A 5' segment of the mouse Zic1 gene contains a region specific enhancer for dorsal hindbrain and spinal cord

Epigenetics of Genes Preferentially Expressed in Dissimilar Cell Populations: Myoblasts and Cerebellum

While studying myoblast methylomes and transcriptomes, we found that CDH15 had a remarkable preference for expression in both myoblasts and cerebellum. To understand how widespread such a relationship was and its epigenetic and biological correlates, we systematically looked for genes with similar transcription profiles and analyzed their DNA methylation and chromatin state and accessibility profiles in many different cell populations. Twenty genes were expressed preferentially in myoblasts and cerebellum (Myob/Cbl genes). Some shared DNA hypo- or hypermethylated regions in myoblasts and cerebellum. Particularly striking was ZNF556, whose promoter is hypomethylated in expressing cells but highly methylated in the many cell populations that do not express the gene. In reporter gene assays, we demonstrated that its promoter's activity is methylation sensitive. The atypical epigenetics of ZNF556 may have originated from its promoter's hypomethylation and selective activation in sperm progenitors and oocytes. Five of the Myob/Cbl genes (KCNJ12, ST8SIA5, ZIC1, VAX2, and EN2) have much higher RNA levels in cerebellum than in myoblasts and displayed myoblast-specific hypermethylation upstream and/or downstream of their promoters that may downmodulate expression. Differential DNA methylation was associated with alternative promoter usage for Myob/Cbl genes MCF2L, DOK7, CNPY1, and ANK1. Myob/Cbl genes PAX3, LBX1, ZNF556, ZIC1, EN2, and VAX2 encode sequence-specific transcription factors, which likely help drive the myoblast and cerebellum specificity of other Myob/Cbl genes. This study extends our understanding of epigenetic/transcription associations related to differentiation and may help elucidate relationships between epigenetic signatures and muscular dystrophies or cerebellar-linked neuropathologies.

An Evolutionarily Conserved Mesodermal Enhancer in Vertebrate Zic3

Zic3 encodes a zinc finger protein essential for the development of meso-ectodermal tissues. In mammals, Zic3 has important roles in the development of neural tube, axial skeletons, left-right body axis, and in maintaining pluripotency of ES cells. Here we characterized cis-regulatory elements required for Zic3 expression. Enhancer activities of human-chicken-conserved noncoding sequences around Zic1 and Zic3 were screened using chick whole-embryo electroporation. We identified enhancers for meso-ectodermal tissues. Among them, a mesodermal enhancer (Zic3-ME) in distant 3' flanking showed robust enhancement of reporter gene expression in the mesodermal tissue of chicken and mouse embryos, and was required for mesodermal Zic3 expression in mice. Zic3-ME minimal core region is included in the DNase hypersensitive region of ES cells, mesoderm, and neural progenitors, and was bound by T (Brachyury), Eomes, Lef1, Nanog, Oct4, and Zic2. Zic3-ME is derived from an ancestral sequence shared with a sequence encoding a mitochondrial enzyme. These results indicate that Zic3-ME is an integrated cis-regulatory element essential for the proper expression of Zic3 in vertebrates, serving as a hub for a gene regulatory network including Zic3.

Comparative Genomics of the Zic Family Genes

Zic family genes encode five C2H2-type zinc finger domain-containing proteins that have many roles in animal development and maintenance. Recent phylogenetic analyses showed that Zic family genes are distributed in metazoans (multicellular animals), except Porifera (sponges) and Ctenophora (comb jellies). The sequence comparisons revealed that the zinc finger domains were absolutely conserved among the Zic family genes. Zic zinc finger domains are similar to, but distinct from those of the Gli, Glis, and Nkl gene family, and these zinc finger protein families are proposed to have been derived from a common ancestor gene. The Gli-Glis-Nkl-Zic superfamily and some other eukaryotic zinc finger proteins share a tandem CWCH2 (tCWCH2) motif, a hallmark for inter-zinc finger interaction between two adjacent C2H2 zinc fingers. In Zic family proteins, there exist additional evolutionally conserved domains known as ZOC and ZFNC, both of which may have appeared before cnidarian-bilaterian divergence. Comparison of the exon-intron boundaries in the Zic zinc finger domains revealed an intron (A-intron) that was absolutely conserved in bilaterians (metazoans with bilateral symmetry) and a placozoan (a simple nonparasitic metazoan). In vertebrates, there are five to seven Zic paralogs among which Zic1, Zic2, and Zic3 are generated through a tandem gene duplication and carboxy-terminal truncation in a vertebrate common ancestor, sharing a conserved carboxy-terminal sequence. Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain the Zic family phylogeny, including their origin, unique features in the first and second zinc finger motif, evolution of the nuclear localization signal, significance of the animal taxa-selective degeneration, gene multiplication in the vertebrate lineage, and involvement in the evolutionary alteration of the animal body plan.

A microarray screen for direct targets of Zic1 identifies an aquaporin gene, aqp-3b, expressed in the neural folds

The Zic1 transcription factor plays multiple roles during early development, for example, in patterning the early neural plate and formation of the neural crest, somites, and cerebellum. To identify direct downstream target genes of Zic1, a microarray screen was conducted in Xenopus laevis that identified 85 genes upregulated twofold or more. These include transcription factors, receptors, enzymes, proteins involved in retinoic acid signaling, and an aquaglyceroporin (aqp-3b), but surprisingly no genes known to be involved in cell proliferation. We show that both aqp-3 and aqp-3b were expressed in adult tissues, while during early embryonic development, only aqp-3b was transcribed. During neurula stages, aqp-3b was expressed specifically in the neural folds. This pattern of aqp-3b expression closely resembled that of NF-protocadherin (NFPC), which is involved in cell adhesion and neural tube closure. Aqp-3b may also be involved in neural tube closure, since mammalian Aqp-3 promotes cell migration and proliferation.

Emerging roles for zic genes in early development

Members of the Zic family of zinc finger transcription factors play critical roles in a variety of developmental processes. They are involved in development of neural tissues and the neural crest, in left-right axis patterning, in somite development, and in formation of the cerebellum. In addition to their roles in cell-fate specification, zic genes also promote cell proliferation. Further, they are expressed in postmitotic cells of the cerebellum and in retinal ganglion cells. Efforts to determine the role of individual zic genes within an array of developmental and cellular processes are complicated by overlapping patterns of zic gene expression and strong sequence conservation within this gene family. Nevertheless, substantial progress has been made. This review summarizes our knowledge of the molecular events that govern the activities of zic family members, including emerging relationships between upstream signaling pathways and zic genes. In addition, advancements in our understanding of the molecular events downstream of Zic transcription factors are reviewed. Despite significant progress, however, much remains to be learned regarding the mechanisms through which zic genes exert their function in a variety of different contexts.

An oligodendrocyte enhancer in a phylogenetically conserved intron region of the mammalian myelin gene Opalin

Opalin is a transmembrane protein detected specifically in mammalian oligodendrocytes. Opalin homologs are found only in mammals and not in the genome sequences of other animal classes. We first determined the nucleotide sequences of Opalin orthologs and their flanking regions derived from four prosimians, a group of primitive primates. A global comparison revealed that an evolutionarily conserved region exists in the first intron of Opalin. When the conserved domain was assayed for its enhancer activity in transgenic mice, oligodendrocyte-directed expression was observed. In an oligodendroglial cell line, Oli-neu, the conserved domain showed oligodendrocyte-directed expression. The conserved domain is composed of eight subdomains, some of which contain binding sites for Myt1 and cAMP-response element binding protein (CREB). Deletion analysis and cotransfection experiments revealed that the subdomains have critical roles in Opalin gene expression. Over-expression of Myt1, treatment of the cell with leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF), and cAMP analog (CREB activator) enhanced the expression of endogenous Opalin in Oli-neu cells and activated the oligodendrocyte enhancer. These results suggest that LIF, cAMP signaling cascades and Myt1 play significant roles in the differentiation of oligodendrocytes through their action on the Opalin oligodendrocyte enhancer.

Identification of a BMP inhibitor-responsive promoter module required for expression of the early neural gene zic1

Expression of the transcription factor zic1 at the onset of gastrulation is one of the earliest molecular indicators of neural fate determination in Xenopus. Inhibition of bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling is critical for activation of zic1 expression and fundamental for establishing neural identity in both vertebrates and invertebrates. The mechanism by which interruption of BMP signaling activates neural-specific gene expression is not understood. Here, we report identification of a 215 bp genomic module that is both necessary and sufficient to activate Xenopus zic1 transcription upon interruption of BMP signaling. Transgenic analyses demonstrate that this BMP inhibitory response module (BIRM) is required for expression in the whole embryo. Multiple consensus binding sites for specific transcription factor families within the BIRM are required for its activity and some of these regions are phylogenetically conserved between orthologous vertebrate zic1 genes. These data suggest that interruption of BMP signaling facilitates neural determination via a complex mechanism, involving multiple regulatory factors that cooperate to control zic1 expression.

The role of Zic genes in neural development

The Zic family of zinc-finger proteins plays a crucial role in neural development. Zic genes are vertebrate homologs of odd-paired, the Drosophila pair-rule gene. Their gene products have zinc-finger domains similar to those of Gli proteins, which act as transcriptional regulators in hedgehog signaling. Recent studies of human, mouse, frog, fish and ascidian Zic homologs have provided evidence that Zic genes are involved in a variety of developmental processes, including neurogenesis, myogenesis, skeletal patterning, and left-right axis establishment. Zic genes appear to have multiple roles in neural development. They control the initial phase during which ectoderm differentiates into neuroectoderm, and they may act as bridges between secreted neural tissue induction signals and the basic-helix-loop-helix class of neurogenesis-inducing transcriptional regulatory factors. Studies of loss-of-function mutations with differing Zic gene subtypes show that the Zic family of genes controls the process of neurulation. Mutations result in neural tube defects, which are seen at different rostrocaudal levels depending on which Zic gene subtype has been affected. Development of holoprosencephaly, forebrain anomalies, and cerebellar dysgenesis indicate that region-specific morphogenesis of the CNS is also controlled by Zic genes. The underlying molecular actions of Zic gene products, which allow them to control development, remain a mystery. Recent molecular characterization has shown that Zic proteins are able to bind Gli-binding DNA sequences in a sequence-specific manner, but with lower affinity than Gli proteins. Zic proteins also can activate transcription from several promoters. Furthermore, Zic and Gli proteins interact physically via their zinc-finger domains, raising the possibility that Zic proteins can act as transcriptional cofactors and modulate the hedgehog-signaling pathway. Clarification of the specific cooperating factors is therefore required in each case. Other evidence also suggests that Zic proteins can inhibit neuronal differentiation by activating Notch signals. This association might be is a clue toward understanding of the multifunctional property of Zic proteins because Notch signaling also is implicated in the control of several developmental processes.

Possible roles of zic1 and zic4, identified within the medaka Double anal fin (Da) locus, in dorsoventral patterning of the trunk-tail region (related to phenotypes of the Da mutant)

Double anal fin (Da) is a spontaneous medaka mutant that exhibits an unique ventralizing phenotype, a mirror-image duplication across the lateral midline in the dorsal trunk-tail region. In the mutant, early D-V specification appears normal but the altered phenotype becomes evident during late embryogenesis. In this study, we genetically specified the mutation to a 174-kb region harboring two zinc-finger type transcription factors, zic1 and zic4, and compared the genomic structures of this region between wild-type and Da mutant fish. No mutation was found in the coding regions of either gene of the mutant, while two fragments, 324 bp and 3-4 kb long, were found inserted downstream of zic1 and zic4, respectively. Probably as a result of this, the expression of both genes is lost in the derivatives of the dorsal (epaxial) somite and the region dorsal to the terminal axis bending. All these tissues are morphologically affected or become ventralized in the mutants. In contrast, the expression in the head region and dorsal spinal cord remained unchanged. Detailed characterization of Da phenotypes revealed a novel defect in the axial skeleton (spina bifida occulta) that was also found in zic1-deficient mice. Finally, zic1-morpholino injection partially phenocopied early Da phenotypes. These findings strongly suggest that zic1 and/or zic4 are required for dorsal identity in the trunk-tail region and that loss of their expression in the epaxial somite derivatives and tail region causes the Da phenotypes.

Identification of a phylogenetically conserved activin-responsive enhancer in the Zic3 gene

Multiple signaling pathways are involved in the induction of the organizer, a major center controlling vertebrate body plan formation. To study these signals, we have focused on the regulation of the Zic3 gene, which codes for a zinc finger transcription factor expressed in the organizer region at the beginning of gastrulation. We searched for DNA regulatory elements in the Zic3 promoter by testing their ability to drive reporter gene expression in early embryos. By this approach, we identified an activin responsive enhancer (Zic3-ARE), which was located in the Zic3 first intron and was essential for dorsal activation of the reporter. The Zic3-ARE was stimulated by activin and Nodal ligands, but not by a dominant negative bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) receptor. The Zic3-ARE contains a repeating consensus homeodomain binding sequence, CTAATTAAA, suggesting involvement of a homeodomain transcription factor(s). Mutations in this motif abolished enhancer activity in dorsal marginal zone and its response to activin in animal pole explants. Inhibition of either Wnt/beta-catenin or activin/Nodal signaling suppressed Zic3-ARE activity in dorsal blastomeres, further illustrating the importance of these pathways in activation of organizer genes.

Zic1 promotes the expansion of dorsal neural progenitors in spinal cord by inhibiting neuronal differentiation

The role of Zic1 was investigated by altering its expression status in developing spinal cords. Zic genes encode zinc finger proteins homologous to Drosophila Odd-paired. In vertebrate neural development, they are generally expressed in the dorsal neural tube. Chick Zic1 was initially expressed evenly along the dorsoventral axis and its expression became increasingly restricted dorsally during the course of neurulation. The dorsal expression of Zic1 was regulated by Sonic hedgehog, BMP4, and BMP7, as revealed by their overexpressions in the spinal cord. When Zic1 was misexpressed on the ventral side of the chick spinal cord, neuronal differentiation was inhibited irrespective of the dorsoventral position. In addition, dorsoventral properties were not grossly affected as revealed by molecular markers. Concordantly, when Zic1 was overexpressed in the dorsal spinal cord in transgenic mice, we observed hypercellularity in the dorsal spinal cord. The transgene-expressing cells were increased in comparison to those of truncated mutant Zic1-bearing mice. Conversely, we observed a significant cell number reduction without loss of dorsal properties in the dorsal spinal cords of Zic1-deficient mice. Taken together, these findings suggest that Zic1 controls the expansion of neuronal precursors by inhibiting the progression of neuronal differentiation. Notch-mediated inhibition of neuronal differentiation is likely to act downstream of Zic genes since Notch1 is upregulated in Zic1-overexpressing spinal cords in both the mouse and the chick.

Molecular properties of Zic proteins as transcriptional regulators and their relationship to GLI proteins

Zic family genes encode zinc finger proteins, which play important roles in vertebrate development. The zinc finger domains are highly conserved between Zic proteins and show a notable homology to those of Gli family proteins. In this study, we investigated the functional properties of Zic proteins and their relationship to the GLI proteins. We first established an optimal binding sequence for Zic1, Zic2, and Zic3 proteins by electrophoretic mobility shift assay-based target selection and mutational analysis. The selected sequence was almost identical to the GLI binding sequence. However, the binding affinity was lower than that of GLI. Consistent results were obtained in reporter assays, in which transcriptional activation by Zic proteins was less dependent on the GLI binding sequence than GLI1. Moreover, Zic proteins activated a wide range of promoters irrespective of the presence of a GLI binding sequence. When Zic and GLI proteins were cotransfected into cultured cells, Zic proteins enhanced or suppressed sequence-dependent, GLI-mediated transactivation depending on cell type. Taken together, these results suggest that Zic proteins may act as transcriptional coactivators and that their function may be modulated by the GLI proteins and possibly by other cell type-specific cofactors.