Chronic hepatitis in children after liver transplantation: role of hepatitis C virus and hepatitis G virus infections

Late graft hepatitis and fibrosis in pediatric liver allograft recipients: Current concepts and future developments

Liver transplantation (LT) in children now has a 20-year survival of >80%, but the longterm outcome of these grafts remains uncertain. Serial protocol liver biopsies after transplantation from several pediatric centres have demonstrated the gradual development of unexplained graft inflammation ("idiopathic" posttransplant hepatitis; IPTH) and graft fibrosis in biopsies obtained >12 months post-LT in children with good graft function and (near) normal liver biochemistry. Although the clinical significance of these findings is uncertain, there is evidence to suggest that IPTH may be a form of rejection or chronic antibody-mediated rejection as it is associated with the presence of auto/alloantibodies; de novo Class II donor-specific HLA antibodies (DSA); previous episodes of rejection, and may improve or be prevented with increased immunosuppression. Currently, the only method of diagnosing either hepatitis or fibrosis has been by serial protocol biopsies as neither serum markers of fibrosis nor noninvasive methods to detect fibrosis such as transient elastography (TE) are sufficiently validated in children. This review will focus on the diagnosis and management of idiopathic posttransplant hepatitis and graft fibrosis, discuss current methods for detecting graft injury, and potential mechanisms for their development. Liver Transplantation 22 1593-1602 2016 AASLD.

Liver transplantation in an African setting

Liver disease in children in the developing world is a frequent occurrence, which is generally inadequately managed because of lack of resources. However, increasingly, there has been a demand for liver transplantation, where primary medical or surgical therapies have failed. The expertise and infrastructure required for a successful outcome are no different from those in more developed countries; if anything, the challenges are greater. Lack of deceased donors because of cultural and religious factors has driven the use of living donors. Short-term survival has generally been good, but long-term outcomes have rarely been reported. In this article, we review the experience of 2 centers at opposite ends of the continent and share our experience of slightly different settings and show that success can be achieved even in resource-reduced environments.

Cirrhosis after orthotopic liver transplantation in the absence of primary disease recurrence

Liver allograft cirrhosis is a relatively uncommon complication of liver transplantation. Most cases can be attributed to disease recurrence, particularly recurrent hepatitis C. Little is known about the frequency, etiology, and natural history of liver allograft cirrhosis occurring without evidence of recurrent disease. The aim of the present study was to review the clinicopathological features in this group of patients. We retrospectively reviewed data from all adult patients who were transplanted between 1982 and 2002 and survived >12 months after orthotopic liver transplantation (n = 1,287). Cases of histologically proven cirrhosis were identified from histopathological data entered into the Liver Unit Database. A total of 48 patients (3.7%) developed cirrhosis. In 29 of them, cirrhosis could be attributed to recurrent disease (hepatitis C, 11; hepatitis B, 4; autoimmune hepatitis, 4; primary biliary cirrhosis, 2; primary sclerosing cholangitis, 3; nonalcoholic steatohepatitis, 4; alcoholic liver disease, 1). In 9 of the 19 patients without evidence of disease recurrence, another cause of cirrhosis could be identified (de novo autoimmune hepatitis, 4; biliary complications, 4; acquired hepatitis B, 1). In the remaining 10 cases, the cause of cirrhosis remained unknown; their previous biopsies had shown features of chronic hepatitis of uncertain etiology. Three patients in this group died, and the remaining 7 are alive with good graft function 3-12 years after cirrhosis was first diagnosed. The prevalence of "cryptogenic" posttransplant cirrhosis was significantly higher in patients initially transplanted for fulminant seronegative hepatitis (6%) than in those transplanted for other diseases (0.3%). In conclusion, posttransplant cirrhosis without disease recurrence is uncommon, but it is more frequent in patients transplanted for fulminant seronegative hepatitis. Chronic hepatitis is the most frequent underlying pathological process in cases where the cause of cirrhosis remains uncertain.

Natural history of unexplained chronic hepatitis after liver transplantation

Unexplained chronic hepatitis (CH) in the adult liver allograft recipient is not uncommon, but its natural history and clinical significance is unknown. A retrospective study was undertaken of adult liver allograft recipients to determine the frequency and natural history of unexplained CH. We evaluated only those patients who had undergone >or=2 liver biopsies after 6 months and were grafted for indications where recurrent disease could be confidently excluded (alcoholic liver disease [ALD] in those who remained abstinent and fulminant hepatic failure [FHF] from drug reactions). Of 288 patients who were transplanted for ALD or FHF, 30 fulfilled the above criteria. CH was first diagnosed at a median of 15.25 months after transplantation. A total of 24 patients showed mild necroinflammatory changes, and 12 had mild or moderate fibrosis. Liver tests did not reflect the presence or degree of inflammation or fibrosis. After a median of 4 years, necroinflammatory scores were increased in 5; new or progressive fibrosis was noted in 13%; 3 had developed cirrhosis; and 5 developed clinical evidence of portal hypertension. Progressive fibrosis was associated with a high titer of anti-nuclear antibodies (>1:1600) and a portal tract plasma cell infiltrate. There was a trend for correlation between necroinflammatory activity and fibrosis stage, but this did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.06). Serum alkaline phosphatase (P = 0.012) and female gender of the donor (P = 0.033) were associated with progressive fibrosis. Unexplained CH is not uncommon in the liver allograft and may progress to established cirrhosis in a subgroup of patients transplanted for ALD or FHF. Standard liver tests do not reflect the extent of these changes, so protocol liver biopsies may be required to detect these changes. We recommend careful history and follow-up in these patients.

Progressive histological damage in liver allografts following pediatric liver transplantation

The long-term histological outcome after pediatric liver transplantation (OLT) is not yet fully understood. De novo autoimmune hepatitis, consisting of histological chronic hepatitis associated with autoantibody formation and allograft dysfunction, is increasingly recognized as an important complication of liver transplantation, particularly in the pediatric population. In this study, 158 asymptomatic children with 5-year graft survival underwent protocol liver biopsies (113, 135, and 64 at 1, 5, and 10 years after OLT, respectively). Histological changes we re correlated with dinical,biochemical, and serological findings. All patients received cydosporine A as primary immunosuppression with withdrawal of corticosteroids at 3 months post OLT. Normal or near-normal histology was reported in 77 of 113 (68%), 61 of 135 (45%), and 20 of 64 (31%) at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively. The commonest histological abnormality was chronic hepatitis (CH), the incidence of which increased with time [25/113 (22%), 58/135 (43%), and 41/64 (64%) at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively) (P < .0001)]. The incidence of fibrosis associatedwith CH increasedwith time [13/25 (52%), 47/58 (81%), and 37/41 (91%) at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively) (P < .0001)]. The severity of fibrosis associated with CH also increased with time, such that by 10 years 15% had progressed to cirrhosis. Aspartate aminotransfemse (AST) levels were slightly elevated in children with CH (median levels 52 IU/L, 63 IU/L, and 48 IU/L at 1, 5, and 10 years, respectively), but this did not reach statistical significance compared with those with normal histology. On multivariate analysis, the only factor predictive of chronic hepatitis was autoantibody positivity (present in 13% and 10% of children with normal biopsies at 5 and 10 years, respectively, and 72% and 80% of those with CH at 5 and 10 years, respectively) (P < .0001). Four children with CH and autoantibodies, who also had raised immunoglobulin G (IgG) levels and AST greater than 1.5 x normal fulfilled the diagnostic criteria for de novo autoimmune hepatitis (AIH). Another two were found to be hepatitis C positive. No definite cause for CH could be identified in the other cases. In condusion, chronic hepatitis is a common finding in children after liver transplantation and is associated with a high risk of developing progressive fibrosis, leading to cirrhosis. Standard liver biochemical tests cannot be relied on either in the diagnosis or in the monitoring of progress of chronic allograft hepatitis. In contrast, the presence ofautoantibodies is strongly associated with the presence of CH. The cause of chronic hepatitis in transplanted allografts is uncertain but may be immune mediated, representing a hepatitic form of chronic rejection.

An evaluation of long-term outcomes after liver transplantation for cryptogenic cirrhosis

Patients with cryptogenic cirrhosis (CC) comprise a significant proportion of liver transplant recipients. Poor outcome after transplantation has been reported by some centers, with fibrosis occurring in a significant proportion of patients. Outcome of 46 patients with CC who underwent transplantation between 1989 and 1999 at King's College Hospital London were compared with time-matched recipients who underwent transplantation for hepatitis C virus (HCV) cirrhosis (n = 58) and patients with alcohol-related cirrhosis (AC, n = 53) during the same time period. Mean follow-up was 46 +/- 37 months for CC patients, 41 +/- 31 months for AC patients, and 49 +/- 31 months for HCV patients. No protocol liver biopsy specimens were obtained, and biopsies were performed only for investigation of biochemical abnormalities. Acute cellular rejection occurred in 30% of CC, 26% of AC, and 37% of HCV patients (P = NS). Overall patient and graft survival at 1 year was 85% and 80% for CC patients, 87% and 81% for AC patients, and 91% and 82% for patients with HCV (P = NS). Five-year patient and graft survival was 81% and 77% for CC patients, 60% and 48% for AC patients, and 79% and 57% for HCV patients (Log rank; P =.369). Twenty-two percent of CC patients had inflammation on last evaluable liver biopsy, compared with 25% of patients who underwent transplantation for AC and 68% of patients who underwent transplantation for HCV. No patient who underwent transplantation for CC had histologic evidence of cirrhosis on last evaluable biopsy, compared with 2% of patients who underwent transplantation for AC and 16% of patients who underwent transplantation for HCV (Chi-squared = 13.053, P =.0015). These results suggest that CC is a favorable indication for OLT and that although a proportion of patients develop inflammation in the liver allograft, this does not result in significant graft dysfunction or loss.

Hepatitis C-Z: recent advances

In this review, recently identified hepatitis viruses (hepatitis C, hepatitis D, hepatitis E, hepatitis F, hepatitis G, transfusion transmissible virus) are described, and the implications for paediatric liver disease discussed.

Recurrent autoimmune hepatitis after liver transplantation: diagnostic criteria, risk factors, and outcome

Approximately 20% to 30% of patients undergoing liver transplantation for autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) develop features of recurrent disease. Diagnostic criteria for recurrent AIH are similar to those used in the nontransplanted liver and include, in varying combinations, biochemical, serological, and histological abnormalities and steroid dependency. However, these criteria are more difficult to apply in the liver allograft because of potential interactions between recurrent AIH and other complications of liver transplantation, particularly rejection, and the uncertain effects of long-term immunosuppression. In the absence of other reliable diagnostic markers, a number of studies have used the histological finding of chronic hepatitis as the main or sole criterion for diagnosing recurrent AIH. However, this also lacks diagnostic specificity because there are many other possible causes of chronic hepatitis in the liver allograft. In addition, approximately 20% to 40% of biopsies performed on patients as part of routine annual review have histological features of chronic hepatitis, for which no definite cause can be identified. Risk factors that have been associated with the development of recurrent AIH include suboptimal immunosuppression, HLA phenotype, disease type and severity in the native liver, and duration of follow up. In many cases in which recurrent AIH seems to be related to underimmunosuppression, biochemical and histological features rapidly resolve once adequate immunosuppression is restored. However, in other cases, recurrent AIH behaves more aggressively, with progression to cirrhosis and graft failure. Areas that require further study include developing uniform criteria for the diagnosis of recurrent AIH, identifying risk factors for severe recurrent disease, and determining optimal levels of immunosuppression that minimize the impact of disease recurrence without exposing patients to the risks of overimmunosuppression.

Prevalence of hepatitis G virus in healthy children in liver disease, and human immunodeficiency virus-1 infection: response to interferon

BACKGROUND

A new virus of the Flaviviridae family, the hepatitis G virus (HGV/HGBV-C), has been identified recently. The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of HGV infection in healthy children, in patients with liver disease, and in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1-infected patients. The role of HGV in the clinical course of chronic HCV, the response to interferon-alpha2b, and the possible implications of intravenous gamma-globulin in the transmission of the virus were also evaluated.

METHODS

Fifty healthy children, 66 patients with a variety of liver diseases, 19 patients with acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), and various batches of commercial intravenous immunoglobulins were investigated. Viral HGV RNA (5'NCR-NS5) and anti-HGV envelope protein E2 were assayed.

RESULTS

The prevalence of HGV infection was 6% in the healthy children and 42% in the liver disease group. Viremia and anti-E2 were found in 11% and 79% of patients with AIDS. Four (27%) of 15 patients with chronic HCV, receiving treatment with interferon, were coinfected by HGV and became HGV-RNA negative during therapy. One year after the end of interferon therapy, three of them were again HGV RNA positive.

CONCLUSIONS

The prevalence of HGV infection is high in healthy children higher in children affected with liver disease, but its potential pathologic implication is questionable, and further studies are warranted. Hepatitis G virus is sensitive to interferon therapy, although the infection often recurs after discontinuation of treatment.

Update on prevention and treatment of viral hepatitis in children

Viral hepatitis is a persisting concern. Outbreaks of hepatitis A occur in developed countries where only 10% to 20% of the population is seroprotected. The disease may cause fulminant liver failure and death. People who are targeted for vaccination include intravenous drug users, homosexuals, and chronic hepatitis patients. Secondary prophylaxis of household contacts is an efficient way to prevent secondary cases. Universal vaccination is now in progress for hepatitis B. Vaccination failure may occur in low birth weight infants, or in infants infected in utero. Chronic carriers of viral hepatitis may progress to cirrhosis and hepatocarcinoma, the latter risk being most important for men infected at birth. Alcohol intake should be avoided in carrier adolescents. Interferon is able to triple the rate of hepatitis B e antigen loss and decouple the rate of hepatitis B s antigen loss after one year, shortening disease evolution and, it is to be hoped, decreasing the risk of unfavorable outcome. Similarly, lamivudine increases by four times the rate of hepatitis B e antigen loss in adults. However, precore mutants may be selected by immune pressure after seroconversion in children, and tyrosine-methionine-aspartate-aspartate (YMDD) mutations appear in 15% of patients treated with lamivudine after 1 year. Hepatitis C is mainly acquired during childhood via true vertical transmission. The risk of acquiring Hepatitis C is related to the presence and amount of RNA for hepatitis C virus in mothers at the time of birth. The infection rate for the hepatitis C virus is higher in children from mothers who have tested positive for HIV, and higher if these children are themselves coinfected with HIV. Treatment with interferon alone has a poor rate of efficiency, although pediatric studies remain scarce. Combination treatment using ribavirin plus interferon yield a higher rate of success in eradicating viral infection in adults.

GB virus C (GBV-C/HGV) and E2 antibodies in children preliver and postliver transplant

The association of GB virus type C (GBV-C) virus and clinical disease is uncertain. The role of GBV-C and (Envelope) E2 antibody in children with liver transplants has not been determined. This study's aim is to examine the prevalence of GBV-C in children with liver transplants, to assess the relationship of GBV-C to posttransplant hepatitis, and to determine the role of E2 antibodies. Sera from 34 children, preliver and postliver transplant, between 1989-1996 were tested for GBV-C (Ribonucleic acid) RNA by the automated Abbott LCx PCR assay. Anti-E2 antibodies were detected by an Abbott immunoassay. Recent posttransplant liver biopsies were examined for hepatitis. The results of the study determined that pretransplant, four children (12%) were GBV-C RNA positive. Posttransplant, 14 (42%) children were GBV-C RNA positive. The GBV-C RNA positive conversion rate was 33% (CI 17.2-55.7%). Patients received blood products from a mean of 68 +/- 34 donors, which correlated with GBV-C acquisition. There was no difference in the incidence (32%versus 36%; p = 0.726) or severity (grade 2.00 versus 0.68; p = 0.126) of posttransplant hepatitis in the liver biopsies of GBV-C RNA negative and/or positive children, respectively. Pretransplant, nine of 32 children were anti-E2 positive. Posttransplant, eight of 32 children were anti-E2 positive, including five children who were anti-E2 positive pretransplant. Of nine children who were anti-E2 positive and GBV-C RNA negative pretransplant, three became GBV-C RNA positive posttransplant. The results of this study conclude that the prevalence of GBV-C infection in children postliver transplantation is high and that blood product transfusions correlate with GBV-C acquisition. Also, no correlation was found between GBV-C RNA and the incidence or severity of posttransplant hepatitis. Finally, E2 antibody presence before transplantation failed to provide complete protection from GBV-C acquisition.