Kinetic analysis of the inhibition of natural killer (NK) activity by multiple populations of tumor-activated suppressor cells

Hierarchical immunosuppression of regional lymph nodes in patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinoma

Patients with head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCCs) manifest defects in cell-mediated immune function. Previous studies in this laboratory have demonstrated regional alterations in the immunocompetence of draining lymph nodes (LNs) in HNSCC patients. In this investigation, we studied functional activity of lymphocytes from lymph nodes in different locations in the radical neck dissections (RNDs) from patients undergoing operations for HNSCC. Lymphocytes from nodes close to the primary tumor ("near" lymph nodes or NLN) exhibited a significant decrease in interleukin-2 (IL-2)-activated cytotoxicity when compared to lymphocyts from distant nodes ("far" lymph nodes or FLN). In addition, co-culture experiments suggested the existence of a soluble regulatory factor, produced by lymph nodes, that inhibited the development of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells in vitro. Further experiments with conditioned supernatants from the lymph node cells confirmed the presence of this soluble inhibitory factor. The inhibitory effect is significantly greater in NLNs than in FLNS. This hierarchical phenomenon suggests a regional network of immunosuppression in HNSCC patients. It is likely that tumor- and lymph node-induced suppression plays a role in limiting the efficacy of current immunotherapy protocols in human beings. A greater understanding of mechanisms of local inhibition of immune function will aid in improving adoptive immunotherapy for treatment of cancers in human beings.

Splenic natural cytotoxic activity is enhanced during growth of a murine fibrosarcoma

We have shown previously that the natural killer (NK) cell activity of DBA/2J mice bearing M-1 fibrosarcomas is consistently depressed at the later stages of tumor growth. The apparent mechanisms of inhibition are suppressor cell activation and prostaglandin E (PGE) production by tumor and lymphoid cells. In contrast, we show here that the natural cytotoxic (NC) activity of cells from the spleen, blood, and lymph nodes of mice bearing M-1 tumors is enhanced when compared to that of age- and sex-matched control mice. This enhanced NC activity does not appear to be due to increased cytolytic activity of macrophages but, rather, to enhanced cytolytic activity of multiple populations of non-adherent cells including B and T cells. Correlated with this is the finding that the NC activity of normal spleen cells is not inhibited in vitro by either PGE1 or PGE2 at levels which are inhibitory to NK cells. NC activity, although independent of PGE, is in fact enhanced by PGE1 in a dose-related fashion. These data indicate that NK and NC cells are regulated differently by PGE and during tumor growth. Utilizing a Winn assay, we also demonstrate that a cloned cell line with NC activity is capable of slowing tumor growth in vivo and that this action is improved if mice are treated with indomethacin concomitantly.

NK sensitivity and lung clearance of MHC-class-I-deficient cells within a heterogeneous fibrosarcoma

The present study examines clonal variations in NK sensitivity in a methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma. Previous studies of clones from this tumor have shown considerable heterogeneity in H-2 expression, and an association between deleted or low levels of class-I products and increased tumorigenicity after subcutaneous implantation in immunocompetent syngeneic mice. Here, fibrosarcoma clones with no or low expression of MHC-class-I products were found to be sensitive to NK-mediated lysis, while clones with high levels of MHC-class-I expression were relatively resistant. One H-2+ (G2) and one H-2- (B9) clone were chosen for more detailed studies. Cold-target competition assays and conjugate cytotoxicity assays in agarose showed that splenic effector cells bound equally well to the H-2+ and H-2- tumor clone, although only the latter was sensitive to NK cell lysis. Treatment with 50 U/ml of rIFN-gamma for 48 hr increased the levels of H-2 expression and made both clones more resistant to NK-mediated lysis. In vivo studies with radiolabelled tumor cells showed that cells from the H-2+ clone survived better than cells from the H-2- clone in the pulmonary capillary bed after i.v. inoculation. This difference disappeared in mice treated with anti-asialo GM1 serum, known to deplete NK cell activity.

Suppression of natural killer cell activity in young and old mice

Spleen cells from female mice of the recombinant inbred strain BPS lack natural killer (NK) cytolytic activity, and can suppress the cytolytic activity of normal NK effector cells. The suppressor cells are not typical B cells, T cells, macrophages, or NK cells; they lack the characteristics and surface markers of each of these cell types. In BPS mice, suppressor cell activity is a dominant and significant characteristic of spleen cells at every age tested (2 weeks to 18 months). In other strains of mice which are normally classified as high-responders in NK assays, such as the C57BL strain, these suppressor cells are less prominent but can be detected when separated (on the basis of their higher density) from other spleen cell populations. As mice of the high-responder strains age, however, the suppressor cells become a significant part of the spleen cell population.