Towards a general procedure for sequencing single DNA molecules

Exonucleolytic degradation of high-density labeled DNA studied by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

The exonucleolytic degradation of high-density labeled DNA by exonuclease III was monitored using two-color fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). One strand of the double stranded template DNA was labeled on either one or two base types and additionally at one end via a 5' Cy5 tagged primer. Exonucleolytic degradation was followed via the diffusion time, the brightness of the remaining DNA as well as the concentration of released labeled bases. We found a hydrolyzation rate of about 11 to 17 nucleotides per minute per enzyme (nt/min/enzyme) for high-density labeled DNA, which is by a factor of about 4 slower than for unlabeled DNA. The exonucleolytic degradation of a 488 base pair long double stranded DNA resulted in a short double stranded DNA segment of 112 ± 40 base pairs (bp) length with two single-stranded tails.

Femtomolar concentration detection limit and zeptomole mass detection limit for protein separation by capillary isoelectric focusing and laser-induced fluorescence detection

Fluorescence tends to produce the lowest detection limits for most forms of capillary electrophoresis. Two issues have discouraged its use in capillary isoelectric focusing. The first issue is fluorescent labeling of proteins. Most labeling reagents react with lysine residues and convert the cationic residue to a neutral or anionic product. At best, these reagents perturb the isoelectric point of the protein. At worse, they convert each protein into hundreds of different fluorescent products that confound analysis. The second issue is the large background signal generated by impurities within commercial ampholytes. This background signal is particularly strong when excited in the blue portion of the spectrum, which is required by many common fluorescent labeling reagents. This paper addresses these issues. For labeling, we employ Chromeo P540, which is a fluorogenic reagent that converts cationic lysine residues to cationic fluorescent products. The reaction products are excited in the green, which reduces the background signal generated by impurities present within the ampholytes. To further reduce the background signal, we photobleach ampholytes with high-power photodiodes. Photobleaching reduced the noise in the ampholyte blank by an order of magnitude. Isoelectric focusing performed with photobleached pH 3-10 ampholytes produced concentration detection limits of 270 +/- 25 fM and mass detection limits of 150 +/- 15 zmol for Chromeo P540 labeled beta-lactoglobulin. Concentration detection limits were 520 +/- 40 fM and mass detection limits were 310 +/- 30 zmol with pH 4-8 ampholytes. A homogenate was prepared from a Barrett's esophagus cell line and separated by capillary isoelectric focusing, reproducibly generating dozens of peaks. The sample taken for the separation was equal to the labeled protein homogenate from three cells.

On the Feasibility of Using the Intrinsic Fluorescence of Nucleotides for DNA Sequencing

There is presently a worldwide effort to increase the speed and decrease the cost of DNA sequencing as exemplified by the goal of the National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI) to sequence a human genome for under $1000. Several high throughput technologies are under development. Among these, single strand sequencing using exonuclease appear very promising. However, this approach requires complete labeling of at least two bases at a time, with extrinsic high quantum yield probes. This is necessary because nucleotides absorb in the deep ultra-violet (UV) and emit with extremely low quantum yields. Hence intrinsic emission from DNA and nucleotides is not being exploited for DNA sequencing. In the present paper we consider the possibility of identifying single nucleotides using their intrinsic emission. We used the finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) method to calculate the effects of aluminum nanoparticles on nearby fluorophores that emit in the UV. We find that the radiated power of UV fluorophores is significantly increased when they are in close proximity to aluminum nanostructures. We show that there will be increased localized excitation near aluminum particles at wavelengths used to excite intrinsic nucleotide emission. Using FDTD simulation we show that a typical DNA base when coupled to appropriate aluminum nanostructures leads to highly directional emission. Additionally we present experimental results showing that a thin film of nucleotides show enhanced emission when in close proximity to aluminum nanostructures. Finally we provide Monte Carlo simulations that predict high levels of base calling accuracy for an assumed number of photons that is derived from the emission spectra of the intrinsic fluorescence of the bases. Our results suggest that single nucleotides can be detected and identified using aluminum nanostructures that enhance their intrinsic emission. This capability would be valuable for the ongoing efforts towards the $1000 genome.

Continuous base identification for single-molecule nanopore DNA sequencing

A single-molecule method for sequencing DNA that does not require fluorescent labelling could reduce costs and increase sequencing speeds. An exonuclease enzyme might be used to cleave individual nucleotide molecules from the DNA, and when coupled to an appropriate detection system, these nucleotides could be identified in the correct order. Here, we show that a protein nanopore with a covalently attached adapter molecule can continuously identify unlabelled nucleoside 5'-monophosphate molecules with accuracies averaging 99.8%. Methylated cytosine can also be distinguished from the four standard DNA bases: guanine, adenine, thymine and cytosine. The operating conditions are compatible with the exonuclease, and the kinetic data show that the nucleotides have a high probability of translocation through the nanopore and, therefore, of not being registered twice. This highly accurate tool is suitable for integration into a system for sequencing nucleic acids and for analysing epigenetic modifications.

An artificial processivity clamp made with streptavidin facilitates oriented attachment of polymerase-DNA complexes to surfaces

Single molecule analysis of individual enzymes can require oriented immobilization of the subject molecules on a detection surface. As part of a technology development project for single molecule DNA sequencing, we faced the multiple challenges of immobilizing both a DNA polymerase and its DNA template together in an active, stable complex capable of highly processive DNA synthesis on a nonstick surface. Here, we report the genetic modification of the archaeal DNA polymerase 9°N in which two biotinylated peptide ‘legs’ are inserted at positions flanking the DNA-binding cleft. Streptavidin binding on either side of the cleft both traps the DNA template in the polymerase and orients the complex on a biotinylated surface. We present evidence that purified polymerase–DNA–streptavidin complexes are active both in solution and immobilized on a surface. Processivity is improved from <20 nt in the unmodified polymerase to several thousand nucleotides in the engineered complexes. High-molecular weight DNA synthesized by immobilized complexes is observed moving above the surface even as it remains tethered to the polymerase. Pre-formed polymerase–DNA–streptavidin complexes can be stored frozen and subsequently thawed without dissociation or loss of activity, making them convenient for use in single molecule analysis.

'True' single-molecule molecule observations by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy and two-color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) and two-color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy (FCCS) are a measure of fluctuations of detected light as a fluorescence molecule diffuses through a femtoliter detection volume caused by a tightly focused laser and confocal optics. Fluorescence from a single molecule can easily be distinguished from the slight background associated with a femtoliter of solvent. At a solution concentration of about 1 nM, the probability that there is an analyte molecule in the probe volume is less than one. Although fluorescence from individual molecules is collected, the data are analyzed by autocorrelation or two-color cross-correlation functions that are the average of thousands of molecules. Properties of single molecules are not obtained. I have been working on problems and opportunities associated with very dilute solutions. The molecule in the confocal probe volume is most probably the molecule that just diffused out, turned around, and diffused back in, i.e., reentered. For the first time, some theoretical results of the novel theory of the meaningful time are presented that enable study of just one single molecule over extended periods of times without immobilization or hydrodynamic focusing. Reentries that may also be called reoccurrences or encounters of a single molecule are significant because during measurement times they give rise to fluctuation phenomena such as molecule number fluctuations. Likewise, four criteria have been developed that can be used to verify that there is only one "selfsame" molecule in the laser probe volume during the experiment: (Földes-Papp, Z., 2006. What it means to measure a single molecule in a solution by fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy. Exp. Mol. Pathol. 80 (3) 209-218).

High-density polymerase-mediated incorporation of fluorochrome-labeled nucleotides

DNA-polymerase-mediated incorporation of different fluorochrome-labeled nucleotides (FdNTPs) was investigated with the goals of optimizing the high-density labeling of probes and exploring DNA sequencing strategies that rely on the controlled, sequential addition of such compounds. By systematically evaluating variables--including polymerase type, buffer conditions, and fluorochrome chemistries--a rational strategy for the sequential addition of labeled nucleotides to a DNA template was demonstrated. A simple structural model of the polymerase-DNA template complex that considered the fluorochrome moiety of the FdNTPs and the linker length also guided this strategy. Complementary results that portend the use of simple photobleaching to enable the reliable quantitation of consecutive additions are presented.

Single-molecule tracing on a fluidic microchip for quantitative detection of low-abundance nucleic acids

Here, we report a method capable of quantitative detection of low-abundance DNA/RNA molecules by incorporating confocal fluorescence spectroscopy, molecular beacons, and a molecular-confinement microfluidic reactor. By using a combination of ac and dc fields via a trio of 3-D electrodes in the microreactor, we are able to precisely direct the transport of individual molecules to a minuscule laser-focused detection volume ( approximately 1 fL). A burst of fluorescence photons is detected whenever a molecular beacon-target hybrid flows through the detection region, and the amount of targets can be directly quantified according to the number of recorded single-molecule flow-through events. This assay consumes only attomoles of molecular probes and is able to quantitatively detect subpicomolar DNA targets. A measurement time of less than 2 min is sufficient to complete the detection.

Incorporation of reporter-labeled nucleotides by DNA polymerases

The incorporation of fluorescently labeled nucleotides into DNA by DNA polymerases has been used extensively for tagging genes and for labeling DNA. However, we lack studies comparing polymerase efficiencies for incorporating different fluorescently labeled nucleotides. We analyzed the incorporation of fluorescent deoxynucleoside triphosphates by 10 different DNA polymerases, representing a cross-section of DNA polymerases from families A, B, and reverse transcriptase. The substitution of one or more different reporter-labeled nucleotides for the cognate nucleotides was initially investigated by using an in vitro polymerase extension filter-binding assay with natural DNA as a template. Further analysis on longer DNA fragments containing one or more nucleotide analogs was performed using a newly developed extension cut assay. The results indicate that incorporation of fluorescent nucleotides is dependent on the DNA polymerase, fluorophore, linker between the nucleotide and the fluorophore, and position for attachment of the linker and the cognate nucleotide. Of the polymerases tested, Taq and Vent exo DNA polymerases were most efficient at incorporating a variety of fluorescently labeled nucleotides. This study suggests that it should be feasible to copy DNA with reactions mixtures that contain all four fluorescently labeled nucleotides allowing for high-density labeling of DNA.

Advances in sequencing technology

Faster sequencing methods will undoubtedly lead to faster single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) discovery. The Sanger method has served as the cornerstone for genome sequence production since 1977, close to almost 30 years of tremendous utility [Sanger, F., Nicklen, S., Coulson, A.R, DNA sequencing with chain-terminating inhibitors, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 74 (1977) 5463-5467]. With the completion of the human genome sequence [Venter, J.C. et al., The sequence of the human genome, Science 291 (2001) 1304-1351; Lander, E.S. et al., Initial sequencing and analysis of the human genome, Nature 409 (2001) 860-921], there is now a focus on developing new sequencing methodologies that will enable "personal genomics", or the routine study of our individual genomes. Technologies that will lead us to this lofty goal are those that can provide improvements in three areas: read length, throughput, and cost. As progress is made in this field, large sections of genomes and then whole genomes of individuals will become increasingly more facile to sequence. SNP discovery efforts will be enhanced lock-step with these improvements. Here, the breadth of new sequencing approaches will be summarized including their status and prospects for enabling personal genomics.

Single-nucleotide polymorphism detection using nanomolar nucleotides and single-molecule fluorescence

We have exploited three methods for discriminating single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) by detecting the incorporation or otherwise of labeled dideoxy nucleotides at the end of a primer chain using single-molecule fluorescence detection methods. Good discrimination of incorporated vs free nucleotide may be obtained in a homogeneous assay (without washing steps) via confocal fluorescence correlation spectroscopy or by polarization anisotropy obtained from confocal fluorescence intensity distribution analysis. Moreover, the ratio of the fluorescence intensities on each polarization channel may be used directly to discriminate the nucleotides incorporated. Each measurement took just a few seconds and was done in microliter volumes with nanomolar concentrations of labeled nucleotides. Since the confocal volumes interrogated are approximately 1fL and the reaction volume could easily be lowered to nanoliters, the possibility of SNP analysis with attomoles of reagents opens up a route to very rapid and inexpensive SNP detection. The method was applied with success to the detections of SNPs that are known to occur in the BRCA1 and CFTR genes.

Enzyme screening with synthetic multifunctional pores: focus on biopolymers

This report demonstrates that a single set of identical synthetic multifunctional pores can detect the activity of many different enzymes. Enzymes catalyzing either synthesis or degradation of DNA (exonuclease III or polymerase I), RNA (RNase A), polysaccharides (heparinase I, hyaluronidase, and galactosyltransferase), and proteins (papain, ficin, elastase, subtilisin, and pronase) are selected to exemplify this key characteristic of synthetic multifunctional pore sensors. Because anionic, cationic, and neutral substrates can gain access to the interior of complementarily functionalized pores, such pores can be the basis for very user-friendly screening of a broad range of enzymes.

Incorporation of reporter molecule-labeled nucleotides by DNA polymerases. II. High-density labeling of natural DNA

The modification of nucleic acids using nucleotides linked to detectable reporter or functional groups is an important experimental tool in modern molecular biology. This enhances DNA or RNA detection as well as expanding the catalytic repertoire of nucleic acids. Here we present the evaluation of a broad range of modified deoxyribonucleoside 5'-triphosphates (dNTPs) covering all four naturally occurring nucleobases for potential use in DNA modification. A total of 30 modified dNTPs with either fluorescent or non-fluorescent reporter group attachments were systematically evaluated individually and in combinations for high-density incorporation using different model and natural DNA templates. Furthermore, we show a side-by-side comparison of the incorporation efficiencies of a family A (Taq) and B (Vent(R) exo-) type DNA polymerase using the differently modified dNTP substrates. Our results show superior performance by a family B-type DNA polymerase, Vent(R) exo-, which is able to fully synthesize a 300 bp DNA product when all natural dNTPs are completely replaced by their biotin-labeled dNTP analogs. Moreover, we present systematic testing of various combinations of fluorescent dye-modified dNTPs enabling the simultaneous labeling of DNA with up to four differently modified dNTPs.

Incorporation of reporter molecule-labeled nucleotides by DNA polymerases. I. Chemical synthesis of various reporter group-labeled 2'-deoxyribonucleoside-5'-triphosphates

Fluorescent-labeled DNA is generated through enzymatic incorporation of fluorophore-linked 2'-deoxyribonucleoside-5'-triphosphates (dNTPs) by DNA polymerases. We describe the synthesis of a variety of dye-labeled dNTPs. Amino-linker-modified 5'-triphosphates of all four naturally occurring nucleobases were used as precursors. Commercially available dyes were coupled to the amino function of the side chain. In addition, we attached novel fluorophore derivatives. The labeled products were obtained in at least 96% purity after HPLC purification. Enzymatic incorporation into DNA and subsequent extension of the modified DNA chain were studied. Vent(R) exo- DNA polymerase and a defined template-primer system were used to analyze each dye-labeled dNTP derivative. Our data suggest that the incorporation efficiency depends on the selected dye, the nucleobase or a combination of both.

Photodeposition of silver can result in metal-enhanced fluorescence

Chemically deposited silver particles are widely used for surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) and more recently for surface-enhanced fluorescence (SEF), also known as metal-enhanced fluorescence (MEF). We now show that metallic silver deposited by laser illumination results in an approximately 7-fold increased intensity of locally bound indocyanine green. The increased intensity is accompanied by a decreased lifetime and increased photostability. These results demonstrate the possibility of photolithographic preparation of surfaces for enhanced fluorescence in microfluidics, medical diagnostics, and other applications.

Progress towards single-molecule DNA sequencing: a one color demonstration

Single molecules of fluorescently labeled nucleotides were detected during the cleavage of individual DNA fragments by a processive exonuclease. In these experiments, multiple (10-100) strands of DNA with tetramethyl rhodamine labeled dUMP (TMR-dUMP) incorporated into the sequence were anchored in flow upstream of the detection region of an ultra sensitive flow cytometer. A dilute solution of Exonuclease I passed over the microspheres. When an exonuclease attached to a strand, processive digestion of that strand began. The liberated, labeled bases flowed through the detection region and were detected at high efficiency at the single-molecule level by laser-induced fluorescence. The digestion of a single strand of DNA by a single exonuclease was discernable in these experiments. This result demonstrates the feasibility of single-molecule DNA sequencing. In addition, these experiments point to a new and practical means of arriving at a consensus sequence by individually reading out identical sequences on multiple fragments.

A new dimension for the development of fluorescence-based assays in solution: from physical principles of FCS detection to biological applications

Ultrasensitive detection methods such as laser-induced fluorescence represent the current state-of-the-art in analytics. Single-molecule detection in solution has received a remarkable amount of attention in the last few years because of its applicability to life sciences. Studies have been performed on the fundamentals of the detection processes themselves and on some biological systems. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is the link for ultrasensitive multicomponent analysis, showing possibilities for experiments on molecular interactions. Based on the theoretical background of FCS, this article gives full explanation of FCS and an update of highlights in experimental biology and medicine studied by FCS. We focus on a repertoire of diverse immunoglobulin specificities, a ribosome display system, single-molecule DNA sequencing, and a mutant enzyme generated by random mutagenesis of amino acids. We describe the usefulness and the enormous potential of the methodology. Further, this contribution clearly indicates that FCS is a valuable tool for solution-phase single-molecule (SPSM) experiments in immunobiology and medicine. In experiments with the Goodpasture autoantibody, we worked out conditions for the design of experiments on a complex single molecule in solution. The possibility to use SPSM-FCS as a quantitation methodology opens up other important applications beyond the scope of this article. Original results extending the published studies are presented for the rational foundation of SPSM-FCS. In this original contribution, we deal with experimental systems for biology and medicine where the number of molecules in solution is very small. This article is mandatory for gaining confidence in the interpretation of experimental SPSM-FCS results on the selfsame, individual single molecule in solution.

Identification of nucleotides with identical fluorescent labels based on fluorescence polarization in surfactant solutions

A solution-phase steady-state polarization-based method for discriminating among the four DNA nucleotides labeled identically with tetramethylrhodamine is described and demonstrated. Labeled nucleotides were dissolved in buffered surfactant solutions. In room temperature 4.5 mM Triton X-100 solutions at neutral pH, the measured steady-state polarizations of tetramethylrhodamine-labeled dATP, dCTP, dGTP and dUTP were 0.261 +/- 0.003, 0.112 +/- 0.003, 0.288 +/- 0.003, and 0.147 +/- 0.003, respectively. A blind test of 40 samples showed no errors in classification based on polarization. The reproducibility obtained during this study demonstrates that the four dye-labeled nucleotides can be discriminated with more than 99.8% confidence.

Highly efficient single molecule detection in microstructures

For DNA single molecule sequencing, the complete detection of all dye-labeled monomers which are cleaved off during the sequencing reaction is an essential requirement. In this work we address the feasibility of single molecule detection in microstructures with a confocal multi element set-up. We present statistical data on single molecule recognition and explain a refined data evaluation technique for single molecule burst analysis. From these data the signal-to-noise ratio in microstructures is evaluated as well as the overall detection efficiency. So far, detection efficiencies of single molecule events of up to 60% have been shown in microstructures.

Fluorescent high-density labeling of DNA: error-free substitution for a normal nucleotide

The enzymatic incorporation of deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates by a thermostable, 3'-->5' exonuclease deficient mutant of the Tgo DNA polymerase was studied for PCR-based high-density labeling of 217-bp "natural" DNA in which fluorescent-dUTP was substituted completely for the normal dTTP. The amplified DNA carried two different sorts of tethered dye molecules. The rhodamine-green was used for internal tagging of the DNA. Since high-density incorporation of rhodamine-green-X-dUTP led to a substantial reduction (quenching) of the rhodamine-green fluorescence, a second "high" quantum yield label, Cy5, was inserted via a 5'-tagged primer in order to identify the two-color product. A theoretical concept of fluorescence auto- and cross-correlation spectroscopy developed here was applied to quantify the DNA sequence formed in terms of both the number of two-color fluorescent molecules and the number of covalently incorporated rhodamine-green-X-dUMP residues. The novel approach allowed to separate optically the specific DNA product. After complete, exonucleolytic degradation of the two-color DNA we determined 82-88 fluorescent U* labels incorporated covalently out of 92 maximum possible U* incorporations. The heavily green-labeled DNA was then isolated by preparative mobility-shift electrophoresis, re-amplified in a subsequent PCR with normal deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates, and re-sequenced. By means of this novel methodology for analyzing base-specific incorporations that was first developed here, we found that all fluorescent nucleotides and the normal nucleotides were incorporated at the correct positions. The determined labeling efficiency of 0.89-0.96 indicated that a fraction of the substrate analog was not bearing the fluorophore. The results were used to guide developments in single-molecule DNA sequencing. The labeling strategy (principal approach) for PCR-based high-density tagging of DNA, which included an appropriate thermostable DNA polymerase and a suitable fluorescent dye-dNTP, was developed here.

Fluorescently labeled model DNA sequences for exonucleolytic sequencing

We describe here the enzyme-catalyzed, low-density labeling of DNAs with fluorescent dyes. Firstly, for "natural" template DNAs, dNTPs were partially substituted in the labeling reactions by the respective fluorophore-bearing analogs. The DNAs were labeled by PCR using Taq DNA polymerase. The covalent incorporation of dye-dNTPs decreased in the following order: rhodamine-green-5-dUTP (Molecular Probes, the Netherlands), tetramethylrhodamine-4-dUTP (FluoroRed, Amersham Pharmacia Biotech), Cy5-dCTP (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech). Exonucleolytic degradation by the 3'-->5' exonuclease activity of T7 DNA polymerase (wild type) in the presence of excess reduced thioredoxin proceeded to complete breakdown of the labeled DNAs. The catalytic cleavage constants determined by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy were between 0.5 and 1.5 s(-1) at 16 degrees C, normalized for the covalently incorporated dye-nucleotides. Secondly, rhodamine-green-X-dUTP (Roche Diagnostics), tetramethylrhodamine-6-dUTP (Roche Diagnostics), and Cy5-dCTP were covalently incorporated into the antisense strand of "synthetic" 218-b DNA template constructs (master sequences) at well defined positions, starting from the primer binding site, by total substitution for the naturally occurring dNTPs. The 218-b DNA constructs were labeled by PCR with a thermostable 3'-->5' exonuclease deficient mutant of the Tgo DNA polymerase which we have selected. The advantage of the special, synthetic DNA constructs as compared to natural DNAs lies in the possibility of obtaining tailor-made nucleic acids, optimized for testing the performance of exonucleolytic sequencing. The number of incorporated fluorescent nucleotides determined by complete exonucleolytic degradation and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy were six out of six possible incorporations for rhodamine-green-X-dUTP and tetramethylrhodamine-6-dUTP, respectively. Their covalent and base-specific incorporations were confirmed by the novel analysis methodology of re-sequencing (i.e. mobility-shift gel electrophoresis, reversion-PCR and re-sequencing) first developed in the paper Földes-Papp et al. (2001) and in this paper. This methodology was then used by other groups within the whole sequencing project.