Analysis of the heat-adaptive response of psychrotrophic Bacillus weihenstephanensis

Recent advances in understanding the effect of acid-adaptation on the cross-protection to food-related stress of common foodborne pathogens

Acid stress is one of the most common stresses that foodborne pathogens encounter. It could occur naturally in foods as a by-product of anaerobic respiration (fermentation), or with the addition of acids. However, foodborne pathogens have managed to survive to acid conditions and consequently develop cross-protection to subsequent stresses, challenging the efficacy of hurdle technologies. Here, we cover the studies describing the cross-protection response following acid-adaptation, and the possible molecular mechanisms for cross-protection. The current and future prospective of this research topic with the knowledge gaps in the literature are also discussed. Exposure to acid conditions (pH 3.5 - 5.5) could induce cross-protection for foodborne pathogens against subsequent stress or multiple stresses such as heat, cold, osmosis, antibiotic, disinfectant, and non-thermal technology. So far, the known molecular mechanisms that might be involved in cross-protection include sigma factors, glutamate decarboxylase (GAD) system, protection or repair of molecules, and alteration of cell membrane. Cross-protection could pose a serious threat to food safety, as many hurdle technologies are believed to be effective in controlling foodborne pathogens. Thus, the exact mechanisms underlying cross-protection in a diversity of bacterial species, stress conditions, and food matrixes should be further studied to reduce potential food safety risks. HighlightsFoodborne pathogens have managed to survive to acid stress, which may provide protection to subsequent stresses, known as cross-protection.Acid-stress may induce cross-protection to many stresses such as heat, cold, osmotic, antibiotic, disinfectant, and non-thermal technology stress.At the molecular level, foodborne pathogens use different cross-protection mechanisms, which may correlate with each other.

Bacillus weihenstephanensis can readily evolve for increased endospore heat resistance without compromising its thermotype

Proper elimination of bacterial endospores in foods and food processing environment is challenging because of their extreme resistance to various stresses. Often, sporicidal treatments prove insufficient to eradicate the contaminating endospore population as a whole, and might therefore serve as a selection pressure for enhanced endospore resistance. In the sporeforming Bacillus cereus group, Bacillus weihenstephanensis is an important food spoilage organism and potential cereulide producing pathogen, due to its psychrotolerant growth ability at 7 °C. Although the endospores of B. weihenstephanensis are generally less heat resistant compared to their mesophilic or thermotolerant relatives, our data now show that non-emetic B. weihenstephanensis strain LMG 18989^T can readily and reproducibly evolve to acquire much enhanced endospore heat resistance. In fact, one of the B. weihenstephanensis mutants from directed evolution by wet heat in this study yielded endospores displaying a > 4-fold increase in D-value at 91 °C compared to the parental strain. Moreover, these mutant endospores retained their superior heat resistance even when sporulation was performed at 10 °C. Interestingly, increased endospore heat resistance did not negatively affect the vegetative growth capacities of the evolved mutants at lower (7 °C) and upper (37 °C) growth temperature boundaries, indicating that the correlation between cardinal growth temperatures and endospore heat resistance which is observed among bacterial sporeformers is not necessarily causal.

Role of the ClpX from Corynebacterium crenatum involved in stress responses and energy metabolism

ClpX and ClpP are involved in many important functions, including stress responses and energy metabolism, in microorganisms. However, the ClpX and ClpP of microbes used in industrial scale have rarely been studied. Industrial bacterial fermentation experiences a variety of stresses, and energy metabolism is extremely important for industrial bacteria. Thus, the role played by the ClpX and ClpP of industrial bacteria in fermentation should be investigated. Most microorganisms have a single clpP gene, while Corynebacterium crenatum AS 1.542 possesses two clpPs. Herein, the clpX, clpP1, and clpP2 of C. crenatum were cloned, and its fusion protein was expressed and characterized. We also constructed clpX deletion mutant and complementation strain. Results indicate that ClpX serves an important function in thermal, pH, and ethanol stresses. It is also involved in NADPH synthesis and glucose consumption during fermentation.

Impact of Moderate Heat, Carvacrol, and Thymol Treatments on the Viability, Injury, and Stress Response of Listeria monocytogenes

The microbial safety and stability of minimally processed foods are based on the application of combined preservative factors. Since microorganisms are able to develop adaptive networks to survive under conditions of stress, food safety may be affected, and therefore understanding of stress adaptive mechanisms plays a key role in designing safe food processing conditions. In the present study, the viability and the sublethal injury of Listeria monocytogenes exposed to moderate heat (55 °C) and/or essential oil compounds (carvacrol and thymol, 0.3 mM) treatments were studied. Synergistic effects were obtained when combining mild heat (55 °C) with one or both essential oil compounds, leading to inactivation kinetics values three to four times lower than when using heat alone. All the treatments applied caused some injury in the population. The injury levels ranged from around 20% of the surviving population under the mildest conditions to more than 99.99% under the most stringent conditions. Protein extracts of cells exposed to these treatments were analysed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The results obtained revealed that stressed cells exhibited differential protein expression to control cells. The proteins upregulated under these stressing conditions were implicated, among other functions, in stress response, metabolism, and protein refolding.

Mechanisms of food processing and storage-related stress tolerance in Clostridium botulinum

Vegetative cultures of Clostridium botulinum produce the extremely potent botulinum neurotoxin, and may jeopardize the safety of foods unless sufficient measures to prevent growth are applied. Minimal food processing relies on combinations of mild treatments, primarily to avoid deterioration of the sensory qualities of the food. Tolerance of C. botulinum to minimal food processing is well characterized. However, data on effects of successive treatments on robustness towards further processing is lacking. Developments in genetic manipulation tools and the availability of annotated genomes have allowed identification of genetic mechanisms involved in stress tolerance of C. botulinum. Most studies focused on low temperature, and the importance of various regulatory mechanisms in cold tolerance of C. botulinum has been demonstrated. Furthermore, novel roles in cold tolerance were shown for metabolic pathways under the control of these regulators. A role for secondary oxidative stress in tolerance to extreme temperatures has been proposed. Additionally, genetic mechanisms related to tolerance to heat, low pH, and high salinity have been characterized. Data on genetic stress-related mechanisms of psychrotrophic Group II C. botulinum strains are scarce; these mechanisms are of interest for food safety research and should thus be investigated. This minireview encompasses the importance of C. botulinum as a food safety hazard and its central physiological characteristics related to food-processing and storage-related stress. Special attention is given to recent findings considering genetic mechanisms C. botulinum utilizes in detecting and countering these adverse conditions.

Bacillus cereus cell response upon exposure to acid environment: toward the identification of potential biomarkers

Microorganisms are able to adapt to different environments and evolve rapidly, allowing them to cope with their new environments. Such adaptive response and associated protections toward other lethal stresses, is a crucial survival strategy for a wide spectrum of microorganisms, including food spoilage bacteria, pathogens, and organisms used in functional food applications. The growing demand for minimal processed food yields to an increasing use of combination of hurdles or mild preservation factors in the food industry. A commonly used hurdle is low pH which allows the decrease in bacterial growth rate but also the inactivation of pathogens or spoilage microorganisms. Bacillus cereus is a well-known food-borne pathogen leading to economical and safety issues in food industry. Because survival mechanisms implemented will allow bacteria to cope with environmental changes, it is important to provide understanding of B. cereus stress response. Thus this review deals with the adaptive traits of B. cereus cells facing to acid stress conditions. The acid stress response of B. cereus could be divided into four groups (i) general stress response (ii) pH homeostasis, (iii) metabolic modifications and alkali production and (iv) secondary oxidative stress response. This current knowledge may be useful to understand how B. cereus cells may cope to acid environment such as encountered in food products and thus to find some molecular biomarkers of the bacterial behavior. These biomarkers could be furthermore used to develop new microbial behavior prediction tools which can provide insights into underlying molecular physiological states which govern the behavior of microorganisms and thus opening the avenue toward the detection of stress adaptive behavior at an early stage and the control of stress-induced resistance throughout the food chain.

Catalase activity as a biomarker for mild-stress-induced robustness in Bacillus weihenstephanensis

Microorganisms are able to survive and grow in changing environments by activating stress adaptation mechanisms which may enhance bacterial robustness. Stress-induced enhanced robustness complicates the predictability of microbial inactivation. Using psychrotolerant Bacillus weihenstephanensis strain KBAB4 as a model, we investigated the impact of the culturing temperature on mild-oxidative-stress-induced (cross-)protection toward multiple stresses, including severe oxidative, heat, and acid stresses. Culturing at a refrigeration temperature (7°C) compared to the optimal growth temperature (30°C) affected both the robustness level of B. weihenstephanensis and the oxidative stress adaptive response. Scavengers of reactive oxygen species have a crucial role in adaptation to oxidative stresses, and this points to a possible predictive role in mild-oxidative-stress-induced robustness. Therefore, the catalase activity was determined upon mild oxidative stress treatment and was demonstrated to be significantly correlated with the robustness level of mild-stress-treated cells toward severe oxidative and heat stresses but not toward severe acid stress for cells grown at both refrigeration and optimal temperatures. The quantified correlations supported the predictive quality of catalase activity as a biomarker and also underlined that the predictive quality is stress specific. Biomarkers that are able to predict stress-induced enhanced robustness can be used to better understand stress adaptation mechanisms and might allow the design of effective combinations of hurdles to control microbial behavior.

Quantification of the effect of culturing temperature on salt-induced heat resistance of bacillus species

Short- and long-term exposure to mild stress conditions can activate stress adaptation mechanisms in pathogens, resulting in a protective effect toward otherwise lethal stresses. The mesophilic strains Bacillus cereus ATCC 14579 and ATCC 10987 and the psychrotolerant strain B. weihenstephanensis KBAB4 were cultured at 12 degrees C and 30 degrees C until the exponential growth phase (i) in the absence of salt, (ii) in the presence of salt, and (iii) with salt shock after they reached the exponential growth phase and subsequently heat inactivated. Both the first-order model and the Weibull model were fitted to the inactivation kinetics, and statistical indices were calculated to select for each condition the most appropriate model to describe the inactivation data. The third-decimal reduction times (which reflected the times needed to reduce the initial number of microorganisms by three decimal powers) were determined for quantitative comparison. The heat resistance of both mesophilic strains increased when cells were salt cultured and salt shocked at 30 degrees C, whereas these salt-induced effects were not significant for the psychrotolerant strain. In contrast, only the psychrotolerant strain showed salt-induced heat resistance when cells were cultured at 12 degrees C. Therefore, culturing temperature and strain diversity are important aspects to address when adaptive stress responses are quantified. The activated adaptive stress response had an even larger impact on the number of surviving microorganisms when the stress factor (i.e., salt) was still present during inactivation. These factors should be considered when stress-integrated predictive models are developed that can be used in the food industry to balance and optimize processing conditions of minimally processed foods.

Functional characterization of Hsp33 protein from Bacillus psychrosaccharolyticus; additional function of HSP33 on resistance to solvent stress

Psychrophiles have been known as efficient organism to degrade organic solvent. To investigate the mechanism of solvent stress and identify the factors that affect the solvent stress in psychrophiles, we selected Bacillus psychrosaccharolyticus one of the psychrophiles and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was performed. Among the protein spots analyzed by 2-DE, five spots induced in 3% IPA stress conditions were identified by MS/MS, and one of these spots was identified as a Hsp33 family. The Hsp33 protein sequence of B. psychrosaccharolyticus exhibited a high similarity with the corresponding proteins of other bacteria. The Hsp33 protein of B. psychrosaccharolyticus has a highly conserved zinc-binding domain (CXCX, CXXC) that includes four cysteine residues in the C-terminus. In addition, the transcriptional induction of the HSP33 of B. psychrosaccharolyticus was confirmed by Northern blot analysis, and formation of free thiol linkage was induced under stress conditions such as exposure to solvents, heat-shock, and oxidative stress. Furthermore, over-expressed strains of HSP33 of B. psychrosaccharolyticus in Escherichia coli improved stress tolerance to the organic solvent when compared with the wild-type. These data suggest that the solvent stress condition was similar to heat-shock or oxidative stress, especially through the triggering of induction and activation of a redox-regulatory chaperone, Hsp33, and Hsp33 plays a critical role in the tolerance to stress.

Non-lethal heat shock protects gnotobiotic Artemia franciscana larvae against virulent Vibrios

Brine shrimp Artemia were exposed under gnotobiotic conditions to a non-lethal heat shock (NLHS) from 28 to 32, 37 and 40 degrees C. Different recovery periods (2, 6, 12 and 24h) and different heat-exposure times (15, 30, 45 and 60 min) were tested. After these NLHS, Artemia was subsequently challenged with Vibrio. Challenge tests were performed in stressed and unstressed nauplii at concentrations of 10(7) cells ml(-1) of pathogenic bacteria, Vibrio campbellii and Vibrio proteolyticus. A NLHS with an optimal treatment of 37 degrees C for 30 min and a subsequent 6h recovery period resulted in a cross-protection against pathogenic Vibrio. A 100% increase in the larval survival (P < 0.05) was observed. We have also demonstrated by Western blot that a NLHS increases the expression of HSP-70 in heat-shocked (HS) treated animals. This report is the first to reveal a cross protection of a NLHS against deleterious bacterial challenges in living crustaceans. The putative role of heat shock proteins (HSPs) in this process is discussed.

Quantification of the effects of salt stress and physiological state on thermotolerance of Bacillus cereus ATCC 10987 and ATCC 14579

The food-borne pathogen Bacillus cereus can acquire enhanced thermal resistance through multiple mechanisms. Two Bacillus cereus strains, ATCC 10987 and ATCC 14579, were used to quantify the effects of salt stress and physiological state on thermotolerance. Cultures were exposed to increasing concentrations of sodium chloride for 30 min, after which their thermotolerance was assessed at 50 degrees C. Linear and nonlinear microbial survival models, which cover a wide range of known inactivation curvatures for vegetative cells, were fitted to the inactivation data and evaluated. Based on statistical indices and model characteristics, biphasic models with a shoulder were selected and used for quantification. Each model parameter reflected a survival characteristic, and both models were flexible, allowing a reduction of parameters when certain phenomena were not present. Both strains showed enhanced thermotolerance after preexposure to (non)lethal salt stress conditions in the exponential phase. The maximum adaptive stress response due to salt preexposure demonstrated for exponential-phase cells was comparable to the effect of physiological state on thermotolerance in both strains. However, the adaptive salt stress response was less pronounced for transition- and stationary-phase cells. The distinct tailing of strain ATCC 10987 was attributed to the presence of a subpopulation of spores. The existence of a stable heat-resistant subpopulation of vegetative cells could not be demonstrated for either of the strains. Quantification of the adaptive stress response might be instrumental in understanding adaptation mechanisms and will allow the food industry to develop more accurate and reliable stress-integrated predictive modeling to optimize minimal processing conditions.

Response of Vibrio parahaemolyticus to ethanol shock

In this study, the growth and survival of Vibrio parahaemolyticus in the presence of 0.0-8.0% ethanol was first examined. V. parahaemolyticus was then exposed to a sub-lethal dose of 5.0% ethanol for 30 and 60 min (ethanol shock). Morphological changes and alterations in cell leakage, thermal tolerance at 47 degrees C, and susceptibility to 8% ethanol and low temperature (4 and -18 degrees C) of V. parahaemolyticus caused by ethanol shock were investigated. In addition, recoveries of the ethanol-shocked cells of V. parahaemolyticus on thiosulfate-citrate-bile salts-sucrose agar (TCBS) and TSA-3.0% NaCl were also compared. The findings revealed that the presence of ethanol in TSB-3.0% NaCl at 6.0-8.0% and 5.0% or less, exerted bactericidal and partial growth inhibition effect, respectively, on V. parahaemolyticus. Recovery of ethanol-shocked cells of V. parahaemolyticus was significantly (P<0.05) less on TCBS than on TSA-3.0% NaCl. A significantly (P<0.05) marked increase of protein and nucleic acid material in the supernatant of cell suspension was found after cells of V. parahaemolyticus were exposed to ethanol shock. Extensive cell disruption, wrinkling and cell-wall pitting, indicative of cell-surface damage were also noted on the ethanol-shocked cells. Ethanol-shocked cells of V. parahaemolyticus exhibited a similar yet higher susceptibility at 4 and -18 degrees C compared with the control cells. Moreover, there was a marked increase in the thermal tolerance and resistance to 8.0% ethanol with cells of V. parahaemolyticus after ethanol shock. Finally, the duration of ethanol shock testing did not affect the extent of increased thermal tolerance. While cells of V. parahaemolyticus subjected to ethanol shock for 60 min showed an increase in their resistance to 8.0% ethanol, they also showed an increase in susceptibility at -18 degrees C, than those ethanol shocked for 30 min.

Fine-tuning in regulation of Clp protein content in Bacillus subtilis

Clp-controlled proteolysis in Bacillus subtilis seems to play a substantial role, particularly under stress conditions. Calibrated Western blot analyses were used to estimate the approximate numbers of heat-inducible Clp molecules within a single cell. According to these numbers, the different Clp ATPases do not seem to compete for the proteolytic subunit ClpP. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments revealed the predicted specific ClpX-ClpP, ClpC-ClpP, and ClpE-ClpP interactions. ClpE and ClpX are rapidly degraded in wild-type cells during permanent heat stress but remained almost stable in a clpP mutant, suggesting ClpP-dependent degradation. In particular, ClpCP appeared to be involved in the degradation of the short-lived ClpE ATPase, indicating a negative "autoregulatory" circuit for this particular Clp ATPase at the posttranslational level. Analysis of the half-life of stress-inducible clp mRNAs during exponential growth and heat shock revealed precise regulation of the synthesis of each Clp protein at the posttranscriptional level as well to meet the needs of B. subtilis.