who had microscopic residual disease prior to APRT had relapse-free survival rates at 3-years of 10% and 14%, respectively. Twelve patients with gross residual disease had rapid recurrences (median time to relapse, 4.9 months) and all have died of their disease. Although 14 patients (38%) have experienced small bowel obstructions, all of these had known recurrent abdominal disease at the time. Twenty patients (54%) had undergone more than two abdominal surgeries prior to APRT, and several were noted to have extensive adhesions at second-look laparotomy. None of the five patients currently believed to be free of disease has experienced a small bowel obstruction. Radiation is only one of several factors that contributed to bowel obstructions. Although APRT may be able to eliminate residual disease in a small proportion of patients with microscopic residual disease after chemotherapy, the aggressive biology of tumors that respond incompletely to chemotherapy and the compromises in radiation dose and schedule that must be made in these heavily treated patients probably contribute to the disappointing results of this treatment.

Whole abdomen radiation therapy after a short chemotherapy course and second-look laparotomy in advanced ovarian cancer

From April 1983 through December 1989, 42 consecutive patients with diagnosis of epithelial ovarian carcinoma were initially managed by aggressive surgery and three courses of endoperitoneal cis-platinum-based chemotherapy followed by an alternating combination chemotherapy and second-look laparotomy. Patients with residual tumor less than or equal to 2 cm subsequently received whole abdominal radiation therapy (WAR). Twenty-eight patients (42% with no residual disease, 21% with microscopic disease, and 36% with residual disease less than 2 cm) were eligible for WAR. WAR was delivered using an open-field technique up to 22 Gy in 20 fractions followed by a pelvic boost of 18 Gy in 10 fractions. The kidneys were shielded posteriorly at 1100 cGy; hepatic shields were not added. One patient did not complete WAR for lung metastases after 5 radiotherapy fractions. The complete treatment program lasted 8 months (range, 6.8-11). The median follow-up of the 28 patients entered into the study was 50 months. Eight patients are alive and disease-free at 5 years. The overall and disease-free survival rates at 5 years are 45 and 30%, respectively. All but 2 patients relapsed within the abdominopelvic cavity and 3 developed brain metastases. Toxic effects, during WAR, required treatment interruption in all but 4 patients: 3 developed a small bowel obstruction requiring surgery and 1 died of surgical complications in complete remission. The poor disease-free survival and the severe toxicity encountered have been valid indications that WAR should be discontinued as a treatment modality in advanced ovarian cancer at our department.

Radiation therapy in stage III ovarian cancer following surgery and chemotherapy: prognostic factors, patterns of relapse, and toxicity: a preliminary report

Twenty patients with FIGO stage III epithelial ovarian cancer who had undergone maximum cytoreductive surgery (including pelvic and paraaortic lymph node dissection) and combination chemotherapy (4-10 cycles, median 6) were treated with irradiation to the abdomen and pelvis with 30 Gy followed by diaphragmatic/paraaortic and pelvis boost fields to 42 and 51.6 Gy, respectively. Second-look laparotomy was not performed. Seventeen of 20 patients completed the planned course of radiation. In 2 cases, failure to complete treatment was related to acute hematologic toxicity, and 1 patient refused further treatment. Five patients (29%) required treatment breaks ranging from 8 to 16 days (median, 12 days) due to pancytopenia. Actuarial overall survival and relapse-free survival at 3 years for the 17 patients who completed radiation was 69 and 47%, respectively, with follow-up ranging from 19 to 53 months (median: 24, mean: 27.6 months). Seven patients (41%) relapsed within the abdomen alone and 2 patients developed extraabdominal lymph node metastasis as their sole site of failure. The prognostic factors evaluated for correlation with relapse-free survival included histologic subtype, grade, amount of residual disease at the time of surgery, and nodal involvement; only residual tumor at surgery (none vs less than or equal to 2 cm or greater than 2 cm) was found to be statistically significant (P less than 0.01). Three-year overall survival correlated with amount of residual disease following the initial cytoreductive surgery. It was 100% for patients with no residual disease, 66.7% for less than or equal to 2 cm, and 26.7% for those with greater than 2 cm residual disease, respectively. Radiation treatment was well tolerated, with only one patient developing treatment-related bowel obstruction 7 months after radiation therapy. The results of this planned trimodality treatment approach compare favorably with those reported following surgery and chemotherapy, particularly in patients who have been maximally cytoreduced.

Salvage whole-abdominal irradiation following chemotherapy failure in epithelial ovarian carcinoma

During the period 1977 to 1985, 12 patients with FIGO stage II and III epithelial ovarian carcinoma failed to achieve a pathologic complete response with chemotherapy and underwent salvage whole-abdominal irradiation (WAXRT). Six of these patients had gross residual disease present at the time of irradiation, and three (50%) were unable to complete the planned radiotherapy. All eventually failed in the treatment field; their 5-year actuarial survival and local control rates were zero. The other six were irradiated without residual macroscopic disease. Five of the six (83%) were able to complete WAXRT as planned without prolonged delays. The 5-year actuarial survival and local control rates for this group were 21 and 25%, respectively. The actuarial laparotomy rate to relieve bowel obstruction following WAXRT was 40% at 2 years. The results from this and other series indicate that salvage WAXRT is not effective for patients irradiated with macroscopic tumor. However, WAXRT appears to be potentially curative for a small but significant percentage of patients irradiated without gross disease, although the risk of significant complications is high.