Nuclear transfer in mammals: recent developments and future perspectives

Stem Cells as Nuclear Donors for Mammalian Cloning

Mammals are routinely cloned by introducing somatic nuclei into enucleated oocytes. Cloning contributes to propagating desired animals, to germplasm conservation efforts, among other applications. A challenge to more broader use of this technology is the relatively low cloning efficiency, which inversely correlates with donor cell differentiation status. Emerging evidence suggests that adult multipotent stem cells improve cloning efficiency, while the greater potential of embryonic stem cells for cloning remains restricted to the mouse. The derivation of pluripotent or totipotent stem cells from livestock and wild species and their association with modulators of epigenetic marks in donor cells should increase cloning efficiency.

Production of Bovine Embryos and Calves Cloned by Nuclear Transfer Using Mesenchymal Stem Cells from Amniotic Fluid and Adipose Tissue

The less differentiated the donor cells are used in nuclear transfer (NT), the more easily are they reprogrammed by the recipient cytoplasm. In this context, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) appear as an alternative to donor nuclei for NT. The amniotic fluid and adipose tissue are sources of MSCs that have not been tested for the production of cloned embryos in cattle. The objective of this study was to isolate, characterize, and use MSCs derived from amniotic fluid (MSC-AF) and adipose tissue (MSC-AT) to produce cloned calves. Isolation of MSC-AF was performed using in vivo ultrasound-guided transvaginal amniocentesis, and MSC-AT were isolated by explant culture. Cellular phenotypic and genotypic characterization by flow cytometry, immunohistochemistry, and RT-PCR were performed, as well as induction in different cell lineages. The NT was performed using MSC-AF and MSC-AT as nuclear donors. The mesenchymal markers of MSC were expressed in bovine MSC-AF and MSC-AT cultures, as evidenced by flow cytometry, immunohistochemistry, and RT-PCR. When induced, these cells differentiated into osteocytes, chondrocytes, and adipocytes. Embryo production was similar between the cell types, and two calves were born. The calf from MSC-AT was born healthy, and this fact opens a new possibility of using this type of cell to produce cloned cattle by NT.

Synchronizing cell cycle of goat fibroblasts by serum starvation causes apoptosis

Cell cycle stage and synchronization of donor cells are important factors influencing the success of somatic cell nuclear transfer. This study examined whether serum starvation has any effect on specific cell death. We also studied the effects of serum starvation, culture to confluence, and full confluency (confluent + 72 h) on cell cycle characteristics and apoptosis of goat dermal fibroblast cells. The cells were obtained from the ear of a 1.5-year-old female goat. The following experimental groups were analysed for fibroblast cells: (i) normally growing, (ii) confluent, (iii) full confluency, (iv) cells starved for 48 h and (v) cells starved for 72 h. Analysis of cell cycle distribution by flow cytometry showed that 4.56 and 51.88% of normal cycling cells were at the G0 and G1 phases respectively. In the confluent group, 80% of the cells were arrested in the G0/G1 phase. Serum starvation for 48 and 72 h arrested 84.78% and 90.1% cells at the G0/G1 phase respectively which showed a significant difference when compared with the control group (p < 0.05). Double staining by PI and FITC distinguishes G0 phase from G1 phase. In the full confluency group, 91.53% of cells were at G0/G1 stage, but in contrast to the serum starved group, this high percentage of G0/G1 cells was mainly associated with G1 cells. Under normal culture conditions, 6.39% of cells underwent early apoptosis. In the confluent group 8.93% of cells showed early apoptosis. Serum starvation for 48 and 72 h caused early apoptosis in 8.91 and 39.83% of the cells respectively. Full confluency treatment did not increase the number of apoptotic cells significantly (8.67%). After 72 h, serum starvation significantly increased early apoptosis (p < 0.05). In conclusion, the use of full confluency is suitable for cell cycle synchronization because it arrests cells at the G0/G1 phase and also induces less apoptosis in comparison with the serum starvation group.

Improved production of genetically modified fetuses with homogeneous transgene expression after transgene integration site analysis and recloning in cattle

Animal cloning by nuclear transfer (NT) has made the production of transgenic animals using genetically modified donor cells possible and ensures the presence of the gene construct in the offspring. The identification of transgene insertion sites in donor cells before cloning may avoid the production of animals that carry undesirable characteristics due to positional effects. This article compares blastocyst development and competence to establish pregnancies of bovine cloned embryos reconstructed with lentivirus-mediated transgenic fibroblasts containing either random integration of a transgene (random integration group) or nuclear transfer derived transgenic fibroblasts with known transgene insertion sites submitted to recloning (recloned group). In the random integration group, eGFP-expressing bovine fetal fibroblasts were selected by fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS) and used as nuclei donor cells for NT. In the recloned group, a fibroblast cell line derived from a transgenic cloned fetus was characterized regarding transgene insertion and submitted to recloning. The recloned group had higher blastocyst production (25.38 vs. 14.42%) and higher percentage of 30-day pregnancies (14.29 vs. 2.56%) when compared to the random integration group. Relative eGFP expression analysis in fibroblasts derived from each cloned embryo revealed more homogeneous expression in the recloned group. In conclusion, the use of cell lines recovered from transgenic fetuses after identification of the transgene integration site allowed for the production of cells and fetuses with stable transgene expression, and recloning may improve transgenic animal yields.

Development of cloned embryos from porcine neural stem cells and amniotic fluid-derived stem cells transfected with enhanced green fluorescence protein gene

We assessed the developmental ability of embryos cloned from porcine neural stem (NS) cells, amniotic fluid-derived stem (AFS) cells, fetal fibroblast cells, adult fibroblast, and mammary gland epithelial cells. The five cell lines were transfected with enhanced green fluorescence protein gene respectively using lipofection. NS and AFS cells were induced to differentiate in vitro. Stem cells and their differentiated cells were harvested for analysis of the markers using RT-PCR. The five cell lines were used for nuclear transfer. The two-cell stage-cloned embryos derived from each cell line were transferred into the oviducts of surrogate mothers. The results showed that both NS and AFS cells expressed POU5F1, THY1 and SOX2, and they were both induced to differentiate into astrocyte (GFAP+), oligodendrocyte (GalC+), neuron (NF+, ENO2+, and MAP2+), adipocyte (LPL+ and PPARG-D+), osteoblast (osteonectin+ and osteocalcin+), myocyte (MYF6+ and MYOD+), and endothelium (PECAM1+, CD34+, CDH5+, and NOS3+) respectively. Seven cloned fetuses (28 days and 32 days) derived from stem cells were obtained. The in vitro developmental ability (morula-blastocyst rate was 28.26-30.07%) and in vivo developmental ability (pregnancy rate were 1.67-2.17%) of the embryos cloned from stem cells were higher (P<0.05) than that of the embryos cloned from somatic cells (morula-blastocyst rate was 16.27-19.28% and pregnancy rate was 0.00%), which suggests that the undifferentiated state of the donor cells increases cloning efficiency.

Differential effect of recipient cytoplasm for microtubule organization and preimplantation development in rat reconstituted embryos with two-cell embryonic cell nuclear transfer

In the present study, we examined the developmental ability of enucleated zygotes, MII oocytes, and parthenogenetically activated oocytes at pronuclear stages (parthenogenetic PNs) as recipient cytoplasm for rat embryonic cell nuclear transfer. Enucleated zygotes as recipient cytoplasm receiving two-cell nuclei allowed development to blastocysts, whereas the development of embryos reconstituted with MII oocytes and parthenogenetic PNs was arrested at the two-cell stage. Previous observations in rat two-cell embryos suggested that the distribution of microtubules is involved in two-cell arrest. Therefore, we also examined the distribution of microtubules using immunofluorescence. At the two-cell stage after nuclear transfer into enucleated zygotes, microtubules were distributed homogeneously in the cytoplasm during interphase, and normal mitotic spindles were observed in cleaving embryos from the two- to four-cell stage. In contrast, embryos reconstituted with MII oocytes and parthenogenetic PNs showed aberrant microtubule organization. In enucleated zygotes, fibrous microtubules were distributed homogeneously in the cytoplasm. In contrast, dense microtubules were localized at the subcortical area in the cytoplasm and strong immunofluorescence intensity was observed at the plasma membrane, while very weak intensity was detected in the central part of enucleated MII oocytes. In enucleated parthenogenetic PNs, high-density and fibrous microtubules were distributed in the subcortical and central areas, respectively. Pre-enucleated parthenogenetic PNs also showed lower intensity of microtubule immunofluorescence in the central cytoplasm than zygotes. In conclusion, the results of the present study showed that zygote cytoplasm is better as recipient than MII oocyte and parthenogenetic PNs for rat two-cell embryonic cell nuclear transfer to develop beyond four-cell stage. Furthermore, microtubule organization is involved in the development of reconstituted embryos to overcome the two-cell arrest.

Holistic differential analysis of embryo-induced alterations in the proteome of bovine endometrium in the preattachment period

During the peri-implantation period, molecular signaling between embryo and endometrium (layer of tissue lining the uterus lumen) is supposed to be crucial for the maintenance of pregnancy. To investigate embryo-induced alterations in the proteome of bovine endometrium in the preattachment period (day 18), we used monozygotic cattle twins (generated by embryo splitting) as a model eliminating genetic variability as a source for proteome differences. One of the twins was pregnant after the transfer of two in vitro produced blastocysts, while the corresponding twin received a sham-transfer and served as a nonpregnant control. The two-dimensional fluorescence difference gel electrophoresis (2-D DIGE) analysis of the endometrium samples of three twin pairs (pregnant/nonpregnant) revealed four proteins with significantly higher abundance (p < 10(-9)) in each sample derived from the pregnant animals: Rho GDP dissociation inhibitor beta; 20 alpha-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (20 alpha-HSD); soluble NADP(+)-dependent isocitrate dehydrogenase 1; and acyl-CoA-binding protein. To verify the accuracy of the 2-D DIGE quantification, the abundances of 20 alpha-HSD were quantified by a targeted cleavable isotope-coded affinity tag (ICAT) approach. The mass spectrometry-based ICAT quantification matched perfectly the results obtained by 2-D DIGE quantification, demonstrating the accuracy of our data. These results demonstrate that our model (monozygotic twins) in combination with the appropriate analytical tools is particularly suitable for the detection of the proteins involved in the embryo-maternal interactions.

Differential development of rabbit embryos derived from parthenogenesis and nuclear transfer

Parthenogenetic development (PA) is often used as a model to investigate activation protocols for nuclear transfer (NT) embryos. The objective of this study was to compare the development, as well as the dynamics of the nuclear materials and microtubules of PA and NT embryos following similar activation treatment. Our results demonstrate that, during parthenogenesis, activation through either electrical pulses or chemical stimulation alone resulted in low cleavage rates and compromised development. A combination of two sets of electrical pulses and a 2-h-exposure to chemical activation medium (5 microg/ml cycloheximide (CHX) and 2 mM 6-dimethylaminopurine (6-DMAP) in KSOM+0.1% BSA) could effectively activate rabbit oocytes, and resulted in a 99% (n = 73) cleavage rate with greater than 60% (n = 73) developing to blastocysts at day 4. However, the same activation protocol following NT resulted in only 65-72% of oocytes cleaved (depending on donor cell type), with less than 20% developing to the blastocyst stage. The differences observed between NT and PA embryos subjected to the same activation protocol were also evident in terms of the time required for their development to the blastocyst stage, as well as the cell numbers present in blastocysts at day 6. Furthermore, laser confocal microscopy revealed that pronuclear formation in the NT embryos was delayed by comparison to that in the parthenotes. In conclusion, our study suggests that an effective protocol for parthenogenesis cannot promise a comparable outcome for NT embryos.

Transgenic nonhuman primates for neurodegenerative diseases

Animal models that represent human diseases constitute an important tool in understanding the pathogenesis of the diseases, and in developing effective therapies. Neurodegenerative diseases are complex disorders involving neuropathologic and psychiatric alterations. Although transgenic and knock-in mouse models of Alzheimer's disease, (AD), Parkinson's disease (PD) and Huntington's disease (HD) have been created, limited representation in clinical aspects has been recognized and the rodent models lack true neurodegeneration. Chemical induction of HD and PD in nonhuman primates (NHP) has been reported, however, the role of intrinsic genetic factors in the development of the diseases is indeterminable. Nonhuman primates closely parallel humans with regard to genetic, neuroanatomic, and cognitive/behavioral characteristics. Accordingly, the development of NHP models for neurodegenerative diseases holds greater promise for success in the discovery of diagnoses, treatments, and cures than approaches using other animal species. Therefore, a transgenic NHP carrying a mutant gene similar to that of patients will help to clarify our understanding of disease onset and progression. Additionally, monitoring disease onset and development in the transgenic NHP by high resolution brain imaging technology such as MRI, and behavioral and cognitive testing can all be carried out simultaneously in the NHP but not in other animal models. Moreover, because of the similarity in motor repertoire between NHPs and humans, it will also be possible to compare the neurologic syndrome observed in the NHP model to that in patients. Understanding the correlation between genetic defects and physiologic changes (e.g. oxidative damage) will lead to a better understanding of disease progression and the development of patient treatments, medications and preventive approaches for high risk individuals. The impact of the transgenic NHP model in understanding the role which genetic disorders play in the development of efficacious interventions and medications is foreseeable.

Embryo-maternal communication in bovine - strategies for deciphering a complex cross-talk

Early embryonic development, implantation and maintenance of a pregnancy are critically dependent on an intact embryo-maternal communication. So far, only few signals involved in this dialogue have been identified. In bovine and other ruminants, interferon tau is the predominant embryonic pregnancy recognition signal, exhibiting antiluteolytic activity. However, this is just one aspect of the complex process of embryo-maternal signalling, and a number of other systems are more likely to be involved. To gain a more comprehensive understanding of these important mechanisms, integrated projects involving specialists in embryology, reproductive biotechnology and functional genome research are necessary to perform a systematic analysis of interactions between pre-implantation stage embryos and oviduct or uterine epithelial cells, respectively. State-of-the-art transcriptomic and proteomic technologies will identify reciprocal signals between embryos and their maternal environment and the respective downstream reaction cascades. For in vivo studies, the use of monozygotic twins as recipient animals provides elegant model systems, thus eliminating genetic variability as a cause of differential gene expression. In addition, suitable systems for the co-culture of oviduct epithelial or endometrium cells with the respective embryonic stages need to be established for functional validation of candidate genes potentially involved in the dialogue between embryos and their maternal environment. The knowledge of these mechanisms should help to increase the pregnancy rate following embryo transfer and to avoid embryonic losses. Candidate genes involved in embryo-maternal communication will also be used to define new quality criteria for the selection of embryos for transfer to recipients. Another application is the supplementation of embryotrophic factors or components of embryo-maternal signalling in optimized formulations, such as bioartificial matrices. As a long-term goal, signalling mechanisms identified in bovine will also be functionally evaluated in other species, including the human.

Studies of the cell cycle of in vitro cultured skin fibroblasts in goats: work in progress

The effect of serum starvation and olomoucine treatment on the cell cycle and apoptosis of goat skin fibroblasts cultured in vitro is reported in this paper. The cells were obtained from the ear of a female goat 1.5 years of age. Analysis of cell cycle distribution by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) showed that 3.4, 60.8 and 15.1% of normally cycling cells were at G1, G0 and S phase, respectively. Serum starvation for 1, 3 and 5 days arrested 70.1, 70.2 and 83.4% cells, respectively, at G0/G1 phase. Seventy-eight percent of confluent cells were at G0/G1 stage, but in contrast to the serum starved group, this high percentage of G0/G1 cells was mainly associated with G1 cells. Of cells not deprived of serum, 73.6% were arrested at G1/G0 when treated with 100 microM olomoucine for 9 h compared to 85.5% of cells that had been starved of serum for 2 days (co-inhibition) (P<0.01). After co-inhibition, 45% of cells entered S phase when re-cultured in normal medium for 5 h, indicating that the inhibition was reversible. Under normal culture conditions, 1.2% of cells underwent apoptosis. Serum starvation for 1, 2, 3, 5 and 10 days caused apoptosis in 1.7, 3.9, 4.5, 11.7 and 90.3% of cells, respectively. Treatment with 100 microM olomoucine for 9h did not increase the number of apoptotic cells significantly (1.9%, P>0.05). When cells were co-inhibited, 4.1% of cells underwent apoptosis. In conclusion, although serum withdrawal for 5 days or more effectively arrested cells at G0/G1 stages, it increased apoptosis of cells significantly. However, co-inhibition by serum withdrawal and olomoucine treatment was found to be an appropriate treatment to obtain more healthy G0/G1 cells based on the low percentage of apoptotic cells after treatment.

Birth of a cloned calf derived from a vitrified hand-made cloned embryo

The hand-made cloning (HMC) technique describes a simplified nuclear transfer process without the need for micromanipulators. The technique involves manual bisection of zona-free oocytes, selection of cytoplasts by Hoechst staining and fusion of a single somatic cell and two cytoplasts. In this proof-of-principle experiment, the objective was to examine the developmental competence of HMC embryos following embryo transfer. Modifications to the original method include not selecting of matured oocytes and simultaneous fusion of cytoplasts and karyoplast. Blastocyst rates for embryos cultured in the glass oviduct system as singles (10.5%; 24/228) or in pairs (16.1%; 36/224) did not differ significantly. Fresh and vitrified–thawed blastocysts were transferred to 16 synchronised recipients (three to four embryos per recipient). Ultrasound examination on Days 35–45 showed an initial pregnancy rate of 43.8% (7/16) and a pregnancy rate >8 months of 12.5% (2/16). A male cloned calf (42 kg) derived from a vitrified HMC blastocyst was delivered by Caesarean section on Day 271. The birth and ongoing survival (15 months, 243 kg) of a healthy and apparently normal calf, combining both HMC and vitrification technologies, provides a ‘proof of principle’ of the technology and a promising alternative to traditional nuclear-transfer techniques.

Recruit of porcine oocytes excluded from nuclear transfer program for the production of embryos following parthenogenetic activation

To evaluate whether oocytes excluded from somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) could be utilized for embryo production by parthenogenetic activation (PA), porcine oocytes with poor morphology after maturation culture were excluded from SCNT and subsequently used for PA with different stimuli. In the first set of experiment, either electric pulse of different strengths (1.75, 2.0 or 2.25 kV/cm for 30 microsec each) or chemicals with different treatment durations [7% ethanol for 5 min followed by exposure to 6-dimethylaminopurine (6-DMAP) for 0, 2, 3 or 4 hr] was employed. Development to the 8-cell and morula stages was significantly (P<0.05) improved by electric stimulation of 2.0 kV/cm, while blastocyst formation was enhanced by chemical treatment of ethanol and 6-DMAP for 4 hr. Subsequently, oocytes were parthenogenetically activated by one of four stimuli; 1) optimal electric (2.0 kV/cm for 30 microsec), 2) optimal chemical (ethanol followed by 6-DMAP for 4 hr), 3) electric then chemical and 4) vice versa. On the other hand, oocytes with normal morphology were subjected to the same experimental treatments for the control. Regardless of oocyte type, a combination of electric and chemical stimulations did not further stimulate preimplantation development, compared with electric activation only. However, combinational treatment greatly increased the cell number of blastocysts in SCNT-excluded oocytes (21.9 to 22.9 vs. 16.9 cells/blastocyst), while such effect was not found in normal oocytes (22.2 to 23.3 cells/blastocyst). In conclusion, porcine oocytes excluded from SCNT still have a potential to develop blastocysts after PA and this might contribute to increasing the efficiency of SCNT for various purposes. A combined activation by electricity and chemical yielded the best rate of preimplantation development with increasing the quality of blastocyst.

A 2-Mb YAC/BAC-based physical map of the ovum mutant (Om) locus region on mouse chromosome 11

The embryonic lethal phenotype observed when DDK females are crossed with males from other strains results from a deleterious interaction between the egg cytoplasm and the paternal pronucleus soon after fertilization. We have previously mapped the Om locus responsible for this phenotype, called the DDK syndrome, to an approximately 2-cM region of chromosome 11. Here, we report the generation of a physical map of 28 yeast and bacterial artificial chromosome clones encompassing the entire genetic interval containing the Om locus. This contig, spanning approximately 2 Mb, was used to map precisely genes and genetic markers of the region. We determined the maximum physical interval for Om to be 1400 kb. In addition, 11 members of the Scya gene family were found to be organized into two clusters at the borders of the Om region. Two other genes (Rad51l3 and Schlafen 2) and one EST (D11Wsu78e) were also mapped in the Om region. This integrated map provides support for the identification of additional candidate genes for the DDK syndrome.

Advances in livestock nuclear transfer

Cloning and transgenic animal production have been greatly enhanced by the development of nuclear transfer technology. In the past, genetic modification in domestic animals was not tightly controlled. With the nuclear transfer technology one can now create some domestic animals with specific genetic modifications. An ever-expanding variety of cell types have been successfully used as donors to create the clones. Both cell fusion and microinjection are successfully being used to create these animals. However, it is still not clear which stage(s) of the cell cycle for donor and recipient cells yield the greatest degree of development. While for the most part gene expression is reprogrammed in nuclear transfer embryos, all structural changes may not be corrected as evidenced by the length of the telomeres in sheep resulting from nuclear transfer. Even after these animals are created the question of "are they really clones?" arises due to mitochondrial inheritance from the donor cell versus the recipient oocyte. This review discusses these issues as they relate to livestock.

Reprogramming nuclei: insights from cloning, nuclear transfer and heterokaryons

Mammals and amphibians can be cloned following the transfer of embryonic nuclei into enucleated eggs or oocytes. As nuclear functions become more specialized in the differentiated cells of an adult, successful cloning using these nuclei as donors becomes more difficult. Differentiation involves the assembly of specialized forms of repressive chromatin including linker histones, Polycomb group proteins and methyl-CpG-binding proteins. These structures compartmentalize chromatin into functional domains and maintain the stability of the differentiated state through successive cell divisions. Efficient cloning requires the erasure of these structures. The erasure can be accomplished through use of molecular chaperones and enzymatic activities present in the oocyte, egg or zygote. We discuss the mechanisms involved in reprogramming nuclei after nuclear transfer and compare them with those that occur during remodeling of somatic nuclei after heterokaryon formation. Finally we discuss how one might alter the properties of adult nuclei to improve the efficiency of cloning.

Adult cloning in cattle: potential of nuclei from a permanent cell line and from primary cultures

Nuclear transfer was used to evaluate the developmental potential of nuclei from a spontaneously immortalized bovine mammary gland epithelial cell line (MECL) and from primary cultures of mammary gland cells (PMGC) and ear skin fibroblasts (PESF) established from 3-year-old cows. Cell proliferation was investigated by incorporation and detection of 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU). The proportion of cells in S-phase was significantly (P < 0.05) higher for MECL cells than for PMGC and PESF, both in the presence of serum (90% vs. 28% and 15%) and following serum starvation (27% vs. 6% and 3%). Nuclei from PESF supported the development of reconstructed embryos to the blastocyst stage significantly better than those of PMGC (60% vs. 26%; P < 0.05). Embryos reconstructed with cells from MECL failed to develop to blastocysts. After transfer of embryos derived from PMGC and PESF, respectively, 2/2 and 5/12 recipients were pregnant on day 42. On day 90, the corresponding pregnancy rates were 2/2 and 3/12. One live calf derived from a PMGC was born at day 287 of gestation. Another live PESF-derived calf was delivered by caesarean section at day 286 of gestation. Our study suggests that nuclei from primary cultures of adult cells can be successfully reprogrammed by nuclear transfer, whereas nuclei from a permanent cell line failed to support the development of nuclear transfer embryos.